, Research Paper
WHAT TO DO ABOUT ETHNIC CLEANSING?
BACKGROUND PAPER
In 1994, unrest swept through the Maryland-sized African nation of Rwanda. Thousands of Hutu extremists launched a massive assault on the Tutsi, who traditionally make up Rwanda s upper class, killing hundreds of thousands of innocent people (Night Rider most days ). The United States immediately responded to this slaughter by turning the other way, denying that a problem existed until years after the genocide had ceased. In 1999, ethnic cleansing (hostility between ethnic groups) broke out in Kosovo in a less severe form. This time, instead of being killed, the Kosovars were driven out of their homes and neighborhoods. This time, United States and NATO forces immediately confronted the problem by launching a substantial air war on the area. Clearly, the doctrine for ethnic cleansing is widely varied, and merits further discussion.
Ethnic cleansing is a phrase for an attempt to purge an area of an unwanted ethnic group. It can include deportation, intimidation, and acts of genocide or mass murder. (Encarta, Ethnic cleansing ). It occurs most frequently in third world countries. Whenever it arises, it is followed by a host of moral questions. Do we just stay out completely and allow the country to deal with its own problems? Or, if we decide to take action, do we merely send medical aid or help militarily? Should we send in the army? Or is an air war the only acceptable option? It all comes down to an ethical issue, with one group insisting that preventing the loss of lives is paramount. The other side states that ethnic cleansing is caused by a fundamental disagreement between two ethnic groups, so unless we allow the groups to resolve their own issues, they can never be content and productive.
Whenever any human rights issue breaks out, there are differing opinions on the appropriate course of action. The difference in the case of ethnic cleansing is that this issue is much more critical than almost any other human rights issue. In the case of ethnic cleansing, the United States approach to intervention could determine the fates of thousands of people. In cases of extreme ethnic cleansing, intervention can take place on an international level, with many nations cooperating in an attempt to bring about a resolution of the perceived injustice. In Rwanda, such an international coalition was formed by Canada to safeguard the repatriation of the exiled Rwandans on their return home. This intended military escort function of the international community was averted, because of the sudden and quite peaceful march homeward of the Rwandans before the coalition had mobilized. Had the military escort occurred, there would have been potential for escalation of the Rwandan problem into an international military crisis, should bloodshed of any kind have erupted during the long march home of the refugees (Whaley). This potential for explosion of what some see as a nation s domestic concern into military action crossing international lines is what can deadlock the strategists, sometimes permitting ethnic cleansing to be substantially completed before a resolution can be endorsed by all nations concerned about the matter.
Although ethnic cleansing has been present throughout history, we are only in the last century really starting to acknowledge it as an issue that needs to be definitively dealt with on a global scale. The incident that caused ethnic cleansing to be a major international issue was Adolph Hitler s extreme ethnic cleansing of the Jewish, which made the rest of the world realize that if SOMETHING was not done, the problem could spread to engulf the entire world. Especially in recent years, with the major world powers militaries sitting, these countries are now starting to intervene in other countries ethnic issues, such as Bosnia, Germany, Iraq, and Kosovo, as well as the intended intervention in the Rwandan refugee repatriation.
There are three positions on this issue. The first is the laissez-faire approach, that we should not intervene in other countries issues, on the grounds that they will deal with it themselves in the way that is best for them. Those with this view would point out that when the US was a new country, it went through the ethnic cleansing of Blacks, Indians, and Mexicans without needing assistance or interference from other nations. Although this side is partly motivated by economic reasons (saving money by not going to war), they are mostly motivated by their laissez-faire ethics.
The second side is those who believe the world powers should intervene. This side is driven almost entirely by ethics, saying that saving lives is paramount to all other concerns. This side feels that to allow one ethnic group to be persecuted by another when we have the power to stop it is morally unspeakable. This side will invariably point to Hitler as an example of what could happen when ethnic cleansing is let to go uncontrolled. This is the side whose views are currently dominant, which caused NATO to intervene in Kosovo.
There is also a middle ground, which believes that cleansing should be allowed to go on, as long as it stays within the country s own borders and does not affect its neighbors adversely. This middle ground supports certain parts of both sides. It believes that while the country should be allowed to conduct its own internal affairs as it sees fit, as soon as the conflict oversteps the nation s borders, we must intervene to prevent the trouble from spreading as it did during the holocaust.
At the present moment, the pro-action side is most influential in determining strategies for dealing with ethnic cleansing. This is illustrated by the Kosovo conflict. Only a few years previously, the anti-action approach was in favor; no outside intervention occurred during the Rwandan genocide. No predictions forecast an end to the issues of ethnic cleansing. As long as distinction can be made between groups, that distinction will be made, and as long as that distinction is made, there will be a few warmongers who will take advantage and cause bloodshed. Although the madness of a few people will not always spread, once in a while it will go out of control, leading to a massive genocide such as in Germany and Rwanda. And when there is another massive wholesale destruction, what will the world powers do about it?
Другие работы по теме:
Balken Reigon Essay Research Paper Balkan RegionThe
Balken Reigon Essay, Research Paper Balkan Region The Balkan Region has always been considered the Powder Keg of Europe. Usually when a war starts in Europe, the starting incident is always somewhere in the Balkans. One of the reasons for this is that through out the region, many different social and religious groups are all living in the same country and all trying to rule.
Dominicans And AfroAmericans Essay Research Paper In
Dominicans And Afro-Americans Essay, Research Paper In America today, there is a large and diverse African-American population. Within this population, there are several ethnic groups. The other ethnic group similar to Afro-Americans is Dominicans. Not only are they both minorities, but they also look similar as well.
Bosnia 2 Essay Research Paper BosniaThe war
Bosnia 2 Essay, Research Paper Bosnia The war in Bosnia-Herzegovina began in 1992. It has left at least a quarter of a million people dead or missing and made refugees of more than half the nation s population. A Treaty was signed on December 14, 1995 in Paris to formally end Bosnian War. It was signed by the presidents of Bosnia, Croatia, and Serbia as well as other international heads of state.
Racism And Prejudice In The World Today
Essay, Research Paper Hitler and the Jews, Apartheid in South Africa all conflicts that originated from some sort of racism. Turmoil in Ireland, war in kosovo all ethnic conflicts. Ever since the beginning of time people have been plagued by racism and ethnic conflicts due to minor differences ranging from religion to appearances.
Genocide In The Former Yugoslavia Essay Research
Paper Genocide in the Former Yugoslavia The Catholics, Muslims, and Orthodox Christians in the former Yugoslavia have been fighting for centuries. They fight for land, they fight for ideas, and they fight for proof that they are best race. The fighting between these three have taken a devastating turn in the latter part of the 20th century.
The Holocaust Vs The Crucible Essay Research
Paper Hitler believed in ethnic cleansing. He wanted the non-white race to disappear. To him non-whites were an inferior race. Individuals of Jewish descent were particularly singled out. Hitler ordered their imprisonment in concentration camps which had deplorable living conditions. Jewish ?prisoners? were badly mistreated and then most were killed.
Ethnic Cleansing Essay Research Paper The Sick
Ethnic Cleansing Essay, Research Paper The Sick of Society Rape is the ultimate act of brutality. Rape is committed by people whose feelings of inadequacy compel them to commit this horrific act on those that are weaker and different from themselves.
Ethnic Cleansing Essay Research Paper The first
Ethnic Cleansing Essay, Research Paper The first and most important human right is the right to live, but sometimes others bend the rules, and this is when genocide begins. Crimes against humanity have been around for many generations, including ours. The genocide against the Armenians by the Ottoman Turks in 1915 was because the Turkish authorities wanted to eliminate the Armenian presence in the country.
644 Essay Research Paper What Does Genocide
644 Essay, Research Paper What Does Genocide Mean? The era of mass murder might be given as a name for the 20th century. Never in the history of the world have so many millions of people been deliberately killed since 1900. These millions weren’t all because of war. They were victims of genocide: the deliberate killings of racial, religious, ethnic, or political groups.
Kosovo Essay Research Paper Kosovo US Involvement
Kosovo Essay, Research Paper Kosovo U.S. Involvement in Kosovo War has been waged in the Balkans for thousands of years. Yugoslavia has been divided, reunited, divided again, undergone wars and been through depressions. Each country within the Yugoslavia region has experienced hardships due to a failing economy, poor leadership, and civil wars.
African Americans Essay Research Paper Ethnic Group
African Americans Essay, Research Paper Ethnic Group Essay For my Ethnic Group Essay, I chose African Americans because they are the group that has, for the most part, been a main target for racism in today society, and through out the whole 18th and 19th century. There are many actual, recorded incidents where this can be shown.
Advancing Aggression Essay Research Paper When referring
Advancing Aggression Essay, Research Paper When referring to the Bosnia-Herzegovina Civil War it is necessary to look at past history of the nation before being able to make an accurate and reliable hypothesis on the decision making that was made during the crisis. The aspect, which will be argued, will be that the principals actions were unjust when referring to the religious injustices that occurred.
Ethinc Cleansing Essay Research Paper Ethnic Cleansing
Ethinc Cleansing Essay, Research Paper Ethnic Cleansing is a process in which an advancing army of one ethnic group expels civilians of other ethnic groups from towns and villages it conquers in order to create ethnically pure enclaves for members of their ethnic group. “Ethnic cleansing is a literal translation of the expression etnicko ciscenje in Serbo-Croatian/Croato-Serbian.
Ethnic Restaurants Essay Research Paper Ethnic RestaurantsI
Ethnic Restaurants Essay, Research Paper Ethnic Restaurants. I always wondered to the fact that United States of America doesn’t have a unique culture. In fact it is the world’s most multicultural country. The country has a lot of different cultures, and not one is similar to the others. No culture is better or worse than another.
James Banks Essay Research Paper Mark ShafferJames
James Banks Essay, Research Paper Mark Shaffer James Banks James Banks believes that there should be more multicultural education taught in schools. Education about ethnic diversity treats cultural pluralism within a nation-state by studying different traits from different groups, which determine one group from another.
Important Events Essay Research Paper There are
Important Events Essay, Research Paper There are many important things that happened in history. One of them would be World War II. This was a very important time in America. Many men and women during the holocaust were losing their lives because of one man s beliefs of ethnic cleansing. This was one of the lowest points in the history of the world.
Walls And Borders Essay Research Paper Walls
Walls And Borders Essay, Research Paper Walls and Borders Do good fences really make good neighbors? (666) Robert Frost s poem Mending Wall examines this as a local issue. It can also be interpreted as a global issue. Frost writes about two neighbor farmers and how a wall between their property effects the relationship between the two.
Collective Memory Essay Research Paper Anthony D
Collective Memory Essay, Research Paper Anthony D. Smith who wrote National Identity and Myths of Ethnic Descent discussed how myths are formed and how they can lead to the ethnic regeneration within a group of people. He associated his ideas on ethnic regeneration with the countries of Turkey, Greece, England, France, and Israel.
Ethnic Conflicts In The Developing World Essay
, Research Paper The idea that inter-ethnic conflict has exploded since the end of the Cold War is somewhat of a misconception in my opinion. The idea that the number of ethnic conflicts has recently exploded, ushering us into a violent new era of ethnic “pandemonium,” is one of those optical illusions that round-the-clock and round-the-world television coverage has helped to create.
Crime And Ethnicity Essay Research Paper Crime
Crime And Ethnicity Essay, Research Paper Crime and Ethnicity A crime rate difference among ethnic groups is probably a cultural universal. Chinese and Japanese Americans have lower crime rates then other Americans: Irish immigrants to England have higher crime rates. In Sweden, Hungarian and Yugoslav immigrants have a higher crime rate.
Mixed Marriages Essay Research Paper Today an
Mixed Marriages Essay, Research Paper Today, ?an increase in the number of interracial marriages in America is an encouraging sign,? experts say. But still, there will always be people who will oppose of it, and would not let it happen in their own family. Today, mixed marriages are not defined as only as marriage involving two people with different ethnic backgrounds, but also in believing in different religions.
American Culture And Gender Vs. Racial Differences
Essay, Research Paper American Culture and Gender vs. Racial Differences With all of the social and economic gains made by women and ethnic groups through the past 30 years, it is amazing how America still focuses on both gender and racial differences. It doesn’t matter if you are African American, Caucasion, Asian or whatever.
Curtis Chang Essay Essay Research Paper Curtis
Curtis Chang Essay Essay, Research Paper Curtis Chang EssayCurtis Chang s essay was so effective it made me look at ethnic minorities differently. Ethnic minorities are not anymore issues that everybody seems to ignore, they are now groups with success. The achievement of this ethnic minority shows how they are able to achieve the American dream.
Ethnic Groups And Minorities Essay Research Paper
Ethnic Groups and Minorities The word minority is a word that is mentioned a lot in our society today. The media use it frequently, and they are using it when they are referring to the blacks, Latinos, and Jews in our society. They are labeled into groups like ethnic groups or minorities. The word minority means something small.
The Main Causes Of War Essay Research
Paper Wars are constantly being fought in the world. Bloodshed had taken place as top leaders ponder their every move in their game of victories and conquests. Behind each and every war that has taken place, there will always be a reason for it.
Kosovo Conflict Essay Research Paper The Balkans
Kosovo Conflict Essay, Research Paper The Balkans have been a very unstable region for hundreds of years. The reason for contention is because of ethnic origin and disputes of which race owns which
The Handmad
’s Tale The Terror On The Balkans Essay, Research Paper What had its roots in the ancient ethnic conflict in the Balkans led to the major tragic events in our modern world. The dictatorship government in Serbia began an operation of ethnic cleansing in the region of Kosovo. Strong Serbian-Christian military and paramilitary forces invaded Kosovo as if they were fighting against an equally strengthened force.
Creation Of Reality In 1984 Essay Research
Paper 1984 Essay Creation of reality takes place everywhere in society, both today, and in 1984. Reality can easily be created. Reality is usually created to sway or alter the public opinion. The creation or alteration of reality can have both positive and negative effects.
Kashmir Conflict Essay Research Paper US Congressman
Kashmir Conflict Essay, Research Paper US Congressman Frank Pallone has condemned the “ethnic cleansing” of Pandits in Jammu and Kashmir and urged Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee to keep the community’s concerns uppermost in his mind during his upcoming visit to the state.
Diversity Essay Research Paper Diversity and the
Diversity Essay, Research Paper Diversity and the Mass Media The question of weather the media?s role in establishing racial and ethnic equality is not only very easy to answer but needs to be answered. People need to think of how important it is. People tend to under estimate this power and hate to admit that the media shapes our opinions about people.
Segregation Essay Research Paper Though 1963 was
Segregation Essay, Research Paper Though 1963 was not the year of integration, it was still a continued debate throughout the southern states. Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary defines segregation as the separation or isolation of race, class, or ethnic group by enforced or voluntary residence in a restricted area, by barriers to social intercourse, by separate educational facilities, or by other discrimitory means.
Us Foreign Affairs Essay Research Paper US
Us Foreign Affairs Essay, Research Paper U.S. Military Aid to Foreign Nations The United States military aid given to Kosovo raises many questions about the foreign affairs policy of the United States of America. Now the U.S. is sending its troops to Timor, a small island off the northern coast of Australia.
Clean Clear And Beautiful Skin Essay Research
Paper One of the most popular trends of today is to have clean, clear, and beautiful skin. This advertisement placed by SmithKline Beecham in the popular teen magazine,YM, rves to
Melting Pot Soldier Essay Research Paper email
Melting Pot Soldier Essay, Research Paper email: Mjfxtitle: Melting pot soldierI found that Melting Pot Soldiers ,by William L. Burton, displays the American Civil War, and its participants, from three views. Firstly, it addresses events of the time by discussing the beginnings of the war and how ethnicity played a role in people s feelings towards the conflict.