Prison Alternatives Essay, Research Paper
Prison Alternatives
Prison inmates, are some of the most dysfunctional people in society. Most of the inmates have had too little discipline or too much, come from broken homes, and have no self-esteem. They are very insecure and are at war with themselves as well as with society. Most inmates did not learn moral values or to follow everyday norms as they were brought up in society. Take a group of people, strip them of possessions and privacy, expose them to constant threats of violence, overcrowd their cell-block, deprive them of meaningful work, and the result is a bitter underclass more intent on getting even with society than contributing to it. There are better ways to deal with crime and punishment in America.
Most of today s correctional institutions lack the ability and programs to rehabilitate the criminals of America. One can predict that a prisoner held for two, four, eight or ten years, then released, still with no education or vocational skills will likely return to a life of crime. Often their life in crime will resume in weeks after their release. Although the best prisons and programs in the world will not cure the problem totally, improvements still must be made.
Next, some believe that if we want to rehabilitate criminals we must do more than just send them to prison. For instance, we could give them a chance to acquire job skills; which will improve the chances that inmates will become productive citizens upon release. These programs must aim to change those who want to change. Those who are taught to produce useful goods and to be productive are likely to develop the self-esteem essential to a normal, integrated personality. This kind of program would provide skills and habits and replace the sense of hopelessness that many inmates have.
Out of ninety-five of America s federal prison institutions only 2.3% of them are violent offenders ( Federal Bureau of Prisons Quick Facts ). So why not save the spaces in our prisons for the violent offenders, sex offenders, and drug offenders and take the nonviolent offenders out and put them to work and rehabilitate them to keep them out of the prison system and solve the overcrowding of them. Prisons take the nonviolent offender and make him live in the same conditions that a hardened killer would have. America has to wake up and realize that the current structure of our penal system is failing terribly. The government must devise new ways to punish the guilty, and still manage to keep American citizens satisfied that our justice system is effective. Restitution programs would make this possible ( Restitution ).
The very nature of prison, no matter how humane society attempts to make it, produces an environment that is harmful to its residents. Even if their release is delayed by longer sentences, those residents will eventually return to damage the community, and we as a society are paying to make this possible. Taxpayers pay approximately $15,000 a year to house an inmate in prison ( McKean ). Why should taxpayers be forced to pay to keep nonviolent criminals sitting in prison cells where they become bitter and more likely to repeat their offenses when they are released?
Instead, why not put them to work outside prison where they could pay back the victims of their crimes? Most inmates that are over crowding our prisons are nonviolent offenders. The government should initiate work programs; where the criminal is given a job and must relinquish his or her earnings to the victim of their crime until the mental and physical damages of their victims are fulfilled. A court will determine how much money the criminal will have to pay for his restitution costs, and what job the criminal will have to do to pay back that restitution.
The most obvious benefit of this approach is that it takes care of the victim, the forgotten person in the current system. Restitution offers the criminal a means to make a real change of character. Imprisonment alone cannot do this; nothing can destroy a man’s intellect more surely than living without useful productive work and purpose. Restitution also provides an alternative to imprisonment for nonviolent criminals. Working with the purpose of paying back their victim allows a criminal to understand and deal with the real consequences of his or her actions. Removing nonviolent offenders from prison would relieve overcrowding thus, eliminating the necessity of spending of public funding for prison construction.
The concept of restitution appeals to America’s sense of justice. Restitution would dissuade crime with the same effectiveness as prison. Prisons in their current state have not done much of a job when it comes to deterrence. Restitution programs would be able to greatly reduce the incidence of further crime, since they restore a sense of individual responsibility, making the offender more likely to be able to adjust to society. It is not so much the type of punishment that dissuades crime, but rather the certainty of punishment. An effective and aggressively run restitution program would be a greater deterrent than the threat of prison. The payoff for crime is so great that many are willing to risk prison. The certainty of restitution, by requiring payment, takes the profit out of crime.
Many Americans believe in our current prison system, and also believe that it is an effective form of punishment for the criminal. Some people say that criminals can live decent, civilized lives in prison and graduate to decent, civilized lives in the free world. It is well known what goes on behind closed doors in prison. Most inmates learn little of value during their confinement behind bars, mostly because they adapt to prison in immature and often self-defeating ways. As a result, they leave prison unimproved, and sometimes considerably worse than when they went in. The first time offender who is arrested for burglary does not belong in a prison where the only thing he will learn is how to become a better and more violent burglar. Instead, why not make him pay restitution to the storeowner whom he robbed? If this form of punishment was initiated for the lesser offender, our prisons will have the vacancies to incarcerate the Jeffery Dahmers of the world in prison for life.
Crime is the result of morally responsible people making wrong moral decisions, for which they must be held accountable. The just and necessary response to such behavior is punishment, which may include restitution for community service, stiff fines, or in cases where the offender is a danger to society, prison. But let’s not kid ourselves any longer. The prison was not designed to cure the individual; it was made to lock him up.
Другие работы по теме:
Angola Essay Research Paper I feel that
Angola Essay, Research Paper I feel that Angola prison system is a very effective correction system. The video demonstrated how the system has different setups to keep the prisoners working to keep them out of trouble. Although Angola is a rough maximum-security system, it seems to have great control over the inmates.
Shawshank Redemption Essay Research Paper 2
Shawshank Redemption Essay, Research Paper Red and Brooks are characters with many similar traits and had gone through many of the same circumstances, but one main difference allows on man to survive outside of Shawshank and the other unable to cope with the outside world. That one main difference was a man named Andy Dufresne.
Capital Punishment Essay Research Paper I am
Capital Punishment Essay, Research Paper I am all for Capital Punishment. I think that if you kill someone you should be given the death penalty. I think that the death of the killer would give family and friends a bit of ease
Teenagers In Jail Essay Research Paper Should
Teenagers In Jail Essay, Research Paper Should teenagers spend their young lives in jail Recently in Detroit, Michigan a teenager was convicted in criminal court for a crime he committed. The judge place him in a juvenile facility and ordered him to mandatory psychiatrist evaluation, and base on his improvement, he will be set free at the age of twenty one.
Blind Ambition Essay Research Paper Blind AmbitionJohn
Blind Ambition Essay, Research Paper Blind Ambition John Dean was counsel to the President. He wanted power and superiority. To advance up the ladder, John Dean got involved in certain activities. Some of which were not legal. One example would be the extortion of money. John Dean didn?t really think of the consequences but of the rewards.
The Knight
’s Tale Essay, Research Paper The Knight’s Tale The Knight’s Tales Theseus meets the widow of the Theban war who remained him of Fortune’s false wheel and thus fill him with pity . Theseus is then at the summit of Fortune’s wheel .
Social Control Theory Essay Research Paper The
Social Control Theory Essay, Research Paper The article “Arizona wants special prison for foreiners” is one example of how ethnicity and crime are an issue and how some feel it should be delt with. As some may see this as a positive thing to do inorder to help the process of deportation or what ever the consequences may be, many others are calling it a plan that would segregate Mexican inmates, being that 89 percent of the foreign inmates would fall under that race.
Prisons Don
’t Work Essay, Research Paper Prison’s Don’t Work In our society, the dual purpose of imprisonment is punishment and/or rehabilitation. Throughout the states, there is an increased prison population. For example, more than 40 states’ prison systems are under court orders to rectify overcrowding. Some prisons have what is called a “zero sum” status.
American Flag Essay Research Paper Betsy Ross
American Flag Essay, Research Paper Betsy Ross lived from 1752 to 1836. She was born to Elizabeth Griscom in Philadelphia. In 1773 she ran away with John Ross to get married. But her
Into The Twilight Essay Research Paper She
Into The Twilight Essay, Research Paper She, the Innocent One, Calls to me. She tightens her thighs, Wanting tenderness and gentleness, Not withered dreams and darkness.
The Analysis Of
“Ode To The West Wind” Essay, Research Paper Mr. Jackson, seeing as you have been found guilty of murder in the first degree by the citizens of the Great Republic Of Texas, I have no choice but to sentence you to death by means of lethal injection, to be administered by a state-appointed prison medical technician within 90 days’ time.
Prison Overpopulation Essay Research Paper The rising
Prison Overpopulation Essay, Research Paper The rising prison population in America is becoming a very serious problem. Too many American citizens are being locked up for crimes that just should not be against the law. The majority of people being convicted and sent to prison is due to the excessively strict drug laws, or the so-called, War on Drugs .
American Me Essay Research Paper American Me
American Me Essay, Research Paper American Me is a movie, made in 1992, directed by and starring Edward James Olmos. This movie based on a true story, about a Mexican-American male spinning over half his life in prison. He grew up in the street of East Los Angeles, were he joined the local neighborhood gang. He and his friends got sent to prison at the age of sixteen for breaking and entering.
Crito Essay Research Paper While awaiting his
Crito Essay, Research Paper While awaiting his execution in prison, Socrates was confronted by his friend Crito, and given an opportunity to escape. Crito offered a multitude of reasons to support his proposal, however Socrates refused to leave on the basis of four premises:- One must never do wrong, even in return for wrong.- It is wrong to break a just agreement.- The agreement between the laws of Athens and its citizens is just because all citizens are allowed two alternatives to obeying the laws.- Leaving would constitute breaking the agreement.Supported my these four premises, Socrates claimed that escaping from prison would be morally wrong.
Capital Punishment By Lethal Inject Essay Research
Paper The process of execution by lethal injection involves a carefully organized program. As it is stated in the article My Friend s Execution by William Vance Trollinger Jr. the process of execution is divided in a number of steps. First, two days before the execution, the prisoner is moved into the death cell, which is located in the depths of the prison.
Prison Prevents Violence Essay Research Paper Prison
Prison Prevents Violence Essay, Research Paper Prison Prevents Violence Violence is a major concern amongst the youths of this generation. It is an important issue that is being neglected. Several causes that may lead to this behavior would be the surroundings the youths are brought up in, or the image they wish to present themselves as – macho, tough, and untouchable.
Socrates Essay Research Paper Socrates arguments that
Socrates Essay, Research Paper Socrates arguments that it would be wrong to escape from prison is as follows. In Critos, Socrates explains to his friend Crito that escaping from prison would go against many of the thins that he (Socrates) believes in; seeking virtue, seeking the truth, not repaying an evil with another evil, obeying the laws of the state and so on.
Shawshank Redemption 2 Essay Research Paper Shawshank
Shawshank Redemption 2 Essay, Research Paper Shawshank Redemption The main character, Andy, is an accountant who was convicted of murdering his own wife. He is taken out of a life in which he is comfortable and placed in an environment that is completely foreign to him. The of other prisoners’ lifestyles are not similar to his own.
Bartleby The Scrivener Essay Essay Research Paper
Bartleby the Scrivener Essay “Bartleby the Scrivener” is a short story written by Herman Melville. The plot is based on the character Bartleby, an office worker who decides to stop doing his work. Bartleby is thrown in prison because he does not adapt to society’s expectations. It is in prison where he dies a lonely man.
My Own Prison By Creed Essay Research
? Paper Richie Lord 10/15/2000 ENC 1101 Song Lyrics What are they saying? “My Own Prison” by the group Creed is a very moving and inspirational song. The reason it is an inspirational song is because it has an excellent meaning. The author of the song Scott Sapp, one of the members of the band, had a hard life and is expressing his feeling about his life in this song.
Handgun Essay Research Paper HandgunBecause the prison
Handgun Essay, Research Paper Handgun Because the prison population has doubled since 1984, it is really urgent for people to pay attention to the method of decreasing the crime rate. Basically, it is true that “locking people up is obviously not the answer to the crime problem. Training and educating people is one answer.” (Los Angeles Time, Joseph Mayfield) But training and educating people to lower the crime rate may only work under some conditions.
Alternatives To Corrections Essay Research Paper Alternatives
Alternatives To Corrections Essay, Research Paper Alternatives to incarceration Ever since the first prison opened in the United States in 1790, incarceration has been the center of the nations criminal justice system. Over this 200 year period many creative alternatives to incarceration have been tried, and many at a much lower cost than imprisonment.
Thesis Comparing Scarlet Letter And Guilt Essay
, Research Paper Many criminals today serve their time in prison and are then set free. Most of them go on to commit other crimes, without learning the lesson their punishment was meant to teach. the worst punishment possible is torture and to live with ones own guilt.
Trial By Ordeal Essay Research Paper Trial
Trial By Ordeal Essay, Research Paper Trial by Ordeal I personally feel that trial by ordeal was a rather, how should I put this, “unjustified” way of determining guilt. Trial by ordeal was a type of “trial” that was used
Drugs In The Prison System Essay Research
Paper Drugs and Alcohol in the Untied State prison system In the Untied States most of the prison population are people that have been involved with Alcohol or some form of drugs. Many of them were high or drunk at the time of there arrest. Most of them only did the crimes to be able to support there drug and alcohol addiction.
Mt Olive Prison Essay Research Paper Mt
Mt. Olive Prison Essay, Research Paper Mt. OliveThe trip to the Mt. Olive State Prison was an experience that I will never forget. I had never thought of all the little things they do to keep the prison safe and under control. From the very start of the tour I thought to myself, “Why does it matter if we have more than one key, or earrings, or any other kind of jewelry.
What Is The Best Alternative To Prison
? Essay, Research Paper ?The U.S. prison population has tripled since 1980 so that on any given day there are 1.5 million Americans behind bars.? (Alternatives 1). There is a clear overcrowding problem in todays prisons. Why? I believe that the population explosion in the prison system is due to the increasing moral decline of America.
Poem Being In A Prison Essay Research
Paper Being In A Prison (Revised) Being In A Prison I am confined to everyday routine Same time, same place, same people Being In A Prison I have to do what is asked of me
US Prison System Essay Research Paper There
U.S. Prison System Essay, Research Paper There are many people who are critical of the US?s prison sysetm; the idea of locking up those who commit crimes against a society simply to keep them from doing harm. Many say that more rehabilatation is necessary to improve these individuals and, therefore, society as a whole.