’s “Profile Of Filmmaker Errol Morris” Essay, Research Paper
Chaim H. Respes
September 16, 1999
Summary of Mark Singer’s
“Profile of Filmmaker Errol Morris”
Dallas police officer, Robert Wood, was shot five times and murdered after pulling over a vehicle for a minor traffic violation. Randall Dale Adams was arrested, convicted and sentenced to death for the crime. Adams plead “not guilty” to the charges. He claimed 16 year old David Harris, whom he had spent several hours with on the day of the crime, was the true killer.
In Mark Singer’s “Profile of Filmmaker Errol Morris,” Singer describes Randall Adams case as it was portrayed in the movie The Thin Blue Line. Singer argues that Morris made the film to prove Adams innocence and illustrate “that Adams had received anything but a fair trial.” Singer, an author for The New Yorker Magazine, took personal interest in the case because he, as well as Morris, believed Adams was innocent and deserved a new and fair trial.
The prosecution won the case against Adams for three major reasons: David Harris’ testimony, Prosecutor Douglas Mulder’s prominence, determination, and the prosecutions three key eyewitnesses, Emily Miller, Robert Miller, and Michael Randell.
After the conclusion of the trial Adams maintained his innocence and filmmaker, Errol Morris met with David Harris and began to have doubts about Adams guilt. Morris investigated the case further and discovered it was “unfair” on constitutional grounds and Adams was in fact innocent.
Morris made a movie entitled The Thin Blue Line, which was a description of the actual events in the Adams homicide case. Morris intended to illustrate thirteen points of unwarranted prosecution.
There were four blatant acts of perjury or outright unfairness in Adams first trial. Judge Metcalf would not permit the use David Harris’ extensive previous criminal record, including pending charges in another county as evidence. This left Adams in the “guilty chair” even before the trial began. Prosecutor Mulder demanded a guilty verdict with a death penalty sentence for this trial and he was willing to go to any length to achieve that. He found three witnesses to the crime scene after offering a $20,000 reward and an all expense paid stay at Dallas motel during the trial. The first witness, Emily Miller, had a daughter who was facing robbery charges in another county and Mulder agreed to drop the charges in exchange for Emily’s testimony. Emily testified to witnessing Adams in the driver’s seat of the car, at the time of the shooting, and she positively identified Adams in a police line-up. Morris conducted interview with the three witnesses, Emily Miller, Robert Miller and Michael Randell. Emily Miller admitted to being directed to pick Adams in the line-up after she chose the wrong man. Robert Miller was quoted as saying; “I didn’t see anything.” Randell admitted to being drunk “out of his mind” when he passed the scene. The fourth major point of perjury in Morris’ defense for Adams was Teresa Turko’s, Robert Woods’ partner, original description of the killer. She described him as “Mexican or light-skinned black” which varied greatly from Adams Caucasian skin. Her original description was not used and had evolved to match Adams description by the time of the trial.
The Thin Blue Line was effective in getting Adams a writ hearing and the chance for a new trial. The judge ruled on six grounds of constitutional unfairness deeming it an unjust trial.
It was apparent that Singer was on the side of the defense for several reasons. Singer said, “Dennis White (Adams attorney) was simply no match for Doug Mulder, who is said to have once boasted, “Anybody can convict a guilty man. It takes talent to convict an innocent man.” He includes this quote to demonstrate Mulder’s determination to win even if he is prosecuting the wrong man. A quote such as that evokes the sentiment of a reader who is in favor upholding justice.
Throughout the excerpt Singer uses words like, “unfortunately” to depict actions Adams’ lawyers did not take, and “ensconced” to describe the so-called witnesses stay at the Alamo Plaza motel. Singer recognized Adams bad luck and referred to it as “consistent.” These words and phrases are influential in expressing his opinion because they have negative connotations and portray the prosecution in a bad light.
Singer’s distaste for “witness” Emily Miller is very clear. He describes her as a “bleached blonde” and says one of her childhood ambitions was to be the “?wife of a detective.” A woman who is willing to settle for the position of wife to her goals, is not a beneficial member to society. Singer makes it a point to quote Emily’s interview with Morris because it shows her ignorance. She did not use proper English and stumbled over her words in brief and barely coherent sentences.
Singer concludes his passage by detailing the writ judges predictions. The judge predicted a new trial for Adams during which he would be freed and pardoned of all homicide charges.
“Profile of Filmmaker Errol Morris” is effective in displaying the actual events in the Adams homicide case. Mark Singer summarizes the movie The Thin Blue Line and includes his opinion about the verdict. The movie was intended to prove Adams innocence by displaying the perjury committed during the trial. Singer included his beliefs in Adams innocence by using negative words towards the prosecution and bad-mouthing the witnesses.
Другие работы по теме:
Gimples Foolishness Essay Research Paper Adam KayProfessor
Gimples Foolishness Essay, Research Paper Adam Kay Professor deall English 220 March 16, 2001 Gimpel’s Foolishness In many stories there are series of conflicts with an individual and his society. In “Gimpel the Fool,” written by Isaac Bashevis Singer, there is conflict between Gimpel and the society in which he lives in.
Caesar And Mark Anthony Essay Research Paper
Caesar and Mark Anthony Today I think Caesar would be a great leader in today’s society. I see him as a running mate for President of The United States. His vice President would be Mark Anthony. I see Caesar, as a well liked candidate by the people because he promises to give them the things that they are in need of.
Scarlet Colored Savior Essay Research Paper The
Scarlet Colored Savior Essay, Research Paper The mark of the beast came from within, the mark of the beast drew her sin. Hate is all she knew, hate from which she grew. Tattered and torn, scorn and forlorn she long awaits her savior. She knows not yet her saviors face, yet she searches- stopping at every corner.
Gospel Of Mark Essay Research Paper Chapter
Gospel Of Mark Essay, Research Paper Chapter 10 verse 45 of the Gospel of Mark portrays Jesus Christ as a servant, “For the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve.” Reading the rest of the verse, the idea that not only did Christ come to be a servant, but he came to be a suffering servant comes to light, “and to give his life a ransom for many.”
Gimpel The Fool Essay Research Paper Contrasts
Gimpel The Fool Essay, Research Paper Contrasts of the two main characters in Singer s Gimpel the Fool indicate that they are two totally different people. These contrasts reveal the different natures that both characters show throughout the story. Both Gimpel and his wife Elka are faced with the same situations, but the way they handle these situations can be easily contrasted.
Gimpel The Fool Essay Research Paper In
Gimpel The Fool Essay, Research Paper In Isaac Bashevis Singer s Gimpel the Fool , Gimpel is treated with no respect from his peers or the society of Frampol where he lives. Gimpel s life has been riddled with tricks and lies from the townspeople for as long as he can remember. No one respects Gimpel or has any sympathy for him and his misfortunes.
A Connecticut Yankee In King Arthur
’s Court By Mark Twain (1835 – 1910) Essay, Research Paper Mark Twain was fascinated by Sir Thomas Malory’s “Morte d’Arthur.” According to his notebook, Twain dreamed one
I Heard The Owl Call My NameMargaret
Craven Essay, Research Paper Margaret Craver?s novel, I Heard the Owl Call My Name, is the story of an ill, Mark Brian, who learns about life, death, and the power of love. His bishop sends him to Kingcome, an Indian village. There he learns enough of the meaning of life to be ready to die. In life people should give and share.
Nazi Essay Research Paper John Mendes 83000Critical
Nazi Essay, Research Paper John Mendes 8/30/00 Critical Thinking Philosophy 100 Singer?s Final solution Singer and the Nazis both took away the rights of other human beings. Both men took away rights because of physical ability, self-awareness, or intelligence.
Iron And Silk Essay Research Paper In
Iron And Silk Essay, Research Paper In the book Iron and Silk, written by Mark Salzman as his point of view, is all about China. Throughout the book, Mark experiences many differences between the Chinese culture and his own American culture. Chinese people want to save face by doing some weird things. First example, kissing in China over the age of two is embarrassing for both children and parents.
Michael Jckson Essay Research Paper Michael Jackson
Michael Jckson Essay, Research Paper Michael Jackson was, and still is the most popular person in the Jackson 5. The fans loved him and his brothers loved him. Michael was definitely the best dancer in the group, which was amazing because he was the youngest in the family. Michael could never sit still, he would always have to get up and dance, or do something athletic.
Heart Is A Lonely Hunter By Carson
Mccullers Essay, Research Paper The Heart is a Lonely Hunter by Carson McCullers is a novel set in a small Southern town in the late 1930’s. McCullers writes about characters who are lonely and rejected. their
Hungrey Essay Research Paper Global hunger is
Hungrey? Essay, Research Paper Global hunger is a major concern that effects the whole world. According to Peter Singer ?the whole way we look at moral issues-our moral conceptual scheme
Hunger And Poverty Essay Research Paper Hunger
Hunger And Poverty Essay, Research Paper Hunger and Poverty During the course of this particular essay, I will prove to you many points. Maybe not to the extreme that it will change one?s thought processes on the subject of hunger and world poverty, but enough to form a distinction between moral obligation and moral capacity.
Singers In The Odyssey Essay Research Paper
During the Odyssey, many singers are mentioned. They told stories of the past and the stories about the gods to entertain the household they were singing for. Singers were well respected because they had a divine gift from the Muses. Phemios and Demodokos are two examples of singers in the poem.
Huck Finn Essay Research Paper Why Huckleberry
Huck Finn Essay, Research Paper Why Huckleberry Finn Rejects Civilization Why does Huckleberry Finn reject civilization? In Mark Twain?s novel The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, Mark Twain describes Huck Finn as a normal down to earth kid from the 1800?s. Huck Finn rejects civilization because he has no reason for it.
Gentle Ben Essay Research Paper A brown
Gentle Ben Essay, Research Paper A brown bear is the largest most dangerous big-game animal in North America. Even so ,Mark Anderson?s only friend is Ben, the
Gimpel The Fool Essay Research Paper Singer
Gimpel The Fool Essay, Research Paper Singer s Gimpel the Fool is written in first person point of view, and the narrator, Gimpel, is the main character in the story. In the opening paragraph in the story Singer shows how reliable of a narrator that Gimpel is. Gimpel shares many of the nicknames he has had given to him in school, including imbecile, donkey, flax-head, dope, glump, ninny, and fool.
Singer Vs Reagan Essay Research Paper Singer
Singer Vs Reagan Essay, Research Paper Singer vs. Regan Despite their rather different philosophical foundations, both philosophers arrive at basically the same conclusions. Singer takes a utilitarian approach, while Regan takes a deontological “rights” and “inherent value” position. In the end they both take a position of vegetarianism and advocated banning animal experimentation and sport hunting.
That Was Then This Is Now Essay
, Research Paper 1. In the story That Was Then, This is Now, the main character was a 16 year old boy named Bryon. Being 16 and living in the 50?s would obviously give anyone a very trendy look. You could either be a ?Greaser? or a ?SOC?. In the novel, Bryon was a greaser. He always wore things such as jeans, and Tee Shirts.
The Rolling Stones Essay Research Paper The
The Rolling Stones Essay, Research Paper The Rolling Stones The English rock band The Rolling Stones was formed in 1962. The five origional members of the group were lead singer Mick Jagger
Interview Essay Essay Research Paper Interview Essay
Interview Essay Essay, Research Paper Interview Essay As a new student in college you meet many people from many different walks of life. The campus is a conglomerate of lifestyles and personalities. Everyday there is someone new to meet and something new to talk about. I got to know Mark Thompson and learned a lot about him and his way of life.
Critic On Huckleberry Finn Essay Research Paper
I felt that this novel, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, by Mark Twain is appropriate and necessary to illustrate the attitudes of pre-Civil war Americans. To me, this book just shows the life of two runaway
BB King Essay Research Paper BB King
BB King Essay, Research Paper B.B. King was a blues singer and guitarist. His full name is Riley B. King. He was born September 16, 1925, near Indianola, Mississippi. An important aspect in King’s life was, of course, when he was first exposed to the blues. ‘I guess the earliest sound of the blues that I can rremember was in the fields while people would be pickin’ cotton or choppin’ or somethin,’ ” he told Living Blues . ” When I sing and play now I can hear those same sounds that I used to hear then as a kid.”B.B.
Mark Twain Essay Research Paper Mark TwainWhat
Mark Twain Essay, Research Paper Mark Twain What the Huck? Though popularity associated with the American frontier and life on the Mississippi, Samuel Longhorne Clemens –Mark Twain actually spent many of his happiest and most productive years in and near New York City. Mark Twain was, without question, the finest sastirist of his time.
Kaffir Boy Essay Research Paper In the
Kaffir Boy Essay, Research Paper In the book Kaffir Boy by Mark Mathebane there are many obstacles that Mark the protagonist has to overcome. The first of his problems was to get through school in his poor South African ghetto. The second was to achieve his goal and receive a tennis scholarship to an American college.
A Noiseless Patient Spider 1881 Essay Research
Paper A noiseless patient spider, I mark’d where on a little promotory it stood isolated, Mark’d how to explore the vacant vast surrounding. It launch’d forth filament, filament, filament, ot itself,
Client Essay Research Paper The Client
Client Essay, Research Paper ?The Client? / John Grisham 1. I enjoyed reading this interesting book. It talks about eleven years old Mark Sway and his younger
Killing Mr Essay Research Paper Killing Mr
Killing Mr Essay, Research Paper Killing Mr. Griffin I read the book Killing Mr. Griffin, by Lois Duncan. There was an English teacher, Mr. Griffin, which nobody liked. Especially one particular group of
Mark Twain Essay Research Paper title
Mark Twain Essay, Research Paper title = Mark Twain papers = Mark Twain Background Mark Twain was born Samuel Langhorne Clemens in Florida, Missouri on November
Mark Essay Research Paper Mark is most
Mark Essay, Research Paper Mark is most likely the first of the Gospels to be written because it is the shortest and tells of the ministry of Jesus. Mark stresses Jesus’ message about the kingdom of God and how it is breaking into human life as good news and that Jesus himself is portrayed as the “gospel of God.” Jesus is explained as the Son of God who is sent down to rescue everyone.