Non-Consensual Speech: Lying Essay, Research Paper
Lies injure those who believe them. If a lie is about a person, and the lie is believed and acted upon, the person lied about is also injured. Thus lying involves at least one non-consenting party. By lying, of course, I do not mean fiction. Reasonable people (becoming scarcer all the time) know that fiction is not literally true. Fighting lies with the truth is the best strategy, but this strategy is often difficult because wealth, power, and access to the media are so unfairly distributed within our society. Thus seeking legal redress through civil suit is also a reasonable recourse.
The relation between information and action must be clearly understood. Information never “causes” action. Information belongs to a different realm of discourse than matter and energy. Information cannot be measured in units of mass, energy, force, etc. Information thus has no direct physical effect. Censors of left and right continually equate the obvious indirect effects of speech upon thought with direct causes of action, and rely upon this equation to justify censorship.
Our brains process information. We evaluate information and make decisions, and these decisions lead to action. The process, of course, can be short circuited. When we respond instantly to someone shouting “Fire!” we have not processed fire as information. We’ve responded to a stimulus, using primitive parts of our nervous systems. Information processing, like stimulus-response reactions, evolved because it helps us survive.
Give people false information and they may make terrible decisions and do terrible things. People, of course, have a responsibility to be skeptical. People should be very wary, for example, about believing anything they read in the Weekly World News or The New York Times. But sometimes reasonable people believe lies and innocent people are injured as a result. In such cases, it is just to grant people a legal cause of action. Both civil and criminal penalties may be appropriate. That’s why we have laws against libel, slander, fraud, false advertising, and falsely shouting “Fire!”.
I don’t, however, under any circumstances support laws against “dangerous” books, regardless of the amount of misinformation they contain. For example, an unsuccessful attempt was made to sue the authors of a book called The Courage to Heal. Many people believe (I am one of them) that this particular book abounds in false information that has caused, and will continue to cause, immeasurable harm. (I don’t believe, however, that the authors’ intent was malicious: I presume that they believe what they’ve written and that their hope was to help people, not to hurt them.) Although I disagree vigorously with its content, I believe absolutely that The Courage to Heal is protected by the First Amendment.
The limits-to-lying argument, of course, can be taken to absurd extremes. Examples of this are attempts to ban speech that “libels” groups, not individuals. If you permit this, it could become illegal to criticize any group whatsoever–even (or especially) Republicans. Another absurdity is the claim of anti-pornography activists that pornography should be banned because it “defames” women or tells men that women want to be raped. (Some pornography, of course, asserts that women enjoy sex and some censorship advocates–such as Andrea Dworkin–believe that intercourse and rape are equivalent.) But pornography is fantasy and is not taken literally by reasonable people. As for unreasonable people, who knows what can set them off?
I’m unsure whether permitting victims of malicious lies legal redress is an “exception that proves the rule” or a true First Amendment exception. I don’t support any form of prior restraint. And sanctions against lying are not content based. That is, truth or falsehood is not a form of “content” but rather a relationship between speech and reality. Nevertheless, permitting legal redress for lying certainly has a “chilling” effect, and this chilling effect can in some instances constitute censorship. In Britain, for example, it is much easier to sue for libel than it is in the US. I much prefer the more stringent libel requirements that exist in America.
33f
Другие работы по теме:
Speech Essay Research Paper SpeechKennedy I don
Speech Essay, Research Paper Speech Kennedy, I don’t know much about you so I have to make something up. Maybe you can change it a little according to how you like it. I cannot help you much on this speech, it is up to you to tell people about yourself. I’m not quite sure how to help you on this one actually. Because you would be telling the class about yourself.
100 Essay Research Paper Sonnet 69
100 Essay, Research Paper Sonnet 69 Can you feel it as my lips touch your skin Ready to share our everlasting love You whisper my name as we are to begin A rose lies by our side, white as a dove
Quotation Speech Essay Research Paper Quotation SpeechHarvey
Quotation Speech Essay, Research Paper Quotation Speech Harvey Fierstein once said ?Never be bullied into silence. Never allow yourself to be made a victim. Accept no one?s definition of your life; define yourself.? Only you can define yourself . . . there?s something so special about that concept; something so intimate about the fact that only you can control your destiny.
Heart Of Darkness Essay Research Paper A
Heart Of Darkness Essay, Research Paper A lie is an untruth. It can be a false statement or a statement left unsaid which causes someone to be misled. In life, lies are told for many different
Truth Or Lie Essay Research Paper January
Truth Or Lie? Essay, Research Paper January 31, 2000 Truth or Lie ….??? The truth should be told most of the time. I do not think however that lying should be put out of our mind because sometimes lying is the only option we have. Lying can be a good thing and a bad thing. Depending on the situation we should analyze it and find out if telling the truth would inflict more harm or lying would.
The Great Gatsby Tragedy From Lies Essay
, Research Paper The Great Gatsby: Tragedy From Lies In the world people try to hide things from each other but one way or another they find out what they are hiding. In the Great Gatsby by F. Scott
Motivation Speech Essay Research Paper IV BROADCAST
Motivation Speech Essay, Research Paper IV. BROADCAST PROGRAMMING: BASIC LAW AND POLICY The First Amendment and federal law generally prohibit the FCC from censoring material in broadcasting. Stations choose the material they determine as best for their community. The FCC does not advise on artistic standards, formats, grammar or the quality of their programming.
How To Get Out Of A Speeding
Ticket Essay, Research Paper How to Get Out of a Speeding Ticket There are many approaches that we humans use to weasel out of a speeding ticket. This is not an easy task, but it has been mastered by a select few. The very reasonable way of just not speeding is used quite often. The method of lying is frequently used.
Lying Essay Research Paper The whole truth
Lying Essay, Research Paper The whole truth and nothing but the truth. If these were words to live by then some of us be in trouble. Most people make a habit out of lying on a daily basis. Everyone tells a lie every now and then. Most lies are those little white lies, the ones to keep out of trouble, and the stupid ones that make no sense.
Effects Of The Speeches Of Brutus And
Antony Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar is one of Shakespeare’s greatest works. It’s about a group of conspirators who kill their king, Julius, in order to be free. Antony, opposed to the assassination, felt that he should avenge Julius’s death. He delivered a speech that convinced the Romans that the murder was unjust, invoking their rebellion.
Crucible Lying Essay Research Paper Notes for
Crucible Lying Essay, Research Paper Notes for an essay on human weaknesses that are prominent in the Crucible Lying (pg. 10 – Abigail Williams) Abigail lied to Parris when he asked if she had
Antony Speech Analysis Essay Research Paper Emotional
Antony Speech Analysis Essay, Research Paper Emotional Speech Analysis William Shakespeare?s ?Julius Caesar? is a well-written stage play. Shakespeare included many good speeches in his plays; one of the best was the one delivered by Antony. Antony?s speech came very shortly after Julius Caesar?s death, and the city was in much chaos.
The Movies Essay Research Paper The speaker
The Movies Essay, Research Paper The speaker in the movie viewed in class on February 5, 2001 gave a very good presentation on the procedures performed during C.P.R. and the benefits of knowing this life saving procedure. Although the speech was audience capturing, there were a few improvements that would have helped improve her presentation.
Bc Speech Assignment Essay Research Paper Research
Bc Speech Assignment Essay, Research Paper Research Assignment #4 Your fourth speech is a research-based persuasive speech. Since your primary goal will be to convince your audience to take a specific action your research burden is higher. Your research is due via email on the date listed on your course schedule.
Persuasive Speech Essay Research Paper Christopher AdairPersuasive
Persuasive Speech Essay, Research Paper Christopher Adair Persuasive Speech To begin with I need an attention getter, so I thought I would get their attention by vaguely suggesting something about a decision everyone has to make when they are sixteen. From there I will tell everyone how and why I am qualified to give this presentation, and why it is important to listen to what I have to say.
Mom Essay Research Paper Death of an
Mom Essay, Research Paper Death of an Innocent I went to a party mom, I remembered what you said. You told me not to drink, Mom, so I drank soda instead. I really felt proud inside, Mom, the way you said I would.
Filtered Speech Experiment Essay Research Paper Filtered
Filtered Speech Experiment Essay, Research Paper Filtered Speech Experiment Purpose The purpose of the filtered speech experiment was to look for three things. The first was to see/hear which frequencies can be eliminated from speech signal and conversely which frequencies can not in order to understand speech.
The Art Of Lying Essay Research Paper
THE ART OF LYING Lying. People have been lying since the beginning of time. Some people are good at it, and some people are horrible at it. There are some that have mastered the art and make money at it. Lawyers, for example, are known for their skill as liars. Whatever profession, hobby, or special interest that brings us to communicate with others a person has will bring the art of lying in to play.
Lying
– Is Lying Morally Wrong? Essay, Research Paper Lisa RiceEnglish 101-03 Lupica-Scott Essay # 5Lying Is lying morally wrong? If you ask most people if they lie, the answer is answered quickly as ?No? but is that a lie in itself. We like to think of ourselves as honest, righteous people, therefore, we lie to ourselves about lying.
Gilbert
’s “In Lying In Bed” Essay, Research Paper Gilbert Keith Chesterton was one of the greatest English authors ever to live. He wrote many essays and novels. He had much time to do this because he was a large man and could not move around easily. In Gilbert’s essay, “In Lying in Bed” his deep understanding of humanity clearly evident.
Prom Speech Essay Research Paper 2000 SpeechWhen
Prom Speech Essay, Research Paper 2000 Speech When we were younger, we couldn t wait to graduate from high school and be done with school. Well, now it s here and we are still pretty exited to be finished, but graduation has taken on a whole new meaning for us.
Lies Of The Crucible Essay Research Paper
LIES OF THE CRUCIBLE Lying has always been considered to be one of the worst things man could do. Yet almost anyone who has ever spoken a word in their life has lied at one point or another. The truth is that lying comes naturally. Lying is an easy way out of situations that could get us in trouble. It truly is an act of pure selfishness.
Lying To Children Essay Research Paper Lying
Lying To Children Essay, Research Paper Lying to Children The environment children grow in is a major contributor in shaping their behavior. Parents must be good role models for their children. If a parent lies to his child, the child will eventually assume that it is OK to tell lies. They will start lying and use more lies to cover up for them selves or for friends.
Why Tim O
’brien Lies Essay, Research Paper Why Tim O Brien Lies All of us are guilty of lying at one time or another. Whether it was a little white lie like whether the toothfairy is real or not, or if it was something significant, such as if you committed a serious crime, we have all done it. Lying is definitely a part of society, and no one really likes it or appreciates it.
Speech Essay Research Paper There are two
Speech Essay, Research Paper There are two opposite points of view to this problem. One side suggests not to place any cods on speech on campuses of college institutions and another side strongly believes that speech must be protected by law. Mrs. Jennifer Kelley is following position of free speech in the article called Speech Codes Should Not Be Permitted on Campuses.
Socrates Lying Arguments Essay Research Paper Socrates
Socrates: Lying Arguments Essay, Research Paper Socrates: Lying Arguments Socrates is a man of great controversy. He has been portrayed as many different personalities such as a sophist to a great philosopher to just a vocal old man. The true nature of Socrates is to be questioned. He spoke his thoughts on life and what his philosophy on life was.
Speech On Blacks Essay Research Paper Blacks
Speech On Blacks Essay, Research Paper Blacks on the Eastern Shore I enjoyed Clara Smalls presentation about blacks on the eastern shore. It was interesting to learn that in the early 1600?s blacks were primarily indentured servants. Blacks only worked for so long then could be released. Some blacks even owed land and had slaves of their own.
It Ain
’t Easy Being A Child Essay, Research Paper I know I haven’t been an easy child, But love for you lies underneath my whims; There is no way I could be tame or mild: I need sometimes to shout and wave my
Why Do We Lie Essay Research Paper
Oops, I just told a lie. It was a little white lie but still, I lied. Why did I lie? What an interesting thought: Why? After thinking about this most complex question I came up with a variety of reasons why people find justification in lying. Be mindful that most of my thoughts stem from books or articles I have read about the not so honest people living in society.
Othello Essay Research Paper OthelloIn Othello we
Othello Essay, Research Paper Othello In Othello, we encounter Iago, one of Shakespeare?s most evil characters. Iago is an officer in Othello’s army and is jealous of Cassio’s promotion to Lieutenant. Through deception and appearance, we see many lies and clever schemes unfold. The astonishing thing about Iago is that he seems to make up his malicious schemes as he goes along without any planning.
Demonstration Critique Essay Research Paper Demonstration Critique
Demonstration Critique Essay, Research Paper Demonstration Critique During my demonstration speech, I was affected by my speech anxiety. Some of the viewable symptoms were the shaking of my hands and also the stuttering of speech. I was able to control myself and relax after I started getting into my information.
The World Essay Research Paper In an
The World Essay, Research Paper In an important speech, oral delivery is key, ingredients to oral delivery are tone, volume, rate, enthusiasm and clarity, how