’s Home Essay, Research Paper
‘SOLDIER’S HOME’: ANOTHER STORY OF A BROKEN HEART
He knew he could never get through it all again.
“Soldier’s Home”
“I don’t want to go through that hell again.”
In the works of Ernest Hemingway, that which is excluded is often as significant as that which is included; a hint is often as important and thought-provoking as an explicit statement. This is why we read and reread him. “Soldier’s Home”is a prime example of this art of echo and indirection.
Harold Krebs, the protagonist of “Soldier’s Home,” is a young veteran portrayed as suffering from an inability to readjust to society–Paul Smith has summarized previous critics on the subject of how Krebs suffers from returning to the familial, social, and religious”home”(71). Moreover, as Robert Paul Lamb notes, the story is also about “a conflicted mother-son relationship”(29). Krebs’ small-town mother cannot comprehend her son’s struggles and sufferings caused by the war. She devotes herself to her religion and never questions her own values; she manipulates her son. She is one of the Hemingway “bitch mothers” who also appear in “The Doctor and the Doctor’s Wife”and “Now I Lay Me.” Her sermons to her son lack any power to heal his spiritual wounds. She has determined that Krebs should live in God’s “Kingdom,” find a job, and get married like a normal local boy .
Although Hemingway locates the story in Oklahoma and excludes it from the Nick Adams group, the husband and wife relationship observed in”Soldier’s Home”is also similar to those in “The Doctor and the Doctor’s Wife” and “Now I Lay Me,” revealing the mother’s dominance of a troubled marriage. Krebs’ noncommittal father is obviously dominated by his wife; she makes the decisions. Her advocacy of marriage for Krebs is ironic: not yet recovered from his various psychic wounds and trapped by the sick marriage of his parents, marriage is the very commitment he must avoid.
Furthermore, a careful reading of “Soldier’s Home” reveals yet another story discernible beneath the main one. Krebs’ indifference towards the girls in the town seems to reflect his disillusionment not only with the war and his parents’ marriage, but also with another experience–Krebs’ breaking up with a lover:
Now he would have liked a girl if she had come to him and not wanted to talk. But here at home it was all too complicated. He knew he could never get through it all again. (147-48)
Here is a significant ambiguity: “it all” may well connote the whole process of being and ceasing to be a lover, and “again” suggests that Krebs has been through this process before.
Descriptions of Krebs’ lack of involvement with the local girls occupy one fourth of the story. These descriptions converge around the word “complicated,” repeated four times in this context. The girls live in “a complicated world” (148); “They were too complicated” (148); “it [to talk to a girl] is too complicated” (149); and “He had tried so to keep his life from being complicated”(152). The latter quotation suggests that the most difficult problem is not the complicated realm of the girls, but Krebs’ fear of the complexity that might result from any approach he might make. Once he talks to a girl, he must get through a complicated sexual encounter all over again. Conversations, for Krebs, make the male/female sexual relationship complicated.
His aversion to such relationships, we are to infer, derives from previous experiences with women that have perhaps reinforced his observations of his parents’ marriage. As many have noted (see Smith 71-72), one of the photographs discussed in the story’s opening paragraphs suggests an unsatisfactory experience with German girls. Krebs and another corporal, both in poorly fitting uniforms, stand with two German girls Who are “not beautiful”beside a Rhine that “does not show in the picture”(145).[1] The picture suggests an irony: the American soldiers, once enemies, date German girls with whom they share no common language. Because the American soldiers do not have to talk, and because the German girls are probably prostitutes, relationships between them are uncomplicated. Without any need for conversation, the soldiers simply satisfy their lust on the prostitutes’ bodies. Just as he emphasizes the German girls’ lack of beauty, Hemingway also erases the Rhine to show the lack of romance in such relationships. In “Soldier’s Home,” he juxtaposes two worlds: the simple one Krebs shared with the German girls, and the potentially complicated realm of the hometown girls.
Both the physical distance between Krebs and the girls and his role as onlooker give him a sense of security. While Krebs remains in a safety zone “on the front porch,” he is protected. The girls walk “on the other side of the street”; nothing can touch him (147-48). Like sophisticated Brett Ashley, these small-town Oklahoma girls celebrate a new era with short skirts and short hair. Krebs admires them, yet he protects himself from the danger of sexual involvement as if he were still suffering from a previous affair. He has to control himself. Only as an onlooker can he avoid the “complicated world”:
But they [the girls] lived in such a complicated world of already defined alliances and shifting feuds that Krebs did not feel the energy or courage to break into it.(147)
Ironically, Hemingway uses the terms “alliances” and “feuds,” words appropriate to conflicts between nations and families, to describe the girls’ complicated world. Moreover, he uses related terms to describe Krebs’ feelings towards that world: “He did not want to get into the intrigue and the politics” (147). By emphasizing discord and friction, such terms suggest a conflict already experienced by Krebs, a conflict further revealed as follows:
He did not want any consequences. He did not want any consequences ever again. He wanted to live along without consequences. Besides he did not really need a girl. (147)
The repetition of “consequences” sounds too portentous for the previous problem to have been a merely casual love affair.
The discontinuity between Krebs’ prewar and postwar periods is obvious. Through the experience of battle, he seems to have lost his belief in God and the Kingdom which his mother claims. Krebs is isolated, having lost all feeling of belonging or togetherness. But he is attracted by the girls’ “patterns” which represent their identification with a group, an identification he once shared. Perhaps his is a bitter and only half-realized nostalgia.
Here is a veteran, a possibly heartbroken young man, who keeps himself away from the complex world, stays on the porches, and simply watches girls on the street. However, Krebs makes an exception for his young sister Helen. She is accepted in his realm. She extracts his pledge to be her “beau”(150). On a superficial level, she seems to be just another girl attempting to pull him into a complex world; however, in her innocence she intends no such thing. An incestuous relationship between brother and sister is suggested in Hemingway’s later, posthumously published work “The Last Good Country” and its related manuscripts . But here, in “Soldier’s Home,” there is no hint of incest.
The brother-sister relationship remains a simple form of love in “Soldier’s Home.”The young sister’s love for her brother is a mixture of respect and innocent affection. Her regard and love have a healing effect on Krebs. Although she is as talkative as her mother, Helen’s invitation is to a simple world. Moreover, Krebs, who has yet to exchange a word with the girls in the town, enjoys talking with his sister because there is no danger of being trapped in the complex man-woman world. Krebs simply accepts her invitation, and goes to the schoolyard to see her pitch, as proof of their mutual love.
Thus, “Soldier’s Home” is a sophisticated story of a variously wounded veteran’s return home. it is a more refined and distanced treatment of Hemingway’s own experiences during and after the war.
Другие работы по теме:
The Alamo Essay Research Paper I shall
The Alamo Essay, Research Paper I shall never surrender or retreat … I Am determined to sustain myself as long as possible and die like a soldier who never forgets what it is due to his honor and that of his country-VICTORY OR DEATH.” This was a letter sent by William Barret Travis during the siege of the Alamo on February 24, 1836.
Archemides Essay Research Paper Archemides
Archemides Essay, Research Paper Archemides Archimedis was born in 287 BC. We also know that Archimedes died in 212 BC at the age of 75 in Syracuse. It is said that a Roman soldier, who was offended by Achimedes, while the Romans seized Syracuse, killed him. Archimedes had a wide variety of interests, which included encompassing, statistics, hydrostatics, optics, astronomy, engineering, geometry, and arithmetic.
MacBeth Essay Research Paper The play
MacBeth Essay, Research Paper The play “MacBeth” written by profound author and playwright William Shakespeare is a story of good, evil, power, and envy. MacBeth ,who is the main character of this play, is a courageous, brave, ruthless, and sometimes asinine soldier who also carries the title of Thane of Glamis.
Archimedes Of Syracuse Essay Research Paper Archimedes
Archimedes Of Syracuse Essay, Research Paper Archimedes of Syracuse (ca. 287-ca. 212 BC) Greek mathematician who flourished in Sicily. He is generally considered to be the greatest mathematician of ancient times. Most of the facts about his life come from a biography about the Roman soldier Marcellus written by the Roman biographer Plutarch.
An Occurrance At Owl Creek Bridge Essay
, Research Paper Peyton Farquhar, a confederate civilian, lives in South Alabama. He owns a plantation and is thirty-five years old. Even though he is a civilian, he is a very loyal confederate.
Reasons For Leaving Essay Research Paper Reasons
Reasons For Leaving Essay, Research Paper Reasons For Leaving Coming back to what used to be home from an extremely traumatic war scenario creates a degree of alienation for any returning soldier. It is even more difficult when the soldier is a teenager whose life away at war is his first lengthy experience away from home.
A Battle Into Adulthood Red Badge
Essay, Research Paper A Battle for Adulthood Throughout the novel The Red Badge of Courage, written by Stephen Crane, a theme is portrayed within a battle that takes place during the Civil War. It is that each person must find the courage to win his or her won battle for maturity or adulthood. A soldier, who is also the main character, Henry Fleming, exemplifies this theme.
Evolution Of A Soldier Essay Research Paper
Henry Becomes A Man In the book The Red Badge of Courage, Henry changes in many ways as a soldier. In the beginning of the story he is scared of battle and runs, yet by the end of the book he is a true soldier. Many important events shape Henry s evolution into a veteran soldier. Many of Henry s own glorified notions of war are what make him so wary and unsure of himself.
Red Badg Of Courage Essay Essay Research
Paper Henry Fleming was just a child when he entered the army. Even though his journey into manhood took a while, he finally got where he was headed . This journey included many people and things, that help Henry along the way.
Ernest Hemingway 2 Essay Research Paper A
Ernest Hemingway 2 Essay, Research Paper A person can easily recognize Ernest Hemingway s writing style by his simple sentence structure, clear dialogue, and the hopelessness of his characters. Soldier s Home , Hills Like White Elephants , and A Clean well-Lighted Place are perfect examples of three short stories that easily define his unique style.
Jump SHip To Freedom Essay Research Paper
This book was about slavery and Arabus who wanted to be free and not have to answer to his slave master Ivers who treated him like dirt. It is hard to compare Arabus
Explication Of Dulce Et Decorum Est Essay
, Research Paper Explication of “Dulce et Decorum Est” In Dulce et Decorum Est Wilfred Owen explores the harsh conditions and realities of war. The burdens of war and the overwhelming weariness faced by soldiers are described in the first ten lines of the poem. Many soldiers in World War I did not have the proper training and equipment to fight a war.
Compare And Contrast 2
Compare And Contrast: “Dead Man’s Dump” By Rosenberg And “dulce Et Decorum Est” By Owen Essay, Research Paper Compare and Contrast: “Dead Man’s Dump” by Rosenberg and “dulce et Decorum est”
The Roman Army What Made It Such
A Great Success Essay, Research Paper Many know that the Roman Empire was by far the strongest of its time, but many don t know why they were able to accomplish such feats such as conquering almost the entire western world. It is a surprise to many that their success was not due to their large army, but rather how they how they motivated their men.
The Choice Of A Life Time Essay
, Research Paper The Choice of A Life Time Imagine that you are an English citizen sleeping in your cabin, when suddenly your are awaken by a loud knock on the door. You jump out of bed, and run to the door. You look through your peek hole, and see what seems to be a tall, strong soldier. You open the door and what seemed to be a soldier announced him self as a minute man.
Johnny Got His Gun Book Report Essay
, Research Paper Dalton Trumbo’s JOHNNY GOT HIS GUN is a controversial anti-war story of a soldier who lost his arms, his legs, and most of his face in a World War I from a shell. Trumbo’s soldier is Joe Bonham who comes from a patriotic background. The boy works in a bakery, supports his mother and sisters after his father’s death, he is in love with sweet Irish girl, and enlists in the army because it’s the thing a young man did for his country.
Survival Of The Fittest Essay Research Paper
Survival of the Fittest John McMurtry, in his essay “Kill ‘Em! Crush ‘Em! Eat ‘Em Raw!” states “that body shattering is the very point of football, as killing and maiming are of war.” The main points the author makes are based on words such as “for the kill” and “casualties.” There cannot be an equal comparison between war and football because football is entertainment, but by definition, war, in its purest form, is survival.
Street Soldier Essay Research Paper Street SoldierStreet
Street Soldier Essay, Research Paper Street Soldier Street Soldier, by Joseph Marshall, is a inspiring well written book. The book is about his life and how he started the Omega Boys Club. The Omega Boys Club is a club that helps keep inter city kids off the streets. There is a connection between the author’s life and certain events in the novel.
War Essay Research Paper WarIn both Saving
War Essay, Research Paper In both Saving Private Ryan and The Thin Red Line, a recurring theme appeared to be the impact of war on the common soldier. Through a variety of different scenarios, the viewer is exposed to the daily hardships that one must endure while in battle. The soldiers are continuously walking a fine line between life and death, and their morale and tenacity does not escape unscathed.
Red Badge Of Courage And The Thin
Red Line Essay, Research Paper I recently watched The Thin Red Line. Not the new, 1998 version however; accidentally picked up the 1964 black and white picture. The story line and plot going on in the movie is very hard to understand, and I read very different from the book The Thin Red Line, but I got the main gist of it.
Summer Of My German Soldier Essay Research
Paper The novel, Summer of My German Soldier, written by Bette Greene is about a young Jewish girl, Patty, who befriends a Nazi soldier. She confides in him because of the lack of parental love in her life. The Nazi soldier shows Patty that she is a person of value and is important in the world. This is something that her parents have never told her.
Krebs In Soldier
’s Home Essay, Research Paper Krebs in Soldier’s Home In Ernest Hemingway “Soldier’s Home” there is a young man named Harold Krebs, who served in the Marines for two years during WWI. He
Alienation Essay Research Paper The term
Alienation Essay, Research Paper The term, Alienation was taken from Webster s Seventh New Collegiate Dictionary. Alienation is mental derangement by. An uncertainty or awkwardness of your surroundings. To the effects of Soldier s Home, the insecurities of how the war and the people back home perceived the events as opposed to the soldier upon their return home.
Character Projections Of Henry Fleming S Char
Essay, Research Paper Character Projections of Henry Fleming s Character in The Red Badge Of Courage In The Red Badge of Courage, written by Stephen Crane about the Civil War tells about the decisions in a young soldiers life in battle. The young soldier, Henry Fleming, is faced with the dilemma of whether or not he should run when it comes down to fighting.
Revolutionary War Essay Research Paper The Prussian
Revolutionary War Essay, Research Paper The Prussian Baron von Steuben, being a newcomer to the Revolutionary cause in America, was in a position to see many of the deficiencies in military discipline and their causes. The reasons for his unique insight may have been due to the fact that he was distanced from the revolutionary ideals in America, and as a result, was able to better observe and understand them; and ultimately use them to shape his new and successful form of discipline in the Continental Army.
The Stage Of Life Essay Research Paper
Infant: This is the stage of live that goes from the moment you are born to a certain age, when you start to go to school. During this stage of your life you develop some skills that will play the key part of your life. Like to walk, to talk, to eat, and a lot more things babies learn at home before they go to school. I don not remember most of my life during this stage if I started thinking about the past the deepest I can reach in my memories is the things that I did during my first years in school.
Open Boat Essay Research Paper Symbolism allows
Open Boat Essay, Research Paper Symbolism allows writers to suggest their ideas within a piece of literature. This is found in most types of writing. Stephen Crane expresses this in his short story, The Open Boat. Through symbolism and allegory, it is demonstrated that humans live in a universe that is unconcerned with them.
Black Man Of Civil War Essay Research
Paper One of the things that were important at war was that the Blacks proving themselves was that of the Black Man acting as a soldier in the Civil War. During the Civil War the decision to use Blacks as soldiers in the
The Red Badge Of Courage And The
Effects On People In War Essay, Research Paper Stephen Crain?s The Red Badge Of Courage shows clearly how the fear and courage soldier goes through in war. The psychology in war changes the soldiers that are in it. Psychology can also be displayed by the propaganda the government will put into the one-sided war effort.
Fear Humility And Courage In Essay Research
Paper Fear, Humility, and Courage in The Red Badge of Courage In The Red Badge of Courage Henry Fleming, the main character grows up in a small town and signs up for the army against his mother will because he dreams of being a hero. Henry enlists in the 304th Regiment of New York Volunteers. However, after Henry joins the regiment he finds that his emotions are all mixed up.
Macbeth Motif Of Blood Essay Research Paper
In William Shakespeare s Macbeth, the motif of blood plays an important factor in the framework of the theme. A motif is a methodical approach to uncover the true meaning of the play. Macbeth s tragic flaw is that he thinks he can unjustly advance to the title of king without any variation of his honest self. The blood on Macbeth s hands illustrates the guilt he must carry after plotting against King Duncan and yearning for his crown.