&Johnson Essay, Research Paper
The Federalist Papers were written by Alexander Hamilton, James Madison, and John Jay in order to garner support for the soon to be Constitution of the United States. In 65, Hamilton discusses the powers of the senate in relation to the impeachment process. The Senate is designated as sufficiently dignified and sufficiently independent since it is able to remain unawed and uninfluenced , and therefore, able to preserve the impartiality between accused and accuser/s. Yet in the impeachment trials of both Presidents Johnson and Clinton, the Senate proved to be anything but uninfluenced as politics came into play during both cases.
During his reintegration of the South into the union, Johnson made enemies of an influential faction in the Republican Party, the Radicals. They believed that their goals could only be achieved once the president had been removed from office. Many other Republicans had been offended with his leniency towards the former Confederate States, forcing them to cooperate with the Radicals, yet impeachment seemed to drastic a measure. Two attempts of impeachment were made, but they resulted in failure. The action of President Johnson that led directly to his impeachment was his deliberate violation of the Tenure of Office Act. The Tenure of Office Act expanded the power to advise and consent” by giving the Senate the right to accept or to reject the dismissal of presidential appointees. Under this law, the president could not remove incumbents in the executive branch while the Senate was in session without a majority vote in favor of the action. When the Senate was not in session, the president could suspend an official and appoint a temporary replacement that would remain until the Senate returned and confirmed it. The president had vetoed the act, but the Republican majority in Congress overrode the veto. Believing that the act was unconstitutional, Johnson discharged Stanton on February 21, 1868, intentionally defying Congress. Eleven articles of impeachment were drafted only after the impeachment vote in the House. The articles dealt with his violation of the Tenure of Office and related events. Former Supreme Court Justice Benjamin Robbins Curtis, representing the President, emphasized that Andrew Johnson had been within his rights under the Constitution in firing Stanton and questioned whether Stanton was even covered under the statute. Also, Johnson, as any other man in the United States, had the right to disobey any law set forth if he believed it to be unconstitutional. However, if such was the case, the trial should have been brought to the Supreme Court rather than the Senate. The basic implication of Curtis was that Johnson could not be removed because he had not committed a crime. Radicals in the Senate countered that even if Johnson had not committed criminal acts he could still be removed for political reasons. According to Alan Hirsch in his Guide to Impeachment:
The fact that the House also voted to impeach Johnson for hostile remarks reveals the political nature of their effort to oust him — to punish the President for criticizing Congress is a violation of the First Amendment’s protection of free speech, not a legitimate use of the impeachment process.
On May 16, 1868, the Senate began voting on the eleven articles of impeachment. Thirty-five Senators voted to convict. Thus, Johnson failed to be removed by one vote, thirty-six votes–a two-thirds majority–being needed to convict. Twelve Democrats and seven Republicans voted for acquittal. Enough Senate Republicans had pledged they would vote to acquit if necessary to prevent the two-thirds majority necessary for conviction because they feared that removing a president over what was essentially a policy disagreement would set a dangerous precedent for the future. (Donald Shafffer) The Tenure of Office Act would later be repealed in 1887 and ruled unconstitutional in 1926 by the Supreme Court.
President Clinton, as the first elected official to be impeached, was charged in two Articles with: 1) Perjury and false and misleading testimony and statements under oath before a federal grand jury (Article I), and 2) engaging in a course of conduct or scheme to delay and obstruct justice (Article III). In response, President Clinton s defense gave the following rebuttal:
The charges in the two Articles of Impeachment do not permit the conviction and removal from office of a duly elected President. The President has acknowledged conduct with Ms. Lewinsky that was improper. But Article II, Section 4 of the Constitution provides that the President shall be removed from office only upon Impeachment for, and Conviction of, Treason, Bribery or other high Crimes and Misdemeanors. The charges in the articles do not rise to the level of high Crimes and Misdemeanors as contemplated by the Founding Fathers, and they do not satisfy the rigorous constitutional standard applied throughout our Nation s history. Accordingly, the Articles of Impeachment should be dismissed.
Arguments arose on whether the issue was a moral issue rather than impeachable one and whether public figures were entitled to private lives. To many, there had never been a true case against Clinton due to lack of evidence that his actions proved to be a threat to national security. Unlike Andrew Johnson, Bill Clinton had public support even after the scandal had been made public. In addition, the American people twice elected Clinton. For a majority in Congress to remove him from office in the absence of persuasive evidence that his actions have damaged the body politic would do far more harm to American democracy than Clinton’s own sordid deeds. (Eric Foner) The American publics, as well as the Senators themselves, were like kids waiting in class for the bell to ring, with both sides tiring of the scandal. (Time 2/18/99) In the end, Clinton was acquitted on both accounts due to lack of a 2/3 vote with a vote guilty to not guilty of 45 to 55 with Article I and a 50 to 50 vote over Article II. In an interview with CBS s Dan Rather (April 1999), Clinton stated the following:
Those that did not agree with what I had done and were furious that it had worked and that the country was doing well, and attempted to use what should have been a constitutional and legal process for political ends, did not prevail That’s the way I saw it….
Not everyone was satisfied with the outcome of the case, though. According to Judicial Watch Chairman Larry Klayman, By limiting impeachment to the Lewinsky affair, the house judiciary committee doomed the quest for justice Ignoring concrete evidence of bribery, likely treason and obstruction of justice in the Chinagate scandal. However, whether that specific case or others will be investigated is open to question.
Thus, both presidents were acquitted for the crimes that they were accused of due to reasons justified in the Constitution. Yet, was impeachment necessary in both cases? By today s standards, Johnson would never have been impeached because what would b thought of as an impeachable offense in the past may not be so anymore in today s times. Political motives were clearly present in both the trials of Johnson and Clinton. However, in Clinton s case, politics has been brought to a new level with various issues, such as morality, coming into play. Party lines were dissolved during his trial as well as loyalties lay not within the parties, but in the color green, which was certainly plentiful during the economic prosperity during Clinton s time. Although the American public may not agree with the decision in Clinton s case, the point of the matter is that the foundation that our Founding fathers created still functions. Whether it is as they envisioned it is another question.
Другие работы по теме:
A New Leader Essay Research Paper A
A New Leader Essay, Research Paper A New Leader I voted Al Gore for president because he has been under our current president Bill Clinton for eight years. Clinton has done an extemely suberb job in office
Aquittals Essay Research Paper The AcquittalsAbuse of
Aquittals Essay, Research Paper The Acquittals Abuse of power has never been welcomed by society. Whether it is in the home, on the job, in our schools or in our government, society subjects these abuses of power to investigation and prosecution. The penalties can be a dismissal from their position, court marshal or impeachment for the president.
Impeachment And Society Essay Research Paper The
Impeachment And Society Essay, Research Paper The abuse of power has never been welcomed by society, whether it is in the workplace or in the government. One who misuses their privileges is subject to immediate investigation and eventually prosecution. For some government officials, the result can be a dismissal from their position, for the President, however, it is known as impeachment.
James Dean Essay Research Paper James DeanEven
James Dean Essay, Research Paper James Dean Even With Curie, Jordan, and Lewinsky….None of them were a Dean There are many parallels that can be drawn between the impeachment of Richard Nixon and Bill Clinton. Both involved the obstruction of justice and lying outright to the American public. But one thing that was omitted from the Clinton trial was a key f
Gerald Ford And Albert Gore A Comparison
And Contrast Essay, Research Paper Gerald Ford (1974-77) and Albert Gore A Comparison and Contrast of the United States Presidency Gerald Ford and Albert Gore: A Comparison and Contrast of the United States Presidency
Monogamy In The Presidency Essay Research Paper
In January of 1998, President William Clinton; forty third president of the United States, was publicly accused of monogamy while in the office of presidency. The accusations were made by a female Whitehouse Intern named Monica Lewinsky. Lewinsky, whom was a Whitehouse Intern, claims to have had sex with President Clinton in the Oval Office of the Whitehouse.
Bill Clinton Essay Research Paper
Many presidents of the United States have been accused of having an affair. Most of these accusations can not be proven. The presidents usually get off the hook and nothing else is said about the affair ever again. In Bill Clinton?s case it is very different. He was accused of having an affair with Monica Lewinsky.
Is President Bill Clinton A Tragic Character
Essay, Research Paper Is President Bill Clinton a Tragic character? A tragic character is someone who is basically good, strong, intelligent, and not a martyr. A tragic character must have good fortune and be successful. A tragic character must also possess a tragic flaw, which in an attribute that would lead to a downfall.
The Law Behind Impeachment Essay Research Paper
The framers of the Constitution had numerous discussions leading up to the ratification of the Constitution. Some of the discussions centered on the Executive branch of the government, while others were about impeachment. Their discussions determined what powers and limitations the executive branch was to operate under, and what to do when the power of the office was abused.
Opinion On Impeachment Hearings Essay Research Paper
mpeachment is a serious offense. It is not a slap on the hand, nor is it a humble form of discipline. Impeachment is the most severe form of punishment a president can receive. To date, only two presidents have been impeached. Andrew Johnson (he was later aquitted by the Senate) and William Jefferson Clinton.
Impeachment Essay Research Paper Impeachment EditorialAs a
Impeachment Essay, Research Paper Impeachment Editorial As a Senator, issues concerning many topics important to our country s well being are brought about, but nothing as important as impeachment. Two presidents who have been tried under the grounds of impeachment are Andrew Johnson and William Clinton.
King William I Essay Research Paper King
King William I Essay, Research Paper King William I Americans these days are too spoiled. Freedom and crime are far too rampant. Whatever happened to the good old days of ruthless, bloodthirsty monarchs? Rulers who would send the citizens quivering with the mere mention of their names. Kings whose wanton cruelty and disregard for human life pleased and amused us all.
Speech To Focus On Plans To Helpchildren
, Poor Essay, Research Paper January 19, 1999 BY JUDITH HAVEMANN AND WALTER PINCUS WASHINGTON POST WASHINGTON–President Clinton will propose in his State of the Union address tonight a $1billion expansion of the federal government’s efforts to help the nation’s most disadvantagedfamilies move from welfare to work, White House officials said Monday.
Speech Analysis Essay Research Paper This is
Speech Analysis Essay, Research Paper This is the speech delivered by President Bill Clinton at the annual White House prayer breakfast on Friday, September 11, 1998, to an audience of more than 100 ministers, priests and other religious leaders. First Lady Hillary Rodham Clinton was also in attendance.
A Time To Step Down Essay Research
Paper A Time to Step Down When the President of the United States is sworn into office on his inaugural day in January, he is sworn to faithfully execute the supreme laws of the land, our constitution. We elect a new President every four years to run our nation, represent the country, and uphold the constitution of the United States.
Bill Clinton Essay Research Paper Award WinnerThe
Bill Clinton Essay, Research Paper Award Winner The most deserving person in the world to receive the Swift Silken Thread for Meaningless Achievement Award is former president William Jefferson Clinton. He was
Clintons Impeachment Essay Research Paper The Good
Clintons Impeachment Essay, Research Paper The Good, The Bad, The Impeached A fake. A liar. A cheat. Is this what should be said about the President? He has committed perjury, obstructed justice, and continues to lie to America about his actions. Bill Clinton is an embarrassment to America and should be impeached.
Clinton
– Argument Essay, Research Paper On Monday October fifth after a full day of historical debate, the House Judiciary Committee decided that there were grounds for President Bill Clinton to be impeached. The third presidential impeachment inquiry in history will be initiated due to the investigation of President Clinton’s relationship with Monica Lewinsky.
Impeachent And Andrew Johnson Essay Research Paper
There has never been a President of the United States that has been removed from office. However, there have been Presidents that have been impeached. Impeachment is when Congress and the Supreme Court exercise what the Constitution calls “Checks and Balances”. Contrary to popular belief, impeachment does not necessarily result in removal from office.
Clinton Impeachment Essay Research Paper ABOVE THE
Clinton Impeachment Essay, Research Paper ABOVE THE LAW ? As the impeachment trial draws to an end there is much controversy about weather or not President Clinton should be impeached. Many say yes and many say no. The
The Impeachment Trial Of President Clinton Essay
, Research Paper President William Jefferson Clinton is the third president in our nation’s history to face the Constitutional threat of impeachment and only the second president to ever be impeached by the U.S. House of Representatives. Andrew Johnson was impeached by the House of Representatives in 1868 for violating the Tenure of Office Act of 1867 when he tried to oust the Secretary of War, Edwin M.
Was Bill Clinton A Good President Essay
, Research Paper Was William Jefferson Clinton a good president? In my opinion, Bill Clinton was not a good president. I am not saying he was the worst one we have ever had, but he did a lot of things to give himself a bad name to the citizens of the United States of America.
Iraqi And Kuwait
– 1990′S Essay, Research Paper When Iraqi forces invaded and occupied Kuwait. The conflict reached its highest point in January and February of 1991 between Iraq and an international combination of forces led by the United States.
Impeachment Essay Research Paper Impeachment A long
Impeachment Essay, Research Paper Impeachment: A long process It is the ultimate punishment for a president: impeachment. But it is a long and complicated route to removing a political official from office and never in more than 200 years of U.S. history has it happened to a president for “treason, bribery or other high crimes and misdemeanors,” as spelled out in the U.S.
Compromise Of 1850 Essay Research Paper Clinton
Compromise Of 1850 Essay, Research Paper Clinton Jolts Canadians With a Plea On Federalism In Ottawa, Canadians on both sides of the nation’s deep linguistic divide say they were stunned by President Clinton’s unexpectedly passionate appeal for national unity and federalism.
Tyranny Essay Research Paper Tyranny At its
Tyranny Essay, Research Paper Tyranny At its birth, the United State’s most pressing concern was to piece together a constitution to secure their floundering liberties and unite the states under a common rule of justice for all. From the Constitution’s elaborate system of checks and balances, one gets the sense the framers seemed very apprehensive about people and their politicians possibly using the government’s power tyrannically.
Trouble With Bill Clinton
’s Character Essay, Research Paper Trouble With Bill Clinton’s Character In the article, “The Trouble With Character” from Time magazine , writer Richard Stengel describes Bob Dole’s attacks on President Bill Clinton’s
Reaction To The Media Coverage On Clintions
Impeachment Essay, Research Paper “I want to say one thing to the American people. I want you to listen to me. I did not have sexual relations with that woman, Miss Lewinsky.
Impeached Essay Research Paper ImpeachedTo be President
Impeached Essay, Research Paper Impeached To be President in the United States the Constitution clarifies that a person must be a natural-born citizen at least thirty-five years of age and a resident of the United States for fourteen years. But right before he steps into office and enters its execution, he takes and swears the following oath or affirmation. “I do solemnly swear (or affirm), that I will faithfully execute the office of President of the United States, and will, to the best of my ability, preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States.” (Article II, Section 1) So, what does that mean to you? Well that you can trust this man to be in charge of the country you live and raise your family in.
Clinton Essay Research Paper WintersCarolyne WattsEnglish 11220
Clinton Essay, Research Paper Winters Carolyne Watts English 112 20 July 2000 ?The Clinton Impeachment Trial? President William Jefferson Clinton is the third president in our nation?s history to face the Constitutional threat of impeachment and only the second president to ever be impeached by the United States House of Representatives.
Bill Clinton Essay Research Paper Bill ClintonWilliam
Bill Clinton Essay, Research Paper Bill Clinton William Jefferson Blythe IV was born on Aug. 19, 1946, in Hope, Arkansas. His father, who was an automobile-parts salesman, died in an automobile accident three months before Bill was born. When Bill was 2 years old his mother, Virginia Cassidy, went to nursing school in New Orleans, La.
Bill Clinton Vs Paula Jones Essay Research
Paper A lawsuit has been filed by Paula Jones, a clerk for the Arkansas Industrial Development Commission, for sexual harassment by then Governor Clinton. In her lawsuit, Paula Jones states that Clinton told an Arkansas State trooper to escort her to a private hotel room where she claims that she was sexually harassed.
The Scarlet Letter 3 Essay Research Paper
The society in which we live in today has evolved a great deal since the seventeenth century. One of the most evident changes was the moralistic attitude towards sins, crimes, and the like. The definition of evil has metamorphasized since the era of Hester Prynne.