Paper
We only choose what we think is good and
if anyone chooses evil it must be through ignorance.
Ignorance is not an excuse
Molly Schweiger
Philosophy 110, Section 07 01
David Turpin, 4-23-01
Plato believes that we always choose good unless we are ignorant. Plato claims being ignorant would be the only excuse for choosing evil. His views of this are apparent in the Meno. As I read up on whether or not we deliberately choose evil I realized there are many sides, many ways to answer this question. My opinion is not as clear as I thought. In this paper I will go through numerous writings on this subject, such as the Meno. The writings by Augustine and Descartes basically support Plato’s argument. While comparing all the writings I hope that I can come up with a conclusion of my own.
During the conversation between Meno and Socrates Socrates urges Meno, through his method of asking questions, that nobody really desires evil. At the beginning Meno believes people do desire good and evil. Socrates says to Meno, that to desire an evil is to desire harm and misery. Meno eventually admits that no one desires evil because no one would ever desire harm or misery. They come to this conclusion, but they make sure to point out that ignorant people can still desire evil because they believe the evils to be good. This still goes along with their belief; no one truly desires what they know to be an evil (Pojman 67).
Overall, I think Socrates and Meno come to this conclusion very rationally. I would agree that anyone who does not desire harm or misery would not choose evil unless they are ignorant and do not really know it is evil. On the other hand I do believe there are some horrible people who do desire harm or misery. Unfortunately, we know in our world today that people choose to harm others. Take Timothy McVeigh, just for example. He knew when he put that bomb in the building in Okalahoma City that it would cause harm and misery to many people. Also, it is quite apparent that Mr. McVeigh is not ignorant. He happens to be a very smart man. Here is a perfect example of someone choosing harm, or evil without having the excuse of being ignorant. Unfortunately, we know there are many more people in the world like this. I give Plato the benefit of the doubt for his opinion because maybe in the time period he lived there were not these extreme examples of people choosing evils on purpose, without the excuse of ignorance.
Augustine’s writings on Free Will contain a segment about whether or not to choose sin. Augustine starts in the Garden of Eden, where all Christians believe everything began. Augustine states that in the Garden of Eden there were God’s commandments from above and the serpent’s, the Devil’s, suggestions from below. God’s commandments are the good and the suggestions from the serpent are evil. Augustine is real blunt when explaining what he believes. He says that if a person has reached a state of wisdom he shall have no problem in not succumbing to the suggestions from the serpent below. He states that even fools, the ignorant, will eventually be able to move on to a state of wisdom. They will then be able to overcome the evil suggestions of the serpent. Augustine does write that those who find wisdom after ignorance will have a problem letting go of the “sweetness” of the evil things they have become accustomed to (Pojman 407).
Again, I see the rational of Augustine’s argument. Being a Christian myself, I know and believe in the whole story of the Garden of Eden. The serpent came into the garden and tempted Eve with sweet fruit from the tree. When Eve took the fruit this is said to be the origin of sin. So the question is, did Eve choose evil? Did she know she was choosing evil? It is hard to specify. I guess I believe that Eve was in an ignorant state when she chooses to eat the fruit. She did not know the consequences of her actions. She knew she was not supposed to take the fruit, but she really did not understand what would happen if she did. This leads me to a dilemma. In saying what I just did about Eve taking the fruit this is saying that the origin of sin, of choosing evil, was caused by ignorance. This backs up what Augustine and the other philosophers stated. Then there is the present. Is evil inevitable now? I believe to a point it is, but we can no longer blame it on ignorance. We know the story of the Garden of Eden, we know the devil is tempting us with evils, and we know what the consequences could be if we choose the evil. This shows we are not ignorant like Eve was; we are in the state of wisdom. After all that is true we still choose evils, ignorance can not be used as an excuse.
Descartes, in his fourth meditation, argues th choice of good or evil in a different way. He first states why his will power and understanding are not to blame for his mistakes. Both the power of willing and the power of understanding come from God. Therefore, he says the power of willing is perfect and everything he understands he understands correctly. Therefore the reason for his mistakes, choosing evil, is the “scope of the will”. This is larger than the intellect. This means he makes mistakes because he does not have the means to understand the mistakes he is making (Pojman 479).
When comparing Descartes to Augustine and Plato I believe his argument to be the least logical. Basically, to me, his argument sounds like a big excuse. I believe we are all capable of understanding the difference between good and evil. The only people who are not able to always understand are young children. In their case it is our job to teach them what is right and wrong. Saying that the will is made of a much wider spectrum than our understanding is ridiculous. For those who are ignorant this is of course true, but I do not believe, as I have stated before, that all those who choose evil are ignorant.
As I researched more on this topic I found some interesting arguments supporting or deterring from the idea that ignorance causes someone to choose evil. One man that states something deterring is Plotinus. Plotinus is considered to be the founder of Neoplatonism. He started out by reading Plato. Plotinus believes the soul can become lost. It can forget what it has previously experienced or learned. In some cases this leads the soul to find evil. Plotinus recognizes this as nothing else but “misplaced desire for the good” (utm.edu/research/iep/p/plotinus/htm). This does not mean to me that the person is ignorant, just lost for the time being. Forgetful of what they have previously learned as good and evil. Even at the end of Meno, Socrates and Meno come to the conclusion that all knowledge is recollection. Therefore, to know goodness and evil we need to recall past experiences that have taught us the difference (Pojman 73).
I found this passage from Plotinus; “Evil, however, is not irremediable, since it is merely the result of privation (the soul’s privation, through forgetfulness, of its prior), and so evil is remedied by the soul’s experiences of love” (utm.edu/research/iep/p/plotinus/htm). I find this to be so beautiful and truthful. After all my reading and contemplating over what I believe, this is it. People choose evil because they have forgotten what they have learned, what they know to be right. Somewhere along the way they have lost their morals they need for deciding between good and evil. This does not mean they don’t know it’s evil, they do. They are for some reason not choosing to listen to the little voice in their head telling them not to choose the evil. Plotinus and I believe that through love from an outside source they can remember. They can recall their misplaced desire for good and evil. Maybe this is too much of a dreamer’s view, but I always like to look at the bright side of things.
Другие работы по теме:
Drugs Essay Research Paper DrugsDrugs What do
Drugs Essay, Research Paper Drugs Drugs. What do we know about drugs? What do we imagine when we say this word? White powder or a young person, wiping out any possibility for his future to grow, killing him slowly. Drugs came in our life and destroyed any relations between parents and children. I say “any” because this is the word, defining exactly what happens when a child starts taking drugs.
Why The Hell Is It Always Me
…….. Essay, Research Paper i’m not happy oright..i feel sad..i wanna give up…i don’t know what si wrong with me …i can’t handle relationships…i don’t what i want..how i feel…i feel too much pressure…i don’t wanna see anyone, i don’t wanna anything..i need to get out of this fucked country…people are annoying me..i can’t stand their attitudes…why is it that i do wrong all the time..or feel like i do, why do i feel like i’m the enemy…why can’t i do anything right for once…why is nobody ever happy 4 me….why do i feel like i have no place..no home..my parents are always annoyed with me about something….i can’t ever do anything right for them..my sisters can never do anything wrong…..they want it they get it…they need it they will have it..why do i have to beg for it..work for it…scrimp for it…worry about will i have enough gas in the car..or will i have to ask mom/dad for the money…then
Ferinheit 451 Essay Research Paper Sysco GonzalezEnglish
Ferinheit 451 Essay, Research Paper Sysco Gonzalez English II “Ferinheit 451″ 1) An even that puzzled me as I read this story is how people could be so ignorant in a world that book burning was a good thing. Books were told to have no significance to anyone and this was just accepted and no one questioned it.
The Bachae Essay Research Paper The Bacchae
The Bachae Essay, Research Paper The Bacchae In the story, The Bacchae The dramatic conflict is how Pentheus goes against the nature and ways of Dionysus and his followers. Pentheus is an ignorant king who believes that he is the all-powerful and that Dionysus is not a god. Pentheus actually states to his father that Dionysus is no god.
Racsim Essay Research Paper Racism is a
Racsim Essay, Research Paper Racism is a very big issue. I think most people say things without realising they are being racist. This doesn t excuse their behaviour but most people
Being Conservative Essay Research Paper Being ConservativeAs
Being Conservative Essay, Research Paper Being Conservative As my friends and I enter a nearby McDonalds down the street, we all have one thing on our minds, food. ?A number nine,? one of my friends calls out, ?with an apple pie.? ?I?ll take a number three with extra mayo,? another one of my friends says. Finally, it is my turn to order. ?Hmm,? I think to myself. ?I am not going to eat because then I?ll have to pay.? I figured if I said I wasn?t hungry then my friends will offer me their food, and in the end I wouldn?t have to pull out my wallet.
Humanism Essay Research Paper HumanismEncarta Dictionary says
Humanism Essay, Research Paper Humanism Encarta Dictionary says that Humanism is a system of thought that centers on human beings and their values, capacities and worth. Encarta also goes on the say that, in philosophy, humanism is an attitude that emphasizes the dignity and worth of an individual. A basic premise of humanism is that people are rational beings who possess within themselves the capacity for truth and goodness.
Ethnic Cleansing Essay Research Paper The Sick
Ethnic Cleansing Essay, Research Paper The Sick of Society Rape is the ultimate act of brutality. Rape is committed by people whose feelings of inadequacy compel them to commit this horrific act on those that are weaker and different from themselves.
The Real Plague Essay Research Paper The
The Real Plague Essay, Research Paper The Real Plague Although never given permission to kill, by supernatural or natural means, man has reserved for himself the right to kill other men. This self-imposed right has been put into use in our civilizations and countries. Whether train of logic is offered or not, murder is very difficult to justify.
Zero Tolerance Essay Research Paper Zero ToleranceTo
Zero Tolerance Essay, Research Paper Zero Tolerance To the best of my knowledge on the subject the zero tolerance rule is a very good rule, because there is no room for error on the part of the criminal justice systemand there is no room for a misleading excuse. So the zero tolerance policy is good. For example, say a person pulls a fire alarm just to get out of a class.
A Thousand Acres Essay Research Paper Just
A Thousand Acres Essay, Research Paper Just set back for a moment and think about a thousand acres, that s an area of land of almost mythic proportions. Just as the changes the people had to go through in this book. In this book the author takes material possessions and other tangible entities and identifies the characters through it.
Ignorance Is Not Bliss Essay Research Paper
Nicholas Sine Period Four 4-6-98 Ignorance is Not Bliss “Ignorance is the primary source of all misery and vice.” –Victor Cousin. As knowledge gives us the power to create, ignorance gives us the power to destroy. Over
Moby Dick Essay Research Paper Ignorance Ignorance
Moby Dick Essay, Research Paper Ignorance Ignorance is seen every day of our lives. Even people in the 1850?s were aware of ignorance. Ignorance is defined as being uneducated or resulting from or showing lack of knowledge. Ignorance can be taken to extremes though. There is complete ignorance where the person thinks that even though they do not understand it all they still know everything.
The Tempest Caliban
’s Ignorance Essay, Research Paper The Tempest: Caliban’s Ignorance Shakespeare portrays Stephano’s view of Caliban as an ignorant slave by taking advantage of the “monster”(Shakespeare, Act II, Scene II, line 31) while he is
Dracula 2 Essay Research Paper Dracula by
Dracula 2 Essay, Research Paper Dracula, by Bram Stoker, is a classic tale of Gothicism. Traditionally, gothic tales only carried single theme of horror. Through Dracula, Stoker breaks this single theme barrier. The theme throughout Dracula is clearly displayed through the characters as they step from ignorance to realization in this tale of horror.
Excuse For Hate Essay Research Paper An
Excuse For Hate Essay, Research Paper An Excuse for Hate There are many people in this world today who feel that prejudice is a regular part of life that must be dealt with along with getting up for work, and taking out the garbage. However, what people do not realize is that prejudice is on the rise in our society, and has been for centuries.
Birds Essay Research Paper The forum speech
Birds Essay, Research Paper The forum speech given on Friday the 14th of April was very interesting to me. Dr. Kirsten Murtagh, the Associate Vice President of The Northern Campuses of FAU, gave her speech on bird watching in Southern Florida. She started out her talk with a quote from Walt Whitman. He said that vagueness and ignorance helps enjoyment.
Beowulf And Revenge Essay Research Paper Revenge
Beowulf And Revenge Essay, Research Paper Revenge Is revenge an excuse to commit murder? Some people might think it is. In the epic poem Beowulf, the anonymous author believes this. Beowulf was
Ignorance Essay Research Paper IgnoranceIn Sophocle
Ignorance Essay, Research Paper Ignorance In Sophocle’s ancient Greek tragedy, Antigone, there is a woman who chooses to go with the feeling inside her heart and obey law of the Gods, rather than to obey civil law. Antigone’s bother Eteoles was given a proper burial after a war in their homeland of Thebes. She wants her brother, Polyneices, who was the enemy, also to be given a proper burial, but the king prohibits the burial.
Pulled Over Essay Research Paper Pulled OverCome
Pulled Over Essay, Research Paper Pulled Over ?Come on Eric do it, come one man show it to us,? Vishal said. ?Eric will you do it for me,? Lynne asked. They were trying to get Eric, Eric Skrout, to show them the Britney Spears dance he has learned. Eric Skrout, Lynne Jennings, Mike Gravas, and Vishal Patel were all going home.
Your Late Essay Research Paper Your late
Your Late Essay, Research Paper Your late, what’s your excuse this time? No, no I don’t want to hear it you can tell me later in detention, sound familiar? Well to half the students in my school it does. That was the usual answer that teachers distribute when students are late to class, which is permissible, but what about what about when your late to home room? Well before you answer that let me explain to you what home room is.
Billy Budd Essay Research Paper In
Billy Budd Essay, Research Paper In Henry Melville s novel Billy Budd, the protagonist, Billy Budd, is a young impressed sailor aboard an English Battleship. Billy shows his actions toward a Christ Figure through his innocence and ignorance, which he shows while interacting with Claggart, the ships Master of Arms.
Sin Is Ignorance
– Socratic Definition Of Sin Essay, Research Paper Sin is Ignorance – Socratic definition of sin Sin is ignorance. This is well known Socratic definition of sin which, like everthing Socratic, is an opinion always worthy of attention. The difficulty with the Socratic definition is that it leaves undetermined how ignorance itself is to be more precisely understood, the question of its origin, ect.
The Dark Side Essay Research Paper The
The Dark Side Essay, Research Paper The Dark Side In Charles Dickens’ well-known novel A Christmas Carol, the second ghost that appears, the Ghost of the present, introduced two very significant characters. The boy, who represented ignorance, and the girl who represented want, were related to Scrooge as a person, to the novel as a whole, and to the real world.
Scrooge Essay Research Paper Ignorance
Scrooge Essay, Research Paper Ignorance & Want In the famous story A Christmas Carol, the Ghost said to Scrooge “”These are your children Ignorance and Want.” as he opened his robe to reveal two small unfortunate poverty stricken children. By this, the ghost meant that because of the cruelty of the world and irresponsibility, these innocent children must suffer.
Oedipus Sight Vs Blindness Essay Research Paper
Oedipus: Sight vs. Blindness The concept of sight versus blindness mentioned throughout Sophocles famous work Oedipus Rex is truly representative of the idea of knowledge versus ignorance, and it used by this playwright to highlight the ignorance and tragic self-discovery of Oedipus. Many of Sophocles characters, including the king himself, incorporate this motif of light versus darkness into their analysis of both Oedipus and the situation at hand.
Sight
& Blindness Imagery In Oedipus Rex Essay, Research Paper Sight and blindness Imagery in ?Oedipus Rex? In this play written by Sophocles called Oedipus Rex, sight/blindness imagery is used as a form of ignorance. In this play, there is allot of ignorance. Some examples of this are when Oedipus talks with Tiresias about who had killed Laius, and when he discovers the truth about his love and about his parents.
The Effects Of Excuse Validation In Reducing
Negative Affect Essay, Research Paper Excuse-making is a common strategy people invoke to feel better following a negative event. When excuses are advanced in public, their effectiveness may depend on whether they are validated by others. The present study was conducted to assess the emotional impact on participants of having their excuses validated by a supportive stranger in a conversation about a real life negative event, as compared to receiving no support from an attentive audience.
Analysis Of Frankenstien Essay Research Paper Who
Analysis Of Frankenstien Essay, Research Paper Who Is The Real Monster Through out the novel we are under the assumption that the demon in the novel is the man who is disfigured and hideous on the outside. While we view Victor Frankenstein as the handsome and caring victim, even though sometimes a monster can not be seen but heard.
WHAT CAUSES A CRISIS Essay Research Paper
Title of Paper : crisis Grade Received on Report : 92 WHAT CAUSES A CRISIS? Such a question may at first seem unanswerable because there are so many different kinds of unpleasant situations into which we humans can get ourselves. In one word, however, the
Playground Of The Gods Essay Research Paper
The Playground of The Gods Cathy Spellman?s, The Playground of The Gods is an exuberant novel which deals with murder in a remote tropical paradise but can further be read as an illustration of man?s ignorance and invasion of nature.