Singer Vs Reagan Essay, Research Paper
Singer vs. Regan
Despite their rather different philosophical foundations, both philosophers arrive at basically the same conclusions. Singer takes a utilitarian approach, while Regan takes a deontological “rights” and “inherent value” position. In the end they both take a position of vegetarianism and advocated banning animal experimentation and sport hunting. In an exchange of letters in the April 25, 1985 issue of The New York Review of Books, Regan writes: “Singer and I have been independently applying and developing very different ethical theories to … the treatment of non-human animals.” He continues that “it is difficult to exaggerate the radical moral difference between Singer’s utilitarianism and the rights view”. At the end of Singer’s reply to Regan, Singer mentions: “The practical value of Regan’s book (All the dwell Therein) lies in its attack on our social practices of using animals as research tools and as mere lumps of palatable living flesh. On these practical issues Regan and I are in full agreement. Viewed from the perspective of a society which continues to accept these practices, the philosophical differences between us hardly matter.”
In 1975, Australian philosopher Peter Singer wrote a book called Animal Liberation. In this book Singer argued that humans should not use animals, all based on utilitarianism. Utilitarians say actions should be judged strictly by their consequences. An action is good if it will provide the greatest benefit to the largest number of individuals. Singer did not stop there, and said that when we calculate consequences, we must take into account the interests not only of human beings but also of animals. If we fail to consider these animals’ interests, or if we give human beings special consideration, we are guilty of “speciesism.” To Singer, animal research is morally acceptable if the benefits to humans or animals used clearly outweigh the harm to the animals used in the research. He usually concludes that the cost to the animals outweighs the benefit to others.
Singer’s contender, Tom Regan set forth another animal rights view in a 1983 book, The Case for Animal Rights. Regan emphasizes that not only people, but also many animals are entitled to certain rights. He bases his reasoning on the idea that both humans and animals have an elementary understanding of the world and know generally what they desire from life. Regan’s rights-based philosophy says that most mammals older than one year qualify for basic rights. Furthermore, Regan argues that it is wrong for humans to use animals for their own needs and in general, to deprive animals of their rights.
Regan disagrees with Singer’s utilitarian program for animal liberation. Regan allocates intrinsic value to animals and humans. This value describes the animals’, or human’s right to life and concern for them. Regan feels that the utilitarian view lacks this intrinsic value. In addition, he states the goals of his theologies: “The total abolition of the use of animals in science, the total dissolution of commercial animal agriculture, and the total elimination of commercial and sport hunting and trapping.” In addition, he sees Singer’s utilitarian view noted above, failing on two accounts. First, utilitarianism is concerned only with the desires of a being, e.g. such as the desire for pleasure. At the same time the view takes no regard for the inherent worth of these beings (human or animal). Second, Regan emphasizes the problem of utilitarianism that it would be morally permissible to arbitrarily make an individual suffer for the benefit of the greater good. Regan issues that “the best theory of morality will be one that grants rights to all beings who have inherent worth. This prevents morality from becoming an exclusive club as in contractarianism, and does not allow individuals to be exploited on behalf of the greater good.”
Regan explains that a being has inherent worth when it is a subject of a life, or when the being has preferences, beliefs, feelings, recollections, and expectations. It has been noted that many animals exhibit these features and therefore have inherent worth. Regan criticizes alternative criteria of inherent worth. To say that only intelligent beings have inherent worth will exclude infants and mentally impaired people, which is inadequate. To say that only Homo Sapiens have inherent value is a form of speciesism, which Singer would agree. Regan’s conclusions agree with Singer that the animal rights movement should be seen as part of the human rights movement.
Regan and Singer base their value of animals on different criteria. While Regan denotes criteria to animals and humans based on intrinsic value, Singer states “The question is not, Can they reason? Nor can they talk? But, Can they suffer?” “The capacity for suffering and enjoyment…” Singer calls this capacity sentience. It doesn’t make any sense to talk about the interests of a rock because a rock is not sentient; it has no capacity for suffering and enjoyment. However, a mouse can suffer, and knows when it is suffering. Singer notes if a being can suffer then it has interests. Interests should be given equal consideration regardless of other differences; therefore any being that can suffer should be given equal consideration regardless of other differences. Regan would agree on the idea that all beings given inherent value, be given equal value regardless of other factors.
In the end both, Regan and Singer wind up getting a similar message across. In general, animals need to be incorporated in the ‘ethical equation’ and given some sort of worth, whether the worth be based on suffering or intrinsic value. Regan is an absolutist in his beliefs while Singer incorporates utilitarian belief and allows for leeway and exceptions to his attitudes. Both Regan and Singer uphold vegetarianism for the sole reasons of how they bring value about to animals. Similar arguments can be applied to cross cultural, cross racial, and cross sexual issues among humans. The two animal rights and animal liberation promoters advocate a more sensitive world where we are all aware of animal suffering and animal worth, not based upon our utility, but for the animals themselves.
328
Другие работы по теме:
Nat King Cole Essay Research Paper NAT
Nat King Cole Essay, Research Paper NAT KING COLE BORN MARCH 17, 1919 DIED FEBRUARY 15, 1965 BORN NATHANIEL ADAMS COLES HE WAS THE FIRST AFRICAN- AMERICAN WHO BECAME A SUCCESS WITH THE WHITE AUDIENCE.
Gimples Foolishness Essay Research Paper Adam KayProfessor
Gimples Foolishness Essay, Research Paper Adam Kay Professor deall English 220 March 16, 2001 Gimpel’s Foolishness In many stories there are series of conflicts with an individual and his society. In “Gimpel the Fool,” written by Isaac Bashevis Singer, there is conflict between Gimpel and the society in which he lives in.
Book Report At Large By David
H. Freeman And Charles C. Mann Essay, Research Paper At Large is a non-fiction novel. The true story of Matt Singer (obviously not his real name), who is mentally retarded in reality, but leads a second life as the hacker, Phantomd and Infomaster . The story takes place from March 1991 to January 1993, and traces the events surrounding Phantomd s escapades as he breaks into one computer system after another.
Down On The Factory Farm Essay Research
Paper Down on the Factory Farm Peter Singer s critique of factory farms is a very detailed description of how huge factory farming companies exploit animals. This practice of farming used to be much more humane when it wasn t so industrialized.
Of Mark Singer
’s “Profile Of Filmmaker Errol Morris” Essay, Research Paper Chaim H. Respes September 16, 1999 Summary of Mark Singer’s “Profile of Filmmaker Errol Morris”
Review Of Sublime Video Essay Research Paper
The music video that I chose to write my paper on, is called "Date Rape" and it is performed by Sublime. I’ve seen the video plenty of times and I taped it back in 1993 when I first got
Adam Sandler Essay Research Paper Adam Sandler
Adam Sandler Essay, Research Paper Adam Sandler is a well-known comedian, musician, actor, screenwriter, and singer. He is known throughout the nation for his accomplishments in the entertainment business.
Gimpel The Fool Essay Research Paper Contrasts
Gimpel The Fool Essay, Research Paper Contrasts of the two main characters in Singer s Gimpel the Fool indicate that they are two totally different people. These contrasts reveal the different natures that both characters show throughout the story. Both Gimpel and his wife Elka are faced with the same situations, but the way they handle these situations can be easily contrasted.
Gimpel The Fool Essay Research Paper In
Gimpel The Fool Essay, Research Paper In Isaac Bashevis Singer s Gimpel the Fool , Gimpel is treated with no respect from his peers or the society of Frampol where he lives. Gimpel s life has been riddled with tricks and lies from the townspeople for as long as he can remember. No one respects Gimpel or has any sympathy for him and his misfortunes.
Nazi Essay Research Paper John Mendes 83000Critical
Nazi Essay, Research Paper John Mendes 8/30/00 Critical Thinking Philosophy 100 Singer?s Final solution Singer and the Nazis both took away the rights of other human beings. Both men took away rights because of physical ability, self-awareness, or intelligence.
Michael Jckson Essay Research Paper Michael Jackson
Michael Jckson Essay, Research Paper Michael Jackson was, and still is the most popular person in the Jackson 5. The fans loved him and his brothers loved him. Michael was definitely the best dancer in the group, which was amazing because he was the youngest in the family. Michael could never sit still, he would always have to get up and dance, or do something athletic.
Ronald Regan Essay Research Paper The perceptions
Ronald Regan Essay, Research Paper The perceptions of Ronald Reagan as a political figure and a foreign policy maker are numerous. He was seen by some, as an “warrior”, by others such as Margaret Thatcher, as a savior, the man who “won the cold war without firing a shot. Some people were concerned about the idea of having a president who had “prejudices about the Soviet Union.
Ronald Reagan 2 Essay Research Paper Dutch
Ronald Reagan 2 Essay, Research Paper Dutch: A Memoir of Ronald Reagan The task of writing a biography on a President of the United States was never said to be an easy one. In fact, if one would ask writer Edmund Morris he would tell how hard it is first hand. For some individuals it would be an honor of a lifetime, for others it would be too strenuous of a task but for Edmund Morris it would be a pleasure.
Heart Is A Lonely Hunter By Carson
Mccullers Essay, Research Paper The Heart is a Lonely Hunter by Carson McCullers is a novel set in a small Southern town in the late 1930’s. McCullers writes about characters who are lonely and rejected. their
Hungrey Essay Research Paper Global hunger is
Hungrey? Essay, Research Paper Global hunger is a major concern that effects the whole world. According to Peter Singer ?the whole way we look at moral issues-our moral conceptual scheme
Hunger And Poverty Essay Research Paper Hunger
Hunger And Poverty Essay, Research Paper Hunger and Poverty During the course of this particular essay, I will prove to you many points. Maybe not to the extreme that it will change one?s thought processes on the subject of hunger and world poverty, but enough to form a distinction between moral obligation and moral capacity.
Drugs And Alcohol Essay Research Paper Alli
Drugs And Alcohol Essay, Research Paper Alli Kelly Drugs in Society Drugs and Alcohol in the Life of Celebrities So you think most celebrities have such “perfect” lives? You are wrong. Many celebrities appear to have “perfect” lives with all the money, popularity and friends they have. But for many celebrities money, popularity, and friends just isn’t enough.
Singers In The Odyssey Essay Research Paper
During the Odyssey, many singers are mentioned. They told stories of the past and the stories about the gods to entertain the household they were singing for. Singers were well respected because they had a divine gift from the Muses. Phemios and Demodokos are two examples of singers in the poem.
A Deeper Look At Gimple The Fool
Essay, Research Paper A deeper look at “Gimple the Fool” At one time or another, everyone, in their life, has looked down upon someone because that someone isn’t as rich, attractive, or even as intelligent as most people. People do this without any regard to the people’s feeling, and without ever imagining what it is like to be in that person’s shoes.
Gimpel The Fool Essay Research Paper Singer
Gimpel The Fool Essay, Research Paper Singer s Gimpel the Fool is written in first person point of view, and the narrator, Gimpel, is the main character in the story. In the opening paragraph in the story Singer shows how reliable of a narrator that Gimpel is. Gimpel shares many of the nicknames he has had given to him in school, including imbecile, donkey, flax-head, dope, glump, ninny, and fool.
Isaac Bashevis Singer Essay Research Paper Research
Isaac Bashevis Singer Essay, Research Paper Research Paper Isaac Bashevis Singer Stephen Eggleston Mrs. Schussler English II Eggleston 1 There are many writers in this world, and many of them write short stories. These short stories are to-the-point works of literature that have one thing in common among all of them, themes.
Diana Krall Essay Research Paper Singerpianist Diana
Diana Krall Essay, Research Paper Singer/pianist Diana Krall got her musical education when she was growing up in Nanaimo, British Columbia, from the classical piano lesson she began at age four and in her high-school jazz band, but mostly from her father, a stride piano player with an extensive record collection. “I think Dad has every recording Fats Waller ever made,” she said, “and I tried to learn them all.” In 1981 Krall won a Vancouver Jazz scholarship to study at the Berklee College of Music in Boston.
Election 1984 Essay Research Paper Thank you
Election 1984 Essay, Research Paper Thank you Let’s take a look back at the presidential election of 1984. The primary candidates in this election were Ronald Reagan for Republican, and Walter Mondale for Democratic.
Ronald Regan Essay Research Paper Reagan Ronald
Ronald Regan Essay, Research Paper Reagan, Ronald Wilson (1911- ), 40th president of the United States (1981-1989) Leonard Park Ronald Reagan was born in Tampico, Illinois. In a family of 3 boys he was the youngest. His father was a traveling shoe salesman. Reagan’s mother taught Reagan how to read at an early age, which heavily influenced him positively.
The Rolling Stones Essay Research Paper The
The Rolling Stones Essay, Research Paper The Rolling Stones The English rock band The Rolling Stones was formed in 1962. The five origional members of the group were lead singer Mick Jagger
Peter Singer Essay Research Paper ESSAY
Peter Singer Essay, Research Paper ESSAY #1 Peter Singer is well known for issues on animal rights and hunger. He proclaims three points in his argument for us to have a moral obligation to assist people that are in poverty. When somebody speaks of the hunger issue and absolute poverty, one must have a general idea what absolute poverty is.
Jim Morrison Essay Research Paper Jim MorrisonAmerican
Jim Morrison Essay, Research Paper Jim Morrison*****American singer and songwriter, born in Melbourne, Florida, and educated at the University of California at Los Angeles. In 1966, he formed a group called the Doors with Ray Manzarek, John Densmore, and Robbie Krieger. The group became known for its extravagant performing style, combining sensual movements and a hard-hitting sound, amplified to huge proportions.
BB King Essay Research Paper BB King
BB King Essay, Research Paper B.B. King was a blues singer and guitarist. His full name is Riley B. King. He was born September 16, 1925, near Indianola, Mississippi. An important aspect in King’s life was, of course, when he was first exposed to the blues. ‘I guess the earliest sound of the blues that I can rremember was in the fields while people would be pickin’ cotton or choppin’ or somethin,’ ” he told Living Blues . ” When I sing and play now I can hear those same sounds that I used to hear then as a kid.”B.B.
Billie Holliday Essay Research Paper Billie HolidayBillie
Billie Holliday Essay, Research Paper Billie Holiday Billie Holiday was a famous jazz singer in the 1930 s and 1940 s. She was born in Baltimore, Maryland in 1915 with the name of Eleanora Fagan. She became successful as by singing in various bands before embarking on a solo career. Billie Holiday was one of the first successful African American females.
The Beatles VS Oasis Essay Research Paper
The Beatles v.s. Oasis Oasis is a band of the nineties that is often compared The Beatles. They try to be like The Beatles only to do it unsuccessfully. The lead singer of Oasis, Liam Galagher tries to be like