Paper
Lessons of the Vietnam War
?American imperialism has suffered a stunning defeat in Indochina. But the same forces are engaged in another war, against a much less resilient enemy, the American people. Here, the prospects for sucess are much greater. The battleground is idealogical, not military. At stake are the lessons to be drawn from the American war in Indochina; the outcome will determine the course and character of new imperial ventures.?
(Noam Chomsky, 1975)
Quite often the lesson of history is that there’s no lesson. – when somebody, particularly a politician starts to tell you a “lesson” of history, pay attention – odds are you’re about to hear a lie, or something stupid.
So, what are the ?lessons? of Vietnam?
The assumption here is that there is almost something salvagable out of the whole mess, if only we can draw the right lessons from it. The United States Military has drawn three of these lessons from the Vietnam war. First, the military has drawn from Vietnam a reminder of the finite limits of American public support for US involvement in protracted conflict . . . Second, the military has taken from Vietnam a heightened awareness that civilian officials are responsive to influences other than the objective conditions on the battlefield . . . Finally, the military took from Vietnam a new recognition of the limits of military power in solving certain types of problems in world affairs. In particular, Vietnam planted doubts in many military minds about the ability of US forces to conduct successful large-scale counterinsurgencies.
Was the war right for American interests?
If we accept the logic of containment, it was right. But should we? It is clear in retrospect now that the Cold War is over, that American policymakers in the fifties and early 60s took that idea too literally, didn’t distinguish between different types of communists with enough precision, didn’t distinguish between essential and inessential American interests, took the idea of “national will” to absurd conclusions, proved to be completely incapable of making a decision to cut their losses, and in the case of Vietnam certainly, failed to understand that a communist could also be a nationalist first. Ho Chi Minh’s apparently sincere admiration for the Declaration of Independence stands as a reminder of an unexplored possibility.
Was the war winnable?
It may have been, if the U.S. acted early and decisively enough. However, there were many reasons why the U.S. government didn?t act decisively early- reasons like the lack of stable government in South Vietnam. Korea had already been proven to be a disaster, and the U.S. was worried about the reprecussions of their actions, the internal disagreement about whether Vietnam was really worth the effort in the first place, and of course the political considerations here in the United States. Think about the depth of Vietnamese nationalism, and the sucess of the communist party in directing that nationalism.
It seems as though the lessons mean nothing
Nevertheless, Vietnam changed a lot of things, and some of the “lessons”
are worth learning. The lesson of idealology is a big one. The great mistake of the anti-war movement was romanticizing the enemy, an enemy “who had little to teach us about how to conduct a modern democratic society.” The lesson of ideology is that it isn’t worth the death of millions of people. Containment wasn’t worth it. Make the spread of communism a political problem, not a militay one. The U.S. was certainly guilty of a kind of imperial arrogance – that we knew best what was best for what we saw as this dependent, backward, third world people. And the U.S. was certainly guilty of seeing the
Vietnamese not as themselves but as pawns in a larger game – what did the Russians and Chinese think? How was this playing in Europe? What did the latest poll numbers say? And U.S. leaders were certainly guilty of misleading the American people.
“This kind of moral corrosion has become all too familiar in the 20th century: the know-it-alls explain away all revolutionary abominations, try to turn the corner on utopian futures, and in the process become mirror-images of the absolutist authority they detest?. Even today, we hear voices on the left conjuring rationalizations for crimes?.”
(Todd Gitlin)
Unanswered Questions
As an individual, read these questions carefully. The class will then be asked to respond to them, and we will compare the ?answers? or suggestions.
Say a massive U.S. bombing and an invasion of North Vietnam had won a peace treaty in 1966- would it have lasted? Could it have?
Would U.S. policy have been different if Kennedy had lived? If watergate had not crippled Nixon?
Would U.S. society be more equal today if LBJ’s presidency had not been destroyed by Vietnam? Would it be less cynical if Nixon’s paranoia (largely due to protests against his war policies) had not led him into illegal activities? Would it be more united today if the anti-war movement had been more supportive of soldiers earlier?
Finally, was the war morally right? This was perhaps the most divisive question about the Vietnam War at the time and probably continues to be the most divisive.
33c
Другие работы по теме:
The US Involvement In Vietnam And The
Philippines Essay, Research Paper The US involvement in Vietnam and The Philippines Introduction Ever since the ?New Imperialist? era, the United States of America has become quite a large Neo-Imperialist power, particularly in The Philippines and also Vietnam. In order to understand this report the term Neo-Imperialism must be explained, this is when one country gives aid to another country in which the country that recieves aid becomes independent on the helping country.
Vietnam War Essay Research Paper The discussion
Vietnam War Essay, Research Paper The discussion of the Vietnam War and its affect on Americans. In this regard, the opinions and experiences of those who fought in the war, as well as those who stayed at
Vietnam Essay Research Paper Harold
Vietnam Essay, Research Paper Harold “Light Bulb” Bryant’s portrayals of life in the Vietnam War offend the human race. Not so much the actions Bryant displayed, but the demeanor of the U.S. armed forces. Through Bryant’s stories one comes to the conclusion that war made these people completely mad, and lost every bit of morality.
MadeUp Nixon Speech Essay Research Paper My
Made-Up Nixon Speech Essay, Research Paper My fellow Americans, I come to you tonight to ask for a hand to lend in my aide. I know that a great number of the silent majority would like to see the Vietnam war to finally come to a close. And, because of my campaign promise, I am standing here tonight to inform you that I have a plan of action that I shall use to uphold that promise.
U.S.A Was Unable To Win The Vietnam
War Because… Essay, Research Paper The U.S.A was unable to win the Vietnam War because they realised too late that the real war in Vietnam was not a military one but a political one.
To Kill A Mockingbird
– Lessons Scout Has Learned Essay, Research Paper This essay can be modified and used for self-benefit in any way. In To Kill a Mockingbird, a novel by Harper Lee, Jean Louise “Scout” Finch,
In 1969 The Plane Came Back Essay
, Research Paper In Kathryn L. Scott?s paper ?In 1969 The Plane Came Back? she addresses the issue of the affect of the Vietnam war on those who served in it.
Logical Intervention In Vietna Essay Research Paper
Logical Intervention in Vietnam American military intervention in Vietnam has always been a highly controversial issue. Many Americans were against intervention in Vietnam. Many Americans question rather the United States should have ever sent troops to Southeast Asia, and if intervention was the correct action, based on foreign policy and bipartisan ideas.
My Experience Essay Research Paper To whom
My Experience Essay, Research Paper To whom that cares!!! At this moment when i am sitting down here writting this, I suddenly think of this time last year when I was fresh out of highschool, hearing about Berea for the first time. I sent my application to Berea with lots of confidence and hope, and I knew I was not accepted.
How Important Was The My Lai Massacre
In Generating Support For The Peace Protest Movement? Essay, Research Paper The Peace Protest Movement was a time in the Vietnam war when people disagreed with it. This was because of a number of things. The amount of money it was costing, The amount of people killed, but it originated largely from the massacre at My Lai.
Killing Fields Essay Research Paper ESSAYThis essay
Killing Fields Essay, Research Paper ESSAY This essay will discuss the events that happened in Cambodia and how these events were similar to the war events that occurred in Vietnam, the essay will also discuss the important differences in the wars in both countries.
Why Do Bad Things Happen To Good
People Essay, Research Paper WHY DO BAD THINGS HAPPEN TO GOOD PEOPLE? Many people wonder why bad things happen to good people and the answer is quite simple. God wants to teach his servants one of his many lessons. In most cases, people tend not to learn any lessons if all they get is the good. On the other hand, if they experience some of the bad, on tends to learn an important life lesson.
Leadership Essay Research Paper The most meaningful
Leadership Essay, Research Paper The most meaningful and challenging experiences in my life have been through sports and the 4-H club. They have instilled the values of perseverance, confidence, and teamwork within me. I feel that my peers and others could learn valuable life lessons through participating in these organizations.
Vietnam Essay Research Paper Vietnam should the
Vietnam Essay, Research Paper Vietnam: should the U.S. have been involved? The Vietnam War created a great deal of controversy in America. Did America really have to sacrifice thousands of lives and millions of dollars? Was it America s duty to be involved in Vietnams affairs? Questions such as these are what derived such a constant debate during the time of the Vietnam War.
American Dream Of The Soldiers Of The
Vietnam War Essay, Research Paper ?When we first got here–all of us–we were real young and innocent, full of romantic bullshit, but we learned pretty damn quick.? This quote was extracted from the
Post Traumatic Stress Disorder Afflicting Vietnam Veterans
Essay, Research Paper Post Traumatic Stress Disorder afflicts a number of vietnam veterans who suffered extremely traumatic, and often consistent, experiences in the vietnam war. Many who do not understand the disorder at all view PTSD(post traumatic stress disorder) as an elaborate diagnosis for a vague set of symptoms that would otherwise be associated with other psycological problems.
Genocide Essay Research Paper GENOCIDEThe word genocide
Genocide Essay, Research Paper GENOCIDE The word ?genocide? has not been in existence for a very long: it was the jurist Lemkin who coined it between the two world wars. The thing itself is as old as humanity and there has never been a societ whose struture has preserved it from committing this crime.(Jean-Paul Sarte)
Norman Schwarzkopf Essay Research Paper Norman SchwarzkopfNorman
Norman Schwarzkopf Essay, Research Paper Norman Schwarzkopf Norman Schwarzkopf and I are alike in many ways. He and I both have family in Germany. His father lives in Germany and my great grandparents live in Germany. He served in Vietnam and so did my grandfather.
Platoon Truth Or Fiction Essay Research Paper
The Vietnam War was a military struggle fought in Vietnam from 1959 to 1975. It began as a determined attempt by Communist society (called Vietcong) in the South, backed by Communist North Vietnam, to overthrow the government of South Vietnam. The struggle widened into a war between South Vietnam and North Vietnam and eventually into an international conflict.
Vietnam Essay Research Paper Against the celebrated
Vietnam Essay, Research Paper -Against the celebrated and glorious backdrop of American history, the Vietnam War stands ghastly out of place. The war was an exercise in economic, military, and political futility. The greatest tragedy of the Vietnam War, however, stems from the unnecessary deaths of 58 000 young American boys and the installment of terror, mistrust, and sorrow in those who found a way to survive in an inferno where the laws of man were obsolete.
Racism Lessons Learned Essay Research Paper Many
Racism: Lessons Learned Essay, Research Paper Many things have been shared in this classroom environment. Issues have been studied that have caught the attention of the class and made them consider things that perhaps were not contemplated before. Over the past semester, one series of lessons have stood out to me more than any other.
Antiwar Movment In Vietnam Essay Research Paper
The antiwar movement against Vietnam in the US from 1965-1971 was the most significant movement of its kind in the nation’s history. The United States first became directly involved in Vietnam in 1950 when President Harry Truman started to underwrite the costs of France’s war against the Viet Minh. Later, the presidencies of Dwight Eisenhower and John F.
Desert Storm Compare And Contrast To Vietnam
War Essay, Research Paper Desert Storm and Vietnam were portrayed in the media are similar because in each the American soldiers had confidence when fighting, both were on tv, journalists and reporters were with soldiers on the battlefield. They were different because Desert Storm lasted six weeks and Vietnam was ten years plus.
Lyndon B Johnson Essay Research Paper Lyndon
Lyndon B. Johnson Essay, Research Paper Lyndon B. Johnson and American Liberalism Bruce J. Schulman This brief biography of Lyndon Johnson outlined his life beginning in rural Texas and followed the ups and downs of his political career. It discusses his liberal, “active government” mentality and its implications on both domestic and foreign issues.
My Lai Essay Research Paper THE MY
My Lai Essay, Research Paper THE MY LAI MASSACRE Boys will be boys. A commonly use quote. So what happens when a group of young men, who have just seen their best friend killed, goes on a search and destroy mission to face a village full of strangers from a distant land? You get the My Lai massacre. The whole village was wiped out by the US Eleventh Light Infantry Brigade.
Sasa Essay Research Paper The theme of
Sasa Essay, Research Paper The theme of a book is very important as to understanding what a novel is about as well as teaching a lesson in life. Authors sometimes write books with no theme in mind, but as the words flow from their pen, themes will emerge unknowingly. The themes are vital as to understanding what is happening within the story, and finding out the meaning.
The Change Essay Research Paper EssayIn this
The Change Essay, Research Paper Essay In this essay I am supposed to discuss a project or activity that best represents me. I thought about this for a while, and I decided I would talk about my piano lessons. My parents didn?t make me take them, and I didn?t take them because it was “just something to do.” There is a lot behind the story.
Why Did The Usa Become Involved In
Vietnam In The 1950S And 1960S Essay, Research Paper Why did the USA become involved in Vietnam in the 1950s and 1960s? The USA became involved in Vietnam because of a cry for help from the Vietnamese president of that time, Ngo Dinh Diem, or at least, they used it as an excuse for what they did. The Americans saw it as a prime example to the rest of the world of how capitalism could conquer communism.
The Lessons And Ghosts Of Vietnam Essay
?, Research Paper Peggy Thomas Czyzniejewski English 112H 9/16/99 The Lessons Learned from Vietnam Lorenzo M. Crowell discusses the lessons that Americans have learned from the Vietnam conflict in his article “The Lessons and Ghosts of Vietnam.” Crowell analyzes the lessons learned from Vietnam and applies them to the military strategies of today.
Vietnam Memorial Essay Research Paper At the
Vietnam Memorial Essay, Research Paper At the age of twenty one, a female undergraduate at Yale University named Maya Lin submitted her design for the Vietnam Memorial. Her idea
Vietnam Survey Essay Research Paper Survey of
Vietnam Survey Essay, Research Paper Survey of The Sixties and Early Seventies In the 1960 s, the baby boomers became teenagers and were growing up in the Cold War. Because of the threat of nuclear disaster, many of these young people felt they were living on the edge of disaster. Many of them blamed their elders who had grown up in the Depression and World War II , this created the generation gap .