’s Eye Essay, Research Paper
Hamlet: In His Right Mind’s Eye
Crazy, or not crazy- That is the question. The matter of Hamlet’s so
called madness, has been an item of debate since the first performance, and will
probably be a continuing argument well into the future. I believe Hamlet was
not crazy, because he proves to be in complete control of his psyche in several
parts of the play. These three reasons are the main points of argument for
Hamlet’s sanity. His behaviors is only erratic in front of certain people, he
shows logic and reasoning in his plotting, and finally, actually admits to
several people to be only ?acting? mad. These are hardly the actions of a
madman.
First of all, the fact that Hamlet’s irrational behavior emerges only
in front of certain individuals shows he was only acting. He acts insane in
front of Polonius, Claudius, Gertrude and Ophelia, while remaining perfectly
normal in front of Horatio, Marcellus, the players and the gravedigger. Hamlet
convinces Ophelia of his madness by going into her room ?with a look so
piteous in purport as if he had been loosed out of hell to speak of horrors,?
(2.1.92)and grabbed her and examined her face. Then he let out ?a sigh so
piteous and profound as it did seem to shatter all his bulk and end his being.?
(2.1.106) After that incident, Polonius believes, that Hamlet’s madness ?is the
very ecstasy of love.?(2.1.115) Claudius is convinced, however, that that is
not the case. He believes that something else is troubling Hamlet. ?Love? His
affections do not that way tend; Nor what he spake, though it lacked form a
little, was not like madness. there’s something in his soul o’er which his
melancholy sits on brood? (3.1.176) After Hamlet kills Polonius, Gertrude
becomes completely convinced that Hamlet is ?Mad as the sea and the wind when
both contend which is mightier.?(4.1.7) With these characters convinced of his
madness, Hamlet is able to carry out several plans to avenge his father’s death.
The logic he uses in his plots is proof of a sane mind. He successfully
uses the players to reveal Claudius is the murderer by changing the play they
perform to reenact the murder of Hamlet’s father. ?Let the galled jade wince;
our withers are unwrung.? . When the murder scene is enacted, Claudius calls for
lights and storms out of the room. Claudius, knowing Hamlet is a threat, has
him sent to England along with Rosencrantz and Guildenstern. the two bear a
letter that was to have Hamlet executed upon arrival in England. But Hamlet
takes the letter while they slept an changed it ?I sat me down, devised new
comission, wrote it fair.? Hamlet escaped on a pirate ship, and Rosencrantz and
Guildenstern did not know about the change of letters until they were the ones
that were killed. These actions required cold calculation and execution, two
things not found in madmen.
Finally, the most important fact showing that Hamlet was indeed not
crazy is that Hamlet admits to being sane several times. When speaking to the
befuddled Rosencrantz & Guildenstern, he cryptically reveals ?I am but mad north
by north west. When the wind is southerly, I know a Hawk from a Handsaw.?
(2.2.400) Although the two do not understand Hamlet’s quote, he’s actually
admitting he can distinguish between things that are different, and thus
perfectly sane. Hamlet admits his sanity more clearly in a Conversation with
Horatio and Marcellus. After the three receive a visit from the ghost, Hamlet
asks the other two to swear never to admit they know anything about Hamlet’s
condition ?never so help you mercy, how strange or odd some’er I bear myself (As
I perchance hereafter shall think meet to put an antic of disposition)?(1.5.190)
In other words, no matter how crazy he acts, Horatio and Marcellus should
not let on to know he is only acting. Finally, the most prominent confession of
sanity is that of Hamlet’s to Queen Gertrude. ?..I essentially am not in
madness, but mad in craft.? Thus he admits once and for all, to be merely
acting crazy.
In conclusion, the possibility that Hamlet may have been mad is only
supported by his inability to act swiftly. Other than that, it is almost
indisputable that Hamlet’s madness was nothing more than an act, devised to
provide a facade for his plan to avenge his father’s death.
344
Другие работы по теме:
Donald Davidson Essay Research Paper In Shakespeares
Donald Davidson Essay, Research Paper In Shakespeare?s Hamlet, there is a murder, and it doesn?t say straight out who the murder is. There are no detectives on the case. No one within in the state is really questioning the murder of the King except for his son. It may not have all the customary qualities of detective story, but it does come across as a detective story in which Hamlet seeks to solve the mysterious death and to revenge for his father.
Main Thought Of Hamlet Essay Research Paper
What I believe to be the main and most important theme of Hamlet is that power corrupts and kills. This is evident in many parts of this play. In the first half of this tale, Shakespeare shows us that the power King Hamlet gave to his brother (free run of the castle, ability to get where the king slept) let to the king’s death.
Bla Essay Research Paper IIIi5690Hamlet condemns himself
Bla Essay, Research Paper III.i.56-90 Hamlet condemns himself to life in this soliloquy. He realizes that by escaping his earthly body through death he will still remain in the prison of painful thoughts. Hamlet, the thinker, cannot escape his conscious self and in that realization decides, “to be.” The foundation of his choice is solipsistic in nature.
Hamlet S Soliloquies Essay Research Paper The
Hamlet S Soliloquies Essay, Research Paper The soliloquies spoken by Hamlet were directed to the audience, rather than seeming like conversations with himself. In the first soliloquy, Hamlet talks about how aggravated at life he is and that if it weren t for God s laws he would commit suicide. He is not really morning his fathers death in this soliloquy but more his disgust for his mother for marring his uncle especially a few months after his father s death.
Hamlet Essay Research Paper Act IV Scene
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Act IV, Scene vii: Claudius convinces Laertes that he is innocent in Laertes’ father’s death and that Hamlet is to blame. A messenger enters with Hamlet’s letter and Claudius is amazed to find that
Hamlets Sanity Essay Research Paper Hamlet s
Hamlets Sanity Essay, Research Paper Hamlet s Sanity In the second act of Hamlet , it is evedent that Hamlet is not the norm . It comes down to the question of either Hamlet is faking his insanity or he has truly lost his mind. Polonius made the ussumption that Hamlet has gone mad with love, a theory inwich holds it s own from a outside point of view.Through further investigation in which Claudius and Polonius spy on Hamlet by using Ophelia as bate .
Hamlet Essay Research Paper ally funny man
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper ally funny man. Hamlet: why are you throwing up another skull. It could be a skull of a lawyer. So who grave is this man. Clown: It?s all mine.
Love In Hamlet Essay Research Paper Hamlet
Love In Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Hamlet is, without any doubt, one of William Shakespeare’s most puzzling plays. Often times, the reader becomes engulfed in the mystery, trickery and deceit in this tragedy. People become perplexed while reading Hamlet when they ask themselves the question, “Does Hamlet truly love Ophelia?”.
Hamlet And Issue Of Insanity Essay Research
Paper In William Shakespeare s play, Hamlet, one of the most important issues is Hamlet s sanity, in which many question his thoughts and actions. In the beginning, Hamlet and Ophelia are sane, but as the play progresses, Shakespeare slowly shows how their minds deteriorate and how Hamlet goes crazy. An example of Hamlet s insanity is when he tells Ophelia to Get thee (to) a nunnery in Scene i of Act III.
Hamlet And His Revenge Essay Research Paper
Hamlet was bound by honor and a code or righteousness. He could not merely kill Claudius as Claudius had killed his father, Hamlet was obligated by personal, honorable, Biblical, and righteous standards to hesitate until the right time. When Polonius said to Hamlet, “Readiness is all”, it sparked the fact the Hamlet must wait until the perfect time to take his revenge.
Hamlet And His Maddness Essay Research Paper
Hamlet and his Madness Since the play Hamlet was first written and performed, critics have analyzed the question “Was Hamlet really mad?” I personally do not believe that he was, but all of the characters in this play have a different opinion.
Hamlet Essay Research Paper The question of
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper The question of Hamlet s insanity is a question raised by many people, is Hamlet a great actor, or has he lost complete sense of what s real? There is no right answer, there is no wrong answer, many readers have different perceptions on what really was going through Hamlet s head.
Hamlets Problem Essay Research Paper Hamlets Problem
Hamlets Problem Essay, Research Paper Hamlets Problem In the play Hamlet, Hamlet is described as daring, brave, loyal, and intelligent, but he is consumed by his own thoughts. Hamlet s inability to act on his father s murder, his mother s marriage, and his uncle assuming of the thrown are all evidence that Hamlet doesn t know what is going on in his own life.
Hamlet Explication Essay Research Paper Hamlet Explication
Hamlet Explication Essay, Research Paper Hamlet Explication In Hamlet, by William Shakespeare, Rosencrantz speaks Act 3 Scene 3 lines 11-23. The lines that he speaks are in response to the Kings request that Rosencrantz and Guildenstern take Hamlet to England immediately. The king feels that Hamlet’s madness is a threat to him and tries to convince the men that it is a threat to the kingdom and that it would be in Hamlet’s best interest to go to England.
Contrast Between Two Hamlets Essay Research Paper
Shakespeare has been translated into many languages. There are many versions of Hamlet movies and theater plays all around the world. I personally read and watched Hamlet in two languages: Russian and English. I will contrast two American Hamlet movies, one of which is by Mel Gibson, with Mel Gibson as Hamlet and another one is staring Lawrence Olivier.
Hamlet Criticism Essay Research Paper In
Hamlet Criticism Essay, Research Paper In Hamlet ; Literary Remains, Samuel Taylor Coleridge describes Hamlet as an intricate planner who s thought process is slow and methodical. He describes Hamlet as someone having Supercilious activities of the mind, which, unseated from its healthy relation, is constantly occupied with the world within, and abstracted from the world without throwing a mist over all common-place actualities.
Hamlet Substance Vs Accident Essay Research Paper
Insanity is an ever growing black hole which envelopes the pitiful mind of the its victim. The mental condition of Hamlet is an example of substance vs. accident. The substance is he is not insane and accident is that he is acting to be insane to trick everyone in the castle to believe he is insane. The mental condition of Hamlet has been well debated throughout the years even though in Shakespeare s tragedy Hamlet does admit that his madness is an elaborate scheme.
Hamlet Foreshadowing Essay Research Paper An example
Hamlet Foreshadowing Essay, Research Paper An example of foreshadowing is when Hamlet’s father came to him as a ghost to inform him of his murder, this caused a rage within Hamlet that foreshadows his revenge. This revenge led to the death of his uncle, mother, and himself. It also created Hamlet’s wild behavior, and caused him possibly to become insane..
Hamlet And Ophelia Essay Research Paper An
Hamlet And Ophelia Essay, Research Paper An example of foreshadowing is when Hamlet?s father came to him as a ghost to inform him of his murder, this caused a rage within Hamlet that foreshadows his
Hamlet A Juvenile Delinquent Essay Research
Paper Hamlet: The tragedy of a man who could not make up his mind. So begins the Olivier version of Shakespeare s Hamlet , and many others follow suit. Hamlet to many is portrayed as a weak-minded individual because he is juvenile. Many have the opinion that he led seven unnecessary deaths because he was a delinquent.
Hamlet 4 Essay Research Paper HamletOne of
Hamlet 4 Essay, Research Paper Hamlet One of the themes I found in the play Hamlet, was the way Hamlet seemed to hold back on getting revenge for his father s murder once he know who did it. After his father s death and the hasty remarriage of his mother to his uncle, Hamlet started to spiral into a suicidal frame of mind.
Hamlet Play Essay Research Paper The Play
Hamlet Play Essay, Research Paper The Play Hamlet by William Shakespeare is arguably his finest tragedy ever written. The characterizations of the cast are odd shaped pieces that fit
Hamlet Vs Laertes Essay Research Paper Hamlet
Hamlet Vs Laertes Essay, Research Paper Hamlet vs Laertes Both Laertes and Hamlet both have similar and unique personality traits. These two characters are essential parts to the structure and theme of this play. Laertes tends to be possibly, in my opinion, an earlier version of Hamlet. Laertes has a positive outlook on life and seems to make the best of his life.
Hamlets Flaw Essay Research Paper What is
Hamlets Flaw Essay, Research Paper What is Hamlet?s flaw???Nor to any one is he known to have defect. No one ever ventures to speak of him slightingly or critically. Why does not the King, Laertes, or
Compare And Contrast Macbeth
’s And Hamlet’s Madness Essay, Research Paper Madness can be described as an internal flaw that both characters, Hamlet and Macbeth, possess. Although their madness is different in some aspects, it can be said that
Hamlet Essay Research Paper Hamlet Hamlet is
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Hamlet Hamlet is the inner person of all mankind” as stated by actor Alan Bates. What did Mr. Bates mean by this? Could he be referring to the love, the corruption, the revenge, or the insanity displayed by Hamlet; or was he
Hamlet Play Review Essay Research Paper On
Hamlet Play Review Essay, Research Paper On Saturday October 14, 2000, the North Carolina Shakespeare festival put on a performance of Hamlet. This show, which was performed at the Carolina Theatre in Durham, North Carolina, was directed by _____________________, who also directed ____________________. ___________________ did a really good job at playing Hamlet, which is a very hard role to act for any actor.
Crazy Hamlet Essay Research Paper Crazy Hamlet
Crazy Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Crazy Hamlet Shakespeare The real question is Hamlet crazy or is he just acting it. In my opinion there are many things throughout the play that make me tend to believe that he is crazy. When Hamlet enters Opheliu”s room and she has the question if he is truly mad or if he is just acting.
Hamlet Essay Research Paper There are many
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper There are many reasons why one would think that Queen Gertrude is clueless about the murder of King Hamlet, yet others think she was involved in the murder. People have their own opinions on this but I believe that Queen Gertrude had an idea about the murder. There are many reasons and facts contributing to my opinion on this.
Hamlet Act I Essay Research Paper In
Hamlet Act I Essay, Research Paper In Act I of Hamlet, the ghost of the king hamlet comes to the battlement, outside a castle in Denmark. Marcellus and Horatio ask the ghost to speak, but
Hamlet Finding Courage To Die Essay Research
Paper Hamlet: Finding Courage to Die In William Shakespeare’s “Hamlet” we see a young man paralyzed with grief over his father. So much so that he is believed to have gone mad. Hamlet
Claudius In Hamlet Essay Research Paper ClaudiusA
Claudius In Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Claudius A Man Masked in Betrayal and Murder What could be worse than killing your brother? Marrying his wife right after! Claudius is the shadiest character in Act I of Hamlet. Claudius had poured the juice of a hebenon (henbane; a very poisonous plant) into his brother?s, Hamlet Sr.?s ear.
Hamlet The Movie Vs Hamlet Th Essay
, Research Paper Hamlet the Movie Hamlet the Play After reading Shakespeare s play Hamlet and viewing the video, Hamlet , many differences and similarities can be found. The video had many good qualities to it. Unfortunately it had many negative aspects also. The same applies for the book. Something s about it were great while other things could have been better.
Hamlet 12 Essay Research Paper Hamlet
Hamlet 12 Essay, Research Paper Hamlet’s “Tragic Flaw” Hamlet’s famous soliloquy (Hamlet, act III, scene 1) shows his depth and ability in thinking, and shows Shakespeare’s ability to manipulate language. Throughout the play, Hamlet stops to think before acting on anything. The more he thinks, the less he does.