Whitman Vs. Dickinson Essay, Research Paper
Whitman Vs. Dickinson
By Monica Perez
Death; termination of vital existence; passing away of the physical state. Dying comes along with a pool of emotions that writers have many times tried to explain. Emily Dickinson and Walt Whitman were two pioneer poets from the Romantic Era, that introduced new, freer styles of writing to modern poetry at the time. Both Whitman and Dickinson have similar ideas in their writing, but each has a unique touch of expression in their works. Both poets have portrayed death in their poetry as a relief, a salvation, or escape to a better place- another life. They have formulated death as a positive yet ambiguous state. In Dickinson’s “Narrow Fellow in the Grass” and Whitman’s “Wound-Dresser”, there exists a link in both poets ideas of death through each individuals style of writing.
Both poets, through their distinct voice and word-choice, arrive at the same conclusion of death being a good and positive thing. Whitman’s “Wound-Dresser” tells the story of an old man remembering his war-tales of watching soldiers die. These dying soldiers resemble Jesus, they were dying for a cause; for their country; for a “world of gain and appearance and mirth” (line 21). This resemblance brings the religious connotation into the poem. He compares the soldiers (Jesus) to nature, “like a swift-running river they fade” (line 18); which gives the impression that to him, God is nature. Whitman also incorporates phrases such as, “I am faithful” (line 56) to reinforce this religious connotation. After all, death is in many ways related to religion, every religion has a theory on death. He states: “-poor boy! I never knew you/ Yet I think I could not refuse this moment to die for you, if that would save/ You” (lines 37-39). Here, Whitman is introducing his acceptance for death. He is not afraid to die for this Boy. Whitman also describes death in a very delicate manner, which allows the reader to feel that death is in a way, good. For instance, he describes the soldiers as noisy in war, but when they die, there is silence. Silence resembles death, yet it’s not a negative way of expressing it. As the poet encounters with more memories of suffering, he calls to death: “Come sweet death! be persuaded O beautiful death!/ In mercy come quickly” (lines 44-45). He believes death will alleviate the pains and that it is good. Another delicate way of describing death, and an excellent choice of words, is when he says he recalls “the experience (as) sweet and sad” (line 63) These young soldiers have so much life ahead of them and they are dying, this makes it ‘sad’. Yet since they are suffering so much, it’s ‘sweet’ that they die. In this particular poem, Whitman portrays an attitude of positive welcoming of death.
The positive outlook that Whitman portrays towards death in his poem the “Wound-Dresser”, is similarly shown in Emily Dickinson’s “Narrow Fellow in the Grass”. She tells a simple story with impressive word choices that allow for deep interpretation and symbolism. Her poem narrates the story of a dead man laying on the ground that looks as if “the Grass divides as with a comb-” (line 5). “He (meaning the dead man) likes Boggy Acre/ A Floor too cool for Corn-” (lines 9-10). Notice as she uses the word ‘likes’ as if the dead man still lived or had feelings towards the place where he died. It seems as if she was contradicting her Puritan decent by in a way believing in an afterlife. The dead man chose a ‘boggy acre’. Boggy is a rich, mineral-filled soil that is close to a body of water. Water represent purification, but it’s also one of the four elements of life; earth, water, fire and air, therefore it also represents Life. Yet the ‘floor is too cool for corn’. Corn grows in hot, dry places. This coolness (winter) is the representation of death. What Dickinson could be trying to say through these simple sentences, is that the man is living after death. This representation of an after-life also gives the impression that, similar to Whitman, she welcomes death. “I feel for them (dead people) a transport/ Of cordiality” (lines 19-20). She’s talking about a transport of dying as if going to another life. Yet, it’s a transport of cordiality which puts death in a gentle manner, further noting her positive outlook on it.
Whitman and Dickinson both describe death as a positive event in a person’s life, yet both poets arrive at same conclusions of death through different procedures. They have their unique styles of portraying similar views. Whitman’s poem the “Wound-Dresser” is very lengthy and descriptive. He uses adjective-filled sentences to describe emotions towards particular situations, enabling the reader to feel through his shoes. His work is more like a story in a poetic form. Unlike Whitman, Dickinson is very concise and ambiguous in her explanations. She is very preoccupied with detail, but allows the reader to interpret her symbolic word-choice via imagination. Her tone to the poem is very innocent-like and simple, yet with much meaning if read between the lines. Whitman’s tone on the other hand, is more straightforward, dramatic and impacting. He describes in more gross detail.
Emily Dickinson and Walt Whitman each differ in the manner in which they write; they each have unique styles. Though they differ in the tone and voice, they arrive at similar conclusions of death in their poems “Wound-Dresser” (by Whitman) and “Narrow Fellow in the Grass” (by Dickinson). Whitman explains the healing effect that death brings to suffering people as sweet and sad. Whilst Dickinson shows signs of death being a path to an afterlife. Both poets portray death as being good.
Bibliography
The Norton Anthology of American Literatutre. shorter fifth edition. norton publishing. london, new york. 1999
Другие работы по теме:
Four Steps To Success Essay Research Paper
For many human beings, death is feared greatly. Maybe it is the mystery surrounding it, maybe it is mystery of what happens after it, or maybe it s the fear that one can no longer be with his or her loved ones. Whatever the case may be, it is a known fact that death can often lead to mourning, anger, and loneliness.
Walt Whitman I Sit And Look Essay
, Research Paper I SIT AND LOOK Throughout various works of literature, one can find numerous parallels. It is possible to see two works with mood and tone alike. Just as it is common to see two works that differ completely from one another in that sense. However, there is one parallel that can almost be guaranteed in all works of literature.
Whitman Essay Research Paper Whitman
Whitman Essay, Research Paper Whitman’s Definition of Individuality During a lecture in 1907, William James said “the philosophy which is so important in each of us is not a technical matter; it is our more or less dumb sense of what life honestly means. It is only partly got from books; it is our individual way of just seeing and feeling the total push and pressure of the cosmos” (Bartlett 546) Individuality has been a prevalent theme in every type of literature for quite some time.
Death 2 Essay Research Paper There are
Death 2 Essay, Research Paper There are many “popular” topics used frequently by authors. Love, religion, and war are some favorites. Two other such topics we typically read about are nature and death. The two can be discussed separately or they can be related to each other. Walt Whitman, a lover of nature, tackled these subjects in “Song of Myself” from Leaves of Grass.
Satire Essay Research Paper With all of
Satire Essay, Research Paper With all of the problems in today s society, it is great to know that we have one great thing going for us. That would be the talented men and women of our government. The powerful president, senators, congressmen, governors, mayors, and other politicians work together to keep this country it s very best.
Poetry Essay Research Paper Literature consists of
Poetry Essay, Research Paper Literature consists of many categories. The short story, the novel, and the poem are examples of these categories. Literature is more often then not a means of exposition for a central point, or theme, through symbolism. Poetry is the arrangement of these symbols and carefully metered language to convey a point.
Walt Whitman Essay Research Paper Walt Whiteman
Walt Whitman Essay, Research Paper Walt Whiteman though himself out to be the poet of American democracy. His poetry described an america where the future had already begun. Whitman believed every individual had as much dignity, and inmportance as anyone else. No job was considered to small or insubordinate.
Whalt Whittman Essay Research Paper Walt WhitmanWalt
Whalt Whittman Essay, Research Paper Walt Whitman Walt Whitman, a famous American poet, was born on May 31, 1819 in the West Hills of Long Island, New York. His mother?s name was Loisia Van Velsor, of Dutch descent., and amazingly could not read very well, if at all. His dad was an English carpenter who probably could not read his son?s poetry.
Carpe Diem Essay Research Paper The phrase
Carpe Diem Essay, Research Paper The phrase carpe diem , Latin for seize the day , asserts that if one does not live life to the fullest, one does not live life at all. Applications of this adage are widespread among numerous literary works. A few of the many examples include the poetry of Emily Dickinson, the motion picture Dead Poet s Society , and Walt Whitman s Song of Myself.
Whitman Vs Dickinson Essay Research Paper Loneliness
Whitman Vs Dickinson Essay, Research Paper Loneliness: A Connection between the Poems and the Lives of the Writers The lives of Walt Whitman and Emily Dickinson have many similarities and differences. Here, we will focus on the similarities in their lives in order to bring to attention a correlation between Whitman’s poem I Saw in Louisiana a Live-oak Growing and Dickinson’s poem # 1510.
Dickinson Vs Whitman Essay Research Paper Two
Dickinson Vs Whitman Essay, Research Paper Two Poets, Walt Whitman and Emily Dickinson are probably two of the most influential people in American poetry. They are regarded as the founders modern American poetry. Walt Whitman (1819-1892), for the time was breaking new ground with his diverse, energetic verse with regards to subject matter, form and style whether talking about overlooked objects in nature such as a single blade of grass or even our own hearing.
Walt Witman
’s Biography Essay, Research Paper Walt Whitman was a nineteenth century poet, who successfully introduced a new kind of poetry to American public. Walt Whitman, influenced by his love of his country and by the time period, wrote poetry about America during the mid to late 1800 s. Walt Whitman was born on May 31, 1819.
American Sign Language Essay Research Paper Emily
American Sign Language Essay, Research Paper Emily Dickinson and Uncle Walt Emily Dickinson and Walt Whitman are two of literature’s greatest innovators, they each changed the face of American literature. they are also considered one of literature’s greatest pair of opposites. Dickinson is a timid wreck loose.
Walt Whitman 2 Essay Research Paper Mysticism
Walt Whitman 2 Essay, Research Paper Mysticism, Democracy, Individuality&Personality The 1881 publication of the Leaves of Grass contained more than twenty-four poems, which were reasonably filled with ten or more diversified types of themes. Walt Whitman the author and compiler of this exceptional work changed the status of poetry writing through his utilization of thought and expression in the publication of the Leaves of Grass.
Leaves Of Grass Essay Research Paper The
Leaves Of Grass Essay, Research Paper The incredible Walt Whitman was a man with many talents. One of these talents being that he could see the world in a view that very few of us could comprehend. He saw the world for what it was and what it could be, nevertheless he saw people for who we are and what we could be. In many people s opinion the world has never seen a more talented and dynamic writer.
On The Beach At Night Alone By
Walt Whitman Essay, Research Paper In ?On the Beach at Night Alone,? Walt Whitman develops the idea that everyone has a connection with everything else, including nature. Whitman uses a variety of writing techniques to get his point across. First, the repetition and parallel structure that his poems contain reinforce the connection between everything in nature.
Dickinson Vs Whitman Essay Research Paper Dickinson
Dickinson Vs. Whitman Essay, Research Paper Dickinson vs. Whitman After receiving five years of schooling, Walt Whitman spent four years learning the printing trade; Emily Dickinson returned home after receiving
Whitman Essay Research Paper In my opinion
Whitman Essay, Research Paper In my opinion the poet which best exemplifies modernism is Walt Whitman. Walt Whitman?s stylistic preference is not exactly mine, but it is definitely a good example of ?modern poetry.? He has broken down many walls of traditional poetry, using the style of long, free verse prose.
Walt Whitman Essay Research Paper walt whitmanA
Walt Whitman Essay, Research Paper walt whitman A World of Politics Thesis: Walt Whitman was a man who used his thoughts on political issues concerning the Civil War within his writings because of many experiences
Birds Essay Research Paper The forum speech
Birds Essay, Research Paper The forum speech given on Friday the 14th of April was very interesting to me. Dr. Kirsten Murtagh, the Associate Vice President of The Northern Campuses of FAU, gave her speech on bird watching in Southern Florida. She started out her talk with a quote from Walt Whitman. He said that vagueness and ignorance helps enjoyment.
Emerson And Whitman Views Of Self Essay
, Research Paper Emerson and Whitman: Views of Self ?What is man anyhow? What am I? What are you?? asks Whitman. Who we are, what our purpose is and what the meaning of life is are all mysteries that man has tried to solve from his earliest history. Whitman and Emerson explore these ideas in their works, Song of Myself and Self Reliance.
Symbolism In Whitman
’s OCaptain! May Cap Essay, Research Paper O Captain! My Captain! By Walt Whitman O Captain! my Captain! our fearful trip is done. The ship has weather’d every rack, the prize we sought is won,
American Philosophy Essay Research Paper In all
American Philosophy Essay, Research Paper In all its forms, American philosophy emphasizes freedom and the supreme importance of the individual. Indeed, an examination of four major American writers shows these concepts in all four main schools of American thought– Epicureanism, Transcendentalism, Pragmatism, and Protestantism.
Beat Beat Drums Essay Research Paper James
Beat Beat Drums Essay, Research Paper James Bettencourt February 11, 2000 ENG 1021 Dr. O?Hara The Sounds of War When a country is at war it is the common people who suffer. In Walt Whitman?s poem, ?Beat! Beat! Drums,? the speaker signifies the sounds of war. The speaker, listening to the banging of war drums and shrill sounds of bugles, relates the interruption these war sounds have on the harmony of people?s lives.
Live Oak With Moss Essay Research Paper
English 11 Live Oak, With Moss Walt Whitman?s Live Oak, With Moss , is an intricate portrayal of love, both physical and mental. Throughout the poem, Whitman incorporates an array of metaphors symbolic of love and the many characteristics associated with love. Dissimilar to mainstream poetry, Whitman introduces a friend-lover relationship between two men, describing the pain and happiness associated with their love.
Song Of Myself Essay Research Paper Author
Song Of Myself Essay, Research Paper Author: Walt WhitmanTitle: Song of MyselfSummary: Song of Myself is a poem by Walt Whitman that encourages the inner-self and emphasizes the unity of all nature. Near the beginning, Whitman vividly describes how free he feels and states that everyone should experience it not at second or third hand.
Walt Whitman Essay Research Paper Walt Whitman
Walt Whitman Essay, Research Paper Walt Whitman’s diverse and self-conscious writing style contains many poetic devices which distinguish him among the great American writers. One such device common to Whitman’s poetry is the use of cataloguing. Through cataloguing, Whitman is able to enter into the text multiple ideas and situations, alluding to topics which are central to his work.
On Walt Whitman
’s Crossing The Brooklyn Ferry Essay, Research Paper One and the Same Walt Whitman asks himself and the reader of the poem, “Crossing Brooklyn Ferry,” what significance a person’s life holds in the
The Search For Immortality In Whitman
’s “On The Beach At Night” And Stevens’ “Sunday Morning” Essay, Research Paper The search for immortality is not an uncommon one in literature. Many authors and poets find contentment within the ideals of faith and divinity; others, such as Whitman and Stevens, achieve satisfaction with the concept of the immortality of mortality.
Whitman
’s Democracy Essay, Research Paper Whitman’s Democracy “I speak the pass-word primeval, I give the sign of democracy, By God! I will Accept nothing which all cannot have their counterpart
Emerson And The Transcendentalists Essay Research Paper
Ralph Waldo Emerson was a great essayist. I like reading about Emerson. He was very interesting. His essay “Self Reliance” told me that I could be an individual, a non-conformest. Many people were influenced by him, including Henry David Thoreau, a neighbor in Concord. Mr. Thoreau wrote the famous book Walden, which details his experiences living alone in the woods of Concord, Massachusetts.