Paper
Cloning: Good or Bad
The rapid development of the technology for cloning has led to moral debates
around the world on whether or not to ban breathing human clones. While the potential
benefits of genetic engineering are considerable, so may be the potential dangers. We
have come to believe that all human beings are equal, but even more firmly, we are
taught to believe each one of us is unique. Is that idea undercut by cloning? That is, if
you can deliberately make any number of copies of an individual, is each one special?
Cloning could provide a way for infertile couples to produce children genetically similar
to themselves. Human cloning may provide numerous benefits to mankind. This is the
new world of cloning, and thanks to a 7-month-old sheep named Dolly, a new science has
been born. As with every new science, there are those who believe in it, and those who
oppose it. In the two articles that are covered in this paper, the first one, BBC NEWS:
Public Express Concern Over Cloning, is against cloning and the second article, THE
NEW ENGLAND JOURNAL OF MEDICINE: Should Human Cloning Research Be Off
Limits, supports cloning. By reviewing the articles, they will tell the audience which has
a better claim by how well it s written.
The first article talks about the negatives of cloning, but doesn t back up the
information. For example, The survey found virtually no support for cloning for
reproductive purposes, even in those groups which might have been expected to be
sympathetic, such as infertile couples . (BBC NEWS, p.1) This article basically is just
stating how segments of the population feels about cloning and not backing it up with
data and other forms of evidence. Throughout the whole article, evidence is very hard to
find. It sounds like the editor felt that everyone knew what was going on in cloning and
not explaining in detail and backing up those claims from people.
The editor did not really have a strong thesis and did not have good rhetoric.
This article brings up the point that many do not agree with the use of cloning for human
purpose in order for parents to choose their child. The article should have gone further
and written up some more information such as, by reproducing characteristics that
parents desire would foul-up the diversity of society. If everyone was able to choose
what characteristics his or her child would have, most people would opt for the
characteristics of famous people who are either extremely smart or who are incredibly
good looking. The generation of the clone people would be so similar in ways of
thinking and in personality that the world would become a very boring place, if that were
the case. The replication and copying of DNA can cause damage to the genetic code. In
this case, it is possible for genetic disorders arise. If a sample of DNA is taken from a
younger person to copy, that person could be carrying a code for some sort of disorder
whose symptoms would not show until later in the person s life. Therefore, the exact
code that would be copied to make another human carries that disorder. There are many
things that need to be sorted out such as who can use cloning and how it will be
controlled so it does not cause problems. This would have been a good detailed
explanation with evidence.
The second article supports cloning and is very well written. The thesis is
completely in support of cloning, Like many others, we believe that any plan to ban
research on cloning human cells is seriously misguided. (New England Journal, p.1) and
back it up with lot of scientific evidence.
This article also states how genetic defects could also be cured with cloning
technology and gives good backing to it. A genetic defect is a mutation in which the
DNA has been altered and caused an abnormality in the body. People who wish to have
a child, could be tested for possible mutations in the DNA, and a genetic solution could
be created and injected into the still developing egg. Mutations are natural, but when it
causes an abnormality it is a hard thing for a person to live with. Through cloning
technology, genetic defects could be treated to the point where the person affected could
live a normal life. A mixture between two people s genetic structure could provide a
way for infertile couples or homosexual couples with a way to create a genetically related
child. The author also talks about the public s view and the respected views of many
distinguished scientists, biotechnology companies, and medical organizations in support
of cloning and then backs up cloning by saying how people could be hurt by not looking
into cloning and the benefits. The difficult ethical judgments about how to apply this
new technology can be made only with full knowledge of the scientific facts. (New
England Journal, p.3) The author talks about the need to really study this concept and
also puts pressure on his fellow colleagues to educate the public about the benefits of
cloning.
This article is also well written in a professional sense with good wording and
grammar. The first article was okay, but didn t seem to really sway the reader with the
lack of evidence and professionalism. The rhetoric in the second article is very strong
and clearly sways the audience by reading it. The first article only stated opinions and
couldn t really sway people toward accepting their view because there wasn t enough
evidence to prove it. The second article distinguished people from the scientific
community backing up this article, but the first article seemed to only have some
opinions of the public.
Judging by the quality of the two articles in persuading me to choose a side, the
second article in support of cloning really got me thinking toward their side. I liked their
professionalism and evidence backing up their claims. By having prestigious people
back up the subject, I really opened up my eyes. Then all the evidence just made sense
also due to the fact that it was written with a lot of professionalism. The thesis was also
well outlined in the second article. The rhetoric was so much better in the second article
because they sounded like they really believed in what they were saying and backed it up,
while the first article just had some views from the public without much evidence. The
second article was just written so much better and with more evidence to sway my
opinion in support of cloning.
Другие работы по теме:
Cloning Essay Research Paper Nicole Pluta November
Cloning Essay, Research Paper Nicole Pluta November 29, 1998 Scientific experimentation has led us to many great discoveries such as: Chemotherapy, heart surgery, and bone marrow transplants. Recently scientists have discovered a new way to heal humans. This is known as cloning. Although they have yet to clone a human they have cloned sheep.
Cloning 6 Essay Research Paper Millions of
Cloning 6 Essay, Research Paper Millions of people. They all look alike, think alike, and dress alike. Sounds like something out of a sci-fi novel, right? Well, with cloning it s possible, maybe. They will look alike, but that s about it. Cloning will help the world, not make it the same. Three pros to cloning are that cloning may hold the secret to eternal youth, the research of genes has changed the thinking of scientists, and that parents would be able to have a child who looks exactly like a model, movie star, etc.
Cloning 2 Essay Research Paper Cloning
Cloning 2 Essay, Research Paper Cloning The new breakthrough of cloning is a great advance in biotechnology. The use of cloning can be both beneficial and harmful to society. There are many reasonable ways to use the methods of cloning. For instance, the use for medical purposes can be helpful in cases such as producing animals with human body systems that could be used for transplanting organs.
Cloning Essay Research Paper As most of
Cloning Essay, Research Paper As most of us know by now, Keith Campbell, a Scottish scientist, cloned a sheep over a year ago. You may think that cloning is a good thing because it is new, but you must consider the implications of it. Cloning can cause war or even destroy civilization. Cloning must be stopped.
Cloning Or Clowning Essay Research Paper Cloning
Cloning Or Clowning? Essay, Research Paper Cloning or Clowning Around? Just like in the fictional book Jurassic Park they cloned dinosaurs for the purpose of entertainment. They thought they could control them like zoo animals, but they were wrong. They also only made female dinosaurs so that they couldn’t reproduce, but in the end nature found a way.
Cloning A Dangerous Science Essay Research
Paper Cloning is a new science that has much to offer. We can learn how to grow and harvest organs, which would eliminate the waiting list for those in need of a heart, liver or other vital organs. Many are worried that cloning will be used for the wrong purposes such as creating multiple copies of one person for the purpose of war.
Cloning Essay Research Paper Human Cloning Ever
Cloning Essay, Research Paper Human Cloning Ever since the cloning of the sheep, people have been wondering weather it is morally right to clone. Now the time has come where we can clone human beings and now people are even more worried about weather it is right or wrong. The thing that many religious people don t like, is that cloning was never mentioned in the Bible.
AntiCloning Essay Research Paper Many people have
Anti-Cloning Essay, Research Paper Many people have different views about cloning. Some believe it to be a good thing. I think cloning is one of the worst things to come into the millennium. Cloning is very dangerous to humans. Not only could it kill a human being, but it could effect a family or others around them.
Cloning Essay Research Paper I choose this
Cloning Essay, Research Paper I choose this article to comprehend the abilities which bioethics gives us. Through generations, technology has advanced immensely. Though cloning is a new technology to the public, it has been around since 1978 ?The birth of Louise Brown, the first test-tube baby, whom generated great controversy.? Society has a great concern toward the particular medicine known as cloning.
Cloning Essay Research Paper A couple that
Cloning Essay, Research Paper A couple that had been married for only two years was in a terrible car accident. The husband, however, was unconscious when the paramedics arrived. He went into a coma shortly after arriving at the nearby hospital. He came out of the coma but never was the same again. It turns out that when he was in the accident, he had severe head trauma, and would be a vegetable the rest of his life.
Cloning Will Help Essay Research Paper Cloning
Cloning Will Help Essay, Research Paper Cloning Will Help Us in the Long Run. One issue that has come up within the past five years is the issue of human cloning. This issue has made many people quarrel about if it is morally right or not. One argument against human cloning that many people are looking into now, is whether cloning is ethical.
Human Cloning 2 Essay Research Paper The
Human Cloning 2 Essay, Research Paper The creation of life has often been the focus of many novels from Frankenstein to Brave New World. This former unconceivable chimera has now been transformed into a reality, with the science of genetics and cloning expanding much more rapidly than any other facet of today s technology.
Fabricating Humans Essay Research Paper Cloning is
Fabricating Humans Essay, Research Paper Cloning is unethical and is not needed in society. Many, if not all, religions agree with the ban of cloning human beings. It has also been argued that cloning would diminish individuality as well. Whether or not cloning is ethical, at this time cloning human beings should be, and is, banned.
Technology Essay Research Paper People very often
Technology Essay, Research Paper People very often debate whether technology is good or bad. Many people believe that technology can only cause harm to their lives and society, while many others strongly defend the technologies which have made their lives much more leisurely and enriching than it could have been several hundred years ago.
Cloning Essay Research Paper Cloning Recently we
Cloning Essay, Research Paper Cloning: Recently, we have all seen the controversy over whether or not we should attempt to clone. If you haven’t heard: A group of scientists in Scotland announced the birth of a sheep cloned from embryonic cells, presaging Dolly. Dolly’s was the birth heard round the world.
To Clone Or Not To Clone Essay 2
To Clone Or Not To Clone Essay, Research Paper The discovery of cloning can be both beneficial and harmful to society. There are many reasonable methods of cloning. For instance, the use of cloning for medical purposes can be helpful in taking human DNA and creating new body parts. Because of the shortage of donors, this could become a valuable asset to our society.
Cloning Is Morally Wrong Essay Research Paper
Cloning is an issue that touches upon the most profound ethical issues. If humans even consider cloning each other then they should revise what is morally and ethically right and wrong. The cloning of any species, whether it s human or non-human is by all means wrong.
Ethics Of Cloning Essay Research Paper Cloning
Ethics Of Cloning Essay, Research Paper Cloning humans is unethical because the clone is not born the normal way, but is created from one parent instead of two by duplicating someone s DNA. Therefore it is causing the clone to be neglected the two-parent family. Some of the scientist that cloned the sheep Dolly says cloning the sheep was a complete success but all are convinced that cloning humans is ethically wrong and should not be allowed. (Kestenbaum, David, 1965) Frank Monton explains that there is now worldwide recognition from governments, professional medical bodies and bioethics committees that to clone a human would be unethical (Monton, Frank, C4).
Human Cloning Essay Research Paper Cloning humans
Human Cloning Essay, Research Paper Cloning humans can be very beneficial. Although cloning has a low success rate, with more research and support, it can become very useful to our society. We will be able to clone people for adoption and clone organs for transplants that would save lives. We could also use research on animals to cure or help diseases and disease research.
Cloning Essay Research Paper Cloning Humans Is
Cloning Essay, Research Paper Cloning Humans Is Ethically Permissible The question whether it is ethically permissible to clone humans has been a debate in the U.S. and in other parts of the world for some time. There are some good reasons that human cloning is relevant in our society, and there are some goods reasons that we shouldn’t practice human cloning.
Human Cloning Essay Research Paper CloningCould cloning
Human Cloning Essay, Research Paper Cloning Could cloning become the thing of the future? Or is it the start of a new generation? To some, cloning could give back a life, or a life of fun, happiness, and freedom. For others it could mean destruction, evil, or power. Throughout this essay you should get a better idea of cloning and the concerns about it.
Cloning Essay Research Paper A clone is
Cloning Essay, Research Paper A clone is really just a time-delayed identical twin of another animal or person. Cloning is accomplished by getting two cells to fuse to become one. The egg gains a full set of genes from the adult and thinks it has been fertilized. Then it begins to divide and become identical twin or clone of the adult.
Cloning Essay Research Paper CloningIt all started
Cloning Essay, Research Paper Cloning It all started as science fiction, something along the lines of pod people. Then this small branch in science fiction grows to be a very popular idea. Then real scientists start believe that it would be possible to clone someone. Finally it happens this small idea of science fiction becomes real with the first clone, Dolly the sheep, but now people are thinking that this might not be such a good idea.
Cloning Essay Research Paper Cloning 1999 Cloning
Cloning Essay, Research Paper Cloning 1999 Cloning is the process of creating a genetic duplicate of an individual. Since the February 1997 announcement of the birth of Dolly, a sheep cloned by Ian Wilmut, cloning research
CLONINING EDATORAL Essay Research Paper CLONING EDATORAL
CLONINING EDATORAL Essay, Research Paper CLONING EDATORAL The recent scientific success of cloning is a controversial topic in today’s world. The Los Angeles Time expresses many views on cloning in recent editorials. In an April, 1997 editorial “Reproductive Research Far Outpaces Public Policy” The Times interviewed both supporters and critics of cloning.
Cloning Essay Research Paper Today there are
Cloning Essay, Research Paper Today there are many scientist that want to clone humans and other organisms in order to make the world a better place. Scientist think that if they can
Cloning Essay Research Paper In recent years
Cloning Essay, Research Paper In recent years, the issue of cloning has been up for debate worldwide. Cloning is the production of one or more individual plants or animals that are genetically identical to another plant or animal. There are two different types of cloning procedures, embryo cloning and adult DNA cloning.
Cloning Is Wrong Essay Research Paper Cloning
Cloning Is Wrong Essay, Research Paper Cloning is Wrong Cloning should never be done to humans or any other of Gods creations. The internet has many examples of why cloning should not be done. even the encyclopedia has articles against cloning. Cloning is a threat to the human race, immoral, and we should never allow it to take place.
Human Cloning Right Or Wrong Essay Research
Paper Should human cloning be allowed and legal? That s an interesting question that has been around for years. Cloning first came to the public attention roughly thirty years ago (Kass 27). After failed attempts to try to make cloning legal on humans, scientists turned to animals. Our own President did not allow scientists to use federal funds to research human cloning.
Cloning Aspects Essay Research Paper The legal
Cloning Aspects Essay, Research Paper The legal aspects of Human Cloning are quite simple and straight forward, and I will outline them for you in the next few minutes and explain to you what they
Cloning Essay Research Paper CLONINGCloning is an
Cloning Essay, Research Paper CLONING Cloning is an issue that only recently has come to light. The technology, still in its infancy, has roused strong views in opposition. Supporters feel that, with the careful continuation of research, the technological benefits of cloning clearly outweigh the possible social consequences.
A Report On Cloning (A Little Biased)
) Essay, Research Paper Cloning is a new technology that humans have just acquired. Before, cloning was something that you could read about in a science-fiction book for a buck. Now, we have seen proof of cloning with the sheeps called Dolly. The big question is if we should clone humans. There are only two ways this could be possible. ?The first way involves splitting an embryo into several halves and creating many new individuals from that embryo.
Cloning Technology Essay Research Paper IntroductionAs technology
Cloning Technology Essay, Research Paper Introduction As technology keeps advancing each year we are left with nothing else but to learn how to use it. In 1997 history was made when Dolly – the first cloned sheep – was born. Questions arose about whether or not it was possible to clone humans. Nobody knows for certain how far cloning can go but nobody can stop technology from becoming advancing.