“Joyce Carol Oate’s Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?” Essay, Research Paper
Refutation
Marie Mitchell Olesen Urbanski reflects on the parallels between a literary work and biblical suggestions in her essay ?Existential Allegory: Joyce Carol Oates ?Where Are You Going? Where Have You Been?? (Studies in Short Fiction, 1978.) In her criticism, she compares the story of Connie?s passive submission to Arnold Friend with the seduction of Eve by the Devil in the biblical myth. She uses Oates? descriptions of Arnold friend to prove that he is the devil and that Connie is an innocent victim.
Urbanski does a convincing job of comparing the story of Connie and Arnold to the story of Eve and the Devil. She emphasizes religious metaphors that Oates used in her story, such as the local hang out representing a sacred building with music played religiously as at a church service. Urbanski slips however by stating ?It is apparent that Friend represents the devil who tempts the chaste yet morally vacuous girl-victim.? It may be argued that Arnold Friend resembles the devil in some ways, but Urbanski fails to give sufficient evidence for this claim, and more importantly, fails to acknowledge the many other possibilities for Arnold Friend?s identity.
Urbanski easily compares Friend to other literary figures. She encounters a problem however when she labels Arnold as Satan simply because it resembles another description of Satan in John Milton?s works. Her argument becomes faulty because of a fallacy of composition. She says that Milton?s Satan, who sits straight with dark eyes and a dark gold neck, is the same as Arnold Friend because he has slitted eyes with dark lashes, a muscular neck and sits atop a golden jalopy. Simply the use of dark eyes and the color gold does not imply that one is the devil. What may be true for Milton?s Satan does not necessarily apply to all other works.
The example of Arnold Friend?s feet not fitting correctly into his boots and associating that with the cloven feet of the devil, also strikes a faulty chord. Urbanski cannot show any proof of the cause for Friend?s feet looking odd because Oates never gives a clear reason for his shoes not fitting correctly. Arnold Friend could be an evil midget, trying to get with Connie to pursue malicious intentions; Simply because one?s shoes do not fit, does not mean that one is Satan. Urbanski does not attempt to give another option to the possibilities of Arnold?s reality. She contends that Arnold?s captivating manipulation is evidence of a superhuman representation. I agree with her argument that Arnold is indeed superhuman, but I strongly disagree with her attempt to label Arnold as one specific force of evil. The facts that Joyce Carol Oates offers to us in her story are that Arnold has shaggy black hair, a tan face and pale body, wears mirrored sunglasses, and his boots fit incorrectly. By those facts, I could infer that Arnold is a man with a bad toupee, using self tanner, and going through his midlife crisis. By his actions and words I am able to add a supernatural force to his appearance and then fully decide that he isn?t like any other person or thing Connie has met before. Simply by his actions and appearance though, I do not have enough evidence to prove that Arnold is in fact the devil.
In her conclusion, Urbanski offers a grander approach to the symbolism of the characters. She explains that Connie represents everyone realizing their insignificance, and Arnold?s representing the furies as a vehicle for that realization. In symbolism of both those characters, I agree with Urbanski. I do believe also that they are representations of a bigger picture that is evident in most people?s existence, and by Oates? depiction of it, more severely in suburban life. Still, in the same conclusion, she adheres to her argument of Arnold being an apparent representation of the devil.
I am not able to give a definite idea of what Arnold friend may be; still I cannot agree with simply calling him the devil. To me, he can be seen as a devil just as much as he can be seen as a goblin, warlock or some other evil being. In the same sense, I could argue that Arnold is Connie?s hero, saving her from the blindness and sadness of her humdrum life. Arnold?s appearance can be seen as evil and scary, but appearances are so often misleading. Joyce Carol Oates has said ?Arnold Friend is a fantastic figure: he is Death, he is the ?elf-knight? of the ballads, he is the Imagination, he is a Dream, he is a Lover, a Demon, and all that.? (Fiction 100 p. 1113) For Marie Urbanski to state that Arnold is the devil seems to show a shallow view of Oates? magical story and not give enough credit to a wonderfully complex antagonist.
1. Urbanski, Mari Mitchell Olesen. ?Existential Allegory: Joyce Carol Oates ?Where
Are You Going? Where Have You Been??? Studies in Short Fiction. Newberry College. 1978. 200-03
2. Pickering, James. Fiction 100: An Anthology of Short Stories. New Jersey: Prentice
Hall, 1998
Другие работы по теме:
Wuthering HeightsBronte Essay Research Paper Critique Wuthering
Wuthering Heights-Bronte Essay, Research Paper Critique- Wuthering Hieghts Wuthering Hieghts is the prototype of all the gothic novels. It contains all the literary elements such as, symbolism, supernatural, and the dark solemn mood classic to all gothic novels. Although the book was well written and rich with literary devices, it did not retain my attention.
Odes Of Keats And Shelley Essay Research
Paper J.A. Cuddon, writing in The Penguin Dictionary of Literary Theory and Literary Terms, defines an ode as "a lyric poem, usually of some length . . . [which]
HG Wells Biography Essay Research Paper HG
H.G. Wells Biography Essay, Research Paper H.G. Wells (www.remotecom.se H.G. Wells) (Times Literary Supplement, “In defence of H.G. Wells) (The Nation, “The Fabians Were Not Amused”)
The Adventures Of Huckelberry Finn
– Critique Essay, Research Paper Critical Biography Mark Twain, the pseudonym of Samuel Clemens, was, as a literary writer, a genius. His use of numerous literary devices throughout the novel are quite unique. Examples of them would be, irony;
Bram Stoker Essay Research Paper Bram StokerAbraham
Bram Stoker Essay, Research Paper Bram Stoker Abraham (Bram) Stoker was born November 8, 1847 at 15 The Crescent, Clontarf, North of Dublin, the third of seven children. For the first 7 years of his life Stoker was bedridden with a myriad of childhood diseases which afforded him much time to reading. By the time he went to college, Stoker had somehow overcome his childhood maladies and while at Trinity College, Dublin, the honor student was involved in soccer and was a marathon running champion.
Refutation Essay Research Paper Bridget King Basic
Refutation Essay, Research Paper Bridget King Basic Comp. Refutation Essay January 11, 2000 Sending Out an S.O.S On January 2nd, while I was perusing the Providence Journal I stumbled upon the editorial page. On the page was an article titled ? Imposing a Rescue Fee? which was written by an anonymous author.
Aristophanes Lysistrata Essay Research Paper A Review
Aristophanes: Lysistrata Essay, Research Paper A Review of Lysistrata Lysistrata, a play written by Aristophanes, was first performed in 411 B.C. It portrays an arousing comedy of a plan to end the war between Athens and Sparta as proposed by an Athenian woman, Lysistrata. To do this, she holds a meeting among the women of Greece in an effort to convince them that men will succumb to peace as a result of sexual frustration.
The Cask Of Amontillado Lit Analysis Essay
, Research Paper Clint Kale 11/22/97 Literary Analysis Literary Analysis: The Cask of Amontillado In Edgar Allan Poe’s short story, “The Cask of Amontillado,” a character named
Book Review On Grapes Of Wrath Essay
, Research Paper A Critical Review of: John Steinbeck s The Grapes of Wrath John Steinbeck wrote this book in the hopes that people would be able to see what was happening to our nation s people. He wanted to open their eyes to see the hardships that migrants faced everyday and he accomplished this through the telling of the Joad s family story.
Appraising My Test Taking Skills Essay Research
Paper The advantages of my test taking skills are effectiveness,organization, and good review tools. Thus, the disadvantages are manageable review time and strategy planning. I find myself mostly “stuck” on planning a strategy.
Watership Down 2 Essay Research Paper Watership
Watership Down 2 Essay, Research Paper Watership Down as Good Literature Watership Down, by Richard Adams, is considered good literature because of the literary techniques and because of the plot. Several literary techniques are used to pull the reader in and the plot is a well constructed to hold their attention.
Lord Byron And His Literature Essay Research
Paper Lord Byron and His Literature Lord Byron was a man whose passion for life seemed unequaled by any of the other Romantic figures. Byron?s personal character, though not entirely so, could be seen in his literature as well as his life.
Literary Analysis Of A
& P Essay, Research Paper Literary Analysis of A & P The short story A & P, by John Updike, can be broken down into a number of components, which include characters, setting, plot, point of view, and the theme.
Geographical Knowledge Essay Research Paper
Not overly impressive knowledge ? many geographical books came to aid literary understanding. ? Map most important for officials to conceptualise land on their borders etc.? Theodosius II orders map of the world. ?
Synopsis Of The Great Gatsby Essay Research
Paper Synopsis of The Great Gatsby Review The review that I read by Charles E. Shain said that gatsby was no more great the any other man of his time. The reason for this is that Gatsby was trying to live in the past, to try to recapture what he once had. Sure he had very much money, ?gonnections?, and many acquaintances, but this does not make a man great.
Judicial Review Essay Research Paper Judicial ReviewThe
Judicial Review Essay, Research Paper Judicial Review The Supreme Court is the only court designated in the constitution. Within it is the Chief Justice of the United States, and eight associates. Being the highest court it is the last resort for all federal court questions. The Supreme Court has the power to determine whether something is constitutional or not, which makes them the final authority.
Ralph Ellison 2 Essay Research Paper Live
Ralph Ellison 2 Essay, Research Paper Live with integrity, respect the rights of other people, and follow your own bliss, these are the words of Nathaniel Branden, a United States psychologist. One person who lived his life by this quote is the American author Ralph Waldo Ellison. Ellison s integrity and respect for others helped him become an important American literary figure.
Review Of Ceremony Essay Research Paper Review
Review Of Ceremony Essay, Research Paper Review of Ceremony Ceremony, written by Leslie Marmon Silko, traces the alienation and destruction of a young Native American who must first come to terms with his past before he can overcome his post-traumatic stress. Throughout this novel, there are many symbols and examples of how not only the main character, but his culture as a whole was ignored, rejected, and destroyed.
Refutation To A Bias Suggestion Essay Research
Paper Refutation to a Bias Suggestion “Some people suggest that the Bible, being a collection of texts written long ago by persons much different from ourselves, does not have much (or any)
Refutation Essay Research Paper Refutation PaperMost Internet
Refutation Essay, Research Paper Refutation Paper Most Internet users are enjoying their freedom of speech on the Net, which is supposed to be protected by the First Amendment of the United States. However there are many organizations who are trying to strip americans of their rights. Their main argument is that of pornographic access to childrin via the web.
The Diary Of Anne Frank
– Book Report Essay, Research Paper The Diary of Anne Frank is about a girl that kept a diary while hiding from Nazi?s in Amsterdam for two years. The diary ends when the Nazi?s found her and her family. Her
Vision Essay Research Paper Literary analysis Vision
Vision Essay, Research Paper Literary analysis: Vision Out of the Corner of One Eye. The main character of “Vision out of the Corner of One Eye “, a short story by Luisa Valezuela, goes through a complete one hundred-eighty degree change over the course of the story.
Review Of Reviews Essay Research Paper I
Review Of Reviews Essay, Research Paper I chose to review John Updike?s Review ?It Was Sad? from the October 14th issue of ?The New Yorker?. In the review, Updike examines
Armenian Literature Essay Research Paper Armenian LiteratureBefore
Armenian Literature Essay, Research Paper Armenian Literature Before the introduction of Christianity into Armenia in the 3rd century AD, Armenian literature was Assyrian or Medo-Persian in character. After that date, however, the language, literature, and finally the alphabet of Greece appeared in Armenian writing, although eastern Armenia retained the Syriac alphabet.
Play Review On West Side Story Essay
, Research Paper Drama Play Review on West Side Story The musical Play that I did my review on was West Side Story by Jerome Robbins. I saw this play at the Woodland High School with my family. We went to see it because my older brother, Nick was in it.
Huck Essay Research Paper Elements of Racism
Huck Essay, Research Paper Elements of Racism in Huckleberry Finn Despite all the criticism, of racism and other questionable material for young readers, Mark Twain?s The Adventure of Huckleberry Finn is a superbly written novel, which in the opinion of this reviewer should not be remove the literary cannon.
Book Review Essay Research Paper Book ReviewFor
Book Review Essay, Research Paper Book Review For Whom The Bell Tolls Ernest Hemingway Pages Read: 74 (really busy) For Whom The Bell Tolls begins with a pyrotechnic for the Russian army reviewing the land where he must blow a bridge to stop enemy movement. He is a little overwhelmed by the task he is assigned to complete yet he is mentally sound in his manner and seems to know exactly how to handle himself in the situation.
Jay Leno Book Review Essay Research Paper
BOOK REVIEW The book I read was “Leading With My Chin”. The author is Bill Zehme. I enjoyed reading this book because of its excellent detail. I would definitely recommend this book to someone that is a Jay Leno fan or like to laugh a lot.
Book Review Essay Research Paper Book Review
Book Review Essay, Research Paper Book Review Eric T. LibeerPark Hill South High School Thursday, May 27, 1999 Book Review By Eric Libeer Homeland, John Jakes’s formidable noel about the final explosive events of the nineteenth century, is the first in a series that will focus attention on a new “Jakes” family, the Crowns.
Transendentalism In Emerson
’s Poetry Essay, Research Paper Ralph Waldo Emerson always considered himself a poet despite his many volumes of Essays and other works. Therefore this essay only deals with Emerson s poetry. Emerson told a lot with his prose but he told more with his poetry. Often, fundamental aspects of transcendentalism are shown through literary devices in his poetry.
Review Of A Review Essay Research Paper
Review of a Review Mark Caro seems to let one flaw ruin an entire movie. In his review of “Unbreakable” Caro admits that the duration of the film is commendable, but its ending is too disappointing to look past. He begins by comparing “Unbreakable” to the highly acclaimed “The Sixth Sense”. By saying that “The Sixth Sense” viewers will be, “on the lookout for clues that might telegraph the inevitable final twist” Caro puts the idea in our minds that we should all expect the same type of ending.