Paper
The Fundamental Theorem of Algebra states that every polynomial equation of degree n with complex coefficients has n roots in the complex numbers. In fact, there are many equivalent formulations: for example that every real polynomial can be expressed as the product of real linear and real quadratic factors.
Early studies of equations by al’Khwarizmi (c 800) only allowed positive real roots and the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra was not relevant. Cardan was the first to realize that one could work with quantities more general than the real numbers. This discovery was made in the course of studying a formula which gave the roots of a cubic equation. The formula when applied to the equation x = 15x + 4 gave an answer getting -121, yet, Cardan knew that the equation had x = 4 as a solution. He was able to manipulate with his “complex numbers” to obtain the right answer yet he in no way understood his own math.
Bombelli, in his Algebra , published in 1572, was to produce a proper set of rules for manipulating these “complex numbers”. Descartes in 1637 says that one can “imagine” for every equation of degree n, n roots but these imagined roots do not correspond to any real quantity.
Viete gave equations of degree n with n roots but the first claim that there are always n solutions was made by a Flemish mathematician Albert Girard in 1629 in L’invention en algebre . However he does not assert that solutions are of the form a + bi, a, b real, so allows the possibility that solutions come from a larger number field than C. In fact this was to become the whole problem of the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra for many years since mathematicians accepted Albert Girard’s assertion as self-evident. They believed that a polynomial equation of degree n must have n roots, the problem was, they believed, to show that these roots were of the form
a + bi, a, b real.
Now, Harriot knew that a polynomial which vanishes at t has a root x – t but this did not become well known until stated by Descartes in 1637 in La geometrie , so Albert Girard did not have much of the background to understand the problem properly.
A “proof” that the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra was false was given by Leibniz in 1702 when he stated that x + t could never be written as a product of two real quadratic factors. His mistake came in not realizing that i could be written in the form a + bi, a, b real.
Euler, in a 1742 correspondence with Nicolaus(II) Bernoulli and Goldbach, showed that the Leibniz counterexample was false.
D’Alembert in 1746 made the first serious attempt at a proof of the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra. For a polynomial f he takes a real b, c so that f(b) = c. Now he shows that there are complex numbers z and w so that
|z| < |c|, |w| < |c|.
He then states the process to converge on a zero of f. His proof has several weaknesses. First, he uses a lemma without proof which was proved in 1851 by Puiseau, but whose proof uses the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra. Secondly, he did not have the necessary knowledge to use a compact argument to give the final emphasis. Despite this, the ideas in this proof are important. Euler was soon able to prove that every real polynomial of degree n, n 6 had exactly n complex roots. In 1749 he attempted a proof of the general case, so he tried to proof the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra for Real Polynomials:
Every polynomial of the nth degree with real coefficients has precisely n zeros in C.
His proof in Recherches sur les racines imaginaires des equations is based on decomposing a monic polynomial of degree 2 into the product of two monic polynomials of degree m = 2. Then since an arbitrary polynomial can be converted to a monic polynomial by multiplying by ax? for some k the theorem would follow by iterating the decomposition. Now Euler knew a fact which went back to Cardan in Ars Magna, or earlier, that a transformation could be applied to remove the second largest degree term of a polynomial. Therefore, he assumed that
x + Ax + Bx +…
=(x + tx + gx + …)(x – tx + hx + …)
and then multiplied and compared coefficients. Euler claimed to g led to h, … being rational functions of A, B, …, t. All this was carried out in detail for n = 4, but the general case is only a sketch.
In 1772 Lagrange raised objections to Euler’s proof. He stated that Euler’s rational functions could lead to 0/0. Lagrange used his knowledge of permutations of roots to fill all the gaps in Euler’s proof except that he was still assuming that the polynomial equation of degree n must have n roots of some kind so he could work with them and deduce properties, like eventually that they had the form a + bi, a, b real.
Laplace, in 1795, tried to prove the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra using a completely different approach using the discriminant of a polynomial. His proof was very elegant and its only ‘problem’ was that again the existence of roots was assumed.
Gauss is usually credited with the first proof of the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra. In his doctoral thesis of 1799 he presented his first proof and also his objections to the other proofs. He is undoubtedly the first to spot the fundamental flaw in the earlier proofs, namely the fact that they were assuming the existence of roots and then trying to deduce properties of them. Of Euler’s proof Gauss says
“… if one carries out operations with these impossible roots, as though they really existed, and says for example, the sum of all roots of the equation x+ax+bx+.” = 0 is equal to -a even though some of them may be impossible (which really means: even if some are non-existent and therefore missing), then I can only say that I thoroughly disapprove of this type of argument.
Gauss himself does not claim to give the first proper proof. He merely calls his proof new but says, for example of d’Alembert’s proof, that despite his objections a rigorous proof could be constructed on the same basis. Gauss’s proof of 1799 is topological in nature and has some rather serious gaps. It does not meet our present day standards required for a rigorous proof. In 1814 the Swiss accountant Jean Robert Argand published a proof of the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra which may be the simplest of all the proofs. His proof is based on d’Alembert’s 1746 idea. Argand had already sketched the idea in a paper published two years earlier Essai sur une maniere de representer les quantities imaginaires dans les constructions geometriques . In this paper he interpreted i as a rotation of the plane through 90 so giving rise to the Argand plane or Argand diagram as a geometrical representation of complex numbers. Now in the later paper Reflexions sur la nouvelle theorie d’analyse Argand simplifies d’Alembert’s idea using a general theorem on the existence of a minimum of a continuous function.
In 1820 Cauchy was to devote a whole chapter of Cours d’analyse to Argand’s proof. This proof only fails to be rigorous because the general concept of a lower bound had not been developed at that time. The Argand proof was to attain fame when it was given by Chrystal in his Algebra textbook in 1886. Chrystal’s book was very influential.
Two years after Argand’s proof appeared Gauss published in 1816 a second proof of the Fundamental Theorem of Algebra. Gauss uses Euler’s approach but instead of operating with roots which may not exist, Gauss operates with indeterminates. This proof is complete and correct.
A third proof by Gauss also in 1816 is, like the first, topological in nature. Gauss introduced in 1831 the term ‘complex number’. The term ‘conjugate’ had been introduced by Cauchy in 1821.
Gauss’s criticisms of the Lagrange-Laplace proofs did not seem to find immediate favor in France. Lagrange’s 1808 2nd Edition of his treatise on equations makes no mention of Gauss’s new proof or criticisms. Even the 1828 Edition, edited by Poinsot, still expresses complete satisfaction with the Lagrange-Laplace proofs and no mention of the Gauss criticisms.
In 1849 (on the 50th anniversary of his first proof) Gauss produced the first proof that a polynomial equation of degree n with complex coefficients has n complex roots. The proof is similar to the first proof given by Gauss. However it is adds little since it is straightforward to deduce the result for complex coefficients from the result about polynomials with real coefficients.
It was in searching for such generalizations of the complex numbers that Hamilton discovered the quaternions around 1843, but of course the quaternions are not a commutative system. The first proof that the only commutative algebraic field containing R was given by Weierstrass in his lectures of 1863. It was published in Hankel’s book Theorie der complexen Zahlensysteme .
Of course the proofs described above all become valid once one has the modern result that there is a splitting field for every polynomial. Frobenius, at the celebrations in Basle for the bicentenary of Euler’s birth said:-
Euler gave the most algebraic of the proofs of the existence of the roots of an equation, the one which is based on the proposition that every real equation of odd degree has a real root. I regard it as unjust to ascribe this proof exclusively to Gauss, who merely added the finishing touches.
The Argand proof is only an existence proof and it does not in any way allow the roots to be constructed. Weierstrass noted in 1859 made a start towards a constructive proof but it was not until 1940 that a constructive variant of the Argand proof was given by H. Kneser. This proof was further simplified in 1981 by M. Kneser, H. Kneser’s son.
Другие работы по теме:
Pythagoras Essay Research Paper Pythagoras was a
Pythagoras Essay, Research Paper Pythagoras was a Greek philosopher that was responsible for some devolpments in mathematics. He was born around 560 B.C. and died around 480 B.C. He was originally from the city of Samos, Ionia(Later day Italy), but moved away from his home to escape the tyranny of Polycrates.
College Algebra I Essay Research Paper Quetion
College Algebra I Essay, Research Paper Quetion: y= -3x , y + 3x=2 Answer: substitute y= -3x in for the “y” in y + 3x=2 y + 3x=2 -3x + 3x=2 ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Leadership Essay Research Paper The most meaningful
Leadership Essay, Research Paper The most meaningful and challenging experiences in my life have been through sports and the 4-H club. They have instilled the values of perseverance, confidence, and teamwork within me. I feel that my peers and others could learn valuable life lessons through participating in these organizations.
Algebra Essay Research Paper Determine and Apply
Algebra Essay, Research Paper Determine and Apply a Formula My topic for this assignment is was to determine the amount of people possible to cross a crosswalk during the time of the crosswalk?s walking symbols. To calculate this I made an algebraic equation to support my idea, and an example to support my equation.
Calculus Problem Solving Essay Research Paper Calculus
Calculus Problem Solving Essay, Research Paper Calculus can be used to solve many problems. Probably the most important is solving real-life problems or situations. An example of this type of problem is a related rates problem. A related rates problem is a problem which involves at least two changing quantities and asks you to figure out the rate at which one is changing given sufficient information on all of the others.
Integral Calculus Essay Research Paper Calculus is
Integral Calculus Essay, Research Paper Calculus is a powerful field of mathematics. Through the years, Calculus has been used to figure out extremely complicated and time-consuming problems in the fields of Physics and Engineering. The field of Calculus is divided into two major groups. The two groups are Differential Calculus and Integral Calculus.
Leonhard Euler Essay Research Paper Leonhard Euler
Leonhard Euler Essay, Research Paper Leonhard Euler 15 April 1707 – 18 September 1783 Leonhard Euler is said to have been the most prolific mathematician in history. His 866 books and articles represent about one third of the entire body of research on mathematics, theoretical physics, and engineering mechanics published between 1726 and 1800.
Sir Isaac Newton And Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz
Essay, Research Paper Sir Isaac Newton and Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz Sir Isaac Newton and Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz are two of the most supreme intellects of the 17th century. They are both considered to be the inventors
Fundamental Factors In Creating A Law Essay
, Research Paper Fundamental Factors To criminilize something, that is to say make it illegal, requires months sometimes, even years of thought. When the lengthy process is underway, the creators of the law must ask themselves two important questions: “Does the action that will be made illegal violate fundamental social values?” and “Is making this action illegal the best way to protect social values?” If the answer in both these cases is a ‘yes’ then the law should be created.
Chinese Remainder Theorem Essay Research Paper CHINESE
Chinese Remainder Theorem Essay, Research Paper CHINESE REMAINDER THEOREM WHAT IS IT ? Mathematics plays an important role in our world, as we know it. It is used everyday to solve all kinds of complex problems enabling us to create a better place for everyone to live in. One particular aspect of Mathematics known as the Chinese Remainder Theorem has a very interesting background.
The Development Of Mathematics Essay Research Paper
Before the time of recorded history, prehistoric people learned to count such things as the animals in their herds and flocks. They probably first used their fingers or pebbles to help keep track of small numbers. They learned to use the length of their hands and arms and other standards of measure. And they learned to use regular shapes when they molded pottery and chipped stone arrowheads.
George Boole Essay Research Paper George Boole
George Boole Essay, Research Paper George Boole was a mathematician in the 19th century. He helped establish modern symbolic logic and created algebra of logic, which they now called Boolean algebra. Boolean algebra is basic to the design of digital computers that we use today.
Achieving Knowledge Essay Research Paper Achieving KnowledgeNewman
Achieving Knowledge Essay, Research Paper Achieving Knowledge Newman presents an argument in which he states that a university s purpose is to train .good members of society. x A university educates students to perform well and better succeed in life. Knowledge plays a key part in the advancement of the student.
Algebra Essay Research Paper ALGEBRA REPORTAlgebra is
Algebra Essay, Research Paper ALGEBRA REPORT Algebra is a branch of mathematics in which letters are used to represent basic arithmetic relations. As in arithmetic, the basic operations of algebra are addition, subtraction, multiplication, division, and the extraction of roots. Arithmetic cannot generalize mathematical relations such as the Pythagorean theorem: which states that the sum of the squares of the sides of any right triangle is also a square.
Karl Gauss Biography Essay Research Paper Karl
Karl Gauss: Biography Essay, Research Paper Karl Gauss: Biography Karl Gauss lived from 1777 to 1855. He was a German mathematician, physician, and astronomer. He was born in Braunschweig, Germany, on April 30th,
Euclid Essay Research Paper Greek MathematicsCentered on
Euclid Essay, Research Paper Greek Mathematics Centered on Geometry (Euclid) The ancient Greeks have contributed much to the development of the Western World as we know it today. The Greeks questioned all and yearned for the answers to many of life s questions. Their society revolved around learning, which allowed them to devote the majority of their time to enlightenment.
Pythagoras Essay Research Paper In 580 BC
Pythagoras Essay, Research Paper In 580 B.C. there lived a man who is know for creating one the best known theorems ever. His name was Pythagoras and the theorem, the Pythagorean Theorem. This Theorem states that the sum of the squares of the two legs of a right triangle equals the hypotenuse squared. This theorem as you can see can be very useful for finding the lengths of a right triangle.
Pythagoras Essay Research Paper The Pythagorean theory
Pythagoras Essay, Research Paper The Pythagorean theory is probably more widely known than any other complex mathematical idea. The theorem was first used by the Eygptians , butthey had no mathematical proof that the idea was correct. Pythagoras is credited with being the first to prove the theorem.
Personal Writing Changing Grades And The Consequences
Essay, Research Paper Personal Writing: Changing Grades and The Consequences I was about to leave my algebra class one day when the teacher asked me a question. “Could you do help me out with my rollbook program?” he asked. “Sure,
A Book Report On Kant
’s Fundamental Principles Of The Metaphysic Of Morals Essay, Research Paper Kant states (38,) “act as if the maxim of thy action were to become by thy will a universal law of nature”. This “categorical imperative” forms the basis of his book, Fundamental Principles of the Metaphysics of Morals. Though at times his writing is confusing Kant lays out his logic as to what a categorical imperative is.
Real Estate Essay Research Paper Mathematics
Real Estate Essay, Research Paper Mathematics ? Knowledge of numbers, their operations, and interrelationships including arithmetic, algebra, geometry, calculus, statistics, and their applications
Fundamental Orders Of Connecticut
– First Constitutiuon Essay, Research Paper Fundamental Orders of Connecticut (1639) Direct Democracy. . .A New Beginning In search of more fertile land and greater political and religious
Geometry Essay Research Paper Geometry was actually
Geometry Essay, Research Paper Geometry was actually first used in ancient Egypt and Babylon at around 2000 BC in both cases. In order for the Egyptians to build such massive structures as the pyramids they had to have made plans for them prior to the actually building, in these plans geometry had to be used.
Government Essay Research Paper 2 We know
Government Essay, Research Paper 2. We know that the fundamental difference between ancient political science and modern political science has to do with the relationship of the individual to the state. For Aristotle, a person was an inherently political animal. For modern political philosophers (social contract theorists), individual rights existed prior to the formation of government.
Median Voter Theorem Essay Research Paper Median
Median Voter Theorem Essay, Research Paper Median Voter Theorem: A Unavoidable Reality Leaving No One Truly Satisfied On the spectrum of politics (or any other ideologically-based matter), personal opinions will inevitably vary from one extreme on the left to the opposite on the right. In a governing system such as that of the United States, where the population directly elects representatives to govern, the position a candidate holds on the spectrum pertaining to certain issues in relation to other candidates becomes increasingly important.
Pythagoras Of Samos Essay Research Paper Pythagorean
Pythagoras Of Samos Essay, Research Paper Pythagorean Theorem The Greek philosopher Pythagoras of Samos is responsible of great advances in the study of astronomy, mathematics and the theory of music. A tyrant ruled Samos at the time and Pythagoras fled to southern Italy at about 532 BC. In Croton, Pythagoras founded a religious school that also specialized in philosophy.
Recreational Use Of Drugs Essay Research Paper
The Recreational Use of Drugs “Junk yields a basic formula of “evil” virus: “The Algebra of Need”. The face of “evil” is always the face of total need. A dope fiend is a man in total need of dope. Beyond a certain frequency need knows absolutely no limit or control. In the words of total need: “wouldn’t you?” Yes you would.
Rise Of Sociology Essay Research Paper The
Rise Of Sociology Essay, Research Paper The Rise of Sociology The field of sociology evolved as a response to the impact of profound social and political fragmentation experienced in the West. A fundamental shift in both social and intellectual patterns created by the economic evolution of the eighteenth century led to great concern among scholars of the period.