, Research Paper
Comparison of Mansfield Park and Metropolitan
Whit Stillman’s attempt to capture Jane Austen’s novel Mansfield Park on film in Metropolitan is a fair adaptation but it is unable to give the viewer the same insights. Stillman manages to have most of Mansfield Parks characters represented in some way or another, however the time needed to develop those characters is simply not there in a two hour movie. It is this development that makes Jane Austen’s books so interesting. She spends an enormous amount of time telling us the backgrounds of the characters, especially Fanny Price. We are then able to interpret their actions knowing their motives and history, whereas in the movie we are often confused about certain behaviors. Stillman is able to capture some of the significant events in Mansfield but without the background, they have less meaning.
Whit Stillman could not simply parallel his characters one-for-one with the ones in Mansfield Park, rather he had to concentrate on including the significant characteristics of Austen’s characters, sometimes in more than one person. If he had tried to copy the nature of the Mansfield Park people the movie would not have been believable. Viewers would not like a perfect character like Fanny, in fact they would probably distrust her more because she was perfect. At the beginning of the movie Audrey Rouget is introduced, obviously meant to be a version of Fanny Price. She is shy, slight, and the appears to be younger than the rest of the group. Like Fanny, she really hasn’t “come out” yet. At first, she is enamored with Tom Townsend, then hates him for leaving her looking stupid when he was supposed to be her escort. The viewer has a hard time with this because they have only known each other for a week or so, and that makes Audrey’s feelings seem trivial. With the benefit of a whole summer of the story, the reader of Mansfield is able to relate with such strong feelings because they are baked up by several examples, not just one. At the end of the movie Audrey sees that Tom cares for her a lot when he comes to “save” her from Rick Von Slonaker. Audrey is not an exact copy of Fanny though, this is shown when she acquiesces to playing in the groups cigarette/truth-telling game. Austen did not allow Fanny to participate in the play at Mansfield, but Stillman adds this touch to show that Audrey has faults which makes the viewer identify better with her.
While Audrey exhibits the nature of Fanny, the movies main character is Tom Townsend and the story centers mostly around him. Similar to Fanny, we see him in almost every scene. However, Tom’s character is a combination of Henry Crawford and Edward Price. After he first appears, he is received in much the same manner as Henry Crawford was in Mansfield. He joins up with a close knit group of friends and is accepted immediately. The women in the group all quiz him about college and insist he come to every party. Audrey takes a liking to him, but is afraid to tell him of her affections because she has never really liked anyone. Tom apparently likes her, but then he gets back together with his old girlfriend Serena Slocum and this breaks Audrey’s heart. Stillman only lets one girl in the group fall for Tom because the viewers would not believe it if all of them fell for him like Julia and Maria for Henry in Mansfield. Since the viewers do not have time enough to learn a bout Tom, they make a first impression based upon his looks, and because he’s not the best looking character they could not see him arriving and stealing all the girls without objection. Once the viewer learns a little more about Tom, about midway through the movie, he begins to take on characteristics of Edward Price. He starts to care about Audrey once he realizes that she feels hurt by him admitting he liked Serena the best, and he is convinced she is running off with Rick Von Sloneker, who interestingly enough also has Henry Crawford traits. The difference between him and Tom is that Rick has all the traits Fanny attributes to Henry, basically being a slime ball with women, while Tom is seen the way all the other characters in Mansfield view Henry, as good company with pleasant airs about him. This shows the viewer that perspective is very important when judging others. While watching Metropolitan, the viewer identifies with Tom Townsend and thinks that Audrey is basically an ultra-sensitive girl. While reading Mansfield Park, the reader identifies with Fanny Price and sees all of Henry Crawford’s poor qualities. Tom then does as Edward would when he and Charlie try to go and “save” Audrey and Cynthia from the clutches of Von Sloneker.
Nick Smith also appears originally having Mrs. Norris’s attitude. He is always disparaging someone or other and giving his opinion to everyone, whether or not he is asked. Then he gets caught making up a story about Rick Von Sloneker, and loses face in front of the group. He is constantly insulting people, especially Von Sloneker and the audience sees him as arrogant and selfish, like Mrs. Norris. He looks down on Tom for not being quite as well of as the rest of them and tries to help him become more fashionable “out of the goodness of his heart”. Mrs. Norris also claims to care for everyone above herself, but the reader sees right through that. She is just a control freak nobody even listens to. Nick goes away near the end of the movie like Mrs. Norris in Mansfield, and nobody seems to miss either too much. However, in another twist to modernize the plot line, Stillman shows that Rick Von Sloneker really is a slime ball at the end of the movie. This vindicates Nick, even though his story about Von Sloneker may have been false, he is right about him so the viewer is able to give him some credit later. While in Mansfield Park, the reader is happy that Mrs. Norris got what was coming to her because she was really bad, the viewer of Metropolitan sees that Nick at least had a good heart and tried to warn everyone about Von Sloneker. Austin has other characters say that Mrs. Norris was basically caring and sensitive inside, but she makes sure that the reader does not believe them.
Stillman includes the jealousy of the character Charlie Black to also help make the movie appeal to more modern themes. He does this to assuage the feelings the audience is having about Tom. They have a hard time believing he is so readily accepted into the group. In real life, most people would be a lot more wary about newcomers. Established groups in our culture do not just take in strangers off the street and say “have our girls and come to all our parties!”. There isn’t any reference to how long the group has been together, but it seems to have been for a long time. Charlie’s jealousy is important to make the group seem like real people living in Manhattan upper crust society. The viewers may not identify with the socialite characters in Metropolitan, but by ascribing “normal” characteristics to them, the audience can see them as somewhat believable. Since the viewer of Metropolitan does not have the benefit of knowing the past history of the group, how they came together and the relationships each member has with another, Stillman has to make the characters believable to the layman. Austin, on the other hand, had the benefit of as much time as she wanted to develop the characters in Mansfield. Most readers in England in the 19th century probably looked upon the characters in Mansfield as very different from themselves. In fact they probably identified with the Price family much more than the Bertram’s, much like people of today do not relate with the urban bourgeois of Metropolitan.
After reading the novel Mansfield Park and watching the movie Metropolitan, it is very evident that Metro is Whit Stillman’s attempt to modernize the novel. He might have been able to do a great job if he had simply rewrote the novel in modern terms, but the simple fact is that he was forced to cut away with a lot of the character developments and plot lines to fit the time frame of a movie. The reader of Mansfield can see where Stillman tries to embody characters in Metropolitan and since they have read the book, they can identify with the group by substituting the background given in the novel to the movie. If the viewer of Metropolitan had no experience either with Mansfield or Austin in general, than the movie would fail to impart the exploration into human nature that was her trademark. It is very clear that Metropolitan can not stand by itself as a work of great value without the reader being familiar with Austen’s literary works, specifically Mansfield Park.
Другие работы по теме:
The Characterization Of Miss Brill Essay Research
Paper In the Bedford Introduction to Literature, Characterization is defined as “… the process by which a writer makes that character seem real to the reader”(2126). In order to do this a writer has multiple tools at their disposal that add to the depth of a character and simplify roles in a story. This includes the use of Protagonists and Antagonists, static and dynamic characters, showing and telling, and motivated and plausible action, as well as many others.
Critical Analysis
– Miss Brill Essay, Research Paper The story Miss Brill, written by Katherine Mansfield, is an analysis of a woman who lives her life through the observation of others. It is written in third person, from the subjective point of view of the title character. Throughout the story, the author uses many characterization techniques to convey to the reader a true expression of the woman s unusual personality.
What Changes Have Taken Place In This
Area Around The Lee Valley Essay, Research Paper The Lee Valley Regional Park Authority was set up in 1967 by an act of parliament to develop the areas along the Lee, many
Summary Of The Setting In
“The Garden Party” By Katherine Mansfield Essay, Research Paper 2000-02-07 A summary of the setting in “The Garden-Party” by Katherine Mansfield. The setting in the book The Garden-Party is a very central element in the story. It is a beautiful summer day and a respectable family are having a garden party.
Orient Express Essay Research Paper A twenty
Orient Express Essay, Research Paper A twenty year old pitcher named Chan Ho Park is in the Korean baseball league on the L.A. Dodgers recruiting team. Every scout was scared to recruit him because of
Character And Point Of View Analysis Of
Miss Essay, Research Paper Katherine Mansfield, in her short story Miss Brill , slowly reveals the nature of her main character. She gradually divulges Miss Brill s personality, leading the reader to believe things about Miss Brill that are not true. Also, the point of view tt Mansfield uses enhances the story and adds to the reader s misinterpretation of Miss Brill until the end of the story.
Miss Brill Essay Research Paper The Third
Miss Brill Essay, Research Paper The Third Person-Point of View as used by Katherine Mansfield in “Miss Brill” Katherine Mansfield s use of the third person, limited omniscient point of view
Miss Brill
– Characterization Essay, Research Paper Miss Brill – Characterization We live in a real world where real people communicate and interact with one another. However, there are a few people in this world who seem to be out of touch with reality and live their life through dreams like the main character in Katherine Mansfield s short story Miss Brill.
The Lee Valley Regional Park Essay Research
Paper The Lee Valley Regional Park Authority was set up in 1967 by an act of parliament to develop the areas along the Lee, many of them by then dis-used and derelict,? for recreation and nature
Barbara Goldsmith Other Powers Essay Research Paper
Barbara Goldsmith, author of Other Powers, demonstrated many times throughout the book that sexual relationships were spheres of force relations in which power is displayed. One such sexual relationship where there were spheres of force relations, in which power was displayed, is the relationship between Roxanna (Roxy) Hummel Claflin and Reuben Buckman (Buck) Claflin, where Buck had great power over his wife Roxy.
Miss Brill By Mansfield Essay Research Paper
Katherine Mansfield?s short story ?Miss Brill? outlines an old woman?s lack of understanding for a world that she observes so intimately. The story is told from the point of view of an aging insignificant character, who on this
Miss Brill Essay Research Paper The point
Miss Brill Essay, Research Paper The point of view that Katherine Mansfield has chosen to use in “Miss Brill” serves two purposes. First, it illustrates how Miss Brill herself views the world and, second, it helps the reader take the same journey of burgeoning awareness as Miss Brill.
Commentary On Miss Brill Essay Research Paper
Miss Brill is a shortstory by Katherine Mansfield seen from a limited omniscient view. The main character and host character for the narrator is Miss Brill, an English teacher who lives in a country with a french speaking population. The observations on which I base these conclutions are the fact that Miss Brill thinks about her english students and visits the Jardins Publicues, french for public park.
Miss Brill Essay Research Paper
Katherine Mansfield’s short story “Miss Brill” is an extremely good example of how a writer can use different literary aspect to bring about an understanding of Miss Brill the character. The use of literary aspects to reveal some truth about a character to the reader are often referred to as characterization.
Miss Brill Essay Research Paper Miss Brill
Miss Brill Essay, Research Paper Miss Brill: Point of View The narrator in the story “Miss Brill” by Katherine Mansfield, is telling us this story in the third person singular perspective. Our narrator is a non-participant and we learn no details about this person, from a physical sense. Nothing to tell us whether it is a friend of Miss Brill, a relative, or just someone watching.
Jurassic Park Essay Research Paper The story
Jurassic Park Essay, Research Paper The story Jurassic Park, by Michael Crichton takes place on a small island near Costa Rica, it s about a park full of dinosaurs created by Dr. Hammond. The
Comparison Essay Essay Research Paper Comparison EssayThere
Comparison Essay Essay, Research Paper Comparison Essay There are many different ways to explain the beginning and creation. Genesis and Edith Hamilton?s ?Mythology,? are two of many literary works you can find. Both show how characters were created and formed. They give detailed understanding and examples of creation.
The Doll
’s House Essay Essay, Research Paper The Doll’s House Essay A contributing factor to the story “The Doll s House” by Katherine Mansfield is the characterization of Kezia as she travels in her innocence through the symbolic world of experience. Kezia is essential to the plot because she represents a taboo, offering opposition to common ways of thinking.
Lea Valley 2
Lea Valley – Where Is The Area Under Study Essay, Research Paper The Lea Valley Regional Park is in Picketts Lock, it is along the A1055. In this area there is recreational land use (golf course
Virginia Woolf And Her Friendships With Women
Essay, Research Paper Virginia Woolf – Friendships With Women Virginia Woolf was sexually abused as a child. While the extent and duration of this abuse is difficult to establish, it is known that two of her older stepbrothers sexually harassed and abused her between the ages of twelve and twenty-one and perhaps as early as six.
Miss Brill Exposed Essay Research Paper Miss
Miss Brill Exposed Essay, Research Paper Miss Brill EXPOSED! Katherine Mansfield s short story , Miss Brill, is a tale of a woman operating at the outer fringe of reality, told from the third person omniscient point of view. The mannerly, refined Miss Brill is an observer of life, one who sits on the sidelines while the game of life is played without her.
Get In Essay Research Paper Click Here
Get In Essay, Research Paper Click Here If YOU Have Friends! Can’t find the paper you need? Try Collegiate Care Comparing Casablanca to 1984 Charlie Parker at Storyville
Mansfield Park And Mary Crawfo Essay Research
Paper The Character of Mary Crawford It can be useful to examine the values and ideas of a novel through the character and portrayal of one character. Mary Crawford is a character central to the themes and
Jane Eyre And Fanny Price Essay Research
Paper A comparison between Jane Eyre and Fanny Price There are many things that can be compared between Jane Eyre and Fanny Price, and I will focus on the fact that they are both orphans that grow up to be independent women. The two are so different yet also so much the same. In the following analysis, I will compare these two characters and decide who can be viewed as the stronger character.
Resource Extraction In Provincial Parks Essay Research
Paper The Value of Resources Extraction in Provincial Parks According to section 7 (3) of the Provincial Parks Act of 1993 companies are permitted to resource development or resource extraction from a provincial park as long as it does not compromise the main purpose of the park. This means, if a park is created for recreational purposes and there is a logging company that wishes to move in they would be more than welcome to.
Jurassic Park Essay Research Paper Jurassic Park
Jurassic Park Essay, Research Paper Jurassic Park is a book about the cloning of dinosaurs and they are used as the park entertainment on an island. In this park where dinosaurs are the attraction, not every thing will go as planed. Reading this book will teach someone how Michael Crichton feels about biological science and the cloning of extinct animals.
Mansfield Park Essay Research Paper Mansfield Park
Mansfield Park Essay, Research Paper Mansfield Park This novel, originally published in 1814, is the first of Jane Austen’s novels not to be a revised version of one of her pre-1800 writings. Mansfield Park has sometimes been
Mrs Brill Essay Research Paper Mrs BrillMrs
Mrs. Brill Essay, Research Paper Mrs. Brill Mrs. Brill, a short story by Katherine Mansfield, takes place in Jardins Publiques seaside town in France. The story is about an elder lady by the name of Mrs. Brill who frequents a nearby park on Sundays to hear a band play. Before leaving to the park she removed her fur.
Jurrasic Park Essay Research Paper Jurassic Park
Jurrasic Park Essay, Research Paper Jurassic Park Jurassic Park takes place on an Island off the Coast of Costa Rica which is owned by a multimillionaire, John Hammond. On this island he has set up a genetical engineering facility which permits him and his scientist to create dinosaur from blood extracted from prehistoric mosquitos, that have been preserved in amber.
The Park Essay Research Paper A couple
The Park Essay, Research Paper A couple of months ago I went to the park with my nephew. I remember the day like is was yesterday. The weather was cool and clouds were overhead. I sat by myself and watched him play and watched everything happen around me. I wasn?t expecting to find so many interesting things just watching people, but amazed at what I did discover.
Grand Canyon Essay Research Paper Grand Canyon
Grand Canyon Essay, Research Paper Grand Canyon National Park Grand Canyon National Park was established in 1919. Located in northern Arizona, the park contains the world-famous Grand Canyon of the Colorado River and includes the river?s entire course from the southern end of Glen Canyon to the eastern boundary of Lake Mead (Microsoft Encarta Encyclopedia).