’s Waldo Two: Positive Change In World Through Manipulation Of
Behavior Essay, Research Paper
B.F Skinner’s Waldo Two: Positive Change In World Through Manipulation of
Behavior
B.F. Skinner, in his novel Walden Two, presents many arguments about how
he foresees a positive change in the world through manipulation of behavior on
the personal level. Sigmund Freud, in his works, specifically Civilization and
Its Discontents, presents his view of human nature and what is innately
problematic about it. Both Freud and Skinner agree that human behavior is the
result of outside factors that severely hinder the concept of free will.
Skinner believes that humans, in the correct environment, can live happily,
while Freud understands that humans are destined to live in “some degree of
anguish or discontent.”
Skinner uses the ideal setting of Walden Two to illustrate his ideas of
how human behavior should be “formed.” Much of Skinner’s argument on how to
eliminate what he knows as problematic rests on his prescription of dismissing
the notion of individual freedom. Skinner does not only say that the concept
of individual freedom is a farce. He takes it a step further and states that
the search for it is where society has gone wrong. He wants no part in the
quest for individual freedom. If we give up this illusion, says Skinner, we
can condition everyone to act in acceptable ways.
Skinner has a specific prescription for creating this utopian society.
He declares that all that is necessary is to change the conditions which
surround man. “Give me the specifications, and I’ll give you the man” is his
simple yet remarkable message. He claims that by controlling what a person’s
environment is, it is possible to craft a man to behave in any way. Skinner
wants to use this notion to create a world without pain and suffering. In
Walden Two, he systematically describes what conditions are necessary to create
a world of happiness.
Skinner proposes that to create his perfect society, one needs only to
come up with the characteristics of what man should be. Since he can then
create any man, he will fill the world with these perfectly-conditioned people
and all will be perfect. Although many of his insights are problematic at the
root level, some of what Skinner proposes is material which should not just be
totally dismissed.
Freud has a much different concept of human existence. He, too, says
that people are “formed” out of experiences and pre-existent conditions.
However, Freud believes that the biggest factor in shaping human behavior is
much more personal and internal. Since everyone experiences things differently,
he claims, it is impossible to shape everyone so that some utopian society will
form, as in Skinner’s case.
Freud recognizes on one level that there is an innate conflict between
the individual and society. So even at the first level, there is a conflict
which will hinder happiness. Freud states that the norms of society are much
too rigorous for the common person because they are in conflict with the inner
desires of the psyche. Keep in mind, this has nothing to do with each
individual’s “roots,” but it states that, upon entering the world, each human
is doomed to conflict with societal standards.
From day one also, each individual feels pressure from every social
direction. His parents influence him by their rearing methods and their
requirements of him. As he begins to develop, his mind does as well, and any
negative experience manifests some degree of conflict between the three parts
of the mind.
Basically, Freud has such a harsh view of reality because he believes
there are so many ways in which the mind is attacked: social, parental, self-
inflicted. One might have no problem dealing with the pressure from society,
yet may, for example, feel guilty about one thing or another. Freud would say
that this would create some sort of conflict in the mind, one which is
inevitable and through no amount of conditioning is prohibitable.
Also, since the three parts of the mind (id, ego, and superego) are
constantly tearing at one another. The ego has to balance the desires of the
id with the standards of the superego while accepting the outside reality. If
any problem occurs and the balance is thrown off, suffering will result. “So
neurosis results from the frustration of basic instincts, either because of
external obstacles or because of internal mental imbalance” (Stevenson 77.)
Both Freud and Skinner find problems with the current social situation.
Freud says that, for the most part, we cannot change the inner mechanisms of
the mind, while Skinner says that any type of conditioning is possible. Maybe
through both of these theories, we can learn to form some sort of resolution.
Concise Bibliography
I. Civilization and Its Discontents, Sigmund Freud.
II. The Communist Manifesto, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels.
III. Walden Two, B.F. Skinner.
IV. Seven Theories of Human Nature, Leslie Stevenson.
Другие работы по теме:
Test001 Essay Research Paper Walden Two by
Test001 Essay, Research Paper Walden Two, by B.F. Skinner was published by the Macmillan Company in 1948 is a spinoff of Henry David Thoreau’s Walden. It is an expansion of the creation of a Utopian society. The society is the creation of T.E. Frazier and is run under his guidance. The story starts with Professor Burris being prompted by one of his prior students to find some information on the existence of Walden Two.
Analyzing Schools Essay Research Paper Paper Topic
Analyzing Schools Essay, Research Paper Paper Topic # 3 It was a typical Monday for Mrs. Otter, after lunch she had her usual 3 classes. Water was the first group, Nets the second and Earth the third. Before she would begin class, students had to follow the agenda for the day. The agenda is located at the front of the board and it tells the students what they will need for the class.
Woburn Essay Research Paper The Woburn trial
Woburn Essay, Research Paper The Woburn trial was an incredibly complex case involving thirty-three plaintiffs, two defendants, a mountain of conflicting hydro-geological and medical testimony regarding causation, and multiple claims including negligence, nuisance and emotional distress. That is why, in my professional opinion, Judge Skinner changed the complete outcome of the trial with his actions, concerning both the procedure of the trial, and his own personal interactions with myself.
A Discussin On Libertarian Philosophy Essay Research
Paper Assignment: Comment on the Following Statements 1) Out of the people edited in Abel or discussed by Palmer, the following are hard determinists Well, Palmer only discusses two hard determinists: B.F. Skinner, and Sigmund Freud. Out of the texts read in Abel, Abel discusses Skinner and D Holbach as hard determinists.
Behaviorism Essay Research Paper Behaviorism Notes and
Behaviorism Essay, Research Paper Behaviorism Notes and other Words Learning — A relatively permanent change in behavior that occurs through experience. Classical Conditioning — Responding Operand Conditioning — Acting Observational Conditioning — Observing Classical Conditioning — A neutral stimulus becomes associated with a meaningful stimulus and acquires the capacity to elicit a similar response. -The organism as responding to the environment (fails to capture active nature of the organism and its influence on the environment. ) -Explains involuntary responses - Pavlov -Reflexes — Automatic stimulus-response connections. -Unconditional Stimulus (US) — A stimulus that provides a response without prior learning. -Unconditional Response — (UP) — An unlearned response that is automatically elected by the US -Conditioned Stimulus (CS) — Previous neutral stimulus that eventually
Lucy Essay Research Paper The behaviorist approach
Lucy Essay, Research Paper The behaviorist approach leads us to believe that personality consists of all of an individuals behaviors. According to Skinner all behavior is determined by contingencys of reinforcment, based on the type and frequency of the reinforcment. If this is true, then we are more apt to repeat behaviors that are rewarded and less apt to repeat punished behaviors.
Mice And MenCrooks Essay Research Paper I
Mice And Men-Crooks Essay, Research Paper I believe that every character in this book is lonely in their own way and has certain needs that they will inevitably never fulfil. I also feel that Crooks is the loneliest character in the book, this is because of the extremely racist and volatile environment on the ranch.
Discussion On Classical Conditioning As An Explanation
Of Learning Essay, Research Paper We use the term “classical conditioning” to describe one type of associative learning in which there is no contingency between response and reinforcer. This situation resembles most closely the experiment from Pavlov in the 1920s, where he trained his dogs to associate a bell ring with a food-reward.
A Civil Action Essay Research Paper In
A Civil Action Essay, Research Paper In a trial, rhetoric is an important part in the success or failure of a case. This is a double-edged sword; it can play out either good or bad. Rhetoric can be used to stress an important detail or idea, but it can also to derail the other side s case, or, just take them out mentally.
Human Behaviour Essay Research Paper Throughout the
Human Behaviour Essay, Research Paper Throughout the first half of the twentieth century, psychologists tended to believe that the explanations offered by classical and operant conditioning were fully adequate to understand human behaviour. Classical conditioning is a form of learning in which a conditioned and unconditioned stimulus become associated, such that the former comes to elicit a response previously elicited only by the latter.
BF Skinner
’s Walden Two Essay, Research Paper Is it possible for psychologists to ever understand the human condition well enough to create a utopia by “engineering” human behavior? This is the challenge thrown out by behavioral psychologist, B.F. Skinner in his novel, Walden Two (1948). Well written and entertaining, Walden Two is directed to the layman rather than to the professional psychologist.
BF Skinner Essay Research Paper BF SkinnerOn
B.F. Skinner Essay, Research Paper B.F. Skinner On March 20, 1904, a man known as B.F. Skinner was born in Susquehanna, Pennsylvania (Encarta 95). His real name was Burrhus Fredric, but he signed his name as B.F. since he was at the tender age of nine (World Authors 764). Skinner accomplished many things in his lifetime.
B F Skinner Essay Research Paper Burrhus
B. F. Skinner Essay, Research Paper Burrhus Frederic Skinner, psychologist and behaviorist, was born in Susquhanna, Pennsylvania in 1904 to William Skinner and Grace Burrhus. His father was a lawywer and his mother was a naturally bright woman. Skinner had only one sibling; his brother died at the age of sixteen.
JIT Manufacturing And Inventory Control System Essay
, Research Paper Since the dawn of human existence evolution in all sectors of society has occurred due to Economic factors. This has mainly happened due to the fact that all technological achievements have occurred in favor of money. Specifically we can admit that Economy is the main reason for growth and development.
Beyond Genre Essay Research Paper Beyond genre
Beyond Genre Essay, Research Paper Beyond genre Austerlitz by WG Sebald trs Anthea Bell Penguin Ј6.99 For some reason, plausibility in fiction is becoming harder to sustain, or even achieve. The problem has got so bad that even Frank Skinner has noted it in his autobiography, saying something to the effect that when one reads a sentence such as: “Maria lit a cigarette” one is tempted to react by saying, “Oh no she didn’t”, and throwing the book away.
BF Skinner Essay Research Paper BF SkinnerPsychologist
B.F. Skinner Essay, Research Paper B.F. Skinner Psychologist, born in Susquhanna, Pa. He studied at Harvard, teaching there (1931-6, 1947-74). A leading behaviorist, he is a proponent of operant conditioning, and the inventor of the Skinner box for facilitating experimental observations.
Of Mice And Men Summary Essay Research
Paper Summary John Steinbeck wrote the book Of Mice & Men in 1937 during the Great Depression. The book is about the lives of two men who travel from job to job working on ranches and farms. These two main characters are George Milton and Lennie Small. George is a short, slight man and Lennie is a large, mildly retarded man.
Psychology Applied Essay Research Paper The ClassroomI
Psychology Applied Essay, Research Paper The Classroom I was placed in an eighth grade English class that is an inclusion classroom. Inclusion classrooms are general education classrooms that include children with special needs. These classrooms typically have one subject oriented teacher and one special education teacher.
Classical Learning Vs Operant Learning Essay Research
Paper There are many different fields of study in psychology. One field of study is the cognitive process of learning. Learning is any relatively permanent change in behavior (or behavior potential) resulting from experience (Baron G-7). The learning process helps us, all organisms, adapt to changing conditions in our environment and the world around us.
Case Study Of Bill Clinton Essay Research
Paper Freudian Perspective Bill Clinton s early childhood did not show many signs of him one day becoming president of the United States. He was from a small town family which was not the usual rich family that is needed to produce a president. The only things that may suggest his drive to become president are the thoughts implanted in his superego(Sdorow, 1995) by the troubles of an alcoholic step-father and the usual troubles of daily life that children must deal with.
Thousand Pieces Of Gold Essay Research Paper
This movie is based on Ruthanne Lum McCunn’s 1981 true-story book of the same name, follows the story of a young Chinese woman, Lalu , brought to the United States in the 19th century by a “wife trader” and sold as a wife to an unscrupulous saloon owner. Lalu attempts to earn the money to buy her freedom and return to China.
Civil Action Essay Research Paper Civil ActionIn
Civil Action Essay, Research Paper Civil Action In 1979, two wells supplying the drinking water for the small New England town of East Worburn, in Massachusetts, were found to be dumping industrial solvents. At this same time in Massachusetts, there were other investigations of industrial dumping. The residents of Worburn had long been concerned about their foul-tasting drinking water and the unexplained high incidence of leukemia deaths of the young children in their community.
Abraham Maslow Essay Research Paper Abraham MaslowAbraham
Abraham Maslow Essay, Research Paper Abraham Maslow Abraham Maslow is known for establishing the theory of a hierarchy of needs, writing that human beings are motivated by unsatisfied needs, and that certain lower needs need to be satisfied before higher needs can be satisfied. Maslow studied exemplary people such as Albert Einstein, Jane Addams, Eleanor Roosevelt, and Frederick Douglas rather than mentally ill or neurotic people.
Memory Essay Research Paper 1There are many
Memory Essay, Research Paper There are many process of memory. The basic of them all are encoding, storage and retrieval. Your short-term memory (STM) has a limited time till the information is forgotten (10-30 seconds). Long-term memory (LTM) virtually has an unlimited storing capacity. Through process of consolidation and hints or cues you can retrieve past memory s and emotions.
Classical
& Operant Conditioni Essay, Research Paper A COMPARISON BETWEEN CLASSICAL AND OPERANT CONDITIONING. This essay outlines the basic principles of classical and operant conditioning and considers the similarities and differences between these two models of learning.
Comparison Of Theories Essay Research Paper Comparison
Comparison Of Theories Essay, Research Paper Comparison of Theories 2 Abstract This paper is a comparison of three different viewpoints on the subject of personality. Carl Jung, B.F. Skinner, and Carl Rogers all had very different outlooks on what defined someone?s personality. As an added feature I have included myself as a theorist because my views are also different from the previous mentioned theorists.
Psychology BF Skiner Essay Research Paper BF
Psychology B.F Skiner Essay, Research Paper B.F. Skinner Running head: B.F. Skinner and His Influence in Psychology B.F. Skinner and His Influence in Psychology Abstract B.F. Skinner was one of the most influential theorists in modern psychology. His work was very important and has been studied by many for years.
Personality Theory Essay Research Paper Chad AtwellPsychologyTuesday
Personality Theory Essay, Research Paper Chad Atwell Psychology Tuesday, October 03, 2000 Learning is defined as Any relatively permanent change in behavior that can be attributed to experience (Coon). It is not, however, a temporary change caused by outside forces. Therefore, things such as motivation, disease and injury cannot be considered to be a form of learning.
Application Essay Essay Research Paper On January
Application Essay Essay, Research Paper On January 26, 2001, 13-year-old Lionel Tate was convicted in the first-degree murder of Tiffany Eunick. The incident occurred in July of 1999 in Pembroke Park, Florida. Tate, then twelve, claimed he was imitating pro wrestlers when he killed six-year-old Eunick.
Development Of Psychology Essay Research Paper John
Development Of Psychology Essay, Research Paper John Wilson Psychology Essay (Development of psychology) In the following essay I will explain the development of major schools in terms of distinguishing features and historical context.
Test Anxiety Essay Research Paper Test AnxietySome
Test Anxiety Essay, Research Paper Test AnxietySome students forget all that they have learned when they walk into a testing situation. We call this “test anxiety.” Psychologists explain “test anxiety” in several different ways, depending on the philosophy of the psychologist who addresses the problem.
Schools Of Psychology Essay Research Paper Schools
Schools Of Psychology Essay, Research Paper Schools of Psychology There are seven major schools of psychology Behavioral, Psychoanalytic, Humanistic, Cognitive, Neurobiological, Sociological, and Industrial. First off behavioral psychology emphasizes the scientific study of behavior and its environmental determinants.
Genie
– The Wild Child Essay, Research Paper Genie-The Wild Child Genie was considered to be beautiful, fragile, and wild. She was born in April of 1957 in Los Angeles where she lived the first 13 years of her life tied to a potty chair, abused and lonely. She could not talk, walk, or even chew. Her arms and legs did not extend fully and she had vision to a distance of only 12 feet.