Plea Bargaining Essay, Research Paper
The most common arguement offered on behalf of plea bargaining is that it
lifts theburden of heavy caseloads from the shoulders of the courts. By ensuring that
most criminaldefendants enter a plea of guilty, plea bargaining eliminates the need for
time-consuming trialprocedures. Harold J. Rothwax, a Manhattan judge said, "We go to plea
bargaining out ofnecessity, not out of desire. It is inescapable." Criminal defendants
charged with felonies couldcompletely overcome the court system if they coordinated their efforts.
"If even half of the 90%of the defendants who now plead guilty should request trial, the judicial
system would breakdown from overload", said B.J. George Jr. Although society would
certainly respond to asubstantially overburdened court system by allotting more resources to it,
such s responce wouldlikely be slow.Proponents of plea bargaining argue that it allows the accused to have a
greater degree ofautonomy over the results of their cases. Unlike a system without a plea
bargaining, in which adefendant either pleads guilty without meeting with the prosecutor or pleads
innocent and thengoes through the trial process, plea bargaining allows the defendant the
intermediate option ofpleading guilty to avoid a harsh penalty. This arguement sees plea bargaining
as an extra checkin the criminal justice system to ensure that the autonomy and liberty of the
accused is respectedby the state. Plea bargaining also protects innocent defendants from the
possibility of harshsanctions. Unfortunate innocent defendants who realize that the case them
against them is toooverwhelming to gain leniency from the judge or to win acquittal from a jury
may view pleabargaining as an attractive alternative to trial. Without plea bargaining,
many of these innocentdefendants would be found guilty and sentenced. Of course, plea bargaining
does not violateone’s right to trial, as defendants always have the option to plead not
guilty and be tried by ajury. Proponents of plea bargaining point out that prosecutors do not force
anyone to pleabargain.Although plea bargaining is not perfect, the pressures placed on the court
system make itthe best way to promote justice. Critics of the practice tend to focus only
on the relativelyinsignificant number of cases where plea bargaining results in injustice.
When evaluating theeffectiveness of plea bargaining in promoting justice, it is important to
focus equally on itsstrengths. In most cases, plea bargaining is a fair and efficient way to deal
with cases. Mostguilty defendants will be convicted with or without plea bargaining, and most
innocentdefendants will be acquitted. Therefore, plea bargaining is usually an
acceptable and moreefficient alternative to trial. One important positive effect that plea
bargaining has on thecriminal justice system is that it preserves the seriousness of the innocent
plea. With pleabargaining, innocent pleas are few and far between, making the judge and
attorneys moreattentive during trials. Without plea bargaining, guilty defendants have less
of an incentive toplead guilty and more of an incentive to go to trial. With more trials to
attend to, and with mostdefendants being ultimately found guilty, the cases of the few innocent
defendants who needtrials the most might not recieve the proper amount of attention from judges
or attorneys.The efficiency excuse can only be used by the most overburdened courts.
Prosecutorsworking in rural areas with relatively low caseloads use plea bargaining just
as prosecutors whowork in major cities. Additionally, plea bargaining was used decades ago,
when courts in generalwere not as overburdened as they are today. These observations, according to
opponents of pleabargaining, suggest that necessity is not the only explanation for the
widespread use of thepractice. An alternative explanation not cited by plea bargaining proponents
is that the practicelifts burdens not only from the courts, but from the shoulders of the judges
and attorneys whowork within them. Attorneys and judges realize that the trials require
significantly more personaleffort and time than plea bargaining. When the court has heard all of the
cases on the docket, thejudge and public attorneys are free to spend their time outside of the
courtroom. Thus, theincentives for public attorneys and judges to use plea bargaining are often
personal. In light ofthis observation, the often cited efficiency excuse does not seem valid. As
one scholar wiselyobserved, "regardless of the caseload, there will always be too many
cases for many of theparticipants in the system, since most of them have a strong interest in
being some place otherthan court.Plea bargaining presents a substantial threat to the liberties of the
accused, especiallythose who are innocent. Prosecutors bargain with the harshest sentence that
they think thedefendant will accept in exchange for a guilty plea. Indeed, because judges
tend to sentenceconvicted defendants who plead innocent with much harsher penalties than
defendants whoplead guilty. Defendants who are clearly guilty would probably be better off
pleading guiltyeven without a plea bargain. On the other hand, a prosecutor will offer more
substantialconcessions to innocent defendants who would have relatively high chances of
acquittal if theircases were to go to trial. Thus, plea bargaining allows the prosecutor to
ensure that innocentdefendants will be just as likely as guilty defendants to plead guilty to
some charge.Plea bargaining violates many basic principles upon which our criminal
justice systemrests. One of these principles is that it is better to let ten guilty persons
go free than it is toconvict one innocent person. Plea bargaining attempts to ensure that everyone
is convicted,albeit with a lighter sentence than if he or she had been found guilty in
trial. For the innocent,conviction is clearly an injustice, but the injustice of convicting the
criminal through pleabargaining is often overlooked. By ensuring that criminals recieve lighter
sanctions, pleabargaining represents an injustice to society. If the criminal justice system
is viewed as a systemwith the end of protecting citizens, plea bargaining and its leniency toward
guilty defendantsthreatens to undermine the system by depriving it of the ability to deter
crime and reform theoffenders. While the doctrine of letting ten innocent defendants go free is
not written in theConstitution, the doctrine that no person "shall be compelled in any
criminal case to be a witnessagainst himself" is This Fifth Amendment right is violated by plea
bargaining, in which theguilty plea, in light of the possibility of more lenient sanctions, is
compelling. If oneincriminates oneself by pleading guilty, the plea bargain violates the Fifth
Amendment.Unfortunately, the Supreme Court made an exception for plea bargaining in
North Carolina v.Alford, in which it held that Alford, who would have pled innocent to murder
had in not been forplea bargaining, was bound to his plea bargain. Alford’s testimony reveals
that he was indeedcompelled to plead guilty, thus incriminating himself: "I pleaded guilty
on second degree murderbecause they said there is too much evidence, but I ain’t shot no man, but I
take the fault for theother man. We never had an arguement in our life and I just pleaded guilty
because they said if Ididn’t they would gas me for it, and that is all." Finally, plea
bargaining violates the principlethat guilt or innocence should only be determined by those deemed fit to do
so. In our society,only judges and fairly selected juries enjoy that status.Plea bargaining
takes already difficultdecisions out of the hands of qualified and socially sanctioned individuals
and places them in thehands of attorneys, who are then subjected to "serious financial and
other temptations todisregard their clients interests", said A.W. Alschuler. Moreover, by
making attorneys viewthemselves as "judges and administrators rather than as advocates",
plea bargaining transformsreal judges into ineffective figureheads who cannot fulfill the role expected
of them by thosewho appointed them.
Другие работы по теме:
The Importance Of Plea Bargaining In Criminal
Trials Essay, Research Paper The Importance of Plea Bargaining in Criminal Trials Screeech! That is the sound of our court system coming to a grinding halt, if plea bargaining were no longer utilized. Not only does plea bargaining
Romeo An Juliet Essay Research Paper hi
Romeo An Juliet Essay, Research Paper hi i need an essay about a character in romeo and juliet that demonsrtated maturity. in a well developed multi pagraph essay and say why you think the character’s maturity was greater than the other characters in the play.
Poetry Essay Research Paper Don t Give
Poetry Essay, Research Paper Don t Give In Dylan Thomas s poem “Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night”, is an urgent plea from Thomas to his dying father, and all men not to give in
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Gun ControlThe
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Gun Control The National Rifle Association (NRA) is a very powerful organization with huge financial backing; it wants laws already in placed to be used more forcefully to control the use of guns in committing crimes. However, people are still dying; something more must be done to take guns out of the hands of those who plan and execute criminal behavior.
Aids In Africa Essay Research Paper WOMEN
Aids In Africa Essay, Research Paper WOMEN will get the power to protect themselves against AIDS, if the World Health Organisation has its way. Encouraging men to use condoms, it has decided, is not enough. They work, but many men dislike them; and women, especially very young ones, often lack the sexual bargaining clout to insist.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Revolving Door Justice Essay Research Paper Revolving
Revolving Door Justice Essay, Research Paper Revolving Door Justice 1) Plea Bargaining is when a person may agree to lesser crime as to not clog up the jury system but when this can be made the accused will wait for a good deal. I think that this is a bad idea because it makes it seem like the justice system can be bought or bargained with and laws can be bent.
Grapes Of Wrath Essay Research Paper PurposeEssentially
Grapes Of Wrath Essay, Research Paper Purpose Essentially, The Grapes of Wrath is a novel of social protest. It was designed to inform the public of the migrant’s plight. It is a plea for the land owners of California and the banks in the dust bowl states to be more tolerant. It shows how the migrants were made to starve by the California land owners and banks just so they could turn a profit.
Insanity Plea Essay Research Paper Do you
Insanity Plea Essay, Research Paper Do you think it?s right for a person to murder someone and say that they did it because they are insane? I think it?s wrong for a person to get off without getting in trouble just because of the insanity plea. If someone commits a crime and had no record of being insane, how could he suddenly become insane? The only reason that people plead insanity is to get off the hook for committing a crime.
The Insanity Plea Essay Research Paper The
The Insanity Plea Essay, Research Paper The insanity defense traces its history to an 1843 assassination attempt on British Prime Minister Robert Peel. Now, about a third of the states allow a guilty by reason of insanity plea (Witkin, 7). Fortunately, on the contrary to popular belief, only one percent of felony cases led to a ruling of not guilty by reason of insanity.
Industry Analysis Essay Research Paper Industry Analysis1
Industry Analysis Essay, Research Paper Industry Analysis 1. The threat of new entrants into the senior housing industry is low and not a major threat to established companies in the industry. One major barrier to entry is the large amount of capital needed to build or purchases housing communities and to provide trained personnel such as managers and nurses to fill them.
Letter On Lysistrata Essay Research Paper Letter
Letter On Lysistrata Essay, Research Paper Letter on Lysistrata: A Plea For Equality Dear friend, The first thing that I noticed, which you might notice also, when I started reading Lysistrata was the very informal style of writing. The second thing I noticed was the strong presence of female authority rivaling against the age old male chavinism of most of the early cultures including the Greeks.
A Place Worth Fighting For Essay Research
Paper Colin Chisholm`s emotive plea for restraint in the development of the Squaw Valley ski area is particularly poignant and compelling. The power of the piece is found in his dramatic and impassioned scene setting. He cleverly intertwines the imagery of the valley with endearing anecdotes of the time he and his family spent there establishing a subconscious link between the two main focuses of the piece.
A Plea For Captain John Brown Essay
, Research Paper After reading A Plea for Captain John Brown , I find it hard to decide which side to take. Knowing a little history about the subject, I originally sided against the Captain, but by reading Thoreau s essay, I am swayed the other way. He makes a very strong argument for John Brown and probably persuaded many people at the time of his writing.
Play Overviews Essay Research Paper Actor
Play Overviews Essay, Research Paper Actor: Gavin Kane Character: Eddie Play: Fool for Love by Sam Shepard Super Objective: Eddie wants May to understand just how much he?s gone through to come and see
Insanity Plea Essay Research Paper
#Bill Killinger Mr. Ripple Academic English Tuesday, Decembor 5, 2000 Insanity Plea Well you finally graduated high school. And you are about to start the new life that waits. You have been a top-notch student. The grades that were brought home during your 12 years of high school were enough to put you on the high school honor society.
Collective Bargaining Essay Research Paper Collective Bargaining
Collective Bargaining Essay, Research Paper Collective Bargaining, in labor relations, negotiations between employersand employees about terms and conditions of employment. The bargainingprocess is concerned with wages, working hours, fringe benefits, jobSecurity, safety, and other matter relating to working conditions.
Criminology
– Thoughts On Plea Bargaining Essay, Research Paper SOCL 4461 May 07, 2001 The current tone of the criminal justice system, particularly the prosecution phase, emphasizes, “clearing the docket”. While this is true of both civil and criminal courts, it is very much encouraged in criminal matters where the prosecution likely has the upper hand on most, if not all, defendants.
Plea Bargaining Essay Research Paper Plea bargainingWhen
Plea Bargaining Essay, Research Paper Plea bargaining When dealing with the Criminal Justice system plea bargaining is something that is a common occurrence. When some type of a negotiation between the prosecutor and the defense attorney takes place and there is no trial, this would be considered a plea bargain. (Criminal Justice, Pg.454) Although the defendant does loose some of his constitution rights by accepting it, he does have some benefits.
Compromise Of 1850 Essay Research Paper Clinton
Compromise Of 1850 Essay, Research Paper Clinton Jolts Canadians With a Plea On Federalism In Ottawa, Canadians on both sides of the nation’s deep linguistic divide say they were stunned by President Clinton’s unexpectedly passionate appeal for national unity and federalism.
Prosecutors Essay Research Paper The Role of
Prosecutors Essay, Research Paper The Role of the Prosecutor All serious criminal cases require the participation of three individuals: the judge, counsel for the prosecution, and counsel for the accused.
Trial By Plea Bargain Essay Research Paper
Criminal Justice Trial by Plea Bargain After I finished this short reading, it dramatically helped my understanding with how cases are dealt with by plea-bargaining. Plea-bargaining is first a verbal agreement made usually between the defense attorney, who is representing the defendant, and the district attorney.
Sex Paper Essay Research Paper The Criminal
Sex Paper Essay, Research Paper The Criminal Justice System How It Deals With Sex Offenders kyle Shellabarger Human Sexuality Better that many guilty shall go free rather than one innocent should suffer. John
Problems To Agreements Essay Research Paper The
Problems To Agreements Essay, Research Paper The method of principled negotiation provides an alternative which combines both hard and soft ways and look into issues based on their merits. It is a method hard on merits while soft on people. It also helps the negotiator acquire what he is entitled to in a fair manner and at the same time prevents unnecessary exploitations.
Labor Unions Essay Research Paper Labor UnionsA
Labor Unions Essay, Research Paper Labor Unions A labor union is as defined in the dictionary, an organization of wage earners formed for the purpose of serving the members’ interests with respect to wages and working conditions. Today there are about 16 million workers in the U.S. that belong to a labor union.
Mary Astell Extreme Solutions Essay Research Paper
Discussion Question: Why did Mary Astell suggest such extreme solutions as a learning environment for woman, and is it necessary? In Mary Astell s From A Serious Proposal to the Ladies is a plea for intellectual equality among the sexes. The author was tired of the oppressive nature of man, which kept her and her sisters from developing their minds.
Clinton Scandal Essay Research Paper Clinton Scandal
Clinton Scandal Essay, Research Paper Clinton Scandal The evidence against President Clinton for sexual misconduct is very strong. There have been too many scandals that have surrounded his presidency. This forces the citizens of the United States to deny his plea of innocence. In the spring of 1995, Monica Lewinsky graduated from Lewis and Clark College.
Infinity Essay Research Paper Throughout all of
Infinity Essay, Research Paper Throughout all of the stellar cosmos, there is only one absolute (debatable): Infinity. Humans are leaves on a giant tree called ?Life?. Where humans bud in the spring, blossom during the summer, then fade away and die during the autumn, the tree will last an eternity as a memento of the past, a reminder of the present, and a positive sign for the future.
Teenage Pregnancy Essay Research Paper Approximately every
Teenage Pregnancy Essay, Research Paper Approximately every two minutes, a teenage girl in the U.S. gives birth. According to Bren Guersny in a book called The Facts about Teenage Pregnancy. While this fact may be sad and startling to most people, it is indeed the truth. Over the past few decades, the problem of teen pregnancy has grown considerably in this country and in particular, in Pomona.
International Joint Ventures Essay Research Paper Summary
International Joint Ventures Essay, Research Paper Summary: Knowledge, Bargaining Power, and the Instability of International Joint Ventures The purpose of the journal article is to identify the primary reason for instability within international joint ventures. The authors begin by defining instability and then continue by linking it to bargaining power.