The Approach of Hermeneutics
The approach of hermeneutics does not assume that all reasoning can be considered within some foundational belief, but rather must be interpreted in their own terms. Hermeneutics is therefore in conflict with many current cultural traditions descended from the dialectic. It is also directly contrasted with deconstruction, which has radically different conclusions about the results of textual analysis.
To read and understand a text of Ricoeur is not to understand it in one way, now and forever. There is no “science” of interpretation, which affords the one correct, true reading. The possibility of understanding arises from “the totally positive relation of belonging.” The “world” of the text and the “world” of the reader come across each other in a “fusion of horizons” that occurs in front of the text. Because in written discourse there is a distance in time and space separating the author and potential readers, there is a radical alienation that separates the reader from the sense of the author and the reference of the text.
This distance functions like the dissimilarity in metaphor and the conflict of meanings in symbols. By reducing the conflict in meanings between the dissimilar “worlds” of the text and the reader, new meanings, new models, and new realities arise in front of the text. Reading becomes a kind of work, of rendering a text as meaningful. For example “the light shines upon you” by trying to understand this phrase one can break it down by defining the words light, shine, upon, and you. By defining these words the reader can get a general idea of the message the writer is trying to produce not just a specific, this may also be known as the hermeneutical circle. Ricoeur writes that:
. . . [I]n explanation we ex-plicate or unfold the range of propositions and meanings, where as in understanding we comprehend or grasp as a whole the chain of partial meanings in one act of synthesis (Ricoeur 1976, 72.)
Explanation corresponds to critical thinking, in science terms, that brakes down the elements or principles of the composition. A reader stands ready at a distance in order to objectify the text, to analyze link patterns and structures, as well as, the historical, social, and psychological contexts, which give rise to a text and previous interpretations of that text. However powerful these investigative lenses may be in interpreting a text, they are not “a presuppositionless grasp of a pregiven being” — the reader will not be able to see the full message the writer is trying to communicate, there is no transparent, direct reading of the text in itself. The reader will only receive the information that relates to the reader were as some information might affect at a stronger level between other readers.
Romanticist hermeneutics opposes the understanding and explanation on epistemological and “on the whole” grounds by opposing two metaphors and two spheres of reality — nature and mind. Hermeneutics seeks to abstract explanation from the interplay process and establish the enlightenment of causal relationships as a singular interpretative move. Ricoeur seeks to link explanation and understanding as a dialectic whole.
In interpretation, we approach a text with some kind of prior understanding or prejudgement. We then move to reading and analyzing the text in the stage of explanation, seeking to discover how and why the text works. From Ricoeur critical reading, we then move to comprehension, which is really just a new level of understanding, which can lead to new critical readings and new understandings. The first time, understanding was a naive grasping of the meaning of the text as a whole. The second time, comprehension help give me a sophisticated mode of understanding, supported by clarifying procedures. In the beginning of the text, understanding is a guess.
At the end, it satisfies the concept of appropriation . . . as the rejoinder to the kind of distanciation linked to the full objectification of the text. Explanation, then, will appear as the mediation between two stages of understanding. If isolated from this concrete process, it is a mere abstraction, an artifact of methodology (Ricoeur 1976, 74-75.)
Misusing the text at a new level of understanding supported by clarifying procedures is the aim of a hermeneutical reading that seeks to overcome the special, activist and cultural distances that separate the written discourse from the reader. This dissociation is what makes possible the objectifying movement of explanation. Explanation can work either to expand a given pre-understanding or to criticize a given pre-understanding. The move to enlightenment ideally involves a “suspension of judgment,” which allows the text to “speak for itself.” This suspension of judgment, however, is always romanticize, because the reader belongs to the world of language, culture and interpretation therefore necessarily use prejudgments or pre-understandings in interpreting a text.
While understanding makes a claim on explanation, explanation can also make a claim on understanding. The process leads to misuse or appropriation, the aim of hermeneutical reading, which seeks to struggle against cultural, spatial, and temporal distance to make one’s own, what was initially alien belongs to everyone.
Другие работы по теме:
Booker T. Washington V. W.E.B. Du Bois
Essay, Research Paper Booker T. Washington and W.E.B. Du Bois were both influential leaders in the fight for desegregation. Booker T. Washington led the less violent and subtle crowd. W.E.B. Du Bois directed his followers in more of a let s get something accomplished now , rather than Washington s more subdued approach.
Roman Essay Research Paper
“Romanesque – Gothic” 50 Minutes/ Rating 9 The difference between Gothic and Romanesque architecture is the spiritual approach. In Romanesque the emphasis was on transcendental and feudalistic systems whereas in the Gothic this approach was humanized and individualized. The Gothic architecture emphasized upward movement towards god, a feeling that cannot be found in a Romanesque basilica although it might have already pointed arches, a key element of gothic architecture.
Yahoo Essay Research Paper Yahoo rode the
Yahoo! Essay, Research Paper Yahoo! rode the bull market Thursday, primarily on the strength of a report by Lehman Brothers, which raised its recommendation on the stock to a “Buy.”
The Art Of Teaching The KWL Approach
Essay, Research Paper The students background information is extremely important. What the child knows will give them a better chance to develop understanding of the vocabulary and of their concepts. A teacher can find out how much background information each student has by using the K-W-L approach. This approach will not only let the teacher know what they already know, but also what they want to learn about the subject and finally what they have learned though their reading.
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Nomad Settlements Essay Research Paper ArRisha
Nomad Settlements Essay, Research Paper Ar-Risha in Jordan ? Bedouin settlement, through architecture and settlement structure insight into Bedouin politics and polities. Ancient service
Dead Poets Society Essay Research Paper Lesley
Dead Poets Society Essay, Research Paper Lesley Spodek 02/07/00 A Representation of A Teacher In the film, Dead Poets Society, Professor John Keating sets an example for all future educators. He takes a different approach to teaching or being a teacher by expressing the need for students, people of all ages, to take risks in life.
Rip Van Winkle Essay Research Paper In
Rip Van Winkle Essay, Research Paper In the story of Rip Van Winkle, a wind story of a bad father/husband is told. The story seems to be a way for the writer to display his anger and resentment towards his spouse. The story is consistently talking about how Rip was dreading going home to see his wife. At the same time it told of his mistreatment of the same wife.
Aristotle On Ethics Essay Research Paper 1
Aristotle On Ethics Essay, Research Paper 1) Explain fully Aristotle?s approach to Ethics. What is the goal of the ethical life? What type of soul is capable of realizing the good life? How do we
Dream Interpatation Essay Research Paper DREAM INTERPRETATIONThere
Dream Interpatation Essay, Research Paper DREAM INTERPRETATION There are many different interpretations of dreams and dreaming. These interpretations tend to fall into two main categories. There is the physiological approach or the psychological approach. The physiological approach deals with the brain’s interpretations of nerve actions.
My Presentation Of Macbeth Act 3 Scene
4 Essay, Research Paper 10Hn This essay will show my interpretation of Act 3 Scene 4 from Macbeth. This scene is a turning point in the play because we see the first glimpse of Macbeth?s guilty conscience, which becomes the cause of
Humanistic View Journal Essay Research Paper When
Humanistic View Journal Essay, Research Paper When reading through my notes for the class, I have found that the humanistic approach to the development of personality is the most interesting. The book describes humanistic as development through interaction. Every day we come in contact with people who then influence the way we think and perceive ideas.
What Do You Want From College Essay
, Research Paper There are three main categories of things that can be gained in a life experience. We can gain materially, gain in our personality, and gain knowledge. According to our goals we pick which we want more of. I want nothing of the first except to aid my approach to the third. The second will happen as it must over time, and I can’t really guess what will be gained or lost there.
Observations Essay Research Paper Ed munsterObservationsAll of
Observations Essay, Research Paper Ed munster Observations All of the essays have one thing incommon, they all deal with observing animals. And with their observation comes at times interaction. They might “mingle” with these animals. Or the observers would just sit there and do what they are supposed to, observe.
Your Biggest Mistake Essay Research Paper Your
Your Biggest Mistake Essay, Research Paper Your Biggest Mistake In response to the question “what has been your biggest mistake?” My biggest mistake is everyone’s biggest mistake, that no one can help. We all take on assumptions throughout our lives, and when we finally come to understand this, we spend our lives undoing all of them in order to approach the truth with assumptionless intelligence.
Creation Or Evolution Essay Research Paper EVOLUTION
Creation Or Evolution? Essay, Research Paper EVOLUTION OR CREATION? In a coherent world like ours people are questioning their religion and not knowing whether to believe in creation by God or evolution, Through out my research I have found four possible answers to this question to incorporate both theories .
Persuasive Essay Essay Research Paper Persuasive Essay
Persuasive Essay Essay, Research Paper Persuasive Essay Driving is a tremendous responsibility. I believe our state should have rigorous driving tests to make the roads safe for others. However I think most teenagers aren’t ready to accept
Freud Essay Research Paper Freud
Freud Essay, Research Paper Freud’s Personality Theory The development of gender roles in deifferent forms of feminsm gives us a revealing overview of Freud’s personality theory. It is relatively
Mr Essay Research Paper An investigation into
Mr Essay, Research Paper An investigation into Hotel Users expectations of The Best Hotel Chain 1. Aims and Objectives 1. To examine what the expectations of hotel users are of The Best Hotel Chain.
Squeegee Kids Essay Research Paper Squeegee Kids
Squeegee Kids Essay, Research Paper Squeegee Kids “Squeegee kids” should better themselves for humanity and the safety of the city. They should not be wandering the streets, loitering, and disturbing people. They have no right to approach anonymous vehicles and apply what they call “cleaning” on the windshield without the owner’s permission.These people should stop and think whether or not they are benefiting from their actions.
Schools Of Psychology Essay Research Paper Schools
Schools Of Psychology Essay, Research Paper Schools of Psychology There are seven major schools of psychology Behavioral, Psychoanalytic, Humanistic, Cognitive, Neurobiological, Sociological, and Industrial. First off behavioral psychology emphasizes the scientific study of behavior and its environmental determinants.
Music Essay Essay Research Paper English 4
Music Essay Essay, Research Paper English 4 Music Essay This paper is a “claim-driven” essay. That means, your goal is to persuade your audience to think the way you do about a particular issue regarding music. You will state a thesis and support this thesis with convincing evidence. Your “convincing evidence” will include analyses of lyrics, CD covers and videos and secondary sources about your musician or genre of music.
Social Realism Essay Research Paper Social Realism
Social Realism Essay, Research Paper Social Realism In Art Social realism, in art, describes both a specific stylistic approach and an overall attitude toward the subject. Social realism aims toward the not so lovely part of life. Its goal is not to amuse but to show the observer the evils of poverty , immorality and war.
First Confession Essay Research Paper Mrs Ryan
First Confession Essay, Research Paper Mrs. Ryan and the Priest In Frank O?Connor?s story ?First Confession?, Mrs. Ryan and the priest are different. Mrs. Ryan and the priest approach Jackie differently and have different affects on him.
Object Orientated Computing Essay Research Paper The
Object Orientated Computing Essay, Research Paper The object orientated approach has changed the way in which computing and programming has been done in the past. These changes affect almost everyone and with computing technology becoming more and more integrated with business and every day life it is useful to look at the importance of these changed to the technology industry.
The French Sociologists Essay Research Paper The
The French Sociologists Essay, Research Paper The French sociologists (holistic approach), during the eighteenth and nineteenth century were much concerned with the nature of society and of the human social institutions. Their interests
Medicare Essay Research Paper How To Fix
Medicare Essay, Research Paper How To Fix Medicare Is The Greatest Challenge. This Issue Is A Very Important One That Will Eventually Come Under Fire As We Approach That Year 2001 When Medicare Is Projected To Go Bankrupt. This Issue Might Not Be Resolved And We Could Be Seeing The End Of Medicare. I This Issue Will Get Solved Some How The Taxpayers Will Pay Medicare Out Of Trouble.