Liberty. Discuss. Essay, Research Paper
“Socialism is primarily concerned with equality, not liberty.” Discuss.
Socialism is an ideology that covers many diverse and divergent ideas and theories. It is therefore very difficult to define it as one ideology in particular. This is an important point because the question is a definitive statement about what socialism is. In fact, it is well summed up by Anthony Wright who wrote “There is no shortage of available definitions of what socialism is, but there is a shortage of agreed definitions.” Because socialism covers such a wide range of ideas, the importance of equality and liberty varies between different theorists. Further to this, it is also worth noting that different theorists define the concepts of equality and liberty differently. However, most theories use either liberty or equality, or both, even if only in criticism of each other.
In an attempt to define socialism as an ideology, many socialists agree that a characteristic theme of socialism is a commitment to equality. However they all differ in their opinion over the extent of its importance. Some perceive it to be the goal of society whilst others see it simply as a means to an end. When socialism emerged as a recognizable ideology in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth it was strongly influenced by some egalitarian thinkers and ideas. These included Rousseau and his demands for popular sovereignty, Robespierre and the Jacobites and Babeuf and his society of equals. Babeuf even said, “For the true and living equality we will give up everything. Let the arts perish if need be! But let us have the equality!” This quote goes to show that for some socialists, equality is their primary goal.
The socialist tradition is one of opposition to the capitalist idea of competition amongst individuals in the name of personal gain. Babeuf also went on to say, “Society must be made to operate in such a way that it eradicates once and for all the desire of man to become richer, wiser and more powerful than others.”
This has led commentators to claim that equality is the key socialist view of society because it seeks to replace the inequality of the capitalist society with an equal social structure. According to Crosland, equality would remove social antagonism because the divide due to the envy and resentment causes the class war.
On the other hand, socialism also has many libertarian thinkers and ideas. Liberal socialists believe socialism to be the key to maximizing liberty through the self-direction of small communities. They want the removal of oppressive state and class structures in order to free the individual. Perhaps the most notable was Fourier who demanded complete freedom from crippling conventions and was quite prepared to have both the rich and the poor in his Utopia. He even went so far as to envisage the investment of capital for profit. However, libertarianism is often seen as too radical. “Libertarianism is the demand for freedom in the sense of the total absence of restraints, external and internal.”
There are some prominent socialists who have made equality their primary aim. Syndicalism is non-libertarian because it emphasizes group loyalty and working class solidarity and sees their future society organized along trade union lines. Lenin also disassociates himself from the idea of liberalism. He saw the future of society being based on the idea of equality and said that after the revolution there would be a move “form formal equality to actual equality.” However, Lenin does go on to modify his stance and his “New Economic Policy signaled a compromise with private enterprise and an acceptance of the importance of liberty.”
A closer look at the writings of Marx, Engels, Tawney and Crosland will go to further show how the ideas of equality and liberty are actually linked within socialist thought. Marx, especially in his later works, adopts a strong egalitarian tone. He talks of a vast association of people, the establishment of industrial armies and the need for a directing authority for production in the future. Of the Gotha program he writes “From each according to his ability, to each according to his needs!” This quote outlines how goods would be allocated along egalitarian lines under communism. Also, it shows that he is putting equality over liberty.
According to Marx, there is no liberal right for the individual to pursue greater personal wealth, but that this is not infringing on his freedom because under communism, men will find true freedom as social individuals. Marx doesn’t believe there to be any conflict between his specific ideas of equality and liberty. However, Marx’s own specific type of equality is the equality of distribution according to needs and not the bourgeois concept of equality of treatment.
Engels goes on to argue that equality means different things to different people at different times. “Thus the idea of equality, whether in its bourgeois or in its proletarian form, is itself a historical product, the creation of which required definite historical conditions that in turn themselves presuppose a long previous history. It is consequently, anything but an eternal truth.”
He makes a further point that goes on to link equality and liberty by saying that an individual cannot be free if he is at the economic mercy of another. “Equality must not be merely apparent, must not apply merely to the sphere of the state, but must also be real, must also be extended to the social and economic spheres.”
Crosland and Tawney also believe that equality and liberty are interdependent. Tawney states that “liberty is rightly preferred to equality when the two of them are in conflict” but then goes on to qualify this by saying that if liberty is properly interpreted in an economic, social and political sense then it is ‘in fact, equality in action.”
“When liberty is construed, realistically, or implying, not merely a minimum of civil and political rights, but securities that the economically weak will not be at the mercy of the strong, [ .] a large measure of equality, so far from being inimical to liberty is essential to it.”
Crosland still argues that equality is still an important socialist ideal but a change in the capitalist system has forced socialists to change their focus. Economic equality and the redistribution of wealth will no longer result in greater overall equality. Instead, socialists must now focus on social equality, such as improving equality in education, in order to improve overall equality. However, he does go on to admit that this idea is still quite liberal but that most liberals would agree that everyone should have an “equal opportunity for wealth, advancement and renown.”
In conclusion, equality might be the classical principal of socialism but the claim that socialism is primarily concerned with equality and not liberty is not justified. Socialism is such a broad ideology that the claim made in the title can only be applied to specific thinkers and not socialism as a whole. “Liberalism been rejected as an ideological creature of capitalism but it has also been incorporated into and fulfilled by socialism” Further to this, the writings of Crosland and Tawney show us that equality and liberty are sometimes actually perceived to be the same socialist end.
Bibliography
A. Wright, Socialisms: Theories and Practices, (Oxford University Press, 1986)
R.N. Berki, Socialism, (J. M. Dent and Sons Ltd., London, 1975)
C. A. R. Crosland, The Future of Socialism, (Jonathan Cape, 1963)
F. Engels, Anti-Duhring; pt 1 ch X
K. Marx, Critique of the Gotha Program
Другие работы по теме:
Basic Iseals Of Declaration Of Independance Essay
, Research Paper The introduction to the Declaration of Independence posses the basic of ideals of America. Four of the ideals extolled in the document are; equality, natural rights, consent if the
Dostoyevsky
’s Use Of Characters In Crime And Punis Essay, Research Paper Socialism means that everyone in society works for the benefit of the whole, rather than for separate individuals, and no matter how much you work, you get an equal share of the outcome. During the course of the novel Crime and Punishment, we may notice that Fyodor Dostoyevsky uses some of the characters to reveal his own ideas about socialism.
Cummunism Essay Research Paper Communism Communism is
Cummunism Essay, Research Paper Communism Communism is the idea of having a classless society of people where everything is supposed to be owned equally by all. In communism, unlike Marxism there is a peasant revolution instead of a proletariat revolution, and unlike in socialism there is a totalitarian government and there is no private property.
Rationalism Essay Research Paper Discuss How Rationalism
Rationalism Essay, Research Paper Discuss How Rationalism Changed The World Between 1650 – 1750 Many changes took place between 1650 and 1750. There was territory expansion as European countries started colonies in the Americas. Political changes took place as well, as people began to rise up against the government.
Locke And Equality Essay Research Paper First
Locke And Equality Essay, Research Paper First of all,the basis for understanding Locke is that he sees all people as having natural God given rights. As God’s creations, this denotes a certain equality.
Analysis Of The Preamble Essay Research Paper
Inferring freedom and equality, most people and processes depend on each other to survive in the natural world. First of all, freedom and equality presuppose each other in some instances, but sometimes they are interdependent. For example, if one looks at the lower class, people within that class are equal among others in that class.
ENST 302 Essay Research Paper March
ENST / 302 Essay, Research Paper March 5, 1999 Harry Greene, ?Frogs and Snakes: The Texture of Diversity? The lecture that was given by Dr. Greene proved to be well worth attending. He focused on snakes and frogs primarily and his in-depth knowledge of biology in the field proved to be very helpful in explaining the evolution, reproduction, and behavior patterns in these creatures.
CapitalimSocialism Essay Research Paper There are many
Capitalim-Socialism Essay, Research Paper There are many different economic systems that reside in someway throughout the world today like capitalism and socialism. Here in the United States, we live in a mixed economy ??one in which private enterprise and governmental participation coexist?. Currently Americans? lives are centered on the individual, according to Adam Smith.
Utopian Socialism Essay Research Paper Since the
Utopian Socialism Essay, Research Paper Since the beginning of the idea of money, there have been those who have wealth, and those who want it. Utopian socialism is not a new idea, and it has remained popular since its creation. Many people know what socialism is, but not that many know the principles Utopian Socialism.
Rousseau Essay Research Paper Jean Jacques Rousseau
Rousseau Essay, Research Paper Jean Jacques Rousseau a French philosopher and theorist, has had an effect on societies of in the past by his expression of general will. In the general will freedom and equality are presupposed. Governments of the past and present have had Roussean content. Freedom and equality have presupposed each other by way of the general will and compelled obedience.
Marxism Essay Research Paper Marxism is a
Marxism Essay, Research Paper Marxism is a type of scientific socialism. Karl Marx was a communist used this to differentiate his ideas from the utopian socialist. His main idea was ?Workers of the world unite.? Marx also wrote the book ?The Communist Manifest?, in 1848.
Socialism Essay Research Paper Socialism is in
Socialism Essay, Research Paper Socialism is in the greatest intrest of the public. It calls workers to unite for a better community. This gives them a better work ethic. An early socialist said, “From each according to his ability, to each according to his need.” This is a very accurate summary of the basis of socialism.
Socialism 2 Essay Research Paper There are
Socialism 2 Essay, Research Paper There are many ways that countries are run. Obviously, most are run by officials–but what kind of system do they govern by? Some of the most important systems used today are capitalism, socialism, and communism.
Communism And Socialism Essay Research Paper Communism
Communism And Socialism Essay, Research Paper Communism and Socialism are types of governments that try to keep people equal. These governments grow in popularity when human society is split into the two classes of have and have-nots; thus, a struggle in social classes cause a reformation in the government.
MacKinnon Essay Research Paper Rousseau and Marx
MacKinnon Essay, Research Paper Rousseau and Marx spearhead the movement of the worker. They attempt to alter current, unjust, stifling situations and bring a natural equivalence to all. Yet, throughout their works, they hardly mention the role of women. Marx does, at one point, acknowledge that women should no longer be known as “private”, but as “collective”: open and free to all men.
Women In History Essay Research Paper Equality
Women In History Essay, Research Paper Equality has been a controversial issue ever since time began. Whether it be race, sex, or religion, it has always been an unsettled topic of concern. Equality between men and
All Hail To The Naacp Essay Research
Paper “All Hail to the NAACP” All hail to the to the NAACP- making sure equality is enforced, and social injustice does not prevail. “Founded in 1909 in New York, by a group of black and white citizens in order to ensure the political, educational, social, and economic equality of minority group citizens of the United States and eliminate racial prejudice.
A Socialist Meeting Essay Research Paper SOCIALIST
A Socialist Meeting Essay, Research Paper SOCIALIST MEETING HELD A roar of agreement echoes from every member of the crowd, and is meant for the orator standing on the platform before them. Sweat running from the man s face, he has just delivered an inspiring speech on the advantages of socialism. This man has given similar orations for over twenty days consecutively, for hours on end.
Facism Essay Research Paper Throughout time the
Facism Essay, Research Paper Throughout time the debate upon which is the best system of government has been ongoing. Somewhere between the realms of democracy, socialism, fascism, communism, and monarchism lies the answer to the perfect system. Traditionally speaking, North America has always tried to remain democratic.
Capitalism Essay Research Paper Capitalism faces several
Capitalism Essay, Research Paper Capitalism faces several challenges and problems. Two main problems with capitalism are, property and income become unequal, and major industries suppress small entrepreneurs. The advantage and costs reflects the fist choice of the buyers that want to spend money. Instead the first choice should be more on the people who don?t have money to spend, like the poor.
The Jungle Socialism Essay Research Paper The
The Jungle Socialism Essay, Research Paper The Jungle: Socialism During the late 1800’s and early 1900’s hundreds of thousands of European immigrants migrated to the United States of America. They had aspirations of success, prosperity and their own conception of the American Dream. The majority of the immigrants believed that their lives would completely change for the better and the new world would bring nothing but happiness.
Capitalism Vs Socialism Essay Research Paper In
Capitalism Vs. Socialism Essay, Research Paper In order to debate between Capitalism and Socialism, it is necessary to understand what the differences, advantages, and disadvantages are of both systems. Basically, Capitalism advocates private property, and that society does better when an individual can purchase and produce as they see fit.
Capitalism Vs Socialism Essay Research Paper Christina
Capitalism Vs. Socialism Essay, Research Paper Christina HaselApril 22, 1999Economics Has Capitalism Defeated Socialism? Socialism and capitalism are not on different ends of the Economic Spectrum, but they could be, judging from the way each author defended his opinion and point of view on the subject.
Socialism And Capitalism Essay Research Paper What
Socialism And Capitalism Essay, Research Paper What is the difference between socialism and capitalism? Is socialism more moral than capitalism? To answer these questions we need to look at both systems and there definitions. Socialism is an economic system in which there is no private property and the state owns all the factors of production.
Liberalism Vs Socialism Essay Research Paper Since
Liberalism Vs Socialism Essay, Research Paper Since the new development of ideologies in the nineteenth century, debates over the better political theory is still continued. Socialism and liberalism are two ideologies that attempt to provide a foundation for society, while both are critics of each other.
Equality Essay Research Paper Equality
Equality Essay, Research Paper Equality I have a vision, that all people be treated equally. Race, religion, sex, age, and other petty differences should not mater. Every one has a rite to me
Political Equality Essay Research Paper The beginnings
Political Equality Essay, Research Paper The beginnings of political equality were dim. America was just beginning to set up a political system when ideas of equality began to arise. Questions concerning citizenship, rights, and civil liberties made plans for the American political system seem overwhelmingly complicated.
Sexual Equality And Socialism Essay Research Paper
Sexual Equality and Socialism In her article, “Sexual Equality and Socialism”, Anne Phillips proposes a number of changes in our society necessary for sexual equality to be fully realized. Phillips draws these ideas from a collaboration of socialist and liberal theories, creating a socialist democratic critique.
Equality In Races Essay Research Paper EQUALITY
Equality In Races Essay, Research Paper EQUALITY IN RACES I love being Puertorican and fdo think that we should always be proud of who we are, Hispanics. Also is a great thing and a good oportunity to be citizens of the United States. The problem is that we?ll always be rejected in some states and from people that think that we?re in the states because we want to take their land, works, etc. and that?s not true.
Classical Utilitarianism Essay Research Paper
“Classical Utilitarianism,” by John Rawls This short piece by Rawls makes the point that “utilitarianism does not take seriously the distinction between persons.” This is an intriguing statement and warrants discussion. Rawls view of utilitarianism is that the goal for society is the fulfillment of the maximum satisfaction of all its members.
Freedom Socialist Party Essay Research Paper In
Freedom Socialist Party Essay, Research Paper In 1965, Clara Fraser and her second husband, Richard Fraser, helped lead the Seattle branch of the Socialist Workers Party in an exodus from the national organization. They founded the Freedom Socialist Party, which was marked by its commitment to women’s liberation, African American freedom, revolutionary socialism, societal and organizational democracy, and principled politics.
Should Social Policy Be Concerned With Creating
Equality Essay, Research Paper Social policy covers a social wide range of social welfare provisions,? that the vast majority of society are able use.? As Mishra notes ?social policy? social arrangements,
Race And Freedom Essay Research Paper Freedom
Race And Freedom Essay, Research Paper Freedom is a word that can be spoken and recognized by any man. Throughout history many have fought and died to gain the assurance of freedom and equality. Though the definition of freedom may vary, the general acknowledgement of it is well known. Thomas Jefferson believed that freedom was having unalienable rights that could not be destroyed by any form of government.