Make Prostitution Legal Essay, Research Paper
Prostitution Theory 101
by Yvonne Abraham with Sarah McNaught
Few things have divided feminists as much as the sex industry. Theorists
who agree on a vast swath of issues — economic equality, affirmative
action, even sexual liberation — often find themselves bitterly opposed over
pornography and prostitution.
Most 19th-century feminists opposed prostitution and considered prostitutes
to be victims of male exploitation. But just as the suffragette and
temperance movements were bound together at the turn of the century, so
too were feminist and contemporary moral objections to prostitution.
Women, the argument went, were repositories of moral virtue, and
prostitution tainted their purity: the sale of sex was, like alcohol, both cause
and symptom of the decadence into which society had sunk.
By the 1960s and ’70s, when Betty Friedan and Germaine Greer asserted
that sexual liberation was integral to women’s liberation, feminists were
reluctant to oppose prostitution on moral grounds. Traditional morality, Greer
argued, had helped to repress women sexually, had made their needs
secondary to men’s. That sexual subordination compounded women’s
economic and political subordination.
Today, some feminists see hooking as a form of sexual slavery; others, as a
route to sexual self-determination. And in between are those who see
prostitution as a form of work that, like it or not, is here to stay.
Radical feminists such as lawyer Catharine MacKinnon and
antipornography theorist Andrea Dworkin oppose sex work in any form.
They argue that it exploits women and reinforces their status as sexual
objects, undoing many of the gains women have made over the past century.
Others detect in this attitude a strain of neo-Victorianism, a condescending
belief that prostitutes don’t know what they’re doing and need somebody
with more education to protect them. Some women, these dissenters point
out, actually choose the profession.
Feminists who question the antiprostitution radicals also point out that
Dworkin and MacKinnon sometimes sound eerily like their nemeses on the
religious right. Phyllis Schlafly, a rabid family-values crusader, has even
cited Dworkin in her antipornography promotional materials. This kind of
thing has not improved the radicals’ image among feminists.
At the other extreme from Dworkin and MacKinnon are sex-radical
feminists like Susie Bright and Pat Califia. They argue that sex work can be
a good thing: a bold form of liberation for women, a way for some to take
control of their lives. The problem there, though, is that the life of a
prostitute is often more Leaving Las Vegas than Pretty Woman (see “Pop
Tarts”).
Many feminists fall somewhere in between the rad-fem and sex-radical
poles. Wendy Chapkis, professor of sociology and women’s studies at the
University of Southern Maine and the author of the Live Sex Acts: Women
Performing Erotic Labor (Routledge, 1997), is one of them. For nine years,
Chapkis studied prostitution in California and the Netherlands, as well as in
Britain and Finland, and conducted interviews with 50 sex workers. Chapkis
says she sees the profession as it is: many of her interviews confirmed much
of the ugliness that radical feminists abhor, as well as the empowerment that
sex radicals perceive.
“I don’t think prostitution is the ultimate in women’s liberation,” she says.
“But I think it’s better understood as work than as inevitably a form of
sexual violence.” What prostitutes need, she argues, is not a bunch of
goody-goodies looking down on them, but decent working conditions.
Chapkis believes prostitution should be decriminalized. Just because it can
be lousy work doesn’t mean it should be stamped out, she argues. After all,
she says, “there are lots of jobs in which women are underpaid,
underappreciated, and exploited.” Criminalizing the profession just
exacerbates prostitutes’ problems by isolating them from the law and leaving
them vulnerable to abusive pimps and johns. “In a profession where women
traditionally are not treated well, aren’t empowered, and should be able to go
to the police for protection and assistance,” she says, “we make the police
an extra obstacle, another threat.”
In the Netherlands, by contrast, where prostitution is decriminalized, police
and prostitutes are on the same side: hookers speak at police academies to
educate the officers about their work, and Chapkis says the communication
pays off in safer working conditions for the women.
But what of the radical feminists’ claim that prostitution is too patriarchal to
be tolerated? Chapkis points out that many things in modern life began as
patriarchal institutions — marriage, for example. Problems within marriage,
she says, can be addressed without resorting to abolition: these days, marital
property is distributed more fairly, and abused wives have places to go for
help. Even Catharine MacKinnon has found a way to reconcile herself to
the idea of getting married. Why can’t prostitution be similarly transformed?
Still, Chapkis isn’t so naive as to see prostitution as benign. There are no
easy generalizations about sex workers’ lives, she says: “I interviewed street
prostitutes who feel powerful and in control and are making a lot of money,
and I met many high-class call girls who hate their jobs.”
Either way, Chapkis is certain that the only option is decriminalization, which
would prevent prostitutes from getting arrested. “I’m as concerned as any of
the abolitionists to deal with the problems of prostitution — violence, drug
use, poverty,” she says. “But you can’t solve those problems by further
criminalizing prostitution, driving it further underground. [That makes] it
more difficult for women to access what help there is.”
Which is where a lot of prostitutes’ organizations stand, too. Tracy Quan,
director of the Prostitutes’ Organization of New York (PONY), a support
group of more than 300 sex workers, has been in the movement to
decriminalize prostitution since 1975. “Prostitutes are just a part of the whole
mix of society, whether people like it or not,” she says. “Prostitution must be
treated like an industry.”
But many workers are careful to distinguish between decriminalization and
legalization, which would create new laws and regulations governing the
industry. That, many sex workers and advocates believe, would only place
additional demands on women whose lives are difficult enough already.
Carmen, a 28-year-old who has been a sex worker for four years, questions
the benefits of legalization, as demonstrated in Nevada. “Under the current
system,” she says, “if you are arrested and incarcerated, you are put behind
bars. Legalization would be the same thing. You’re being put behind barbed
wire, and it is dictated to you where you can go, when you can go there, and
who you can talk to. That’s certainly not enticing to me.”
Norma Jean Almodovar of COYOTE (Call Off Your Old Tired Ethics), a
national advocacy and assistance organization for sex industry workers,
explains that “those of us who are out-and-out whores want our [fellow
workers] to be free.” Quan adds that although some prostitutes find that
legal brothels such as those in Nevada work for them, others choose illegal
action because they want to be in control.
“Nevada doesn’t encourage hookers to become madams,” Quan says. “And,
to us, it is very much an industry just like any other money-making career.
We want to know there is a level of hierarchy where upward mobility is
possible.”
And many prostitutes are as cynical about the government and the cops as
they are about pimps and johns. “There have been numerous examples of
how law enforcement officials have used laws as a form of extortion,” says
Almodovar. ” `Blow me for your license’ is not the answer.”
335
Другие работы по теме:
Al Capone 2 Essay Research Paper Al
Al Capone 2 Essay, Research Paper Al Capone Alphonse Capone was perhaps the most famous of all American gangsters in history. Al Capone was involved in many serious crimes including the Saint Valentine’s Day Massacre, income tax evasion, and the illegal selling of liquor. He also took part in the running of gambling and prostitution.
Legalizing Casinos Essay Research Paper People have
Legalizing Casinos Essay, Research Paper People have made lots of mistakes throughout the history. Most of them were sooner or later solved out; however, some still remain problematic issues that need to be revised and solved. One of the most frightening issues of the twentieth century is gambling. U.S.
Whore Essay Research Paper DonRay WHORE December
Whore Essay, Research Paper Don-Ray WHORE December 7, 2000 Prostitution, a practice in which a person, typically a woman, becomes sexually available to another for a price is the premise of the movie Whore, in which a single mother of one turns to prostitution in order to earn some extra money (McCaghy, p.391).
1984 Some Prophecies Have Come True Essay
, Research Paper 1984: Some Prophecies Have Come True In many ways 1984 by George Orwell, was ahead of its time— ironically, it parallels present day society in the U.S. in many ways. Yet at the same time,
Letters From A War Zone Essay Research
Paper "Letters from a War Zone" deals with the controversy between men and women banning pornography. In this essay there are many strong personal views on pornography
Crime And Prostitutes Essay Research Paper Prostitution
Crime And Prostitutes Essay, Research Paper Prostitution is ambiguous to define. The Macquarie dictionary defines prostitution as 1. the act or practice of engaging in sexual intercourse 2. any base or unworthy use of talent, ability, etc. But the act of prostitution involves many other associated facets that are included under this extensive act.
Prostitution
– Thailand/Canada Essay, Research Paper Introduction Prostitution exists in almost all cultures and civilizations of the world today. Just as the cultures differ richly from one another, prostitution and prostitution policy vary greatly throughout the globe. Although the act of prostitution itself is widely similar all over, the policies that are affecting the sex trade are the most influential in shaping the unique and individual sex industries of different countries.
Thailand Prostitution Essay Research Paper Prostitution PaperThe
Thailand Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Prostitution Paper The society in Thailand has an up and rising problem that they better look into very quickly, or else the well being of every citizen could be in great danger. This problem is prostitution and it poses almost equally as great of a threat to the nation as would a major war.
Progressive Era Essay Research Paper PhilipsUS History
Progressive Era Essay, Research Paper Philips US History II During the Progressive Era in the United States, there were many changes happening. Some were happening with the people in the United States, some with the people controlling the United States, and some changes were just going on around both of them.
Prostitution Essay Research Paper Prostitution in a
Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Prostitution in a broad aspect, is a relatively indiscriminate sexual exchange made for material gain. Individuals prostitute themselves when they grant sexual access for money, gifts, or other payment and in so doing uses their body in commodity. In legal terms the word prostitute refers only to those who “engage frequently and overly in such sexual-economic exchanges” (Britannica Encyclopedia Online).
Prostitution Essay Research Paper I Introduction Prostitution
Prostitution Essay, Research Paper I. Introduction Prostitution, performance of sexual acts solely for the purpose of material gain. Persons prostitute themselves when they grant sexual favors to others in exchange for money, gifts, or other payment and in so doing use their bodies as commodities. In legal terms, the word prostitute refers only to those who engage overtly in such sexual-economic transactions, usually for a specified sum of money.
Child Prostitution In Asia Essay Research Paper
Children as Chattels Close your eyes. Imagine a young girl about six tied to a bed in a brothel and forced to service fifteen to thirty men in one night. Imagine this girl living in poverty, after all promises of selling herself told of riches. Now imagine this girl is your own. These are not pretty thoughts, but these actions are commonplace in Asia.
Teenagers Problems Essay Research Paper Teenagers problemsToday
Teenagers Problems Essay, Research Paper Teenagers problems Today in the modern society, there a lot of problems, especially problems related with teenagers. A lot of factors influenced in this situation. For example some teenagers felt lack of love from their parents. Another factor is the lack of education because of poverty.
Sex Slavery In Thailand Essay Research Paper
The desire to be wealthy in the glittering growth of the Thai economy not only lures Many girls into prostitution, but also keeps them there. Although it has not been legal to
Prostitution 2 Essay Research Paper Solicited SexTwo
Prostitution 2 Essay, Research Paper Solicited Sex Two consenting adults can have sex, so why is it illegal for two consenting adults to have sex but to have one pay the other. Prostitution should be legal because it would save money and make the live of partakers more safe.
Legalizing Prostitution Essay Research Paper A comedian
Legalizing Prostitution Essay, Research Paper A comedian asked why is it illegal to sell sex but its okay to gibe it away. A beautician performs a service when she cuts your hair. The service is taxed, and the beautician makes money on the service she provided. The beautician, in performing this service, is doing nothing illegal, and is well within her constitutional rights.
Legalizing Prostitution Essay Research Paper Prostitution is
Legalizing Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Prostitution is an issue which has caused controversy cross-culturally and historically and which has many individuals reexamining the logistics of it. If prostitution is decriminalized it will become economically profitable and feasible for not only the prostitutes, but also western society as a whole.
Prostitution Essay Research Paper Specific Purpose To
Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Specific Purpose: To persuade the audience that prostitution should be legal. Introduction I. Open with Impact: If Ann Landers is for prostitution, then how far out can the notion be?
Prostitution Should Be Legal Essay Research Paper
Prostitution Should be Legal Referred to as the ?oldest profession?, prostitution ?. . . has long been a problem which has provoked and disturbed Americans? (Kinsie 3). ?Prostitution [is] the performance of sexual
Legal Prostitution Essay Research Paper Prostitution has
Legal Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Prostitution has long been considered as illegal. But is it necessary to do so? It is said that prostitution causes inconvenience and troubles to general public. However, the act that considers prostitution as illegal causes inconvenience and troubles to prostitutes either.
Politics Of The 1900 Essay Research Paper
The events that occur in Upton Sinclair?s book ?The Jungle? were same things that people in the early 20th century had to deal with everyday. For example labor was exploited to the employers benefit. Political corruption and prostitution were some main points in the book. The most important idea, the book supports socialism over capitalism as an economic and social structure.
Taxi Men Story Essay Research Paper The
Taxi Men Story Essay, Research Paper The main character in the story is the taxi cab driver, he was a born Singaporean who s been residing there since birth and been a taxi cab driver for almost twenty year, he s one of your usual taxi cab driver that has many things to discuss. In the story he spoke things about Singapore from his time to present time, he said Singapore used to be simple and peaceful, not much crowded with cars and buses and many changes took place, but the main element that rises in the story is about prostitution which focuses on teenage prostitution, he has seen teenage girl doing this, he has become an instrument for the prostitutes to bring them to the place where they sell their body.
Perspectives On Prostitution Essay Research Paper Perspectives
Perspectives On Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Perspectives on Prostitution Beginning around 1910, many religious and civic organizations in the United States started to develop a nationwide campaign against the immorality of prostitution. Although the government and other organizations may view prostitution as an immoral act, depending on a person s social perspective, he or she may view prostitution as being acceptable in today s society.
Sex Prostitution And The Penal Law Essay
, Research Paper Sex, Prostitution, and the Penal Law As the Bill and Monica drama has shown, sex addiction is not neccessarily what you would think it is. It is often not about the pervert, the exhibitionist, or the pornographer, although it can be. It is about your friendly neighbor down the street who turns out ot be, as everyone learns during the divorce, a hopeless womanizer.
Prostitution Essay Research Paper What is prostitution
Prostitution Essay, Research Paper What is prostitution? Prostitution is the After one year from the ratification of this article the manufacture, sale, or transportation of intoxicating liquors within, the importation thereof into, or the exportation thereof from the United States and all territory subject to the jurisdiction thereof for beverage purposes is hereby prohibited.
Prostitution Essay Research Paper Government Regulation of
Prostitution Essay, Research Paper Government Regulation of Prostitution is Key The question of whether prostitution should be legalized has been an extremely controversial issue over the past few years. Many people who oppose government regulation of prostitution claim that America?s morality is at stake.
Why It Should Be Legal Essay Research
Paper Why Marijuana Should be Legal For my final paper I am going to do it on why marijuana should be legal. I will provide factual information that will prove that there are more reasons that it should be legal than illegal. Using studies done by doctors and scientist that prove that it is used to cure many illnesses and medical conditions.
Deviance And Prostitution Essay Research Paper In
Deviance And Prostitution Essay, Research Paper In sociology, the term deviance refers to all violations of social rules, regardless of their seriousness (Essentials of Sociology 136). Deviance is an individual or organizational behavior that violates societal norms and is usually accompanied by negative reactions from others.
Child Porn Essay Research Paper The child
Child Porn Essay, Research Paper The child sex trade has been traditionally identified with underdeveloped third-world countries; particularly in Southeast Asia, where the cheap prices, ready availability of underage prostitutes and lax law enforcement have attracted Western sex tourists. However, the child sex trade is ever present in even the most civilised and advanced countries, and is an age-old problem that has long been underestimated.