Malaysia is among the countries in Southeast Asia which has experienced remarkable economic growth and industrialization in the past decade. It is unique in that its success is not a result of adopting any one model for development. Rather, Malaysia?s government identified its goals and sought to create a country-specific model of development suited to their needs for growth. An example of this is the Malaysian government?s increase in exports of manufactured goods rather than concentrating on natural resource commodities as suggested by the World Bank and International Monetary Fund. (pg.6 , HBS)
Unlike its neighbor Singapore, Malaysia is blessed with an abundance of natural resources. Although its exports of natural resource commodities have declined in recent years in favor of manufactured goods (pg. 6 , HBS), Malaysia?s natural resource industry remains an important part of the country?s economic and political agenda.
Malaysia?s Forest Products Industry
It is difficult to ignore the fact that 60% of Malaysia is covered with natural forest and that timber generates more foreign exchange than any other natural resource in Malaysia. The Malaysian government recognized the economic potential of the forest product industry early in the decade and proceeded to play a key role in further developing and promoting this particular sector of its economy through a concessions system and the encouragement of downstream industries.
The Concession System granted logging rights to private parties in exchange for royalties paid to the Malaysian government (pg. 11, HBS). Granting logging concessions to private parties also allowed Malaysia?s government to generate interest in the forest products industry while maintaining a degree of control over the areas and particular use the timber could be logged for. This system did not prove to be very effective in the hands of private interest groups in search of increased profits. With only 1,600 employees to patrol the undeveloped forest areas, the Sarawak Forest Department found it difficult to prevent illegal logging (pg. 12, HBS).
Protection of domestic markets from foreign competition is a common practice among industrializing countries. In the case of Malaysia?s forest products industry, the government encouraged local production of lumber, furniture, and other wood products through the restriction of exporting unprocessed logs. This was known as downstream industries. The encouragement of downstream industries was another important agenda for the Forestry Department of Peninsular Malaysia, a government branch for the overseeing of Malaysia?s forest products industry. “The idea that the forests could be used as a springboard for downstream integration, or ?resource based industrialization? appealed to many Malaysian officials.” (pg. 13, HBS) To these officials, downstream integration allowed for the employment of a large percentage of the market labor force as well as a decrease in the amount of timber needed to produce jobs and export revenues. (pg. 13, HBS) To further encourage downstream int!
egration, the Malaysian government granted tax breaks, subsidies, and other incentives to domestic manufacturers.
The Problem
Developing industries which deal with the production of natural resource products are very likely to be placed in the international spotlight by drawing criticism from environmental groups around the world. Such is the case for the Malaysian government as explained in the Harvard Business School case study in which Malaysian prime minister Mahathir bin Mohamad was faced with media scrutiny regarding his country?s forest product industry during a visit to the United States. Being a country that is heavily dependent on foreign investment for its economic growth, Malaysia could not afford to simply ignore the criticism its country receives from westerners whose investments they are attempting to attract into the country. The problem lies in differing views on the side of western environmentalists and the Malaysian government.
Western Critics
Although Malaysia contains only 2 – 3% of the world?s tropical forests (pg.3, HBS), the biological potentials and environment potentials found in its rainforests are a cause for concern among western environmentalists.
These environmentalists are quick to point out that often times, the welfare of the environment is far from the minds of those governing a newly industrializing country seeking to capitalize on its possession of valuable natural resources. According to the London Rainforest Movement and the Singaporean and Malaysian British Association, “the rapid destruction of the Sarawak rainforest means that a hugely rich natural laboratory with vast potential for the health of humankind will be destroyed FOR EVER.” (pg. 3, HBS) Where an environmentalist may see the medical and environmental values of a living forest, the Malaysian government sees a commodity perfect for foreign exchange and economic growth.
The environmentalists also accuse the Malaysian government of condoning acts such as forest “mining” (pg. 3, HBS) in which the amounts of timber harvested exceed the growth of the remaining timber, and interference in the rights of indigenous people living within the forests.
According to western critics, the most effective way of creating change in Malaysia?s forest products industry would be to initiate a worldwide boycott of Malaysian wood products to which the Malaysian government strongly opposed.
The Malaysian Government
Despite the accusations from western environmentalists and critics of exploitation of Malaysia?s rainforests, the country?s government insists they have taken significant steps in ensuring the long term preservation of the forests through new techniques, research and development, and the establishment of special committees and task forces.
According to the Forest Research Institute of Malaysia (FRIM), Malaysia is currently exploring alternatives to conventional logging techniques such as helicopter logging. The advantage of this method of logging is a reduction in forest disturbance because the need to construct roads is minimized. This system would also minimize soil erosion which leads to flooding. The Forest Research Institute of Malaysia (FRIM) was established to develop guidelines for forestry management and biodiversity conservation.
The National Forestry Policy 1978 (revised 1992) was established to “conserve and manage the forest through sustainable management and maintain its important roles in the national economy and preservation of environmental stability” (WWW). This document details specific strategies the Malaysian government seeks to achieve in protecting its rainforests. However, western environmentalists question the effectiveness of such a well intentioned document without the proper resources to enforce them with.
Possible Solutions
It is difficult to adopt and enforce policies restricting Malaysia?s use of its resources because of its importance of sustaining economic growth and development as a newly industrializing country. From reading the case study and researching current information regarding Malaysia?s forest policy on the World Wide Web, there is no doubt that the Malaysian government is aware of the international concern of its forest products industry. In recent years, the Malaysian government has sought to diversify its industries. The success of Malaysia?s forest conservation policies greatly depends on its ability to succeed in increasing exports of various manufactured goods as well as attracting greater foreign investment.
In the meantime, there are several possibilities the Malaysian government can explore in convincing the international community that its efforts in forestry are sincere.
In terms of the concession system in the logging industry, one possibility would be to make it more difficult for private parties to obtain logging concessions by having the Malaysian government demand higher royalties in return. The increase in revenue can then be redirected to aid efforts in policing the rainforest in order to prevent illegal logging practices.
A first step for both the Malaysian government and western environmentalists would be to hold a forum to discuss relevant issues of concern with one another rather than relay disagreements and criticisms through the international media. By holding a forum involving both representatives from the Malaysian government and various environmental groups, the international spotlight is briefly taken off the accusations which would then allow for free discussions towards a solution both sides are satisfied with.
Другие работы по теме:
Hopes And Dreams Essay Research Paper Hopes
Hopes And Dreams Essay, Research Paper Hopes and Dreams Science has been the backbone of my life ever since my high school days in Malaysia. Although I studied many science subjects like Physics and Biology, I was especially fond of chemistry. My fondness of chemistry was attributed to my chemistry teacher Mr.
Lakemu Basin Essay Research Paper The people
Lakemu Basin Essay, Research Paper The people of the Lakekamu Basin love their old way of life and their forest. They don t want to lose their forest. What they want is their forest and a way to make money from it because they need to support their families. They want to be able to but the same things that people living in America or Europe buy.
Jewelry From Africa Essay Research Paper Most
Jewelry From Africa Essay, Research Paper Most jewelry of Africa comes from the kingdom of Benin, which is located in a tropical rain forest in southern Nigeria. In the kingdom of Benin, the Oba rules over the life and death of his subjects. In the Equatorial Rain Forest, ivory is plentiful and is valued for it?s rich patina and magical powers.
Rain Forest Essay Research Paper RAIN FOREST
Rain Forest Essay, Research Paper RAIN FOREST JOURNAL ESSAY Every second, one acre of all the Earth s rain forests is destroyed. Already, half of all the rain forests have been destroyed. This is unacceptable and it must be stopped. We all must help with all our efforts to save the rain forests. If we keep on cutting down the rain forests at this pace, there will be no rain forests left in fifty years!
Temperate Deciduous Forest Essay Research Paper Temperate
Temperate Deciduous Forest Essay, Research Paper Temperate Deciduous Forest Temperate deciduous forests are found in all of the continents except Antarctica. Temperate deciduous forests are most commonly found in eastern US, Europe, western Asia, parts of Australia, and Canada.
Temperate Deciduous Forests Essay Research Paper A
Temperate Deciduous Forests Essay, Research Paper A Deciduous forest is one in which plants shed their leafs in the fall. The trees change colors as the seasons cycle; the green leaves of summer give way to the bare branches of winter.
Stairway To Heaven Essay Research Paper In
Stairway To Heaven Essay, Research Paper In the first verse the writer talks about a lady who is buying him a present. If she gets the right thing than he will be happy and it would be
Forest Gump Essay Research Paper I am
Forest Gump Essay, Research Paper I am doing my oral presentation on the Drama movie Forest Gump rated M15. (pause) This movie traces a fictitious life to portray and comment on
Into The Forest Essay Research Paper Into
Into The Forest Essay, Research Paper Into the forest. In the novel ?into the forest? the two main characters, Nell and Eva, lived together their entire lives. Although they grew up with together in the same remote place with the same parents, they developed unique personalties and views on life.
Promote Malaysia On A Shoestring Budget Essay
, Research Paper It is not an easy task to promote Malaysia to the foreign countries with only a small budget available. However, there is nothing impossible as long as we have the courage to do it. As we all know, Malaysian government as well as private sectors sponsors students to continue their studies to the foreign countries every year.
Crucible Essay Research Paper Summary of The
Crucible Essay, Research Paper Summary of The Crucible This story takes place during the late 1600’s. In the beginning Abigail, Mary Warren, and Betty were in the forest conjuring up spirits of the dead. They wanted to find out why children were dying in their infancy. Tituba knew how to conjure so she was the one who did it, while the other three danced.
Forest Of Voices Essay Research Paper In
Forest Of Voices Essay, Research Paper In Chris Anderson s essay titled Forest of Voices he talks about the forest around his house and what it means to him. However there is a much deeper meaning to his essay. Throughout the essay, one can get a hint of human interference and human interaction with forests.
Something Evil Essay Research Paper Something Evil
Something Evil Essay, Research Paper Something Evil In the world there are so many large things that people find evil that they just completely over look the minute. When most people are taking about war and other things that they have no control over they should be looking to the more local issues. When asked to write this paper I didn t know what to write so I consulted a couple of students and they all told me the same types of things war, pollution, and cutting down the rain forest.
Why Schools Need The Grading System Essay
, Research Paper C.D. 1/5/99 New School Policy Essay School Number (WHATEVER SCHOOL) is considering a new policy.Students will not receive grades in any classes.Before passing this policy,the principal wants to know how it will affect students.This new policy can have some good effects and bad effects.How would it affect teachers?How would it affect students who plan to go to collage?How would it affect students who usually get bad grades?All these things have to be taken into consideration.In the following paragraphs I will state what I think of this new policy.
Old Growth Forest Essay Research Paper Science
Old Growth Forest Essay, Research Paper Science- Old growth forest To destroy or not to destroy, that is the question at hand in this assignment. There are two distinct sides in this grand battle, there are the people who want this heritage forest destroyed whilst there are the other group who would like to see it kept as part of Tasmanias history.
Cultural Comparison Law And Order Essay Research
Paper Cultural Comparison Essay Law and Order In the United States police are suppose to be honorable and fair. We all know not all of them are. In Malaysia, according to Daphne Chan, you can bribe the police to let you off. “All you have to do is ask ‘do you want to settle this now?’” she said. In Pakistan, on the other hand, they don’t even have minor violations like speeding and seat belt laws.
Standards In Taiwan Were Three Times Those
In Malaysia. Essay, Research Paper In 1992 the GDP per head of Malaysia was $2200 and that of Taiwan was $6600. Discuss the basis and confidence with which an economist might conclude that living standards in Taiwan were three times those in Malaysia.
South American Rainforest Destruction Essay Research Paper
Rain forests are a critical part of everyday life. Even if you don’t live near a rain forest, you still can feel the effects of the rain forest. Take a deep breath. The air you are breathing comes from the rain forests, as they are known as the ‘lungs of the world.’
Scarlet Letter Forest Symbolism Essay Research Paper
Jacquie Kaloz10/13/00Symbolism of the Forest Nathaniel Hawthorne’s novel, The Scarlet Letter, is filled with a variety of symbols. The forest is a place where the characters can be free and careless, but is also known as a evil place where the Black Man lives. One of the symbols he uses is the forest, which is symbolic in a number of ways.
American Revolution Essay Research Paper Q
American Revolution Essay, Research Paper Q: Explain why Japan reacted to western ideas by adopting a policy of isolation. How did this reaction to outside influences effect Japans development over the next few centuries.
Malaysia Essay Research Paper Malaysia
Malaysia Essay, Research Paper Malaysia’s Defiant Surrender Key points:+ Malaysia’s currency controls in September 1998 was a signal of the government’s refusal to accept any blame for its financial troubles, and its readiness to make foreign investors suffer for the sins of the international markets.+ One control was preventing foreigners from taking money out of the stock market for a year-lifted on February 4, 1999.+ On February 4th, Malaysia’s currency still worthless abroad.+ Malaysian government imposed hefty penalties on investors:If money invested before February 15th and repatriated before the end of March-30% levyIf money invested after February `14th and repatriated anytime after-30% tax on 1st year profits.+ Malaysian government targeted only certain foreign direct investors.+ New FDI commitments fell by 12% in 1998.+ The bigger question surrounding the controls has always
Echo Essay Research Paper Echo was a
Echo Essay, Research Paper Echo was a nymph who lived in the forest. She romped and played with all of her fellow nymphs. One day she came across a beautifull man named Narcissus. At first she was scared of him, but soon grew quite attached. The gods looked down upon an infatuated Narcissus with disdain. They sentenced him and his new love to horrible fates.
Mother Nature Essay Research Paper Nature has
Mother Nature Essay, Research Paper Nature has a certain presence or spirit. It s an almost indescribable feeling just to go out to the middle of the sea or into a forest and just sit there in awe of its beauty. Nature has a certain mystique and mystery to it that draws people to it. Nature, described as mysterious and secretive, is a recurrent theme throughout many stories.
Schools 2 Essay Research Paper SCHOOLSThere are
Schools 2 Essay, Research Paper SCHOOLS There are hundreds, if not thousand of schools in this world. In Malaysia, we have seven types of schools. They are Malay schools, Tamil schools, Chinese schools, international schools, private schools, and religious schools.
Fiscal Policy Essay Research Paper Policy that
Fiscal Policy Essay, Research Paper Policy that uses taxation and government spending to steer the economy. Fiscal policy describes two governmental actions by the government. The first is taxation. By levying taxes the government receives revenue from the populace. Taxes come in many varieties and serve different specific purposes, but the key concept is that taxation is a transfer of assets from the people to the government.
Mythology And Policy Essay Research Paper Mythology
Mythology And Policy Essay, Research Paper Mythology and policy has been a part of human culture for as long as there has been civilization . Day provides us with a history of the beginnings of social welfare. She speaks how social policy as well as social welfare has effected individuals, families, and the larger society of today.
Australian Foreign Policy Essay Research Paper Australian
Australian Foreign Policy Essay, Research Paper Australian Foreign Policy Topic 2 Due Date: 26/5 Teacher: Br Smith Student: Luke O?Connor ?Australia was a good friend to the Indonesian independence movement in the years after World War 2, but Australia stood silently by as Dutch New Guinea was given to Indonesia.
Cell Phones Essay Research Paper As part
Cell Phones Essay, Research Paper As part of school policy, cell phones are not permitted on school grounds. This rule must be abolished. Students who are in after school activities need cell phones to contact parents.