Means A Useful Summary Of Machiavellis The Prince Essay, Research Paper
In Machiavelli’s ‘The Prince’ it would appear, at first, that Machiavelli is advancing the argument that ‘the ends justify the means’. However, I am unsure that this is a useful summary of ‘The Prince’ and that it may be an over simplification and even a misunderstanding.
‘The Prince’ has been condemned for promoting fraud, force, and immorality in politics, justifying the use of evil means by a beneficial end. It has also been associated with corrupt, totalitarian government. Indeed the word Machiavellian refers to cunning, amoral, corrupt opportunistic political practices. ‘The Prince’ was even put on the papal Index of Prohibited Books in 1559 for its lack of conventional morality. This apparent lack of principles appears to be best demonstrated in Machiavelli’s examples; Cesare Borgia, Agothocles and Oliverotto.
Machiavelli in chapter 7 appears to celebrate Cesare Borgia’s policy of having his own minister executed and displayed to absolve him of any cruelty. Having explained to the reader what Cesare Borgia does Machiavelli states “So, now I have surveyed all the actions of the duke, I still cannot find anything to criticise”. Machiavelli even states that one “cannot hope to find a better model to imitate than Cesare Borgia.”
Agathocles’s “bold achievements” were that he “had his soldiers kill all the senators and the richest citizens.” Machiavelli says that “there seems to be no reason why he (Agathocles) should be judged less admirable than any of the finest generals.” Machiavelli even appears to advocate violence in one of his conclusions, in chapter 8; “So the conclusion is: If you take control of a state, you should make a list of all the crimes you have to commit and do them all at once.”
It is, therefore, easy to see why ‘The Prince’ is misinterpreted and summarised by the phrase ‘the ends justify the means’. However, Machiavelli was one of the first political commentators to critically analysis politics in this scientific way. It is this difference that causes the misunderstanding; Machiavelli’s ‘The Prince’, is simply showing how the government actually works in practice, rather than, like the other writers of his time, writing about how it ought to work. This is shown by the quote from chapter 8; “I do not intend to discuss in detail the rights and wrongs of such a policy.”
Through ‘The Prince’, Machiavelli’s goal was to aid the ‘prince’, or would be ‘prince’, to conquer and preserve their state. Machiavelli simple demonstrates that the most effective and easiest way of achieving this is through “well-used cruelty”. This is shown through the examples of kind rulers failing; “Marcus, Pertinax, and Alexander, all of whom were unassuming, lovers of justice, haters of cruelty, sympathetic and kind, all came, apart from Marcus, to a tragic end.” This is effectively summarised by; “there are some ways of behaving that are supposed to be virtuous, but will lead to your downfall, and others that are supposed to be wicked, but will lead to your welfare and peace of mind.” In this way ‘The Prince’ uses historic and contemporary examples of what policies for ruling a state are effective and which ways simply do not work.
‘The Prince’ was undoubtedly written about monarchies not republics; “I shall omit any discussion on republics as I have discussed them fully elsewhere”; and as such it was intended to aid the monarch/prince (the Medici family in particular) in conquering and preserving a state of their own. Therefore, the summary ‘the ends justify the means’ is not a useful summary of ‘The Prince’. It may, however, represent the ideas and values held by the monarchs/princes of the 16th century. It is not a useful summary as far as the judgement over whether to follow the ‘cruel’ or ‘kind’ way of ’statecraft’ is not decided in ‘The Prince’, which simply shows that the most efficient/effective and easiest way for achieving this may well be through following a more cruel, deceptive and ‘cunning’ policy.
Другие работы по теме:
Билеты по химии
и частичные ответы на некоторые из них Билет №1 Простые вещества . Количество вещества. Число Авогадро. Качественный анализ анионов и катионов. Билет №2
БД Информационная система Железнодорожная станция
Составить » используя СУБД Microsoft Access Необходимо разработать информационную систему, обслуживающая пассажиров на предмет покупки билетов и получения информации о тех или иных составах. Система не привязана к конкретной станции и, тем самым с любой станции можно купить билет на любой состав, как следующий через эту станцию, так и не следующий, но внесённый в систему.
The system of english tenses
IRREQULAR VERBS become begin bend bite blow break bring build catch choose come cost draw dream drink drive fall feed feel fight find forget give have hear
Religion Paper Essay Research Paper
“Food is for the belly and the belly for food, you say. True; and one day God will put an end to both. But the body is not for fornication; it is for the Lord–and the Lord for the body.” 1st Corinthians 6:13 The Broadman Bible Commentary In the Broadman Commentary it talks most about how the Corinthians were using a phrase of the day to justify the practice of sexual immoralities.
Machiavelli Essay Research Paper When an action
Machiavelli Essay, Research Paper When an action is described as Machiavellian, there are often times negative connotations associated with the specific deed. Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin may be described as Machiavellian because they went to great lengths to attain their goal. The two pillaged and murdered ruthlessly to produce visible results.
Madame Meursault
’s Stranger Essay, Research Paper Meursault, a young man living in Algiers, receives a report of his mother Madame Meursault’s funeral. He attends her funeral, but he does not show any outward signs of
How Tv Impacts Teens Essay Research Paper
Bud…Weis… Er! This is a phrase that teenagers hear everyday. Where do they hear this? They hear it on TV. It is a phrase used in a commercial for beer. This phrase is used to attract people s attention including teenagers. This is one of many problems with TV these days. TV teaches teens the wrong material. Some of the other problems with TV include violence and dialogue.
The Watchmen Essay Research Paper In Alan
The Watchmen Essay, Research Paper In Alan Moore?s The Watchmen, Moore presents the reader with two drastically different characters who have one strikingly similar trait. Ozymandias is a handsome, rich, public, and powerful man. Rorschach is an ugly, poor, private, and almost worthless man. Despite all of these contrasts, they share a common philosophy: they believe that the ends justify the means.
Bill Of Rights And Constitution Essay Research
Paper First of all as for the long quote on the term paper handout, I would have to agree with it due to the fact that it was probably written back in the days and back then this quote would justify many issues and arguments. I agree with the quote due to the fact that there were many criminals back then and harder to control, such as the Ku Klux Klan where they had control over certain things.
My Life A Perilous Journey Essay Research
Paper My Life: A Perilous Journey A perilous journey; the perfect phrase to describe my entire eighteen year life. As far back as I can recall, I have been running into numerous trials and
Contrast In Do Not Weep Maiden For
War Is Kind Essay, Research Paper Contrast in “Do Not Weep, Maiden, for War Is Kind” In the poem “Do Not Weep, Maiden, for War Is Kind” by Stephen Crane, contrast is used to make a statement about the war. The poem shows the different view points of the war, how different people involved in the war, took the war.
Mercantilism Essay Research Paper Mercantilism as a
Mercantilism Essay, Research Paper Mercantilism as a global economic policy tends to subscribe to the following premises: wealth is an essential means to power, power is essential as a means to the acquisition of wealth, wealth and power are each proper ultimate ends of national policy, and there is a long run balance of trade between these ends.
Is Mark Hulliung Right About Machiavelli Essay
, Research Paper Is Hulliung right? Hulliung discusses how people understand Machiavelli and what he thinks of some of Machiavelli?s concepts. In the chapter of ?interpreting Machiavelli?, Hulliung argues in the issues of means and ends, idealism Vs realism, political violence and weather Machiavelli is a pagan.
Speeding Tickets Essay Research Paper The popular
Speeding Tickets Essay, Research Paper The popular movie “Top Gun” coined a phrase that reads “I feel the need, the needfor speed.” Many drivers today would agree with that phrase. Speeding is one of themost common ways that people break the law. When people break the law there areunpleasant consequences.
The Night Nurse Essay Research Paper The
The Night Nurse Essay, Research Paper The Night Nurse Grace has many meanings in the English language today. One of these meanings is to be pardoned from one?s actions. In ?The Night Nurse,? by Joyce Carol Oates, Grace
Euthanasia Essay Research Paper In rare instances
Euthanasia Essay, Research Paper In rare instances, societies justify killing. It is accepted in war, in self-defense, and, within the United States, for punishment of awful crimes. This week, the Supreme Court considers another exception: whether doctors should be allowed to speed the end for people who are terminally ill.
The Qualities Of The Prince Essay Research
Paper Essay on Niccolo Machiavelli Niccolo Machiavelli recommends a very practical course of action for the prince: obtain power by direct and effective means, which is necessary. In the story "The Qualities of the Prince" by Niccoli Machiavelli, the concept "The ends justify the means" is saying that a prince should hold absolute control of their territories, and they should use any means of resort necessary to accomplish this end, including violence and deception.
Those Winter Sundays Essay Research Paper Joshua
?Those Winter Sundays? Essay, Research Paper Joshua Erd, Box 630 Fawn Knight ASEN 101-02 29 November 2000 Those Winter Sundays Review The poem of ?Those Winter Sundays? has a very interesting and peculiar ending. The author of the poem leaves the ending open. By an open ending I mean the author ends the poem with a question.
The Prince Essay Research Paper The PrinceThe
The Prince Essay, Research Paper The Prince The Prince had no actual characters, but instead discussed and analyzed the political policies of political leaders, highlighting their faults and strengths. The setting was 1513 Europe. This is the same time when major areas were having power struggles and religious conflict was rampant.
Carpe Diem Dead Poet Society Essay Research
Paper Carpe diem Carpe Diem; seize the day capture it by the ears. Dead poets society the movie focuses on this phrase. Suck the marrow out of life according to Mr. Keaton this phrase meant to not ever let a day pass with out you. Problems such as death of a student Neil Perry, the expulsion and Keaton fired were all the bad things that happened because of carpe diem.
Reapers Essay Research Paper ReapersJean Toomer
Reapers Essay, Research Paper ReapersJean Toomer’s poem “Reapers” brings a sense of death to the reader’s mind. The speaker conveys a dark mood and setting. That setting and mood provide imagery that virtually takes the reader along on this journey with Death himself. As a reader you start to feel a sense of despair.
Society Is Evil Essay Research Paper Humans
Society Is Evil Essay, Research Paper Humans are both good and evil. I heard somebody say that society makes you evil, but I don?t agree. Society labels you as evil. Con-artists are at
Education Today Essay Research Paper Testing today
Education Today Essay, Research Paper Testing today has taken over schools. The pressure of society for a person to strive to reach the best schools and therefore the best education, to do this your test scores have to be the best. This brings up the question on weather or not the highest test scores show who the smartest people really are? These high test scores raise the question, does the school you go to have an influence on how you do on your tests.
To Speed Or Not To Speed Essay
, Research Paper The popular movie, “Top Gun” coined a phrase that reads “I feel the need, the need for speed.” Many drivers today would agree with that phrase. Speeding is one of the most common ways that people break the law. When people break the law there are
Analysis Essay Research Paper In her poem
Analysis Essay, Research Paper In her poem One Perfect Rose, Dorothy Parker misleads the reader throughout the first and second stanzas into believing this poem is a romantic tribute to a tender moment from her past through her word choice and style of writing. However, the tone of the entire poem dramatically changes upon reading the third and final stanza when Parker allows the reader to understand her true intention of the poem, which is a cynical and perhaps bewildered view of the memory.
Civil Liberties And CrimeThrough Reducing Crime Can
We Still Keep Liberty? Essay, Research Paper Do the ends justify the means? Upon first contemplation of how it could be thought that by reducing crime one takes away liberty, I was confounded. I couldn’t envision a situation where it would be necessary to remove liberty in order to reduce and possibly even eliminate crime.
Rawls Essay Research Paper Can the Unjust
Rawls Essay, Research Paper Can the Unjust be Rectified Can the Unjust Be Rectified? Robert Nozick, in his essay Rights and the Entitlement Theory, discusses the rights of individuals and just acquisition. He makes it clear that these rights and/or acquisitions cannot be taken away by anyone, either by an individual or by a collective identity such as the state.