It is better to give than to receive . I believe I was about nine years old when I heard that statement for the first time . It was in church. It was one of those things that I randomly chose to hear while sitting in church every Sunday. Normally anything that was said in that building never made sense to me and I never had any use for retaining it. This time however something did make sense to me. Perhaps it was because my parents had been telling me that same thing except in a more ambiguous and indirect manner. “Isaac you should share your toys; Isaac why don’t you give your food to your sister if you don’t want it?; Isaac get your old toys and clothes together so you can donate them to the Salvation Army.” So as I grew up I had a somewhat strong belief that it was better to give than to receive. I am now nineteen years of age and I have come to see that what I heard in that church ten years ago isn’t always necessarily the true.
Harris claims utilitarianism as the basis of his idea , and in the actual context and definition of the term he is correct . According to Webster’s Revised Unabridged Dictionary, ? 1996 Utilitarianism is defined as the doctrine that utility is the sole standard of morality, so that the rectitude of an action is determined by its usefulness. Jeremy Bentham who is known as the founder of this theory elaborates that “laws should be socially useful and the greatest happiness of the greatest number should be the foundation of morals and legislation.” Harris’ idea in essence follows the “Guidelines” of utilitarianism. The idea is advantageous to man as whole because of the fact that it maximizes the number of lives saved. If this plan that Harris has were to be implemented there definitely would be a great number of lives saved everyday .
Opponents of the Survival Lottery might speak of the utilitarian solution in a disparaging tone. Harris could argue the fact that utilitarianism is a demanding moral position that often asks us to put aside self-interest for the rest of society . Morality is about producing good consequences, not having good intentions, so we should think more along the lines of doing whatever will bring the most benefit to all of humanity. Utilitarianism is concerned about consequences, not intentions.
Harris’ idea of removing organs from people and donating them to the people who need them seems to be a utilitarianist view in nature , but it doesn’t agree with what Bentham believed, which was that we should try to increase the overall amount of pleasure in the world. Harris’ view doesn’t increase pleasure. Instead it seems to bring pain. For the families and friends of the lottery winners there is an extreme amount of pain and discomfort. There is an argument that it cannot possibly be right to take the life of a human being. A strong argument against the Survival Lottery is that it is a violation to the Eighth Amendment of the United States Constitution, which condemns cruel and unusual punishment. How can murder not be immoral? Citizens under a social contract, agree not to kill only because others also agree not to kill. It is the function of penal laws to prevent murder by demonstrating to society that it is not in their best interest to murder.
The term utilitarianism is specifically applied to the proposition that the highest objective of a moral action is the achievement of the greatest happiness for the greatest number. Usually the utilitarian theory of ethics is opposed to ethical doctrines often brought into question by that inner sense called the conscience. As a result Utilitarianism generally disagrees with the view that moral decisions depend on the will of God. Certainly there are things in life that are irreplaceable , such as ?Life. What Harris is suggesting that we sacrifice a few lives to preserve many more. The question that is being asked is such: Is it morally correct to take something that is as precious and irreplaceable as a life from someone even though many more lives would be saved? I believe that question shouldn’t even be asked. No human being has the right to take the life of another no matter the circumstance . It is unethical to kill period, no matter how you look at it.
Do to others as you would have them do to you. This one Golden Rule would neither contradict nor lie parallel to the Survival Lottery because the rule applies to individuals as opposed to society . For the most part I can’t think of too many people that would want to win the Survival Lottery and at the same time I’m sure they wouldn’t wish such luck to anyone else.
I am a believer in Utilitarianism to an extent. However I must say John Harris’ Survival Lottery is past that extent. This is because the idea goes against many of my values and beliefs such as the killing of an innocent person. Concluding I want to say that I do not represent the whole of society and their general view of course, however this essay does take some of my personal beliefs into account. I use myself as a typical human being and I feel my opinions and reasoning have cogency.
Другие работы по теме:
TraditionA Rose For Emily The Lottery Essay
, Research Paper Tradition People throughout the world do things for many different reasons. Religion, peer pressure, or tradition are some of the reasons the people do things. In the U.S. we have many traditions such as Christmas. Some people have strange or out of the ordinary traditions. The two short stories ?The Lottery? and ?A Rose for Emily? both portray tradition.
If I Won The Lottery Essay Research
Paper If I won the lottery, I would choose to remain in my condominium and do some remodeling. The room that I have the most plans for is my daughters room. First, I would paint the walls and woodwork. I want to the bottom half of the walls pink and the top half white with a chair rail border to divide the two colors.
The Lottery Essay Research Paper The LotteryThis
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper The Lottery This story reveals how selfish people can be in the society. In “The Lottery” villagers are an isolated group of individuals who could careless about one another, even their own family members. Although the author doesn’t explain why this village is completely separated from the rest of the world, the story truly reflects our society, that people ignore bad events happening around the world, as long those bad events do not happen to them.
Lottery Essay Research Paper The LotteryThe story
Lottery Essay, Research Paper The Lottery The story takes place in a small town with a population of about three hundred. They are all gathering for a lottery in the Town Square. The lottery has been a tradition since the beginning of the town?s history. Some parts of the ritual had been forgotten and they even lost the original black ballot box.
The Lottery Essay Research Paper Shealynn TakashProfessor
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper Shealynn Takash Professor Allen English 20 29 February, 2000 THE BLACK BOX: SYMBOLIC OF DEATH AND FADED TRADITIONS While the setting of Shirley Jackson?s, The Lottery, takes place on a clear, sunny, June day, it does not take long for the skies to turn gray as she introduces the readers to the black box.
The Lottery 3 Essay Research Paper The
The Lottery 3 Essay, Research Paper The Lottery, written by Shirley Jackson is a story that takes place in a small town of approximately three hundred residents. Every year on June 27th the townspeople congregate in a giant mass in the middle of town, where the lottery takes place. This lottery is a ceremony in which each family throughout the town is represented by a tiny white piece of paper.
The Lottery Essay Research Paper THE LOTTERYThe
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper ?THE LOTTERY? The theme of violence and tradition is persuasive in the short story ?The Lottery? written by Shirley Jackson. This theme is not a generalized theme of violence, but a
Utiliatariasm And Its Authors Essay Research Paper
Utilitarianism is the principle idea for the greatest happiness for the greatest numbers. In other words, maximize the pleasure while minimizing the pain. One such philosopher and believer of Utilitarianism is Jeremy Bentham, who lived from 1748 until 1832. He believed that there should be a moral system, and that it should do two things.
Forgotten Essay Research Paper ForgottenThe true meaning
Forgotten Essay, Research Paper Forgotten The true meaning of most traditional rituals, that I am familiar with, are forgotten and replaced with something distorted. In fact, in the story, ?The Lottery? by Shirley Jackson, the true meaning of the lottery?s ritual is forgotten. But on the other hand, violence still remains a very remembered role in this gruesome lottery.
The Lottery As An Allegory Essay Research
Paper Jackson s “The Lottery” as an Allegory Shirley Jackson s “The Lottery” is an excellent example of an allegorical short story. In this story, the reader learns of a town s “lottery” that takes place once a year, every year. It has been a tradition in this small rural town for many years and the villagers never question these activities, they just blindly go along with it.
The Lottery Essay Research Paper Page
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper Page – 1 Gothic is defined as ?a style of fiction that emphasizes the grotesque and the mysterious.? Similar to the works of Edgar Allan Poe, many of Shirley Jackson?s stories are considered ?gothic? fiction. One such story is ?The Lottery? which was first published in 1948.
A Criticism Of Essay Research Paper Due
A Criticism Of Essay, Research Paper Due to the lack of conflict and decision in The Lottery many readers will find the plot uninteresting, but at the same time the story is influential for each of its readers. Cleanth Brooks and Robert Penn Warren, prominent figures for the school of New Criticism, compare The Lottery to a fable and a parable because of its lack of characterization and broad pattern (250).
The Lottery Essay Research Paper At the
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper At the end of “The Lottery,” by Shirley Jackson, Tessie Hutchinson said, “It isn’t fair.” Tessie was correct; the lottery wasn’t fair. Death wasn’t fair, especially if you were the sacrificial lamb for the sake of tradition.”Lottery in June, corn be heavy soon,” took many innocent lives each year since the first settlers.
The Lottery Essay Research Paper 27 June
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper 27 June bisects the summer soltstice and Independence Day, which is a contrast between superstitious paganism and rational democracy. The sunny day and the blooming of flowers indicate a happy, festive occasion. The reader does not realize that The Lottery is not a happy occasion until its tragic end.
LOTF Essay Research Paper Introduction
LOTF Essay, Research Paper Introduction The first main problem the boys have in the novel Lord of the Flies is that they are unprepared for survival on an uninhabited
Lottery 2001 Essay Research Paper Lottery 2001The
Lottery 2001 Essay, Research Paper Lottery 2001 The sounds of the graduation were loud and excited everyone in the place had a buzz about them. This was Dusty and I’s last year and we decided to do something really cool before we go off to college. We got are diplomas and went out to celebrate with our families.
Comparitive Essay Essay Research Paper There are
Comparitive Essay Essay, Research Paper There are many stories of survival. When I think of survival I think of two things, The movie, Never Cry Wolf, and the story, When the Legends Die. These two are stories of men who survived in the wild after many obtacles. They were both very different but they were still the same.
Ethics Risk Taking Essay Research Paper The
Ethics Risk Taking Essay, Research Paper The paper is about risk taking and self-command. It was written for a philosophy class in ethics. The title of the paper is “Risk Taking”. It recieved 95 points out of a
Glass Ceiling Summary Essay Research Paper Utilitarianism
Glass Ceiling Summary Essay, Research Paper Utilitarianism favors unequal treatment in the work place.CONTROLLING IDEA: Big corporations should be forced into applying affirmative action to equal out the male/female ratio in management positions.
The Lottery Essay Research Paper Essay
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper Essay # 1: Sociological Theory “The Lottery” is a short story by Shirley Jackson that was published in 1948 and gave a good example of the definition of the term sociological theory. This theory is a set of ideas on how people behave and how institutions operate. The analysis of this short story and the of the work of Emile Durkheim shows the relationship of the two in the field of Sociology.
The Survival Lottery Essay Research Paper Brian
The Survival Lottery Essay, Research Paper Brian Ellis Philosophy Essay Critically assess the survival lottery In his article “The Survival Lottery,” Harris suggests a situation where a possible course of action would be to kill a healthy person and use his organs for transplantation, thereby saving several lives at the cost of one.
The Work Of The Mind Of Shirley
Jackson Essay, Research Paper The Work of The Mind of Shirley Jackson Shirley Jackson is the author of two very unique short stories titled ?The Lottery? and ?The Possibility of Evil?. She has a very odd style of writing and plot. Her themes are usually pertaining to the peculiar things that humans, the smartest being on the planet, will do upon one another.
The Lottery Essay Research Paper In Shirley
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper In Shirley Jackson?s “The Lottery,” she uses the element of surprise. The way the story ends is unlike anything anyone could predict. There are however several alternative ways
The Role Of Tradition In
“The Lottery” Essay, Research Paper The Role of Tradition in “The Lottery” Throughout time, tradition has played a key role in all culture’s lives. They shape the way a culture lives and interacts with the world around them. Traditions bring one another together and it is a time to enjoy each other’s presence.
Education Essay Research Paper The Georgia Lottery
Education Essay, Research Paper The Georgia Lottery Corporation The Georgia Lottery was created in November 1992 by the people of Georgia to enhance education funding. The Lottery for Education Act createdthe Georgia Lottery Corporation (GLC) to oversee and operate the lottery. Rebecca Paul was hired in February 1993 as president of the GLC, andfour months later, on June 29, the Georgia Lottery was launched.
Classical Utilitarianism Essay Research Paper
“Classical Utilitarianism,” by John Rawls This short piece by Rawls makes the point that “utilitarianism does not take seriously the distinction between persons.” This is an intriguing statement and warrants discussion. Rawls view of utilitarianism is that the goal for society is the fulfillment of the maximum satisfaction of all its members.
The Lottery Essay Research Paper Slips of
The Lottery Essay, Research Paper Slips of Fate In the short story "The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson, the author uses irony to expand on a theme of traditions that continue although they are ludicrous and barbaric. "Like a lamb to slaughter" comes to mind for both the characters in this story and the reader.
Everyday Use Essay Research Paper Tradition
Everyday Use Essay, Research Paper Tradition: “Everyday Use” and “The Lottery” Essay written by Pia Adams Tradition is an important part of everyone’s life. Some people follow traditions so deeply rooted in their everyday life that they don’t even recognize them as such. Why do you cook rice a certain way? Well, that’s the way Grandma always did it.
The Irony In
‘The Lottery’ Essay, Research Paper The Irony in “The Lottery” Shirley Jackson wrote the story “The Lottery.” A lottery is typically thought of as something good because it usually involves winning something such as money or prizes. In
LAW Ceciro Plato Socrates St Thomas Essay
, Research Paper REVIEWING KEY CONCEPTS 1) Define natural and positive law. Identify the fundamental differences between the theories of natural and positive law. Give an example to illustrate each of these theories.
The Ohio Lottery And The Problems It
Produces Essay, Research Paper The Ohio Lottery and the Problems That It Produces In August 1974 the first ticket for the Buckeye 300 was sold. This was a big year for the state of Ohio. It marked the start of something that would grow into a resemblance of the garden of good and evil. Though lottery is a big moneymaker for the state, it is also a cause of a horrible addiction.