Essay, Research Paper
Sterilization of the developmentally disabled or the mentally retarded is an issue that has long been debated in America. Mental retardation is defined as the inability to learn normally and develop mentally. Traditionally in America if a mentally retarded person was born to a family, that family had 2 choices- take care of the child at home, or it was strongly recommended that the child was sent to a state run institution or hospital. The state institution was where this person would spend his or her entire life. Unfortunately these hospitals were often huge warehouses of people with disabilities, or mental illnesses. These hospitals offered no contact with the community to the people that lived there, and were often poorly run, and patients were over medicated, and sometimes abused. The sterilization of persons with mental retardation began as a method of birth control in state hospitals and was carried on with the idea that the mentally retarded will not be able to care for their children or that they will produce more mentally retarded children.
A mentally retarded person exhibits a low level of intelligence and impaired adaptive behavior; Biomedical specialists typically view retardation as the manifestation of an impaired brain. Other experts emphasize the importance of social and cultural influences in defining retardation; proponents of this viewpoint consider intelligence relative, depending on the social setting (Farber 21).It should be noted that in the past, children of unwed mothers, and immigrants were often labeled as mentally retarded as well. The majority of people though, that do have developmental disabilities are only considered mildly retarded and are able to function in society having the ability to hold jobs and develop and maintain relationships and live independently if they have access to education and the community.
Early in the twentieth century the plight of the metal retarded was ignored or dealt with primarily in state institutions. In addition authorities regarded mentally retarded women as being sexually promiscuous and as producing many illegitimate children (Farber 29). Because of this belief many retarded women would be placed in state institutions at the onset of puberty and sometimes released when they reached menopause. Many people have advocated sterilization for the retarded. Nobel Prize winning physicist William Schockley is quoted saying that he advocated sterilization for people with low IQs and supported a sperm bank for geniuses. A letter from Ben wood, a father of IQ testing stated his beliefs at the education testing service in 1972 when he said:
It may be said in all soberness that professional reliefers and most other indigents who produce children thereby commit crimes against humanity which are fully as serious as many acts now considered felonies. They have no moral right to produce such children and therefore should have no legal right to immunity from punishment that constructively fits the crime, such as some form of painless sterilization of both guilty parents, which would be permanent.Before 1930 there were numerous elite groups interested in the problems of the mentally retarded. Some of them were connected with eugenics and sterilization. However, in the early 1900?s several states had already passed laws permitting the sterilization of the mentally retarded. These laws were enacted in the belief that 90% of feeblemindedness was familial in origin (Baumeister 32).
Actions have been taken to reverse these laws in recent years mostly because of the backlash of the mentally retarded that have been unknowingly sterilized, and because of human rights advocate?s. In the Supreme Court case Skinner V. Oklahoma, the courts decided that ?Involuntary sterilization infringes upon the fundamental rights of man to procreate and have children?. But still in this country 40 states deny a retarded person the right to marry, supposedly because mentally retarded individuals are not competent marriage partners. However, in society about one out four marriage ends in divorce and the abuse of children and spouses goes on every day. By these standards most people with normal IQ?s would not be seen as good partners or parents. The other excuse for sterilization is that the mentally retarded will give birth to more babies with developmental problems. Today even this argument holds little ground. Present knowledge indicates that most mental retardation is not genetically caused and therefore cannot be inherited by following generations (Presidents 33).
Because of the stigma of mental retardation many mentally retarded couples are just learning now that they are unable to produce children. In Kendevill Indiana, at the age of 15, Linda Sparkman was sterilized unknowingly and is now suing Judge Harold D. Stump for allowing it to happen. The Judge, who insists that Mrs. Sparkman is ?Severely retarded?, had not told her beforehand that she would be sterilized. He had not appointed a lawyer to look out for the girl?s interests, nor had he given her a right to object to the operation. He did not make his sterilization order public or even record it in the imposing well kept courthouse where he resides (Mann A1). This case is extremely important in that the Supreme Court is deciding to review the handing of the Sparkman cause in order to decide if there is ?any conduct by a judge so egregious that the usual immunity from lawsuits provided to members of the bench should be removed? (Mann A1). Mrs. Sparkman and her husband Leo have sued Judge Stump for 3.25 million dollars claiming he has violated their human rights. Indiana law does still permit sterilization of the ?Insane feeble minded or epileptic, but only if the individual is institutionalized and if he or she is notified beforehand of the operation.?
Sterilization of the mentally retarded is an issue that has divided the country
for years. Because of human rights activists these cases are finally few and far
between. The future does hold many issues that will reopen these cases such as
the new era of genetic testing. Should we fear tests for genetic abnormalities
will cause discrimination against those with positive tests, and should we spend
precious public and private funds developing testing methods for every conceivable
genetic cause of mental retardation? These questions lay unanswered, but as state
institutions shut down, and the mentally retarded are finally being integrated
into the society and community that was taken away from them we need to rid ourselves
of the ideas that kept them hidden for so long, and help them join our society.
We are all humans, and in America we are granted the God given rights to life,
liberty and the pursuit of happiness. That should include the developmentally
disabled and their right to have a family, and belong to one.
Baumeiser, Alfred A. ?Mental Retardation? Random House. 1969Cowley, Geoffrey. ?Testing the Science of Intelligence? Newsweek. 24 Oct. 1994 56-60.Faber, Bernard. ?Mental Retardation in Society? Brown, 1973.Hamilton, Anne. ?Gentic Testing? The Hardford Current. 14 June 1995 A19Lemann, Niholas. ?The Great Sorting? Atlantic Monthly Sept. 1995 84+Mann Jim. ?Suit is Linda Sparkman?s Only Recompense? Baltimore Sun 27 Nov. 1987
A1, 3.
Presidents Council on Mental Retardation. [Washington D.C.] 1989 32-33
Другие работы по теме:
Civil Liberties Essay Research Paper Civil LibertiesThe
Civil Liberties Essay, Research Paper Civil Liberties The term civil liberties refers to the “freedoms that individuals enjoy and that governments cannot invade”. These rights include a persons freedom of speech and religion.
Equal Rights Essay Research Paper Throughout history
Equal Rights Essay, Research Paper Throughout history equal rights has always been a major issue in the United States, and around the world. People have fought and even died to protect their rights and the rights of others in this country. Most people assume that colored citizens are the only one?s that are affected by the lack of equal rights, but that?s not true.
Langston Hughes And His Significance As A
Black American And As A Poet. Essay, Research Paper Langston Hughes was famous for his poetry, which helped to fuel the civil rights movement. His poetry also earned him fame but he still seemed to remain financially disabled. He didn’t get much recognition for his poetry until after he died.
Something Made A Difference In My Life
Essay, Research Paper There are two things in my life that are extremely important to me. One of these things is sports and the other is helping people. Basketball has been a part of my life for many years. Helping people has always been important but only recently have I been able to combine these two together.
Me And My Daughter Essay Research Paper
1a) Some right that Betty is not intitled to are, that she is not allowed to express herself and express her opinions which means she can’t express herself by what she wears or what she does with out getting beaten by Moody
Supre Court Abortion Decisions Essay Research Paper
Supreme Court Decisions That Greatly Impacted The Reproduction Rights Of Women When talking about Supreme Court decisions that have greatly impacted the lives of women it is very hard to settle on just five of the many cases that have been ruled in favor of the rights of women. When discussing the topic of reproductive freedom and The Supreme Courts rulings on these matters ten cases can and must be discussed in order to provide a total overview and timeline of these historic rulings.
Abortion Essay Research Paper Tim Stanley The
Abortion Essay, Research Paper Tim Stanley: The Last Celebration of Roe v. Wade As a part of Minnesota?s National Abortion and Reproductive Rights Action League (NARAL) Tim Stanley came to inform us and promote involvement in pro-choice activism. He discussed his concern about the future of women?s rights and present legislation and politics that can affect this issue.
Plant Autogamy Essay Research Paper Plant Autogamy
Plant Autogamy Essay, Research Paper Plant Autogamy Self fertilization or autogamy is a reproductive strategy used by some species of plants. Autogamous plants tend to have fewer flowers and the flowers themselves tend to be smaller with smaller reproductive structures than those of plants that reproduce sexually.
Citizenship Essay Research Paper 1 What is
Citizenship Essay, Research Paper 1. What is citizenship? According to The Citizenship debates, by the term citizenship, we must understand not only a bundle of formal rights, but the entire mode of incorporation of individuals and groups into the society (251). Citizenship is important because it has become a legal status carrying with it rights to certain things?perhaps immunities, perhaps possessions, perhaps expectations?available or available to many kinds of person for many kinds of reasons (37).
Nazi Essay Research Paper John Mendes 83000Critical
Nazi Essay, Research Paper John Mendes 8/30/00 Critical Thinking Philosophy 100 Singer?s Final solution Singer and the Nazis both took away the rights of other human beings. Both men took away rights because of physical ability, self-awareness, or intelligence.
Guide Dogs Essay Research Paper My report
Guide Dogs Essay, Research Paper My report is going to be on guide dogs. In this I will show how the guide dogs are used in everyday life. I will show how they are trained to help the blind. I will show you about guide dogs and service dogs. I will also show you the dog breeds used for guide and service dogs. In this I will show you the importance of guide dogs to the disabled.
Outcasts In Society In Relation To John
Steinbeck’s “Of Mice And Men” Essay, Research Paper Throughout history, many groups of people have been the target of persecution by a much larger or more dominant group, often the common people. Among these groups are or were: blacks, the disabled, women, children, the elderly, and members of other religions.
Inclusion Essay Research Paper InclusionAccording to the
Inclusion Essay, Research Paper Inclusion According to the Curry School of Education, approximately 80% of students with learning disabilities receive the majority of their instruction in the general classroom (?Inclusion.? curry.edschool.virginia.edu/curry/dept/cise/ose.html. 10 Oct. 1999).
American Disabilities Act Essay Research Paper Equal
American Disabilities Act Essay, Research Paper Equal Opportunities In 1990 the United States Congress passed the Americans With Disabilities Act. This act, frequently referred to as the ADA, was intended to protect disabled Americans from discrimination and to remove the social and architectural barriers that prevent the disabled from participating in mainstream society (Hoover 137).
Euthanasia And The Robert Latimer Case Essay
, Research Paper Euthanasia is undoubtedly an issue that plagues the minds of those living with children or adults who are severely disabled. Rarely is one found to have a ?neutral? outlook upon it; that is, a side must be chosen, for or against. It is too delicate a topic to be ?in the middle? about. Over the years, cases involving euthanasia have caused massive controversies as to whether or not it is feasible to take the life of another human being in order to ?put them out of their misery?.
Negative And Positive Rights Essay Research Paper
Throughout societies in history and presently, we can see the employment of two primary forms of rights: positive and negative. The bulk of the following attempts to highlight the differences between the two. The proponents of each will also be discussed.
Capitalism Essay Research Paper The protection from
Capitalism Essay, Research Paper The protection from force, that is, the protection of individual rights, would be achieved through the use of a police force to protect the rights of citizens at home; a military, to protect the rights of citizens from foreign aggression; and a court system to enforce contracts and settle disputes between citizens.
Freedom And Rights Essay Research Paper Freedom
Freedom And Rights Essay, Research Paper Freedom and Rights How would you feel if your individual rights and freedoms were stripped from you during a national crisis? In many countries, the people s individual rights and freedoms are supposed to be protected by the government. But, in some cases, those individual rights and freedoms were taken away from the people during a national crisis.
A Fair Chance For The Girls Essay
, Research Paper ?A Fair Chance for the Girls? In this article the author Edward Clarke writes about the harmful effects of education on the sexual development and reproductive capacities of women. While reading this article I was forced to be open minded and accept every aspect of this reading in order to fully understand it.
The Bill Of Rights Essay Research Paper
The Bill of Rights Bill of Rights The first ten amendments to the US constitution are called the Bill of Rights because they provide basic legal protection for individual rights. The
Stephen Hawking Essay Research Paper
Stephen Hawking is a hero to me for the inspiration which he has provided for many disabled people. The modesty that Hawking has about his brilliance. And the controversial
America And The Disabled Essay Research Paper
Is it right for America to treat the disabled the way they do? America ignores the need to modernize public facilities for the disabled. However, the government provides for these facilities. Supporting the disadvantaged is something that may not be to the financial advantage of our government. Thus, America tends to treat disabled unfairly.
Americans With Disabilities Act Essay Research Paper
On July 26, 1990, the Americans with Disabilities Act was signed into law intended to make the American society more accessible to people with disabilities. The general purpose of this legislation is to extend the prohibition against discrimination on the basis of race, sex, religion, and national origin to persons with disabilities.
Rights Of The Disabled Essay Research Paper
The Rights of People with Disabilities Many people with disabilities have been fighting for equal opportunities and equal treatment. Discrimination against people with disabilities was at an overall high but, in the last ten years new laws have been passed and equality is one step closer. Why disability rights? One man tells a story on why people with disabilities need rights and laws to get the same opportunities.
What Is Human Rights Abuse Essay Research
Paper What are Human Rights Abuses? Human Rights Abuses are occurrences where there are violations on an individual’s right to act in a way to make moral decisions. Tis includes violations against an individual’s political rights,worker rights, and freedom of religion,speech, press,peaceful assembly and association.
Dawn Social Justice Group Essay Research Paper
DAWN The social justice group DAWN (disabled woman?s network Ontario) is a province wide organization of woman with all types of disabilities. They are a feminist organization which supports woman in their struggle to control their own lives. Dawn Ontario is controlled by women with disabilities. The members include woman with disabilities and non-disabled woman.
Transforming America With The Civil Rights Movement
Essay, Research Paper Transforming America with the Civil Rights Movement The civil rights movement transformed American society in to a color conscience society and started the anti-free speech political correct movement that we are seeing today. The civil rights movement gave African Americans the right to be treated as regular citizens but it was the urban riots of the mid-1960s and the voiced black rage that changed the tone of the civil rights movement.
Managing Classroom Behavior Essay Research Paper MANAGING
Managing Classroom Behavior Essay, Research Paper MANAGING CLASSROOM BEHAVIOR REPORT #1 Managing classroom behavior can be a difficult task, especially if you have a child who is always causing disturbances. Once you have identified that there is a problem, you should ask yourself six simple questions.
WomenS Rights Essay Research Paper Womens Rights
Women?S Rights Essay, Research Paper Women?s Rights, rights that establish the same social, economic, and political status for women as for men. Women?s rights guarantee that women will not face discrimination on the basis of their sex. Until the second half of the 20th century, women in most societies were denied some of the legal and political rights accorded to men.
Human Rights Essay Research Paper Human RightsThroughout
Human Rights Essay, Research Paper Human Rights Throughout history, people?s human rights have been violated, but efforts have also been made to address the violations, and protect their rights. Human rights are rights as regarded as belonging fundamentally to all persons. Today, everyone is entitled to the same rights.
Lock Outs In Sql Server Essay Research
Paper Lock Outs in SQL Server If you lock yourself out of SQL Server without being able to log on with a sysadmin login, you don’t have to reinstall SQL Server. To access SQL Server, you need to use the registry key for SQL Server 2000 and SQL Server 7.0 that determines the authentication mode of SQL Server.