Paper
The Secret Sharer by Conrad
In the many critical articles that we have read in class on Joseph Conrad’s “The Secret Sharer” many of the authors believed that a secret that was being shared with the reader. They also believed that the secret is Leggett and the captain are sexually attracted to each other. They go on to say that since Conrad wrote the story and this relationship is in the story than Conrad must have had these feelings himself. I do not believe that these authors are correct. They seem to be bringing aspects to the story that are not apparent to me. I am not saying that their ideas are not possible but they do seem far-fetched.
Cesare Casarino wrote in his article “The sublime of the closet; or Joseph Conrad’s secret sharing.” That the secret that is shared with the reader is that the captain and Leggett are involved in a homoerotic relationship.
in scenes replete with touching, groping, mingling, and clasping, “He caught hold of my arm, but the ringing of the supper bell made me start. He didn’t though; he only released his grip” For whose glances “mingle” and whose hands meet “gropingly” and linger “united in a steady and motionless clasp” except the glances and hands of lovers? (Casarino 235)
Casarino seems to use the language of the story to make his point. He makes assumptions that since Conrad uses certain words than he must have meant to give an underlying meaning, a “secret” meaning that I do not see. I am not familiar with Conrad’s other works, but could this just be the writing style that Conrad uses? Could the writing style and words be common for the time when the “Secret Sharer” was written? These two ideas need to be considered before we start placing judgements on words. Casarino does not take these consideration into account.
James Phelan writes that the secret that the narrator is sharing with the reader is one that is covert. He goes on to say that as the story goes on the secret should be come more apparent to the reader. Mr. Phelan uses scenes to prove his point that seem odd to me. The section of the story that he uses that gives me the most problem is when the narrator sees his hat in the water. ” — yes, I was in time to catch an evanescent glimpse of my white hat left behind ” (Conrad 60) Mr. Phelan uses this section to compare the captain giving his hat to Leggett as if he had given him a ring. He than says Leggett leaving the hat behind is a way for Leggett to give the gift back as ” a powerful symbol of their unconsummated relationship ” (Phelan 138) I do not see how the hat can represent a gift between lovers. It is a gift between friends at most collaborators at least. Phelan writes about when the narrator and Leggett are in bed together they are experiencing a homoerotic moment “I would smuggle him into my bed-place, and we would whisper together ” (Conrad 49) Phelan seems to believe that since the two are whispering they must be whispering sweet nothings into each others ears. He believes that they stop at whispering because if the continued with any other expressions would be loud and alert the crew. He fails to remember that the narrator is hiding Leggett from the rest of the crew. They must remain quite otherwise they will be discovered. This seems self-evident to me. I will admit that my interpretation skills may not be as skilled as Phelan’s but I feel he may be looking at the story too critically.
Bonnie Kime Scott has some ideas that I do not agree with. In her article “Intimacies Engendered in Conrad’s “The Secret Sharer”, She says that because the captain and Leggett have been around other men without women around they are more likely to have a homosexual relationship. Kime Scott says that, “Leggett and the captain were trained at Conway, an all-male school; they have spent years on voyages, almost exclusively in the company of men.” It seems if this is true than there would have been a larger number of homosexual relationships during the time “The Secret Sharer” was written. Kime Scott uses Eve Sedgwik’s Epistemology of the Closet to show proof of the eroticism that the sea produces. In Kime Scott’s article, she quotes parts from Sedgwik’s piece that talks about Billy Budd and Portrait of Dorian Gray. I am unfamiliar with the second work but I have read Billy Budd and I do not remember the eroticism that she is trying to prove in this story. She also is saying because Conrad’s name is on a list that is compiled by Sedgwik her statement holds some kind authority. The idea that by using Sedgwik’s piece as briefly as she did weakens her article to me. She is depending on the reader of her article to accept the authority of another to prove her point.
The proof that Leggett and the narrator are involved in some kind of homosexual relationship seems to lack the evidence that many of the critics say it holds. The critics above all hold the same opinions even though the where using different theories to interpret the work. I believe that they may have latched on to an idea that was proposed by someone else and ran with it. Not that they did not have original ideas but they all relied on other articles to prove their point or to justify their views.
Другие работы по теме:
Heart Of Darkness Essay Research Paper Most
Heart Of Darkness Essay, Research Paper Most Literate people know that by going into the Heart of the Jungle, Conrad was trying to relay a message about the heart of man, and the story is worldly wide read as one of the
Hollow Men Essay Research Paper n TS
Hollow Men Essay, Research Paper n T.S. Eliot’s poem The Hollow Men, T.S. Eliot contrasts his straw-filled hollow men with the “lost violent souls” of Mr. Kurtz and Guy Fawkes. Mr. Kurtz is a
Ordinary People 2 Essay Research Paper Jay
Ordinary People 2 Essay, Research Paper Jay Lampkin Death, guilt, and forgiveness are experienced by everyone in life. In the novel Ordinary People, Judith Guest explores these episodes of life extensively through Beth,
Comparing Teenager Essay Research Paper It has
Comparing Teenager Essay, Research Paper It has been proven that the environment that one grows up with will affect that person’s life forever. People, especially, help to mold the life of another person. The novels Ordinary People, by Judith Guest, and The Catcher in the Rye, by J.D. Salinger, explore periods of time in the lives of two teenage boys who are both changing because of the people around them.
Ordinary People Essay Research Paper In the
Ordinary People Essay, Research Paper In the novel Ordinary People, by Judith Guest, many people affect Conrad. Three people that have an affect on him are his father, mother and therapist. Conrad goes through significant changes by the way he has been affected.
Ordinary People By Judith Guest Rite Of
Passage Hero Essay, Research Paper A rite of passage hero is a character who changes or matures as a result of experience. In Ordinary People by Judith Guest, Conrad is a rite of passage hero who changes as a result of his recovery journey. This novel deals with the Jarrett family and Conrad s attempted suicide/depression and his stages of recovery.
DonconstructionThe Secret Sharer Essay Research Paper DeconstructionDeconstruction
Donconstruction/The Secret Sharer Essay, Research Paper Deconstruction Deconstruction is a post-structural school of philosophy and literary criticism that was developed by French philosopher Jacques Derrida. Although he is credited with its origins, he seems to have borrowed heavily from German philosophers, Friedrich Neitzsche and Martin Heidegger, who ? radically questioned the validity of basic philosophical concepts? and Chinese philosopher, Lao Tse who embraced the harmony of opposites.
The Symbolism Of
“The Secret Sharer” By: Joseph Conrad Essay, Research Paper “The Secret Sharer” by Joseph Conrad is a story of deep mysterious thought. The main character is a young captain who becomes aware that he does not yet know his ship, or his crew, or, indeed, himself. His character is one of complicated emotion and deep inner struggle.
The Secret Sharer Essay Research Paper The
The Secret Sharer Essay, Research Paper The Secret Sharer This book has two main characters the Captain, who is the central main character, and Leggatt, the secret sharer, whom is the competitor, along with minor characters such as the first and second shipmates. The captain narrates the story, but he is telling the story years after it actually took place.
Comparison Of Two Books Essay Research Paper
When asked to create an image of Africa in one’s mind many people describe a stuningly similar vision, one which includes primative landscapes as well as a primative way of life. In the past, and even somewhat today, Africa is considered to be a location that resembles a most natural form of earth. The novels Heart of Darkness and Things Fall Apart are both novels that take place in Africa and have contrasting outlooks on a very similar senerio.
The Secret Sharer By Joseph Conrad Essay
, Research Paper A Captain s Metamorphosis In the short story The Secret Sharer by Joseph Conrad, the captain of the ship, the Colorado, changes from an insecure and inexperienced ship captain to a more confident and secure individual, due to his experiences with the Secret Sharer. At first, the captain is not sure of his place on the ship and does not feel right about being in charge.
Similarities In Joseph Conrad
’s Novels Essay, Research Paper I hereby hand over all copyrights I might have for this paper. You are free to use it for what ever purpose you see fit. Jonathan Welden
Significance Essay Research Paper Matt SantoPeriod 3March
Significance Essay, Research Paper Matt Santo Period 3 March 14,1997 Significance The significance of the title ?Ordinary People? is that it is ironic because there are not ordinary people in the book. It does not correspond with the novel itself. As defined in Webster?s Dictionary, ordinary means usual, common, or normal.
The Crusades Essay Research Paper Crusades Essay
The Crusades Essay, Research Paper Crusades Essay During the years 1095 to 1204, there was a series of campaigns led by the Christians to rid the Holy Land from the Muslims. The Holy Land was the area around Modern Day Jerusalem and Israel, which both Christians and Muslims considered to be rightfully theirs.
Symbolic Use Of Ivory In
‘Heart Of Darkness’ Essay, Research Paper In Heart of Darkness Joseph Conrad often uses vague,?muted? descriptions, leaving a melange of possible meanings in the reader?s lap. One exception to this trend is Conrad?s symbolic use of ivory. Within the frame of the story, his references to ivory can obviously be seen as a representation of the white man?s greed.
The Secret Sharer Essay Research Paper
“The Secret Sharer” The short story “The Secret Sharer” by Joseph Conrad centers around a character of a sea captain who is insecure and has great feelings of inadequacy on his fist job as Captain of a ship. In the story the Captain befriends a fugitive by the name of Legatt who is clearly shown to be a figment of the Captains imagination rather than an actual human being.
Secret Sharer Essay Research Paper The Secret
Secret Sharer Essay, Research Paper The Secret Sharer written by Joseph Conrad, centers around a character of a sea captain. Its title and opening paragraphs forecast a story of mystery, isolation, duality, darkness and silence. The novel proves true these predictions reveling thematic and image patterns directly proportional to them.
Significance Of Communication In Joseph Conrad
’s T Essay, Research Paper The Significance of Communication in The Secret AgentCommunication is a crucial point when explaining the downfall of the characters in Joseph Conrad’s The Secret Agent. Between Winnie, Stevie, and Verloc there exists little direct communication, which is instrumental to the demise of each of them.
Ordinary People Essay Research Paper There are
Ordinary People Essay, Research Paper There are many factors that contribute to strong relationships. Some of the key elements are communication, trust, and forgiveness. In Judith Guests novel, Ordinary People, there are several relationships where these elements are portrayed. They are illustrated either in a positive or negative manner, usually between several family members.
Lord Of The Flies And Heart Of
Darkness Essay, Research Paper A Comparison and Contrast of Lord of the Flies and Heart of Darkness Achebe uses positive tone in his description of the African jungle; whereas, Conrad makes use of negative connotations. Their portrayals of the jungle reflect their attitudes toward their subject; Achebe sees it as a hospitable home whereas Conrad sees a tragic trap.
Secrets Of Life Essay Research Paper There
Secrets Of Life Essay, Research Paper There is one part of my life that no one knows about. This secret has caused me to act in ways I thought I wasn’t capable of doing. For the past five years, I
A Short Essay On Conrad Black
’s Depiction Of Women Essay, Research Paper Joseph Conrad?s novella, Heart of Darkness, the representation of women is extremely limited. Conrad?s portrayals are extreme stereotypes meant to depict
Youth By Joseph Conrad Essay Research Paper
Joseph Conrad suffered from a sudden visit from reality. Before he went took a trip to the Congo, he thought he was still a youth; he had an adolescent mindset of invincibility. However, in the Congo, Conrad realized, Hey, I m old. He became self-conscious. From then on, Conrad viewed life with an incredible sense of indifferent pessimism.
Wag The Dog Essay Research Paper Wag
Wag The Dog Essay, Research Paper Wag The Dog The movie starts with the President hit with the claim he had sexual relations with a firefly girl during a tour of the white house, and all this happens two weeks before the election. I m not sure if this movie was actually based upon the Lewinsky scandal that our current president is facing, but it seems this movie came at the right time.
Ordinary People 2 Essay Research Paper The
Ordinary People 2 Essay, Research Paper The book Ordinary People explains the troubles that occur in a typical American family. The family, the Jarrets, tries to maintain as much as a normal life as possible without a dysfunctional status. In the beginning of the story, the family deals with minor problems that had little impact to them.
Ordinary People Essay Research Paper Book Review
Ordinary People Essay, Research Paper Book Review of Ordinary People Ordinary People, by Judith Guest, is a novel about the difficulties and problems that occur in a seemingly normal family after the death of one of it?s members. The main character, Conrad, witnesses his brother, Buck, drown. After this tragic happening, Conrad attempts suicide by slashing his wrists.
Youth
– Then & Now Essay, Research Paper Youth : Then & Now The spirit of youth has changed dramatically since the days of Joseph Conrad and his story, “Youth.” Conrad strongly emphasises the
Heart Of Darkness Essay Research Paper 1
Heart Of Darkness Essay, Research Paper 1. Does Conrad really “otherize,” or impose racist ideology upon, the Africans in Heart of Darkness, or does Achebe merely see Conrad from the point of view of an African? Is it merely a matter of view point, or does there exist greater underlying meaning in the definition of racism?
Ordinary People Essay Essay Research Paper Ordinary
Ordinary People Essay Essay, Research Paper Ordinary People Essay By: Melissa In the novel, Ordinary People, written by Judith Guest, Calvin Jarrett is better off as an individual. During the novel, Cal makes very drastic changes, in his own time. One of them is in chapter 17, when he and Conrad are cleaning out the garage and he asks him about Dr.