Consumers Essay, Research Paper
The Tobacco Industry: Liable for it’s Consumers?
Should the tobacco industry be held liable for illness and death caused by smoking? Currently, the Federal government is looking into this in numerous court cases, scientific studies, and a never-ending battle between national health, and the big tobacco giants. But to make an educated opinion, both sides of the argument must be heard.
We hear about it all the time: Smoking causes this and smoking causes that. Not a day goes by that the media frenzy doesn’t find something bad about smoking. Another reason why smoking will shorten your life span, increase stress, and kill you 5 minutes faster. The truth in the matter is that smoking is just generally bad for your health. There’s no way in denying it, the Federal Drug Administration has hundreds of studies on the effects of smoking; “nicotine in cigarettes… is a drug”, “cigarettes… lead to addiction”, etc. But why, then, all the fuss about lawsuits? Actually, why would cigarettes still be legal? A bit odd they still exist, and generate so much money, don’t you think? A while ago, in the 1950’s, the FDA passes a regulation that forced cigarette companies to place warning labels on the side of their products, informing consumers of the dangers of the consumption of their product. Well, if people know about the effects, wouldn’t a case be deemed frivolous in court? How is their case heard?
There are two reasons for this: states are suing in place of citizens, and the tobacco companies allegedly lied about the effects of smoking. Currently, there is a huge, multi-plaintiff, multi-state suit against a large consortium of tobacco companies. Companies such as R. J. Reynolds, Brown & Williamson, Ligget & Meyers, and Phillip Morris Inc. are all under fire by over 39 states. Florida leads the group, asking for reimbursement for the money spent through Medicaid, the Federal Insurance program, for the treatment of illnesses, diseases, and deaths related to tobacco use. Each state is suing in place of all the recipients of Medicaid, who remain anonymous. This is because of something called subrogation, where the insurance company has the right to sue in place of their client, with the insurance company accepting all risks and costs involved. Also all the profits.
The states had a rock hard case, and the tobacco industry folded. They opted to settle. The New York Times calculates the cost of the settlement to be $378.5 billion. The actual people who suffer from cigarette use receive not a cent, but they do have lower premiums. Why settle when you lose over 350 billion dollars? Must have been a pretty rock hard case, huh?
It has been shown, in a 1995 investigation of the effects of nicotine in cigarettes, that the “tobacco manufacturers ‘intend’ that their products have addictive… effects”. Seems that the tobacco companies deliberately addicted people to cigarettes to ensure high sales figures. That may be true, but tobacco companies claim “assumption of risk” in defense against all claims.
“Assumption of risk” means, in a nutshell, that if you knowingly participated in something, and were fully aware of or had full access to a list of the consequences of your actions, the owner or producer of that something is not liable for what happens to you. Since there were warning labels on cigarette packs, and FDA investigations are publicly available, why should the tobacco companies be held responsible for something you did, knowing that it causes cancer, etc? This defense has withstood scrutiny for decades, and no one could pinch a penny from the large tobacco corporations because of it.
Tobacco brands though, like Marlboro, glamorized smoking, some say. The Marlboro man, and Joe Camel, are almost cultural icons. Movies show smoking as something ‘cool’. Surely this warps young children’s minds, and causes them to partake in something addictive. The ultimate marketing scheme, right? Wrong. Most everyone says Joe Camel made children want to smoke, but the reality is totally different. Advertisements effect choice of brand name, not the initial decision to smoke, studies show. Banning advertisements would actually increase the number of smokers, an international poll showed. So the tobacco companies aren’t liable then, right?
Here’s where a mockery of due process comes in, as the tobacco companies’ many, overpriced lawyers like to say. A law called the Florida Medicaid Third-Party Liability Act(in Florida’s case, most other states copied Florida’s actions) totally blows the “assumption of risk” defense out of the water. It states that the cigarette companies fraudulently misrepresented the risks involved with smoking, concealed from consumers the addictive nature of their products, and targeted young individuals. That being said, how could the consumer make an informed judgement about the nature of smoking? Hence the “assumption of risk” does not apply to something you know nothing about. Now the tobacco companies have nothing to pull themselves out of the water with.
But even if they did, the entire mindset that created the Florida Medicaid Third-Party Act would not have it stand for long in court. The Florida Supreme Court allowed this outlandishly unconstitutional act to pass, and the Federal Supreme Court will not challenge it. It “meets the rationale of the times”. Sure, it may be good for society, but isn’t the legality of it an issue? It seems not, to the hundreds of millions of tobacco sufferers across the globe. Not to mention it won’t tear apart the deep pockets of Big Tobacco, which is what the state governments are really after.
Many fight the argument from a morals and ethics standpoint. They’re selling poison to our children, they say. This seems to be the strongest view, as many would not even bother with the laws and court proceedings or history of the topic. This seems to be the one the masses follow.
So should the tobacco industry be held liable for illness and death caused by smoking? Morally, yes. Legally, that’s a tough one. But I’ll stick to the good ol’ politicians, who’ll pass any law or bill, no matter how outrageous, to fill their pockets and remain in office for another term. I mean, come on, the state is the court and the plaintiff, and they just so happen to pass an act that pretty much forces them to win their case 20 minutes before they file their suit. How obvious to everyone the abuse of power shown. Let’s hope our government acts this erratically on something everyone can agree on though next time. Perhaps demonopolizing other industries. With Big Tobacco going down fast, the future seems to be looking up… I need a cigarette, how about you?
363
Другие работы по теме:
Summary On The Articles About Second Hand
Smoking Essay, Research Paper Secondhand Smoke, Is It a Hazard? In the 1950’s and 60’s scientists gave the people a lot of evidence on the deadly effects of smoking where the tobacco companies on the other hand tried to put the doubt in people?s minds through the campaigns to show that it is not all true. By the time people actually decided to take care of their health and finally saw how life-threatening smoking could be by real life examples, the tobacco companies already got rich from its sales.
Secondhand Smoke Is Bad For Your Health
Essay, Research Paper Reyes Freytes Phil 112 4-20-01 Secondhand Smoke I went on the Internet and started surfing around until I found this web-site called www.no-smoker. This site is About Americans for Nonsmoker’s Rights. The article I read was called “Things are changing”. The issue is secondhand smoke is bad for your health.
Smoking Essay Research Paper SmokingAfter reading the
Smoking Essay, Research Paper Smoking After reading the article “Whose lungs are they, anyway?” by Janet Singleton, I was able to determine the proposal at issue. The issue in this article is about why people decide to smoke and who s responsible for making hat decision. Should we put the blame one the tobacco industry or is it just people’s own decision to smoke? The position I stand in is I feel that the tobacco industry should not be held responsible for smokers’ decision to smoke.
Bureau Of Alcohol And Tobacco Essay Research
Paper BUREAU of ALCOHOL, TOBACCO, and FIREARMS The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms is one of the most important Federal Agencies we have. It is dedicated to reducing violent crime, collecting revenue and protecting the public. The ATF, for short, has many different programs for alcohol, firearms, arson and explosives, and tobacco.
Tobaco Indusrty Influence Essay Research Paper Over
Tobaco Indusrty Influence Essay, Research Paper Over the last five years, researchers have calculated that the teenage smoking rates have climbed tremendously. Graph number one shows a steady increase in the number of teenagers who smoke heavily. Graph number two shows how teenage smoking has made a comeback, and how the number of teen-agers smoke occasionally and who develop heavier habits has increased sharply in recent years.
The Tobacco Wars Essay Research Paper The
The Tobacco Wars Essay, Research Paper The Tobacco Wars The U.S. government regulates the sale and distribution of tobacco products in many ways. Some examples of the way the government regulates are setting an age limit and taxing tobacco products. In the economic world, the tobacco wars are a serious issue.
Tobacco
’s Unfair Treatment Essay, Research Paper Tabacco and its unfair treatment Unfortunately for the tobacco industry we live in an unfair society where the population always wants to point the finger at someone other than themselves. Tobacco has been around as long as anyone can remember, and unfortunate for the tobacco industry, they made it possible for the smoking American to be able to buy fully processed and manufactured cigarettes.
Bureau Of Alchohol Tobacco And Firearms Essay
, Research Paper THE BUREAU OF ALCOHOL, TOBACCO AND FIREARMS The Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms(ATF) was founded in 1972, established as a separate agency inside the U.S. Treasury Department. Before this
Can We Stop Teens From Smoking Essay
, Research Paper Stopping teens from smoking is a big challenge many communities face today. Many communities can only watch without action while local businesses continue to sell tobacco products to minors, even under risk of penalty of law.
Tobacco Smoking And Its Risks Essay Research
Paper I am here to talk to you about smoking its risks and its consequences. First, to understand how smoking tobacco affects your body you have got to understand how smoking works inside your body
Smoking 2 Essay Research Paper Teen Tobacco
Smoking 2 Essay, Research Paper Teen Tobacco Wars Even though there is a seemingly huge restructuring of the tobacco marketing industry underway, it s all one giant shift in targeting with kids now semi-protected, and the college age
Tobacco Loss At Home Is A Gain
Overseas Essay, Research Paper BOSTON – MONDAY, APRIL 27, 1998 OPINION/ESSAYS Tobacco Loss at Home Is a Gain Overseas Kathryn Mulvey Under the stress of battling US regulators, the internal tobacco industry mindset is getting easier to see. It realizes it has
Teen Smoking Essay Research Paper Problems With
Teen Smoking Essay, Research Paper Problems With Teen Smoking in America Teen smoking is a serious problem in the United States because the tobacco industry targets teenagers with their persuasive advertising. We see often in public places, teenagers who are standing around, smoking cigarettes. Recently, there has been legislation that has been turned down by Republicans in Congress, which was supposed to send a strong message to the tobacco industry.
Secondhand Smoke And Its Effects Essay Research
Paper Secondhand smoke and laws about smoking in public places “What the smoker does to himself may be his business, but what the smoker does to the non-smoker is quite a different matter This we see as the most dangerous development to the viability of the tobacco industry that has yet occurred The strategic and long run antidote to the passive smoking issue is, as we see it, developing and widely
Smoking In Public Essay Research Paper 11299Whinery
Smoking In Public Essay, Research Paper 11/2/99Whinery 1 Got a Light Little Boy? For years, there has been a huge debate on whether cigarette smoke affects both the people being around the smoke, or the people doing the actual act itself. There is a huge cloud of ?smoke? on this topic that needs to be cleared.
Influence Of Television Essay Research Paper Did
Influence Of Television Essay, Research Paper Did 1960s TV Influence Kids To Smoke? Jurors Spent The Day Looking At Examples Of Cigarette Placement In Vintage TV Clips The Latest | The Players | They Said It The Paperwork | The Archives: How We Got Here | The Front Page ST. PAUL, Posted 5:28 p.m. March 09, 1998 — One woman juror kept time with the music as the theme from “The Beverly Hillbillies” was played Monday in Minnesota’s tobacco trial to show how cigarettes were marketed to youth.
Tobacco Essay Research Paper THIS IS A
Tobacco Essay, Research Paper THIS IS A PAPER REGARDING THE TOBACCO INDUSTRY (3 PAGES). The Killing Business? This paper is about the tobacco industry. Some would find that the label ‘killing business’ is very appropriate. Others would say that that name is misleading and inaccurate. Biased, I am not. So we will look at the issue in regards to the industry from both consumer and producer points of perspective with fairness and equality in reach.
Tobacco Advertising Essay Research Paper Tobacco AdvertisingAlthough
Tobacco Advertising Essay, Research Paper Tobacco Advertising Although the Tobacco Industry recently paid enormous fines to the US Government and Individual states, they continue to promote smoking and influence young human beings world wide to use their products through multi dimensional advertising.
Effects Of Media On Today
’s Society Essay, Research Paper Effects of Media Today?s Society In today?s society the media has a great effect on what people buy. The media has been telling us what to buy since the beginning of the printing press. There is only one problem now; industry is trying to target certain groups that are more susceptible to buy their products.
Tobacco Essay Research Paper Tobacco Products Must
Tobacco Essay, Research Paper Tobacco Products Must Be Illegal How is it possible for something that kills so many people to be legal in a country that boasts the supreme protection of it?s citizens?
Tabacco Crazy Essay Research Paper The tobacco
Tabacco Crazy Essay, Research Paper The tobacco companies have been getting a lot of bad reviews lately. They are being sued for millions of dollars for smokers’ Medicaid bills. I do not understand why they are being sued. The tobacco companies are only trying to make a living like everyone else. Warning labels are put on cigarette packs, and everyone knows about the hazards of smoking.
Tobacco Companies
’ Denial Essay, Research Paper Tobacco companies are now in trouble, confronted by all the scientific research results from the society, that cigarets makers have been concealing the fact that tobacco contains an addictive drug from an unwary public. Tobacco industry researchers say throughout the years it has been showed that smoking causes diseases such as oral and lung cancers, emphysema, and heart disease.
Tobacco Companies Essay Research Paper Tobacco companies
Tobacco Companies Essay, Research Paper Tobacco companies are killing our youth with advertising. Over 3, 000 children experiment with smoking tobacco everyday. With hundreads of studies proving tobacco to be harmful, this is a large number of new smokers. The majority of new smokers are not adults, but are actually children.
On Tobacco Paper Essay Research Paper About
On Tobacco Paper Essay, Research Paper About The Cigarette Papers On May 12, 1994, a package containing 4,000 pages of secret internal tobacco industry documents arrived at the office of Professor Stanton Glantz at the University of California, San Francisco. The anonymous source of these “cigarette papers” was identified in the return address only as “Mr.
Teen Smoking Essay Research Paper Teen SmokingDue
Teen Smoking Essay, Research Paper Teen Smoking Due to peer pressure, propaganda and availability, teenage smoking has been on the rise since 1986. Three thousand children start using tobacco each day
Tobacco Should Be Illegal Essay Research Paper
Tobacco Should Be Illegal! Why isn t tobacco considered a drug? When the facts are reviewed, tobacco produces all of the effects of a drug although isn t recognized as one. What makes tobacco different from any other drug?
Tobacco Use Essay Research Paper Comparative forms
Tobacco Use Essay, Research Paper Comparative forms of tobacco use In 1492 native Indians were smoking rolled up tobacco leaves. In the 16th century tobacco smoking spread to Europe. By the late 1800 tobacco tolled in paper called cigarettes were a major industry with billions being sold each year.
Tobacco Essay Research Paper Tobacco comes from
Tobacco Essay, Research Paper Tobacco comes from the tobacco plant, nicotiana tobacum. Leaves of the plant may be smoked, inhaled in form of snuff, or chewed. Tobacco smoke contains about
Market Failure And The Tobacco Essay Research
Paper Market Failure and the Tobacco Industry Any business or corporation in operation today is subject to market failure if they aren t already experiencing it. Market failure is the simple misallocation or the inefficiency of allocation of resources. This then results in waste or lost value that the company or business must endure and deal with.