Law Paper Essay, Research Paper
The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms is being cited more frequently as a basis for Canadian lawsuits. One such case that has received much attention in the Canadian, as well as International spotlight is that of Ernst Zundel. Mr. Zundel contends that Government parties denied him his freedom of speech as protected under the Charter . The purpose of this paper is to evaluate Mr. Zundel s claim by exploring the contrasting principles that apply to his case. Furthermore, this paper will evaluate the societal implications that have been brought forward with respect to freedom of speech. Finally, this paper will determine whether or not section 2(b) of the Charter should be amended or left as is.
Mr. Zundel is a familiar face to the Canadian Courts. Mr. Zundel, who calls himself a German-Canadian Human Rights Activist , is now attempting to sue Members of Parliament as well as the Prime Minister for depriving him of his constitutional right to freedom of speech . All political parties of Parliament joined together and unanimously agreed to bar him from speaking in Parliament. Section 2(b) of the Charter provides that everyone has the following fundamental freedoms: freedom of thought, belief, opinion, and expression, including freedom of the press and other media of communication.
It is true that free expression is indispensable to successful democracy , however, should free speech be allotted to those who choose to abuse it by promoting hatred, spew racist remarks, degrade and insult others? Section 181 of the Canadian Criminal Code staunchly contrasts Section 2(b) of the Charter as it states everyone who willfully publishes a statement, tale, or news that he knows is false and that is likely to cause injury or mischief to public interest is guilty of an indictable offence and liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years.
How now could Canadians have a section which protects free speech and another that prohibits it if it known to be false? This contradiction of sections can be eliminated if section1 of the Charter is applied, which sets reasonable limits to sections of the Charter. Should Mr. Zundel s rights of freedom of speech be limited? Mr. Zundel s rights should be infringed upon so as to protect society s rights as a whole. The issue is not whether Mr. Zundel is permitted to hold his beliefs (which he is) or whether he may express these beliefs to those who are willing to listen (which he is permitted). The issue is that when he attempts to hold a press conference about his views he is now infringing on society s rights. He is attempting to sway public opinion while at the same time injuring those who are the targets of his racist speech. Although his views may not promote violence and hate per se, racist views may be harmful even when expressed calmly, without anger and animosity. Indeed, their influence (their silencing effect) may be greater when they are presented as thoughtful contributions to public opinion.
Mr. Zundel s case is sure to raise objections from both ends of the spectrum. Critics who oppose the restriction of speech, even speech in the form of racism and hatred, argue that the government is the presumptive enemy of free speech and should not be authorized to choose between speech it likes and speech it despises . Another argument against the restriction of speech is the Slippery Slope argument. This states that any restrictions on speech, once permitted, have a sinister and nearly inevitable tendency to expand , meaning that once one form of speech is restricted it is certain that other types of speech will soon be restricted as well.
Advocates of the restriction of certain forms of speech claim that racist speech provokes harmful consequences. Racist speech is harmful three times over: to the targets of racist speech, who feel degraded and powerless, to the perpetrators, whose moral sense is thereby diminished, and to society as a whole . Racial speech may also set a precedent to other would-be racist activists, who will be permitted to spread their harmful views because others before him/her were permitted to do so.
It is quite obvious from this most recent case involving Mr. Zundel that the Charter is often abused. Although the majority of society has no problems with it, there are a few members of society, such as Mr. Zundel, who claim their rights, which are protected under the Charter, are being restricted. It therefore raises the question if that certain sections of the Charter, such as section 2(b), are misleading, should they be amended? The answer is no. Mr. Zundel contends that his rights are being restricted, but in fact, they are not. Mr. Zundel is free to believe whatever he chooses to believe and he is free to express his opinions to those who are willing to listen to his beliefs. What he is complaining about is that he is restricted from promoting hate speech on Parliament Hill where everyone will, no doubt, be exposed to his racist views. Amending section 2(b) to include all forms of speech would not change it all that much since it already protects all forms of speech. Amending the section to restrict certain types of speech would then be denying people their freedom of speech. No matter how the Charter is laid out, there will always be certain members of society, such as Mr. Zundel, who claim that they are being deprive of their constitutional rights.
The Charter of Rights and Freedoms was enacted in 1982 for all Canadian Citizens. It was legislated so that all members of society would be protected by the Charter to prevent their rights from being abused or denied. However, it is unfortunate to see that certain members also use it to there own advantage by spreading racist speech and then claiming that it is within their constitutional rights to do so, as is the case of Mr. Zundel. Luckily, we have members within our society who would like to stop this type of abuse from occurring. This is where Mr. Zundel s lawsuit against the Members of Parliament and the Canadian Jewish Council arises. Mr. Zundel s right to freedom of speech was not denied when Parliament denied him access to speak at Parliament Hill. Sections of the Charter, such as s.2(b), should not be amended as it quite straightforward and fair as it is. Although Mr. Zundel s rights are being violated, Parliament should have the power to legislate certain restrictions on speech (such as hate speech) so as to protect society as a whole.
Bibliography
Nahlah Ayed, Zundel s lawsuit, press conference spiked, Globe and Mail, 23 January 1999
Kimberly A. Gross & Donald R. Kinder, A Collision of Principles: Free Exhibition, Racial Equality and the Prohibition of Racist Speech, British Journal Of Political Science XVIII (1998): 445-471
Peter Hum, All parties agree Zundel should not sue, National Post, 19 January 1999
Peter Hum, Political parties unite to fight Zundel lawsuit in court, Ottawa Citizen,
19 January 1999
Peter Hum, Judge tosses Zundel lawsuit, Ottawa Citizen, 23 January 1999, p. C3
Peter Hum, Judge throws out Zundel s case against federal parties National Post,
23 January 1999
Paul Lungen, Zundel lawsuit includes PM, Canadian Jewish News, 19 November 1998,
Другие работы по теме:
Eco 2 Essay Research Paper SURVEYOR NEEDEDSurveyor
Eco 2 Essay, Research Paper SURVEYOR NEEDED Surveyor Job Description The Canadian Government is looking for a surveyor. This could be your lucky day. If you are totally identical to what is bellow then we want you. So don’t miss out on this great opportunity. Fill out your Resume today.
American Media Dominating Canadian Culture Essay Research
Paper American Media Dominating Canadian Culture The possibility of the American media taking over Canadian culture has always been an intimidating issue for Canadians over the past few decades. It has been known that the American model of life is one that is very different from ours and that the ?americanization? of Canada could prove to be a threat of losing our own values and beliefs.
Want To Be A Canadian Essay Research
Paper Want to be a Canadian? I have been in Vancouver for one and half year, so I have seen many Canadians. Since I was asked to write something based on my experience in
Chrysalids Essay Research Paper In the words
Chrysalids Essay, Research Paper In the words of the Houghton Mifflin Canadian dictionary, deviation is defined as “an abnormality, a departure”. David Strorm, the protagonist in the
Canadians And Americans Essay Research Paper Canadians
Canadians And Americans Essay, Research Paper Canadians and Americans There is much that has distinguished the Canadian experience as different from thatwhich has, and continues to, define the American experience. At first glance, superficiallyCanada and the United States share many aspects in common, for as one comedian oncestated “Canadians are just unarmed Americans with health care”, and for the most part,this is the common belief, as viewed by other nations in this world.
Canadians And Americans Two Different Societies Essay
, Research Paper Canadians and Americans There is much that has distinguished the Canadian experience as different from that which has, and continues to, define the American experience. At first glance, superficially
Oh Really Essay Research Paper Oh Reallyyou
Oh Really? Essay, Research Paper Oh Really, you think i am a lark, the dogs they run and bark, but when i say to them, shut up shut up shut up, you say to be nice to them,
Hcokey Night In Canada Essay Research Paper
September 27, 1999 Luke Rossy Hockey Night in Canada Over the past few decades, the Canadian sport of hockey slowly moved on to the United States and Europe. Only six teams remain in Canada and most of them are either just making enough money to survive or they are in dept. Only two or three Canadian teams are doing ok, fiscally that is.
Canadian GDP Essay Research Paper The output
Canadian GDP Essay, Research Paper The output or GDP of Canada has increased from 1995 to 1999. This means that more people became employed or productivity has risen. With the GDP on the rise, Canada is able
The Patriotic Canadian Essay Research Paper For
The Patriotic Canadian Essay, Research Paper For over 130 years, Canada still keeps its word. Our Fathers of Canadian Confederation expressed their firm commitment when they signed the British North Amerian Act 139 years ago. Peace, Order and Good Government. For as long as I can remember, Canada has promoted peace any way possible.
War Measures Act Essay Research Paper War
War Measures Act Essay, Research Paper War Measures Act: 1942 As the Wong s were lead away from their house the general in charge was promising the family that they were only doing this as a precaution and that their house would be there awaiting there return when the government thought it to be appropriate. But Mr.
Women Sufferage Essay Research Paper History EssayDuring
Women Sufferage Essay, Research Paper History Essay During the last 4 months, I?ve studied a lot about Canadian history and come across many great historical events that have shaped Canadian identity. The two most defining moments between the years 1900 to 2000 were women?s suffrage which was an issue to determine if women should have the right to vote or not.
Poem She Sat Essay Research Paper She
Poem: She Sat Essay, Research Paper She sat… helpless in her room praying to whatever god there may be to let her call to him. could god ignore such a painful cry?
Canadian Film Industry Essay Research Paper ConclusionWe
Canadian Film Industry Essay, Research Paper Conclusion: We as Canadians watch movies on a weekly basis. On average, most people rent videos or attend the local movie theatre to attend and view the latest film. However, Canadians are not aware that they have become desensitized to the global Americanization of the U.S. film industry, which has been turned strong by Hollywood.
IDENTITY Is Not A Strong Enough Word
Essay, Research Paper How do others see Canadians, do Canadians have a unique national identity? Although the United States (US) has some influence on most countries, Canadian life revolves around the US, and sometimes, how much we hate Americans. Most countries cannot say that they are made up of two separate nations (English and French), Canada, on the other hand, can say this.
Computers Essay Research Paper Why We StartedInternet
Computers! Essay, Research Paper Why We Started Internet Mental Health is a free encyclopedia of mental health information. It was designed by a Canadian psychiatrist, Dr. Phillip Long, and programmed by his colleague, Brian Chow.
Was The Internment Of Japanese Canadainas During
World War 2 Justified Essay, Research Paper By the eve of Pearl Harbor, nearly 23,000 people of Japanese descent lived in Canada, principally in British Columbia. Three quarters of these people were Canadian born citizens. After the bombing of Pearl Harbor by the Japanese Army, the Canadian government put the War Measures Act in effect and interned all of Canada s Nikkei.
Freedom And Rights Essay Research Paper Freedom
Freedom And Rights Essay, Research Paper Freedom and Rights How would you feel if your individual rights and freedoms were stripped from you during a national crisis? In many countries, the people s individual rights and freedoms are supposed to be protected by the government. But, in some cases, those individual rights and freedoms were taken away from the people during a national crisis.
Child Poverty Essay Research Paper CHILDREN AND
Child Poverty Essay, Research Paper CHILDREN AND POVERTY IN CANADA The purpose of this project is to discuss child poverty and child welfare practice. There is a need to critically examine the issue and situate the causes of
What Is Irony Essay Research Paper Irony
What Is Irony? Essay, Research Paper Irony is a method of assertion used by authors in literature and poetry. Although many writers have employed this literary technique for centuries, the meaning of the word can be difficult to understand. This essay will help to describe the correct meaning of this diverse word and illustrate how it is used.
Crosscultural Communication Barriers Essay Research Paper Thesis
Cross-cultural Communication Barriers Essay, Research Paper Thesis: A number of different factors contribute to cross-cultural communication barriers. This thesis will be proven through the examination of Canada?s past history, current policies and future plans concerning immigration and assimilation of immigrants into Canadian society.
Canadian Senate Essay Research Paper The Canadian
Canadian Senate Essay, Research Paper The Canadian SenateToday the Canadian Senate does not do all that much for the Canadian government. It no longer does the job that it was created to do. It barely stops any bills that go through. They re paid a lot of money to just sit and do nothing. The Canadian Government could work fine without the Senate.
The Canadian Senate Essay Research Paper The
The Canadian Senate Essay, Research Paper The Canadian Senate By Andrew Donogh Today the Canadian Senate does not do all that much for the Canadian government. It no longer does the job that it was created to do. It barely
Bank Manager Essay Research Paper The career
Bank Manager Essay, Research Paper The career that I have chosen to research is the Bank Manager. The bank manager has to have excellent people and communication skills, also they have to be
The Shipbuilder Essay Research Paper The Name
The Shipbuilder Essay, Research Paper The Name Controversy in The Shipbuilder There are many instances in Ken Mitchell s play The Shipbuilder, where the main character Jaanus Karkulainen, insists on being called by his Finnish name Karkulainen. In the play, many characters call him Johnny Crook. This situation creates controversy about names and shows how important names are to some people.
Canadian Health Care VS US Health Care
Essay, Research Paper One of the major differences between the U.S. and Canadian health care system is the payment system. In the United States, physicians are paid more for doing more, and the return on their time is higher if they perform a procedure than if they use their cognitive skills. Because of the fact that procedures often require hospital care, this approach translates into higher expenditures for hospital care.