David Herbert Lawrence Essay, Research Paper
David Herbert Lawrence As a twentieth century novelist, essayist, and poet, David
Herbert Lawrence brought the subjects of sex, psychology, and religion to the
forefront of literature. One of the most widely read novels of the twentieth century,
Sons and Lovers, which Lawrence wrote in 1913, produces a sense of Bildungsroman1,
where the novelist re-creates his own personal experiences through the protagonist
in (Niven 115). Lawrence uses Paul Morel, the protagonist in Sons and Lovers,
for this form of fiction. With his mother of critical importance, Lawrence uses
Freud’s Oedipus complex, creating many analyses for critics. Alfred Booth
Kuttner states the Oedipus complex as: “the struggle of a man to emancipate
himself from his maternal allegiance and to transfer his affections to a woman
who stands outside the family circle” (277). Paul’s compromising situations
with Miram Leivers and Clara Dawes, as well as the death of his mother, display
the Oedipus complex throughout Sons and Lovers. At an adolescent age, Paul’s
oedipal love towards his mother is compromised by a young lady named Miram Leivers.
This profound situation puts Paul to the emotional test of Oedipal versus physical
love. As Kuttner goes on to state: “Paul’s admiration for his mother
know no bounds; her presence is always absorbing. Often at the sight of her, ‘his
heart contracts with love’” (278). Paul’s maternal relationship
defines the Oedipus complex. Miram pulls Paul away from his mother, while Paul’s
mother, Gertrude, sees Miram as a threat to her son. Paul, even though Miram is
around, still will not commit totally to her because of the strong ties between
mother and son. Paul says to his mother, “I’ll never marry while I’ve
got you – I won’t…” (Lawrence 240). Lawrence wrote frequently
of Paul’s love belonging to his mother and only his mother (212). Though
Miram Leivers could not truly find Paul’s heart, another woman named Clara
Dawes provides more stress on Paul’s maternal relationship. Although Paul
loved Clara, he still kept his attraction toward his mother. “Everything
he does is for her, the flowers he picks as well as the prizes he wins at school.
His mother is his intimate and his confidant” (Kuttner 278). Clara tried
desperately to win Paul over, but her social sophistication was too much for him.
Paul tells his mother: “I don’t want to belong to the well-to-do middle
class. I like my common people the best. I belong to the common people”
(Lawrence 250). Clara shows frustration with Paul because of his maternal devotion.
Again Lawrence displays the Oedipus complex through Paul to his mother, “And
I shall never meet the right woman as long as you live” (341). Paul’s
Oedipal love would be tested once more by him dealing with the death of his mother.
Paul, though, was tough enough in handling this dilemma. R.P. Draper recognizes
the loss of Paul’s mother as: Their special, private, intimate grief over
the impossible dream, and the magnificence of the woman, and the devotional quality
of Paul’s love, render the deathbed scenes poignant and innocent (292).
The verification of Kuttner’s statement is seen as Lawrence has Paul react
to her death in this manner: “my love – my love – oh, my love!
My love – oh, my love!” (384). Lawrence also writes of Paul’s
continuing love for his mother: “Looking at her, he felt he could never,
never let her go. No!” (385). Kuttner Implies: “But death has not
freed Paul from his mother. It has completed his allegiance to her. For death
has merely removed the last earthly obstacle to their ideal union” (280).
The love that Paul feels towards his mother would never die. He loves her just
as much when she died as he did when she was still alive. Paul continues life
having a maternal devotion that no other woman would ever be able to fill. Throughout
the novel, Paul is seen as one who lives for his mother. Mark Spilka explains:
“For if Paul has failed in his three loves, he has drawn from them the necessary
strength to live” (293). Sons and Lovers was written with Lawrence almost
defining the Oedipus complex through Paul. With this in mind, Kuttner gives this
insight about the novel: Sons and Lovers possesses this double quality to a high
degree. It ranks high, very high as a piece of literature and at the same time
embodies a theory which it illustrates and exemplifies with a completeness that
is nothing less than astonishing (277). Psychologists of today still accept the
Oedipus complex as a viable explanation for the love and fascination that male
children display towards their mothers. Lawrence successfully created an educational
novel as well as an easily readable and interesting novel. Literary critics tend
to speculate that Sons and Lovers was written by Lawrence as somewhat of an autobiography
centering Paul’s life around his own. Whether or not this is true will never
be determined, though it will continue to remain a favorite topic for critical
analysis for years to come.
Draper, R.P. “D.H. Lawrence
on Mother Love.” Essays in Criticism 8 (1958): 285-289. Rpt. In TCLC. Ed.
Dennis Poupard. Vol. 16. Detroit: Gale, 1985. 293-294. :Kuttner, Aldred Booth.
“Sons and Lovers’: A Freudian Appreciation.” The Psychoanalytic
Review. 3 (1916): 295-317. Rpt. In TCLC, Ed. Dennis Poupard. Vol. 16. Detroit:
Gale, 1985. 277-282. :Lawrence, D.H. Sons and Lovers. New York: Barnes & Noble,
1996. :Niven, Alastair. “D.H. Lawrence.” British Writers. Vol. 7.
1984. 87-126. :Spilka, Mark. The Love Ethic of D.H. Lawrence. (1955): 244. Rpt.
In TCLC. Ed. Dennis Poupard. Vol. 16. Detroit: Gale, 1985. Bibliography **** Works
Cited : **** raper, R.P. “D.H. Lawrence on Mother Love.” Essays
in Criticism 8 (1958): 285-289. Rpt. In TCLC. Ed. Dennis Poupard. Vol. 16. Detroit:
Gale, 1985. 293-294. :Kuttner, Aldred Booth. “Sons and Lovers’: A
Freudian Appreciation.” The Psychoanalytic Review. 3 (1916): 295-317. Rpt.
In TCLC, Ed. Dennis Poupard. Vol. 16. Detroit: Gale, 1985. 277-282. :Lawrence,
D.H. Sons and Lovers. New York: Barnes & Noble, 1996. :Niven, Alastair. “D.H.
Lawrence.” British Writers. Vol. 7. 1984. 87-126. :Spilka, Mark. The Love
Ethic of D.H. Lawrence. (1955): 244. Rpt. In TCLC. Ed. Dennis Poupard. Vol. 16.
Detroit: Gale, 1985.
Другие работы по теме:
I Am Daivd Essay Research Paper I
I Am Daivd Essay, Research Paper I Am David is written by Anne Holm and is about a boy called David. David is a twelve year old boy who has spent his life in a concentration camp. One day a man from the camp helps him to escape. He is told that he must go north until he comes to Denmark. He doesn’t know what life is like outside the camp and is constantly scared in case he gets caught.
David Berkowitz Essay Research Paper David Berkowitz
David Berkowitz Essay, Research Paper David Berkowitz was born in 1953. Rejected and adopted as a child, he concealed his low self-esteem by compulsive lying and bragging. And his extreme shyness toward women by assailing them, starting when he was in his early twenties. His courage bolstered by several non-fatal stabbing attacks.
Fifth Child Essay Research Paper The Fifth
Fifth Child Essay, Research Paper ?The Fifth Child? In ?The Fifth Child,? Lessing contrasts society?s idea of an ?ideal? family to the ?real? dysfunctional family in our everyday lives. Harriet and David?s dream was to have the ?ideal? family. They made the mistake of setting standards too high for themselves and putting a front of an ideal family, which was just a cover for the real dysfunctional one.
Biogeography Essay Research Paper bBiogeographyAfter reading the
Biogeography Essay, Research Paper bBiogeography After reading the text on David Quammen?s voyage through many different islands of the world, I was hit with a certain impression of the world. The first thing that amazed me about how David Quammen wrote the book is that, within a few chapters I felt that the timeline of the creation of earth and suddenly shrunk immensely.
Chrysalids Essay Research Paper In the words
Chrysalids Essay, Research Paper In the words of the Houghton Mifflin Canadian dictionary, deviation is defined as “an abnormality, a departure”. David Strorm, the protagonist in the
Nathan
’s Rebuke Essay, Research Paper Nathan s Rebuke Many people are familiar with David s sins involving Bethsheba that resulted in adultery and murder. Though these were dark pages in David s record, they were preserved so that lessons might be learned by those who followed after. These lessons to be learned not only came from David s mistakes, but from the rebuke that Nathan gave to David because of his sins.
Searching For Davids Heart Essay Research Paper
Searching For David?s Heart, and the author is Adele Griffin. The main characters in this book is David and his sister Marcy. David is a 15 year old boy who likes sports and is well known at his school, he is a very popular
Tale Of The Body Thief Essay Research
Paper Tale of the Body Thief is Anne Rice?s fourth book in the vampire series. Tale of the Body Thief is the story of the dumbest decision Lestat ever made. A strange man,
Montana 1948 Essay Research Paper MONTANA 1948ESSAY
Montana 1948 Essay, Research Paper MONTANA 1948 ESSAY QUESTION Montana 1948 is about the loss of innocence and the painful gain of wisdom. Discuss. In Montana, the summer of 1948 held a series of tragic events which were to have a permanent and decisive impact on David and his parents. This chain of events were to turn David?s young life and that of his family upside down forever and which was to so angrily lead him out of childhood, destroying his innocence and youthful naivety in the process.
Kidnapped The Classic Essay Research Paper A
Kidnapped The Classic Essay, Research Paper A Classic To Be Read A book that I believe every college student should read is Kidnapped, by Robert Stevenson. This novel has a great amount of dialect throughout, well developed characters and is
Absalom Son Of David Essay Research Paper
Absalom’s story unfolds in the household of King David. The key members of this household were Absalom, Amnon, and Tamar. Absalom and Amnon were David’s sons and Tamar was David’s daughter.
Jeruselem Essay Research Paper Ariel David What
Jeruselem Essay, Research Paper Ariel, David. What do Jews Beleive. New york: Schocken Books, 1995. 8 Dec. 2000 . World history. D, G -. Torah. Egypt: G-D, 1515. 1 Jan. 1000 . The holy book.
DikinsonLawrence Essay Research Paper Although Emily Elizabeth
Dikinson-Lawrence Essay, Research Paper Although Emily Elizabeth Dikinson and David Herbert Lawrence lived and wrote during two different times, and in different parts of the world, their poetry contains many similarities. At the time Dikinson was being laid to rest in Massachusetts, Lawrence was born in Nottingham, England.
David Herbert Lawrence Essay Research Paper As
David Herbert Lawrence Essay, Research Paper As a twentieth century novelist, essayist, and poet, David Herbert Lawrence brought the subjects of sex, psychology, and religion to the forefront of
Henry David Thorea Essay Research Paper Henry
Henry David Thorea Essay, Research Paper Henry David Thoreau conducted an experiment, living simple, and peaceful in a small cabin that he built himself. The observations about nature, the importance of the individual, value of a simple life, and more relevant today, as environment abuses multiply, the pressure to consume increases, and the pace o life continues to speed up.
Scholarship Essay Research Paper 7500 scholarshipBy David
Scholarship Essay, Research Paper $7,500 scholarship By David Johnson On September 30, 1999, Charles Johnson won a $7,500 scholarship from the Department of Agriculture at Washington State University for being Central High School’s number one student.
Music Writer Essay Research Paper Music WriterThe
Music Writer Essay, Research Paper Music Writer The job of being a music writer entails many things. As most people believe, they do more then criticize artists work. In an email interview between Steven Ward, and David McGee (a music writer), David tells of how he works for BarnesandNoble as a country music editor.
Unabomber Essay Research Paper In Michael Ventura
Unabomber Essay, Research Paper In Michael Ventura’s essay, “The Ties That Bind”, he explains the dilemma in which David Kaczynski (brother of Ted Kaczynski, the infamous Unabomber) faces. He can either: 1) betray his brother turning him in, 2) do nothing and let society down. Either way he is left feeling extreme guilt.
David And Legend Essay Research Paper The
David And Legend Essay, Research Paper The legend of David and Goliath is a very familiar one to many people. It is an oral legend that has been told from one generation to the next. It has been mostly assumed to be a fictional story. The question is how do we know it is fiction. This is the problem historians have when using the tool of oral bards or legends.
David Awaiting Goliath Essay Research Paper David
David Awaiting Goliath Essay, Research Paper David Awaiting Goliath Before going to Eleganza, the only sculpture that I had ever seen, besides the small statues in neighbors’ yards, was in books that I had looked at. When I entered the museum I noticed the many sculptures that occupied the small space. After walking around, observing the different sculptures and listening to Dr.
David VS Goliath Essay Research Paper According
David VS Goliath Essay, Research Paper According to the story, David openly trusted in God when he went to fight against Goliath the giant. But the question is, why did he pick up five stones, did he think he would miss?
A Comparison Of Arthur Becomes King And
David And Goliath Essay, Research Paper A Comparison of Arthur Becomes King and David and Goliath Two of the most renowned leaders of all time, King Arthur and King David, have
King David Essay Research Paper The Life
King David Essay, Research Paper The Life of King David In this essay I will be talking about the life of King David. He was a man who went from being a giant slayer, to a king, to a man in exile and, then he went
David Hume Essay Research Paper In reading
David Hume Essay, Research Paper In reading the ideas of David Hume, I have came to believe that he was telling us the miracles don?t exist. They are sort of a ?Mission impossible.? We
Story Of David Copperfield Essay Research Paper
THE STORY OF DAVID COPPERFIELD (First Section) I didn’t see the start of the movie because I was sick. 22 March 2001 (Seconde Section) In this part of the story David is on this way to live with his Uncle Dan Peggotty of two weeks in Yarmouth. While he was is Yarmouth he meat the people that lived with his Uncle Emily that he falls in love with and he is the neece of Uncle Dan.
David Copperfield Summary Essay Research Paper David
David Copperfield Summary Essay, Research Paper David Copperfield enjoys his early childhood with his mother and their kindly servant, Peggotty. But when his mother marries the cruel Mr. Murdstone, he is sent away to Salem House, a run-down London boarding school where the boys are beaten by Mr. Creakle.
Les Miserables 2
Les Miserables & David Copperfield Essay, Research Paper Moshiur Rahman English 11 Writing 2/12/01 David Copperfield & Les Miserables In the novel, David Copperfield by Charles Dickens & Les Miserables by Victor both consists of tragedy and romance.
DH Lawrence Biography Essay Research Paper David
DH Lawrence: Biography Essay, Research Paper David Herbert Lawrence was born on September 11, 1885, the fourth child and third son of a miner in Eastwood, Nottinghamshire. Despite having grown up in a lower class home and without many friends, he has become the most frequently studied novelist of the twentieth century .
School Ties Essay Research Paper
Society often judges people on their labels, on their background but not on who they really are. All sorts of people to judge other individuals, such as close friends, teammates and competitors . In the movie School Ties, the main character David Green suffers because he becomes hated as a result of others? prejudice.
Son Of Sam Essay Research Paper David
Son Of Sam Essay, Research Paper David Berkowitz in whom he?d like to call himself the ?Son of Sam?. ?Sam? was a 6,000-year-old man inhabiting the body of a neighbor, Sam Carr. David also believed that Sam ordered him to kill. He also believed that Sam Carr?s dog ordered him to kill.
DlfgjqlDfkgq Essay Research Paper David Herbert Lawrence
Dlfgjql;Dfkgq Essay, Research Paper David Herbert Lawrence was born on 11th September 1885 in Eastwood, Nottinghamshire. His birthplace, 8a Victoria Street, is now maintained as a museum, in the style of a turn of the century house. He was an author of novels, short stories, poems, plays, essays, travel books, and letters.
King David And Jesus Essay Research Paper
King David and Jesus are alike in several ways. David was the youngest son of Jesse, a shepherd from Bethlehem. David was “discovered” by Saul when, according to one tradition, he played his harp to sooth Saul’s melancholy. He later went on to slay the giant warrior Goliath, a task which amazed many, since not even trained warriors were able to defeat him.
School Essay Research Paper DAVID One of
School Essay, Research Paper DAVID. One of the greatest heroes of ancient history was David, a poor shepherd boy who killed the giant Goliath. According to the Biblical story of his life, which is told in detail in the Old Testament, David was born about 3,000 years ago.