, Research Paper
The short story, “Rocking-Horse Winner”, and the movie based on it contrast considerably. When the written story has ended the movie continues with ideas, which may not come from the author. Three major differences of the two are: the mother, the father, and the ending. In the movie the mother, Hester, is portrayed as a loving and self-sacrificing person. While in the short story she is exposed to be a cold-hearted, and greedy person. Another instance where the short story and movie differ is the role of the father.
In the beginning of the written story the author reveals Hester to be a cold-hearted mother. “She had bonny children, yet she felt they had been thrust upon her, and she could not love them”(75). In public she is thought of as the perfect mother, but in private she and her children know her true feelings. “Everyone else said of her: ‘She is such a good mother. She adores her children.’ Only she herself, and her children themselves, knew it was not so. They read it in each other’s eyes”(75). Hester resents her children and her husband. She blames all of her bad “luck” on the fact that she is married to an unlucky man. “And aren’t you lucky either, mother? I can’t be if I married an unlucky husband. But by yourself, aren’t you? I used to think I was, before I married. Now I think I am very unlucky indeed”(77). In the written story Hester also appears to be greedy. When Paul arranges for her to receive one thousand pounds a year for five years, Hester wants it all at once. “He said Paul’s mother had had a long interview with the lawyer, asking if the whole five thousand could not be advanced at once, as she was in debt”(83).
In the movie “Rocking-Horse Winner” Hester is depicted as a loving and self-sacrificing mother. When the Uncle Oscar refuses to give the mother any more money, she takes her favorite garments to a local tailor. She then proceeds to sell them and a suitcase for an unfair price. In the movie Hester is very concerned when Paul’s brain starts swelling. She tries to convince him to go away to the country, however he persuades her to let him stay until after the derby. When Paul goes into the coma-like state his mother sits at his bedside and cries when he dies. After Paul dies Hester wants nothing to do with the money, she even tells Bassett to burn it. The heartless Hester in the written story never shed a tear when Paul died.
Another major difference between the written story and the movie is the character of the father. In the short story the author only mentions him briefly. “The father went to town to some office. But though he had good prospects, these prospects never materialized”(76). Hester talks about her husband being unlucky frequently, but the husband is never present. Yet in the movie the father plays a moderately significant character. Throughout the movie he is included in the dialogue. He even stands up to Hester a couple of times. Everyday the father goes to work while trying to find a better job. Everyday when he gets home she asks if he had any luck finding a better job. When he reply’s that he didn’t have any luck, she belittles the job he does have. When the father loses the job he does have Hester and Uncle Oscar both scold him.
The most important difference between the movie and the written story is when the written story ends the movie continues with ideas, which may not come from the author. The movie continues to show the viewer Hester’s reaction to Paul’s death. When Paul dies she orders Bassett to take the rocking horse out of the house and burn it. When Bassett asks her what she would like him to do with the money her reply is “Burn it.” Hester exclaims, “I just want to see the end of it!” To which Bassett replies “You will never see the end of it.”
These three differences are only the major differences. Throughout the movie and written story there are numerous less significant discrepancies. The author’s version is acted out in the reader’s mind, while the movie must rely on music, setting, and ability of the actors to clearly layout the plot.
34e
Другие работы по теме:
May SwensonS
“Women” Essay, Research Paper In May Swenson?s poem, Women, the imagery and structure work very well with the content of the poem. Swenson writes a poem about women and what they should be. At first glance, the image of the poem could be a play on women and their curves. However, once the reader examines the content of the poem, it is clear that Swenson is using the image of the poem to play on what women should be, or perhaps what they are perceived to be.
The Rocking Hrose Winner Essay Research Paper
The Rocking Horse Winner When a person is lucky, it does not have to mean that they are fortunate with money. Luck is the chance for things to go the way you want them to go with out having any control over the situation. In The Rocking Horse Winner, Hester, the mother seems to believe that luck is strictly having money, and when there is no money, there is no luck.
The Autobiography Of Miss Jane Pittman Essay
, Research Paper In the novel The Autobiography Of Miss Jane Pittman, there were many different stories about JanePittman’s life. In the movie there were not as many stories as the novel, but they were still quite
Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon Essay Research Paper
Response Paper I have been a fan of martial arts movies since the late Bruce Lee so I figured Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon, even though it was the winner of four academy awards, would just be another attempt to make a poor example of a kung fu movie that lacked culture and poor acting. Acting, scenery, choreography, and story line made this an incredibly good movie.
Movie Arsenic And Old Lace Essay Research
Paper Movie: Arsenic and Old Lace The movie Arsenic & Old Lace is based on the play about a movie critique who’s two aunts , choose to put lonely men out of there reason by
Coping With Reality Essay Research Paper Man
Coping With Reality Essay, Research Paper Man s Inability to Cope with Reality Like many pieces of art, it is difficult to interpret and analyze short stories. The plot and theme in short stories are often undeveloped and not very detailed, therefore the true meaning of the story can easily go unnoticed by the reader.
Comparision And Contrast Between The Rocking Horse
Winner And The Road Not Taken Essay, Research Paper J. Mathis 2 The Comparison and Contrast of “The Destructors” and “The Rocking Horse Winner” Life’s stories shared through the view of two writers. Both stories have many
The Storm And The Rocking Horse Winner
Essay, Research Paper As a general rule, children love fairy tales. We grow up being read Grimm’s or watching Disney remakes of classics. Parents love telling children fairy tales not only because they have an opportunity to spend time with their sons and daughters, but also because fairy tales, like fables, always contain a lesson or moral within them.
Analysis Of Two Related Works By Chekov
Essay, Research Paper Dr. Mangum March 3, 1997 A Comparison of the Magic in “The Rocking-Horse Winner” and “A Very Old Man With Enormous Wings” Magic arises out of the two main characters of D.H. Lawrence’s “The Rocking-Horse Winner” and Gabriel Garcia Marquez. Paul, in the first story, pulls out higher forces to help him decide who the winner of the next horse race will be.
The RockingHorse Winner Essay Research Paper Many
The Rocking-Horse Winner Essay, Research Paper Many essential steps must be implemented when taking a written story and turning it into a real life motion picture. D.H Lawrence, author of the short story ?The Rocking-Horse Winner? depicts a common demon we all face; greed, society?s need for more possessions and money often drives people to do drastic things.
Compare And Contrast Essay Of An Occurrence
At Owl Creek Bridge Essay, Research Paper The same story all with the same plot, same characters, and in the end the exact same sorrowful outcome. Both the book and the film are about the same story called An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge, but somehow it seems like you get a much better picture and realization of the story and what is going on if you read it on paper opposed to film.
Compare And Contrast Once Upon A Time
And The Rocking Horse Winner Essay, Research Paper “Compare and Contrast “Once Upon a Time” and “The Rocking Horse Winner” There are similarities and differences between Nadine Gordimer’s “Once Upon a Time” and D. H. Lawrence’s “The Rocking Horse Winner.” Both works take the reader on an emotional journey that deliver a social message with an impact.
Boys And Girls Comparative Ess Essay Research
Paper The movie remake of Alice Munro s short story Boys and Girls fails to represent the author s intention; in comparison to the short story. The movie eliminates crucial events, which enables the audience to have impression of what the girl is feeling and show sympathy for her. As a result of eliminating the scene in which the horse is getting killed; the audience is unaware of how the girl copes and is affected by the situation.
Character Of Hester In Lawrence
’s “The Rocking-Horse Winner” Essay, Research Paper Brandace Barker English IV Ms. Barrera 22 May 2000 The Character of Hester in Lawrence’s “The Rocking-Horse Winner”
The Search For Love In The Rocking
Horse Winner Essay, Research Paper The Search for Love in “The Rocking Horse Winner” “There was a woman who was beautiful, who started with all the advantages, but she had no luck” (873). Both of the main characters in ” The Rocking Horse Winner”, Hester and Paul, are in pursuit of love. First the mother, Hester, “married for love, and the love turned to dust”, she gained children from her marriage but, ” she could not love them” (873).
Rocking Horse Winner 2 Essay Research Paper
The Hidden Truth The plot in “The Rocking-Horse Winner” by D. H. Lawrence reveals to the reader conflicts between Paul and his mother using different levels or forms of secrecy. There are secrets hidden throughout the house that leads Paul and his mother to an unpleasant life. The first level of secrecy is the actual secrets that Paul and Paul’s mother keep from each other.
The Rocking Horse Winner Essay Research Paper
The Rocking Horse Winner Lucky. That?s what this whole story is about, being lucky. It seemed that to be successful in this society you had to have a certain amount of luck about you to be able to make money to survive. Paul seemed to be the first to realize it when he asked his mother “why don?t we keep a car of our own? Why do we always use Uncle?s, or else a taxi?” When she replied that it was because they were poor he asked why and she said “Because your father has no luck.”
Symbolism In The Rocking Horse Winner Essay
, Research Paper D. H. Lawrence’s “The Rocking-Horse Winner” is a short story that widely uses many techniques in which elaborate on the importance of many topics discussed. The character foils, which add to Paul’s character, give a sense of the boy’s growing need to gamble and become lucky. The whispering house is a main symbol in the plot that leads to the outcome of the story and the main force that drives the young boy to find a winner.
Rocking Horse Winner Essay Research Paper The
Rocking Horse Winner Essay, Research Paper The Rocking-Horse Winner The main themes in ? The Rocking-Horse Winner? are the pursuit of love and luck. Both of the main characters in ” The Rocking-Horse Winner”, Hester and Paul, are in pursuit of love. First the mother, Hester married for love, and the love faded, she gained children from her marriage, but she could not love them.
The Old Red Rocking Horse Essay Research
Paper The Old Red Rocking Horse Gifts that have sentimental value are worth more than diamonds. As I sit here looking at my old wooden rocking horse that my grandmother made so lovingly for me as a child, I see that it looks worn and the shine of the new paint is no more. The red saddle does not sparkle like it once did, and the white paint is starting to chip off, leaving the bare wood showing through.
Analysis Of A Short Story Essay Research
Paper ANALYSIS OF A SHORT STORY The Rocking-Horse Winner by D.H Lawrence is a reflection of society s materialism, the search for material happiness leaving on the side the real matter of life. People are looking for happiness in the wrong place.
Comparison Of Paul
’s Case, The Rocling Horse Winner And The Secret Life Of Walter Mitty Essay, Research Paper In the short stories, “Paul’s Case,” “The Rocking-Horse Winner,” “The Secret Life of Walter Mitty,” and “Mr. Reginald Peacocks Day,” the main character has their own form of illusion. These characters try to escape from everyday reality by living in their own fantasy.
BookMovie Comparison Hamlet Essay Research Paper Usually
Book-Movie Comparison Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Usually, when a movie is made about a story in a book or a play, the two stories are not exactly the same. The movie tends to add small details or leave some out in order to meet time limits and to make the story what they think will be more interesting. Such is the case with Shakespeare s Hamlet.
In A Groove Essay Research Paper The
In A Groove Essay, Research Paper The short story “In a Grove” by Ryunosuke Akutagawa was made into a movie called Rashomon. The movie and the short story share both similarities and differences.
Rashomon Commentary Essay Research Paper Rashomon CommentaryIn
Rashomon Commentary Essay, Research Paper Rashomon Commentary In Ryunosuke Akutagawa’s short stories In A Grove and Rashomon, an epic conflict of appearance vs. reality is reinforced by the world-renowned movie “Rashomon”. Although the stories and the movies use different symbolism and have many distinct differences, they both support this theme.
Irony In The Rocking Horse Winner Essay
, Research Paper Rocking Horse Irony “The Rocking-Horse Winner” by D.H. Lawrence is a story about a boy named Paul who lives with parents that lack love and are filled with greed. Tormented by a house that whispers to him, Paul dies trying to convince his mother that he is lucky by picking horse race winners while he rides a rocking horse.
Movie The Fan Essay Research Paper Movie
Movie: The Fan Essay, Research Paper Movie: The Fan An extraordinary film that every movie ?guru’ should see is The Fan. Putting this picture on a pedestal would be the right thing to do. My counter-
Ivanhoe Essay Research Paper Sean Pendergast
Ivanhoe Essay, Research Paper Sean Pendergast The story of Ivanhoe takes place during the Middle Ages in England with the year being 1194 A.D. It is about the adventures Ivanhoe encounters upon returning from the crusades with his friend and king, King Richard the Lion Heart. Ivanhoe has been disowned by his father because of this, and is forbidden to marry his true love, Lady Rowena.
The Clash Of The Titans Essay Research
Paper The movie “The Clash of the Titans” was very good because it was a fantasy-adventure based on Greek mythology and Greek history. Perseus, the son of Zeus, must face a variety of awesome challenges in pursuit of his destiny. It is a long and episodic movie with fine elements that focuses its story on ancient mythology.