Airline Deregulation Essay, Research Paper
On October 24, 1978, President Carter signed into law the Airline Deregulation Act. The purpose of the law was to effectively get the federal government out of the airline business. By allowing the airlines to compete for their customers’ travel dollars, was the thinking, that fares would drop and an increased number of routes would spring up.
Expected Results
The results of airline deregulation speak for themselves. Since the government got out of the airline business, not only has there been a drop in prices and an increase in routes, there has also been a remarkable increase in airline service and safety. Airline deregulation should be seen as the crowning jewel of a federal de-regulatory emphasis. Prices are down: Airline ticket prices have fallen 40% since 1978. Flights are up: The number of annual departures is up from 5 million in 1978 to 8.2 million in 1997. Flights are safer: Before deregulation, there was one fatal accident per 830,000 flights, now the rate is one per 1.4 million flights. So what’s the problem?
Misplaced Priorities
It appears that the Clinton administration and some in Congress will cut off their nose to spite their face. By almost all measurable ways, airline deregulation has been a success. But in response to a few small start-up airlines complaining to the Department of Transportation about "predatory pricing," Washington legislators and regulators are poised to act. "Predatory Pricing" is code for: "fares are too cheap for some airlines to compete in that market ’cause they will lose money". In response, the Department of Transportation recently proposed guidelines to limit the maximum number of seats an airline can offer on particular routes and which forbid them from dropping prices below certain levels, all in the name of "fair" competition. In other words, " we can’t have prices get too cheap because then the Value-Jets of the world won’t be able to jump into the market place." Of course then you would be paying $400 to fly from New York to Boston just for the chance to have a thrill-a-minute ride across New England. But as long as a guy with a pair of Ray-Bans and a crop duster can "compete" with Delta and American, then the D. of T. is happy.
Flying High, What Are They Smoking?
Where is the common sense in the Clinton Administration’s airline policy? The administration claims to desire full competition, but shudders at the one result of competition that truly benefits the consumer – low fares. A drop in fares has been the best result of the Airline Deregulation Act of 1978. It has been the impetus for the increase in the number of flights, which in turn has spurred a drive for greater safety in airlines. But with the current airline market, this development has given us one negative. Since ticket prices have dropped to new lows, the realities of an industry which operates on such economies of scale dictates that only a few competitors have the capacity to operate within the market. This is not the desired effect of either political side on this issue, but it is an economic necessity with the environment that has been created, very similar to that of public utilities and phone companies.
The Best of Both Worlds
The U.S. airline market admittedly operates in an oligarchal fashion. But is this not the best policy for air travel? The success of the large carriers has enabled a drop in fares, and while entry into the market is difficult, it is not impossible. Upstarts such as Southwest Airlines are able to find a market niche and exploit it into profitability. Maybe benevolent oligarchy should be the term…
Turn the Market Loose!
Those in the de-regulation camp see an opportunity to expand on the Deregulation Act. When the act was written, the government was taken out of the business of setting fares and routes. But various municipalities still retain ownership over airports. Given the massive improvements in the airlines since dergulation, why not apply this same thinking to airport ownership? The results should only be more of the same: better service, cheaper prices, and more market freedom.
But the legislation winding its way through the legislative maze that is Congress does anything but move towards increased privatization. S. 1331, sponsored by Senator John McCain (R-AZ), would make it more difficult for large carriers to offer low fares. The justification for this action it to make entry into the market easier, and therefore increase competitiveness within the industry. But while this may enable small airlines to enter markets, it essentially creates an affirmative-action program for corporations that are inefficient by reserving runway space for these airlines.
The only good language in the Senate bill is that which would eliminate perimeter restrictions on Washington’s Ronald Reagan Airport. This would kill the rule that prevents flights to and from National from more than 1250 miles away. While this may just be a measure so that Congressmen won’t have to drive to the out-of-town Dulles Airport in Virginia, it is a good precedent to set for other airports and the elimination of market restrictions.
The House has a companion bill, H.R. 2748, which does not go as far as the Senate bill in its regulatory language. But Speaker Newt Gingrich (R-GA) has predicted that Congress will pass some airline bill this term. A senior aide for a Republican on the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee said, "I don’t know if the two sides will come together this year."
So the legislative status of the re-regulatory fever is still in doubt. But with a Republican Congress which seems to advocate that position, an airline bill could still pass which takes the aviation industry in the wrong direction.
"Problems" in the airline industry have not risen due to too much competition within the industry. To the contrary, Washington regulators should turn the industry loose in any more ways that it can. Lowering restrictions to enter the market place, emphasizing private ownership of aviation matters, and encouraging open and free competition within the scope of anti-trust law should be the goals of the Clinton Administration. Instead of heading towards re-regulation, Washington should get out of the airline business for good.
Другие работы по теме:
The Incident Essay Research Paper Sachi HerreraEnglish
The Incident Essay, Research Paper Sachi Herrera English 1311-10 Dr. Quazi October 16, 2000 The Incident Wow! I have had one of those incredibly weird days. I was coming back from my Prayer and Spirituality class and feeling mediocre as I usually do. I wasn?t expecting anything out of the ordinary to happen to me but something did.
Deaf President Now Essay Research Paper ASL
Deaf President Now Essay, Research Paper ASL 1 4 October 2000 Deaf President Now Protest #2 First of all?I had no clue of how large of an issue The Deaf President Now Protest was. It surprised me that it had not been talked about in my past history classes. The Deaf President Now Protest was so symbolic to that of the Woman?s Rights Movement and Civil Rights Movement.
E E Cummings Essay Research Paper Edward
E E Cummings Essay, Research Paper Edward Estlin Cummings was born in Cambridge, Massachusetts on October 14th, 1894. He was a poet, playwright, prose writer, and painter whose vision found embodiment in an array of artistic devices, where typography, punctuation, grammar, syntax, diction, imagery, and rhythm were often pushed to their limits.
Airline Deregulation Essay Research Paper Give credit
Airline Deregulation Essay, Research Paper Give credit where credit is due. Twenty years ago, the Carter Administration and Congress, behind the ceaseless efforts of Alfred E. Kahn, former chairman of the now defunct CAB (Civil Aeronautics Board), deregulated the airlines, a move that has saved consumers billions of dollars.
Reckless Homicide Essay Research Paper Pilot Charlie
Reckless Homicide Essay, Research Paper Pilot Charlie Ashmore is in deep trouble when he fails a drug test that will suspend him to the Airline Company he works for. He turns to his brother, Michael, an attorney for the Airline Company, for help. Michael hides the positive test results so that Charlie can continue to fly.
German Exports To Rusia Essay Research Paper
German Oct exports to U.S., Russia, UK rise FRANKFURT, Jan 7 (Reuters) – German exports to North America, Japan, Great Britain and Russia rose significantly in October last year,
The Airline Industry Essay Research Paper On
The Airline Industry Essay, Research Paper On December 17, 1903, two men changed the way of travel forever. No, I am not talking about cars or trains. I am talking about one of the greatest inventions of the twentieth century. Wilbur and Orville Wright invented flight. (Grolier, 1999) This invention sparked a concept of traveling in the air.
Bruce Lee Essay Research Paper
“Ticallion Stallion” October 10, 1996 English, 9th Grade Final Bruce Lee This essay is dedicated to Bruce Lee, without a doubt the most famous, skilled, and
Niels Bohr Essay Research Paper October 21
Niels Bohr Essay, Research Paper October 21, 1998 Niels Bohr Niels Bohr was born in Copenhagen, he is the son of a physiology professor, and went to school at the University of Copenhagen, this is where he got his doctorate in 1911.
Letter Essay Research Paper October 16 2000Mrs
Letter Essay, Research Paper October 16, 2000 Mrs. Jensen 319 Bibb Graves Jacksonville, AL 362265 Dear Mrs. Jensen I attended Rome High School of Rome, Ga. Rome High School is about forty-five minutes from Jacksonville. Just head towards Piedmont, Al and then drive straight to Cedartown, Ga. The road signs will lead you there.
California Utility Essay Research Paper Chris Parker
California Utility Essay, Research Paper Chris Parker 482.004 Dr. Singer In 1996 deregulation allowed California utility companies to sell power plants and collect over 19 billion dollars in ratepayer subsidies. The money was used to purchase plants in other countries, reward executives with huge pay raises and buy back stock.
Energy Deregulation Essay Research Paper As we
Energy Deregulation Essay, Research Paper As we have witnessed the rolling blackouts and emergency alerts throughout many parts of our state of California within the past 12 months, there is a question waiting to be answered. Why do we have an energy crisis when there are other states that are doing just fine? Before we come to any hasty conclusion, let us ask ourselves what happened to the energy policy during the mid 90s? During that period the electric utilities went from being highly regulated to being deregulated following the trend in successful deregulation of many industries such as airline and telecommunication industries.
Late 1990s American Essay Research Paper In
Late 1990s American Essay, Research Paper In the late 1990s Americans for the first time found themselves in the position of being able to choose an electricity provider, as the once staid and monopolistic electric utility industry entered an era of freewheeling competition and deregulation. In this book Richard F.
Southwest Airlines Essay Research Paper In lecture
Southwest Airlines Essay, Research Paper In lecture, professor Bobrowski discussed the three components necessary to achieve quality and performance excellence, one of these being continuous improvement. In Nuts!, it is shown how Southwest Airlines gains their competitive advantage by following a policy of continuous improvement.
Is Bigger Really Better Essay Research Paper
?Does Bigger Really Mean Better When looking at the aviation industry?s desire to merge into one mecca airline, a good example is with United Airlines and US Airways, many consumers forget about
Heather Garcia Essay Research Paper On October
Heather Garcia Essay, Research Paper On October 23, Heather Garcia came to our communications class to talk about her experiences working in the field of communications. Ms. Garcia is originally from San Diego, California, and is class of 1998 graduate of Western Kentucky University.
The Best Soccer Player Of All Times
Essay, Research Paper Diego Armando Maradona is the best soccer player of all times. He was born in Villa Fiorito in Argentina on October 30, 1960. Since the World Cup in Mexico (1986), I believe it would be a fair statement to call Maradona the smartest soccer player up to date. Evidence of his creativity will always be remembered with the goal he did against England.
Ketchup Essay Research Paper October 30 2000Ms
Ketchup Essay, Research Paper October 30, 2000 Ms. Peggy Charen 5335 W. Lake Dr. Memphis, TN 65804 Dear Ms. Charen I received your letter concerning the new Ketchup labels. I can see where you are coming from, but can assure you that is not what is happening in our classrooms.
Deregulation Of Natural Gas Essay Research Paper
The Deregulation of the Natural Gas Industry The main objective of my paper is to discuss the key points surrounding the deregulation of the natural gas industry. I will lead into this discussion by explaining how the industry performed during a period of regulation and what transpired forcing a change to deregulate.
Margaret Thatcher Essay Research Paper Margaret ThatcherMargaret
Margaret Thatcher Essay, Research Paper Margaret Thatcher Margaret Thatcher was the longest serving Prime Minister for more than a century and was the first woman to serve as Prime Minister. A graduate of Oxford, with a master of arts degree she worked as a research chemist and a barrister, concentrating on tax law, before being elected to the House of Commons in 1953.
Persuasive Letter Essay Research Paper O
Persuasive Letter Essay, Research Paper O & Y Tax Service October 19, 2000 Hilda Black 622 N. Bank Lane Park Forest, IL 60045 Dear Ms. Black, Thank you for your letter describing the problems about your tax problem. I believe that I informed you of the appropriate charges on your account when you talked to me about the transition you were about to make.
Japanese Deregulation Essay Research Paper JAPAN
Japanese Deregulation Essay, Research Paper JAPAN’S “BIG BANG” FINANCIAL DEREGULATION: IMPLICATIONS FOR REGULATORY AND SUPERVISORY POLICY Former Prime Minister Ryutaro Hashimoto announced that government would undertake an extensive deregulation of Japan’s financial system by 2001 a proposal likened by senior officials to the “Big Bang” financial deregulation in the United Kingdom more than a decade ago.
T E Lawrence Essay Research Paper Colonel
T E Lawrence Essay, Research Paper Colonel T. E. Lawrence, known as Lawrence of Arabia, was a guerrilla leader in the Arab Revolt of 1916-18, which expelled the Turks from western Arabia and
Deregulation Essay Research Paper Electricity is one
Deregulation Essay, Research Paper Electricity is one of the largest selling commodities in the nation. In 1994, over $200 billion worth of electricity was generated and sold. In the same year, $30 billion in cattle were sold, and $6 billion in wheat changed hands.Electricity has traditionally been delivered through a tightly regulated monopoly where corporate profits were artificially established and assured by oversight panels.
Great Depression Essay Research Paper Great Depression
Great Depression Essay, Research Paper Great Depression began in the early 1930’s, and lasted about a decade. The main cause for the Great Depression was the combination of the greatly unequal distribution of wealth throughout the 1920’s and extensive stock market speculation that took place during the later part that same decade.
James Carter Essay Research Paper Jimmy Carter
James Carter Essay, Research Paper Jimmy Carter (James Earl Carter, Jr.), thirty-ninth president of the United States, was born October 1, 1924, in the small farming town of Plains, Georgia, and grew up in the nearby community of Archery. His father, James Earl Carter, Sr., was a farmer and businessman and his mother, Lillian Gordy, a registered nurse.
Article Essay Research Paper EN102018 January 2001The
Article Essay, Research Paper EN1020 18 January 2001 The Article ?British Airways sacks pilots seen drinking before flight?, talks about how pilots abuse the drinking rules set up by the airlines. One of the airlines, British Airways, announced that they had fired two of their pilots because they had been filmed while drinking and they were due to fly the very next day.
American Airlines Essay Research Paper 1 Issues
American Airlines Essay, Research Paper 1. Issues 2. American Airlines? objectives 3. The airline industry 4. Market 5. Consumer needs 6. Brand image 7. Distribution system 8. Pricing 9. Marketing
Northwest Settlement Essay Research Paper Northwest Settlement
Northwest Settlement Essay, Research Paper Northwest Settlement Reached Northwest Airlines and its mechanics agreed to a tentative contract settlement, potentially ending more than four years of talks that ultimately led to White House intervention.