Le Colonel Chabert Essay, Research Paper
Le Colonel Chabert exhibits the relationship between strong and weak
characters. The degree of strength within a character reflects how well
the character survives in society. In society, weak characters often have
no identity, profession or rank. Stronger characters have power to succeed
from inner confidence, motivation and ambition. Any drastic changes
brought to the body or soul by the environment corrupts that person’s
strength thereby affecting their ability to function properly in society.
This comparison of characters gives an understanding of Balzac’s
pessimistic view of nineteenth century society.
?
A character’s strength and energy in the novel determines their
survival in society. Colonel Chabert has been known to be a courageous
hero in the past, “… je commandais un r?giment de cavalerie ? Eylau.
J’ai ?t? beaucoup dans le succ?es de la c?l?bre charge…” Once he returns
to Paris after his injury, he loses his identity and becomes the ” weak
character ” of society. This is a rapid decline down the “ladder of
success” and Chabert tries desperately to climb back up to the top, where
he had been before. At the beginning of the novel, there is a vision of a
slow non-energetic man walking progressively up the stairs to lawyer
Derville’s study which contrasts the boisterous energy of the clerks.
Chabert reaches Derville’s study and is determined to find the lawyer to
help him find justice for his infortunes, “… me suis-je d?termin? ?
venir vous trouver. Je vous parlerai de mes malhers plus tard.” Chabert
demonstrates some energy left in him by his will to retrieve everything
that he lost. This energy to gain back his power changes to furious and
revengeful energy upon learning what his wife had done, “Les yeux de
l’homme ?nergique brillaient rallum?s aux feux du d?sir et de la
vengeance.” After a period of time, Chabert loses hope and bids farewell
forever. He gives up his identity to become an unknown person as he
realizes that his strength of character is not enough to keep him alive in
this society. He sees himself weakening when seeing his wife and her
children as he does not have the heart to break up her family. He tells
his wife, “Je ne r?clamerai jamais le nom que j’ai peut-?tre illustr?. Je
ne suis plus qu’un pauvre diable nomm? Hyancinthe…” Hence, Chabert
becomes a numbered person in an institution, “Je ne suis pas un homme, je
suis le num?ro 164,…” Also, he becomes the weakest among everyone in the
institution, ” En ce moment, le colonel Chabert s’assit au milieu de ses
hommes ? faces ?nergiques,… ” In contrast, Madame Ferraud represents a
woman who has strong innovative traits, starts at the bottom but gradually
rises to the top after Chabert had gone. She becomes driven by her passion
to enter the upper class and become “Une femme comme il faut”. She uses
her persuasive and aggressive qualities to satisfy her ambitions. Once at
the top, she has the power to survive better than Chabert. At one point,
Madame Ferraud is weakened when Derville confronts her for lying about the
letter from Chabert. This shows that the characters do not remain in a
consistent position and this determines whether or not a character is
capable of surviving well or not. The personality and appearance of
characters become transformed as a result of changes in the environment.
For instance, Chabert appreciates the help he is receiving from Derville.
He acknowledges Derville’s kind words by saying humbly, “… Voil? le
premier mot de politesse que j’entends depuis…” Chabert is surprised that
the treatment from Derville surpasses the ten years of rejection by his
wife, justice and society. His sufferings have caused him be more kind
hearted and more considerate to others. He is willing to live without
pleasure, to remain poor and mediocre. This is a startling contrast to his
past where he had been an ambitious man. Chabert’s strength is decreasing
as “Ses souffrances physiques et morales lui avaient d?j? vici? le corps
dans quelques-uns des organes les plus importantes.” On the other hand,
Madame Ferraud’s rise to power results in a more persuasive, independent
and high spirited woman. This is shown by,
?
“Encore jeune et belle, Madame Ferraud joua le r?le d’une femme ? la
mode, et v?cut dans l’atmosph?re de la cour. Riche par elle- m?me,
riche par son mari,… elle en partageait la splendeur.”
?
In addition, Madame Ferraud “?tait enevelop?e dans un ?l?gant peignoir,
les boucles de ses cheveaux… Elle ?tait fra?che et rieuse.” Her gracious
actions and her manner of speech is characteristic of her new personality.
This is to her advantage as she uses these characteristics to calm Chabert
and convince him to stay at her home. She has a superficiel layer covering
her body to hide the false image in order to accomplish what she wants,
?
“…elle monta chez elle, s’assit ? son secr?taire, d?posa le masque
de tranquillit? qu’elle conservait devant le comte Chabert, comme une
actrice qui, rentrant fatigu?e dans sa loge apr?s un cinqui?me acte
p?nible, tombe demi-morte et laisse dans la salle une image
d’elle-m?me ? laquelle elle ne ressemble plus.”
?
Therefore, Madame Ferraud does not concern herself with people beneath
her but rather, her quest to remain on top. There is a marked difference
between characters in terms of the inner self and heartfelt sentiments.
Chabert is a man filled with sorrow and despair after his return to Paris.
He is extremely melancholy as his sufferings outweigh any happy
experiences in his life,
?
“Je compris que l? o? j’?tais, l’air ne se renouvelait point, et que
j’allais mourir. Cette pens?e m’?ta le sentiment de la douleur
inexprimable par laquelle j’avais ?t? r?veill? …Quoique la m?moire
de ces moments soit bien t?n?breuse,…les impressions de souffrances
encore plus profondes que je devais ?prover…”
?
Chabert feels desperate when he says, “J’ai ?t? ?nterr? sous des mort,
mais maintenant je suis enterr? sous de vivants,…” He is extremely
injured to what he has experienced that “son extr?me malheur avait sans
doute d?truit ses croyances.” Sadness prevails in Chabert’s heart and
there is a bleak outlook to his future, “Des grosses larmes tomb?rent des
yeux fl?tris du pauvre soldat et roul?rent sur ses joues rid?es. A
l’aspect de ces difficult?s, il fut d?courag?.” Chabert at “L’Hospice de la
vieillesse” has lost any traces of raging energy left in him as “Le vieux
soldat ?tait calme, immobile, presque distrait…Son regard avait une
expression de sto?cisme…” Madame Ferraud is heartless and has no
feelings towards anyone except for her desire for power. For example, the
marriage to Count Ferraud,
?
“… elle con?ut d’attacher le comte ? elle par le plus fort des
liens, par la cha?ne d’or, et voulut ?tre si riche que sa fortune
rend?t son second mariage indissoluble, si par hasard le comte Chabert
reparaissait encore.”
?
Even though she is a cold, unfeeling woman, there is one sign of
emotion left caused by a momentary vision of her past life, “Deux grosses
larmes roul?rent toutes chaudes sur les mains de sa femme…” The personal
feelings of weak and strong characters brings a different perspective and
thus distinguishes them from one another.
?
Balzac often uses visionary poetic images such as the infant, animal,
light and dark, to illustrate the contrast between the characters. The
infant image is a romantic element where the character refuses reality and
remains a weak, na?ve child. For example, Chabert is a child; “O? en
?tais-je? dit le colonel avec la na?vet? d’un enfant d’un soldat, car il y
a souvent de l’enfant dans le vrai soldat,…” In addition, Chabert loses
his temper and Derville controls him by saying, “Laissez-moi r?parer vos
sottises, grand enfant!” Finally, Chabert refuses his identity and looks
at Derville with “une anxi?t? peureuse, avec une crainte de viellard et
d’enfant.” Derville states Chabert’s destiny, “Sorti de l’hospice des
Enfants trouv?s, il revient mourir ? l’hospice de la Vieillessse,…” The
animal image is used to show how animals are considered to be beneath the
human race. Often, Chabert is treated as a dog, “Enfin, le jour m?me o?
l’on me jeta sur le pav? comme un chien,…” Chabert’s self pride becomes
shattered as all of the clercs ignore him ; “Il se mit ? regarder
modestement autour de lui, comme un chien qui, en se glissant dans une
cuisine ?trang?re,… The change of light and darkness presents a
contrast between happiness and sadness as well as the energy of each
character. The sun is a form of bright light that does not shine whenever
there is some dismal feeling and lack of energy in the atmosphere, “notre
soleil s’est couch?, nous avons tous froid maintenant. ” Balzac uses the
sun to indicate the never ending darkness for Chabert as “Je ne suis plus
q’un pauvre diable nomm? Hyacinthe, qui ne demande que sa place au soleil.
Adieu…” His facial expressions are marked with darkness, “Les bords du
chapeau qui couvrait le front du viellard projetaient un sillon noir sur le
haut de visage.” Balzac has a pessimistic view of society in Paris.
Paris has become a large modernized society and its traditional charm has
disappeared. Hence, the characters change according to the rise of this
new society. For example, Chabert returns to a transformed place,
“…amener pour la France une ?re de prosp?rit? nouvelle, alors la soci?t?
parisienne changea de face.” In this society, he becomes non existant,
ridiculed and weakened to the lowest denominator. He is shocked of what he
sees, “Oh! monsieur, revoir Paris! C’?tait un d?lire que je…” The writer
expresses his disgust of society through Derville’s condemnation of
society, “Vous allez conna?tre ces jollies choses-l?, vous; moi, je vais
vivre ? la campagne avec ma femme, Paris me fait horreur.” Balzac uses the
contrast between each characters’ strength to justify the degration of
the weak characters.
?
The society is corrupted with sin, injustice and disease. There are
always successses and failures in the society but the survival of certain
individuals depends on the interaction between the relative strength of the
character and society. Weak characters do not survive well from lack of
fierce energy present in the strong characters. These deficiencies cause
the powerful characters to dominate in society and the weak ones quickly
forgotten, set apart from the rest of the world. Balzac does not approve
of this inequality between individuals so he presents a pessimistic and
satirical view of society and the individuals in it.
?
?
Bibliograpy
1. Balzac, Honor? de. Le Colonel Chabert. France: ?ditions Gallimard, 1974, pp.21-121.
?
2. Dargan, John. Balzac and the Drama of Perspective. New York: French Forum Publishers, 1985, p.45.
Другие работы по теме:
Romeo An Juliet Essay Research Paper hi
Romeo An Juliet Essay, Research Paper hi i need an essay about a character in romeo and juliet that demonsrtated maturity. in a well developed multi pagraph essay and say why you think the character’s maturity was greater than the other characters in the play.
Louisa May Alcott Essay Research Paper Louisa
Louisa May Alcott Essay, Research Paper Louisa was born in Germantown, Pennsylvania on November 29, 1832. Her parents, Bronson and Abigail May Alcott decided to name their second daughter after her aunt, Louisa May Green. Her father was a noted New England Transcendentalist philosopher and educator who worked only irregularly throughout Louisa May’s life.
Antigone 2 Essay Research Paper Some individuals
Antigone 2 Essay, Research Paper Some individuals in literature try to do what they believe is right, even though they face oppositions. In the play “Antigone”, by Sophocles, and “A Few Good Men”, by Rob Reiner, Both Colonel Jessep and King Creon are two such inividuals. In both of these plays, they are both successful in doing what they believe is right, but they both face oppositions.
Barn Burning Essay Research Paper In the
Barn Burning Essay, Research Paper In the story ?Barn Burning? one question that sticks out to me is at what point should a person make a choice between what his parents and/ or family believes and his own values. In this story Colonel Sartoris is faced with the decision of either going along with the views and actions of his father or making the decision of running away and leaving his family behind.
The Autobiography Of Miss Jane Pittman Essay
, Research Paper In the novel The Autobiography Of Miss Jane Pittman, there were many different stories about JanePittman’s life. In the movie there were not as many stories as the novel, but they were still quite
Untitled Essay Research Paper Ticonderoga and Crown
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Ticonderoga and Crown point The immediate object of the attack on the British Forts at Ticonderoga and Crown Point on May 10 and 11, 1775 was first to capture the forts themselves, but also to obtain a cannon and supplies to use for the impending seige of Boston. Washington, who assumed command of the American forces on July 2, 1775, could not attempt this attack without heavy artillery, which was procured by Colonel Ethan Allen, Colonel Benedict Arnold and Colonel Seth Warner with Vermont?s Green Mountain Boys.
Catch22 And My Antonia
… Character Comparison Essay, Research Paper Perhaps the most directly conflicting characters in Catch-22 and in My Antonia are Colonel Cathcart and Antonia. Both of these characters are ambitious and each sees a road that runs ahead toward something called success or wealth , but the roads that they see are constructed differently.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
5 Generals Of The Civil War Essay
, Research Paper 5 Generals of the Civil War Colonel Benjamin H. Grierson was a union soldier that led his men through the key southern transportation states of Mississippi and Louisiana. Him and his men totally believed in the scorched earth policy. The policy was to destroy anything that their opponent can use against them or demolish anything that the enemy can use to better their chances of victory.
Barn Burning By Faulkner Essay Research Paper
In William Faulkner?s ?Barn Burning,? the main character is Colonel Sartoris Snopes, or ?Sarty? for short. This young boy is torn between loyalty to his father and morality, and this story deals with that struggle.
Killer Angels Essay Research Paper Detailing the
Killer Angels Essay, Research Paper Detailing the events around four days in late June and early July, 1863, the story follows four men as they march into the field for what will become the bloodiest three days in American history. Robert E. Lee leads the Confederate troops on an invasion of Pennsylvania, believing it is the only way the South can still force Washington to accept peace, and a Southern victory.
Love Wanted Essay Research Paper Love WantedMiss
Love Wanted Essay, Research Paper Love Wanted Miss Emily Grierson was somewhat of a recluse. She spent the last years of her lonely life at home all alone except for the Negro man that was her life-long servant. Her build was that of a small woman, but through the years of her grieving she had gained many pounds and she had become quite large.
Paris Essay Research Paper After the revolution
Paris Essay, Research Paper After the revolution there were many novels written and in which portray Paris and its culture. Novels such as Colonel Chabert and The Red and the Black both portray views of Paris and its culture but from opposite ends of society. Colonel Chabert shows more of the poorer class and The Red and The Black show more of the higher class.
A Rose For Emily By William Faulkner
Essay, Research Paper The story A Rose for Emily by William Faulkner in my opinion was a very interesting story. The story was about a old and troubled woman named Emily Grierson who because of her father?s death had become one of the towns obligation?s and also one of it?s problems. Emily a very stubborn old lady who refused to pay her taxes because of a little tale that Colonel Sartoris who was the mayor at the time had told her.
My Fair Lady Essay Research Paper In
My Fair Lady Essay, Research Paper In the opening scene of the play/musical we meet all of the main characters, Professor Henry Higgins, Eliza Doolittle, and Colonel Pickering. It is also here that they are each introduced to one another.
Theodore Roosevelt Essay Research Paper Theodore Roosevelt
Theodore Roosevelt Essay, Research Paper Theodore Roosevelt was one of the most successful presidents in the United States history. He achieved many goals in life. Some of these goals were as follows: 1) He won the Spanish-American War; 2) He won the Nobel Peace Prize; 3) He was the youngest president in United States history.
Bridge Over The River Kwai Essay Research
Paper The Bridge over the River Kwai “Who pants for glory finds but short repose: a breath revives him, or a breath overthrows”…Alexander Pope The position of glory is a precarious one at best says Alexander Pope. One who desperately seeks glory will find it only in passing, and in his quest for it can, in fact be consumed and consequently destroyed by it.
Movie Glory Essay Research Paper Movie Glory
Movie: Glory Essay, Research Paper Movie: Glory The movie Glory (though having seen it 4 times) still amazes me. It is a very emotional movie. It is about the fact that blacks were starting to not be
Romance In The House Of Seven Essay
, Research Paper The House of Seven Gables: What are the effects of Romance used in the novel-as defined by Hawthorne in his Preface-on the moral of the story?
Harry Potter Essay Research Paper The Best
Harry Potter Essay, Research Paper The Best book I ever read this summer was Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban. Some of the characters in the book are Harry Potter, Bathilda Bagshot (author) , Wendelin the Weird (witch) ,Vernon Dursley ,Petunia Dursley,Dudley Dursley ,Ron Weasley, Hermione Granger, Hedwig (Harry’s owl), Lily Potter, James Potter, Errol (Weasley’s owl), Arthur Weasley, Bill Weasley, Molly Weasley, Scabbers, Ginny, Percy Weasley, Fred Weasley, George Weasley, Hagrid, Minvera McGonagall, Sirius Black, Marge Dursley (Dudley’s aunt, Harry’s relative by marriage), Ripper (Marge’s dog) , Colonel Fubster (takes care of Marge’s other dogs w/ her), Stan Shunpike (Knight Bus assistant) , Neville Longbottom, Ernie Prang (Knight Bus driver), Madam Marsh (woman on Knight Bus).
The Lack Of Comprehensive Speech In Catch
22 Essay, Research Paper The Lack of Comprehensive Speech in Catch 22 Most of what we really say has no meaning. This concept is perfectly supported in Catch 22, by Joseph Heller. Almost every character and scene in
One Hundred Yerar O Soltude Essay Research
Paper ONE HUNDRED YEARS OF SOLITUDE KEY LITERARY ELEMENTS SETTING The setting of One Hundred Years of Solitude is the fictional town of Macondo, Columbia, which is much like Garc?a M?rquez?s
Roswell Essay Research Paper More than 50
Roswell Essay, Research Paper More than 50 years ago an event occurred that permanently changed the way many Americans feel about the government. In July of 1947, in Roswell, New Mexico, strange wreckage was found. The first press release, issued by Colonel William Blanchard, identified the material as a “crashed alien disk”.
Legends Of The Fall
— Literal Analysis Essay, Research Paper Legends of the Fall Legends of the Fall are a fictional drama/romance film by Edward Zwick. Set during World War 1 in the hills of Montana. The main setting was in the Ludlow ranch, where the author develops five particular characters: Colonel Ludlow, Alfred, Samuel, Tristan, and Susana.
T E Lawrence Essay Research Paper Colonel
T E Lawrence Essay, Research Paper Colonel T. E. Lawrence, known as Lawrence of Arabia, was a guerrilla leader in the Arab Revolt of 1916-18, which expelled the Turks from western Arabia and
Theodore Roosevelt And The Rough Riders Essay
, Research Paper Theodore Roosevelt and the Rough Riders Theodore Roosevelt was not much of a military man but the United States did everything with him that they could. After volunteering for duty, he was sent to help command the First United States Volunteer Calvary. Theodore was then under the command of the regimental commander Colonel Leonard Wood.
William Faulkner Essay Research Paper Biography on
William Faulkner Essay, Research Paper Biography on William Faulkner William Faulkner was born in New Albany, Mississippi on September 25, 1897 and then moved to Oxford, Mississippi with his family at the age of 5. Most of the novels written by William Faulkner take place in the area in which he himself was born and raised.
Rose For Emily Essay Research Paper rose
Rose For Emily Essay, Research Paper rose for emily Emily in Past and Present In the story A Rose for Emily , William Faulkner contrast the past with the present times. The past is easily represented in Emily herself, in Colonel Sartoris, in the old Negro servant, and in the Board of Alderman who accepted the Colonel s point of view that Emily be remitted of her taxes.
Dandelion Wine Essay Research Paper Dandelion Wine
Dandelion Wine Essay, Research Paper Dandelion Wine is a book written by Ray Bradbury. Dandelion Wine is a book about a summer through the eyes of a 12-year-old boy. It establishes a change of Douglas s childhood to manhood. It will show how a young, orgulous boy goes through many stymies. Douglas Spaulding is a boy growing up in a somewhat deserted town.
The Effects Of The Titanic Essay Research
Paper One of the most advertised events of the 1910’s was the so-called Unsinkable Titanic and it’s controversial sinking on April 14, 1912. When news of this British made luxury liner, weighing 46,000 gross tons reached American shores the press went wild. The idea of an unsinkable ship was bewildering.
Miss Emily
’s Male Interaction In A Rose For Emily Essay, Research Paper Miss Emily’s male interaction in A Rose for Emily The way that a person is raised has a lot to do with their