Free Speech Essay, Research Paper
The first amendment to the constitution guarantees the right of free speech and
of the press. Unfortunately, some individuals have used this right to protect
themselves from litigation when they produce material that is pornographic,
hateful or when they use ethically questionable methods when reporting a story.
The government has attempted to intervene through passing laws and imposing
regulations. The problem with placing restrictions on free speech is that the
question of who will decide what is appropriate and what is not will inevitably
be raised. There are two positions when debating this issue : 1) protect free
speech even though some people abuse it or 2) freedom of speech does not
outweigh the need for ethical principles. Two of the ethical dilemmas facing the
media today are the conflicts of freedom of the press versus individual rights,
and the right of the press to refuse to reveal their sources. The media has
often claimed that the public has a right to know but they do not limit that
right to know to a certain area of public concern. Reporters have written
stories on the sexual lives of movie stars claiming public interest but simply
because the public is curious does not mean they have a right to know.
Certainly, most people would not want their entire life story being printed as
public knowledge and subject to ridicule. The issue of privacy was brought to
the forefront by the untimely demise of Princess Diana. She was being chased by
reporters who had been following her all night when she was involved in the car
accident that killed her. Many people then criticized the press who had been
following her all night. Does the media have the right to follow and harass
people simply on the basis that they are public figures or do public figures
deserve to have a private life? The issue of revealing sources has been debated
for years, particularly after the Watergate scandal of the seventies. Recently
an issue regarding the confidentiality of a source arose but for a different
reason. Dan Cohen is sued two newspapers for breach of contract because they
promised him confidentiality when he provided them with information. After they
had received the information the newspapers decided that the information
reflected more on Cohen and proceeded to print the information with Cohen’s
name. Cohen won the suit but the damage to his reputation was already done.
Those are only two of the many issues involved in free speech. Ethical restraint
would set guidelines for journalists and protect individual rights. The first
issue would be to set objective and universal guidelines so that there would be
no debate over who sets the ethical code. The problem would be enforcing these
guidelines. The Radio Television News Directors Association and the Society of
Professional Journalists both have ethical codes, which include respecting those
whom you are reporting about and keeping confidentiality. Those ethical
standards are not enforced and so some do not follow them. Some people believe
in free speech at all costs. Free speech without restraint causes public outcry
and violates people’s civil rights like their right to privacy. The difficulty
is that people see any form of restraint as censorship and then claim that the
government will begin running our lives and making our decisions. If the ethical
standards agreed upon were universal they would satisfy everyone and if the
journalists would follow them there would be no need for government
intervention. Using the example of Dan Cohen’s issue of confidentiality the
ethics of the reporters involved can be analyzed. The act of printing his name,
in and of itself, was not wrong. The intention of the journalists was to inform
the public since Cohen was associated with a politician who was running for
governor and the information Cohen had was on the opposing candidate. The
circumstances were the gubernatorial race was in its final days. The reporters
had the right to accept and publish the information since it was public record
and did not violate the rights of the opposing candidate. They exercised their
right to free speech and of the press in that respect. The ethical issue was
whether the reporters violated Cohen’s rights when they broke their promise of
confidentiality and printed his name with the article. The question then would
be should they have printed his name? Following Aristotle’s ethical theory of
the golden mean, the journalists were wrong. The extreme one side would have
been to print his name while the extreme on the other side would have been not
to print anything. A compromise would have been to print the information with
the statement that the source was connected and was biased. Aristotle, however,
believed in virtue and so did not believe in lying. The reporters were also
wrong because they broke their promise to Cohen and so lied to him. If the first
position were accepted and free speech was permitted, unchecked the consequences
would be severe. Nothing would stop people from publishing false information or
keep pornographers from distributing their material wherever they wish. One
person’s right to free speech would infringe on any number of another person’s
rights. The press would lose all credibility in the eyes of the public. The
reporters who printed Cohen’s name would not be held accountable because few
people would believe them anyway. Riots would break out during marches because
the opposing view would be allowed to voice their opinion wherever and whenever
they chose. Hate groups such as the Klu Klux clan could paper entire cities with
propaganda, which could include false information. The press could infringe upon
privacy rights to gain their stories and could even invent their own news with
no standards to live up to. Eventually, the government would have to intervene.
If the second position were accepted and an ethical code were adopted and
enforced the media would gain credibility in the eyes of the public. The
standard of material presented would be higher and it would all be true. The
reporters from the example would be held accountable because most would agree
that lying to an individual in order to get a story is wrong. The people would
be responsible for enforcing the ethical restraints and not the government. The
society as a whole would be better informed and able to make better decisions.
The principles and values important in this issue are and individual’s right to
speak freely, a reporter’s right to inform the public, Rawl’s veil of ignorance
in discussing what is fair and Aristotle’s theory of virtues. Position 2 is more
convincing because it provides a guideline of what is fair. Position 1 may seem
like an extreme but without any restraint at all it is possible. Position 2
attempts to set up objective guidelines which everyone can agree on while
Position 1 allows everyone to decide for themselves and that type of
subjectivism negates justice, which most people agree, is needed. The debate
over what type of restraint should be placed on the first amendment and who
should enforce that restraint if indeed any restraint at all should be allowed
has continued for years. No one wants their right to free speech infringed upon
and yet no one wants any of their other rights violated either. Journalists have
been using the right to free speech and of the press to use questionable methods
in gathering information and reporting the news. Without objective and universal
ethical standards no one is going to win this argument.
Другие работы по теме:
Free Speech Essay Research Paper The United
Free Speech Essay, Research Paper The United States is recognized and admired all over the world, as a representative of liberty and civil rights. The First Amendment to the US constitution, presented in the Bill of Rights passed by Congress on September 25, 1789 and ratified December 15,1791, discusses religious and political freedom.
MadeUp Nixon Speech Essay Research Paper My
Made-Up Nixon Speech Essay, Research Paper My fellow Americans, I come to you tonight to ask for a hand to lend in my aide. I know that a great number of the silent majority would like to see the Vietnam war to finally come to a close. And, because of my campaign promise, I am standing here tonight to inform you that I have a plan of action that I shall use to uphold that promise.
Kujfgkg Essay Research Paper Here it is
Kujfgkg Essay, Research Paper Here it is, February already! Damn! This year is flyin by like a car hit bum! It’s also time for me to be campaigning for president again. So far so good. In New Hampshire, I spent not one cent and Gary Bauer spent 800 thousand bucks only to get 324 votes more than I did!
Journalism Essay Research Paper While Burl Osborne
Journalism Essay, Research Paper While Burl Osborne is a strong believer in the right to free speech, he said that ” the urge to censor is the reaction of well-intended people to the expression of views that they find repugnant.”
Poem Destiny Essay Research Paper Sometimes I
Poem: Destiny Essay, Research Paper Sometimes I wonder if life is just meant to be If we have not a choice in the matter, or we really are free I walked down the street on one fine day
1St Amendment Essay Research Paper HE FIRST
1St Amendment Essay, Research Paper HE FIRST AMENDMENT “Congress shall make no laws respecting an establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the
Speech Of Tribute Essay Research Paper I
Speech Of Tribute Essay, Research Paper I can remember a time in my life that we all can refer to. A time when the world seemed too big to get a grasp on, too big for it to see you. I believed it would swallow me whole? but as you can see, it didn?t. Remember when we were young and our hopes were high, our goals and dreams seemed untouchable? Sure you do, I remember.
The Constitution Essay Research Paper Congress shall
The Constitution Essay, Research Paper Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of Religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, this Amendment is the most important part of the constitution. Without free speech, we the people of the United States would not be able to speak openly and freely about issues that affect our everyday life.
I Have A Dream (MLK) (A Speech
Summary) Essay, Research Paper On August 28, 1963 on the steps of Lincoln Memorial in Washington D.C., one of the most profound civil rights Leaders recited a speech for all to live by. Martin Luther King Jr. was the man who made history that day in 1963, with the world-renowned speech ?I have a Dream?.
Freedom Essay Research Paper Free to me
Freedom Essay, Research Paper Free to me means that you have no restrictions, no laws, and no boundaries controlling you. You can do basically what you want, when you want. If people were to follow my idea of freedom though, the world would be a chaotic place to live.
Effects Of The Speeches Of Brutus And
Antony Essay, Research Paper Julius Caesar is one of Shakespeare’s greatest works. It’s about a group of conspirators who kill their king, Julius, in order to be free. Antony, opposed to the assassination, felt that he should avenge Julius’s death. He delivered a speech that convinced the Romans that the murder was unjust, invoking their rebellion.
Antony Speech Analysis Essay Research Paper Emotional
Antony Speech Analysis Essay, Research Paper Emotional Speech Analysis William Shakespeare?s ?Julius Caesar? is a well-written stage play. Shakespeare included many good speeches in his plays; one of the best was the one delivered by Antony. Antony?s speech came very shortly after Julius Caesar?s death, and the city was in much chaos.
The Movies Essay Research Paper The speaker
The Movies Essay, Research Paper The speaker in the movie viewed in class on February 5, 2001 gave a very good presentation on the procedures performed during C.P.R. and the benefits of knowing this life saving procedure. Although the speech was audience capturing, there were a few improvements that would have helped improve her presentation.
Bc Speech Assignment Essay Research Paper Research
Bc Speech Assignment Essay, Research Paper Research Assignment #4 Your fourth speech is a research-based persuasive speech. Since your primary goal will be to convince your audience to take a specific action your research burden is higher. Your research is due via email on the date listed on your course schedule.
Persuasive Speech Essay Research Paper Christopher AdairPersuasive
Persuasive Speech Essay, Research Paper Christopher Adair Persuasive Speech To begin with I need an attention getter, so I thought I would get their attention by vaguely suggesting something about a decision everyone has to make when they are sixteen. From there I will tell everyone how and why I am qualified to give this presentation, and why it is important to listen to what I have to say.
Filtered Speech Experiment Essay Research Paper Filtered
Filtered Speech Experiment Essay, Research Paper Filtered Speech Experiment Purpose The purpose of the filtered speech experiment was to look for three things. The first was to see/hear which frequencies can be eliminated from speech signal and conversely which frequencies can not in order to understand speech.
Areopagitica By Milton Essay Research Paper What
Areopagitica By Milton Essay, Research Paper What is the meaning of virtue? Milton answers this question in his speech Areopagitica. Milton will dicuss his meaning of virtue and show his anger at
John Rocker
’s Suspension Essay, Research Paper Philosophy Ethical Theories Topic 1 An argument can be made that Major League Baseball s decision to suspend John Rocker from baseball due to his expressing bigoted views in a magazine interview is not right. This argument states that free speech is an important moral value, and since John Rocker has the right to free speech, suspending him for expressing his bigoted views violates the spirit of free speech.
Filtering The Net Essay Research Paper Filtering
Filtering The Net Essay, Research Paper Filtering the Net Over the last several years many attempts have been made to put a limit on what can be viewed on the Internet. In 1996, it was the Communications Decency Act and in 1999 the Child Online Protection Act. Both were shot down because they were said to violate the first amendment right to free speech.
Prom Speech Essay Research Paper 2000 SpeechWhen
Prom Speech Essay, Research Paper 2000 Speech When we were younger, we couldn t wait to graduate from high school and be done with school. Well, now it s here and we are still pretty exited to be finished, but graduation has taken on a whole new meaning for us.
America Has Become Too Free Essay Research
Paper America is the free-land, according to everyone who lives in this nation. Also, within the society, the freedom of speech has become eminently freer, which is surveyed through the profusion of music, movies, books, and the other aspects of culture contributed in our society today. But how free is too free? The society we live in which violence is largely contributed in those numerous forms of entertainment could be influencing the uprising in crimes across the U.S.
The Effects Of The Speeches Of Brutus
And Anthony Essay, Research Paper The Effects of the Speeches of Brutus and Antony Julius Caesar is one of Shakespeare’s greatest works. It’s about a group of conspirators who kill their king, Julius, in order to be free. Antony, opposed to the assassination, felt that he should avenge Julius’s death. He delivered a speech that convinced the Romans that the murder was unjust, invoking their rebellion.
Speech Essay Research Paper There are two
Speech Essay, Research Paper There are two opposite points of view to this problem. One side suggests not to place any cods on speech on campuses of college institutions and another side strongly believes that speech must be protected by law. Mrs. Jennifer Kelley is following position of free speech in the article called Speech Codes Should Not Be Permitted on Campuses.
Hate Speech And The First Amendment Essay
, Research Paper On college campuses today the debate rages to limit certain kinds of speech that is racists and sexist, some students say that they have a right to say what ever they what because of the First Amendment and doing so will a volition of this right, but this kind of speech threatens the rights of minorities and dose let them engage in the leering process.
The Inaugural Speech Essay Research Paper PAID
The Inaugural Speech Essay, Research Paper PAID ADVERTISEMENT Summary of President John F. Kennedy s Inaugural Address This inaugural speech establishes what John F. Kennedy s vision is for the United States–actually
Free Speech And Free Action Essay Research
Paper Free Speech and Free Action Freedom of speech differs from freedom of action. But speech and action are so closely interwoven in human behavior that it’s not always immediately obvious which is which. Thus it’s not surprising that we often criminalize speech as well as, or even instead of, the action that it accompanies.
Gunther Essay Research Paper Freedom of speech
Gunther Essay, Research Paper Freedom of speech is the right to speak and write without fear of government limitations. In the United States freedom of speech and press are commonly called freedom of expression. Both freedoms are protected by the First Amendment to the Constitution. However, freedom of expression in colleges all around the United States is limited very often.
What Freedom Of Speech Means To Me
Essay, Research Paper WHAT FREEDOM OF SPEECH MEANS TO ME The Bill of Rights states, “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or profiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.” This is quite possibly the amendment that makes the United States the democratic and orderly country it is.
Cry For Freedom Essay Research Paper Cry
Cry For Freedom Essay, Research Paper Cry for FreedomAlthough Patrick Henry and Martin Luther King, Jr. are both skilled orators and use similar rhetorical devices to appeal to their audiences, they call for freedom for two totally different kinds of people. Both Patrick Henry and Martin Luther King, Jr. show their strengths as speakers through their use of these rhetorical devices.
Demonstration Critique Essay Research Paper Demonstration Critique
Demonstration Critique Essay, Research Paper Demonstration Critique During my demonstration speech, I was affected by my speech anxiety. Some of the viewable symptoms were the shaking of my hands and also the stuttering of speech. I was able to control myself and relax after I started getting into my information.
The World Essay Research Paper In an
The World Essay, Research Paper In an important speech, oral delivery is key, ingredients to oral delivery are tone, volume, rate, enthusiasm and clarity, how
What Price Freedom Essay Research Paper What
What Price Freedom? Essay, Research Paper What is the price for FREEDOM? It’s is obvious that the price for freedom is not free but that it is rather large. After obtaining freedom, we look back and wonder was it worth it? Was freedom overpriced? In other words, did we sacrifice and pay too much to be free?