Stalin Essay, Research Paper
Thesis Statement: Stalin’s plan of collectivization did not help but rather hurt Russia’s
chances of becoming an affluent nation, free of agricultural plights.
Outline
I. Introduction
II. Collectivism and it’s problems
A. Stalin’s declaration of collectivism
1. Procedures within the system
B. The Kulaks
C. ‘Dekulakization’ (the disposing of the kulaks)
1. Clearing them away from collectivism
D. Problems of collectivism after the Kulaks
1. The famine
E. Results of famine
1. Government reaction
2. Peasants reaction
III. Stalin’s feelings on occurrences during collectivism
IV. Failure of the early years of collectivism
A. Advantages of collectivism for Stalin
B. Stalin’s reasoning for collectivism
C. Collectivism as a waste
V. Conclusion
Abie Heiney
W. History Term Paper
3/27/’97
Mrs. Glickman
Collectivism Under Stalin
Collectivism, ‘a political or economic theory advocating collective control over production and distribution’ (Conquest 146), in Stalin’s mind, was the key to curing the agricultural ailment in Russia and in turn making Russia a more successful and powerful nation. Stalin’s plan to collectivize did not help but rather hurt Russia’s chances of becoming an affluent nation, free of agricultural plights. His methods were so inhumane that any morally correct person would never condone his outrageous behavior.
In May of 1928 Stalin decided that he wanted to take on a new form of agriculture, that which was collectivized. It required the peasants “to move lock, stock, and barrel to new farms which would be owned equally by every member, run cooperatively, and forced to hand over a certain amount of grain to the state each year.” The government felt that with the modern machinery they would be capable of producing more food with fewer workers. Individuality no longer remained in the world of agriculture in Russia, no independent selling, and no more New Economic Policy (N.E.P.), which was issued by Lenin in reaction to the post-revolution setbacks in agriculture and was considered capitalistic. It was a successful program which Stalin decided to do away with to help support his plans. Stalin said “The pause has finished, and we are returning to socialism and communism” in reaction to the N.E.P (Lewis 59-61).
There was only one thing that stood in the way of Stalin pursuing his dream and that was the Kulaks, who were the wealthier class peasants. The Kulaks, unwilling to give up the grain, which they had produced, to the Bolsheviks, started to assiduously hide it (Radzinsky 141). They did not support the plan of collectivism since they would end up having to give up their hardly acquired land and let the Soviet government become their landlords which they found to be unjust. The Kulaks were also ordered to sell the grain to the government at a low price, but they refused and Stalin felt that something had to be done about these troublesome people (Conquest 147).
Stalin’s decision on how to deal with the disagreeing Kulaks was extremely immoral. He made a plan of ‘Dekulakization’, which was the dispersing of all Kulaks from the collective farms along with anything that had to do with the plan of collectivization. In reaction the Kulaks destroyed all their crops and livestock in protest. Many of the Kulaks were forced into labor camps while others had to face their fate in the horrible death camps. The anti-kulak campaign death toll came to a rough three million people (McNeal 129-131). “Just as the German’s proclaimed that Jews are not human beings. Thus did Lenin and Stalin proclaim, Kulaks are not human beings (Conquest 160).”
Now that the Kulaks were no longer a problem Stalin thought that everything would begin to run smoothly, but he was wrong. Along with the Kulaks went the extreme farming skills they had acquired which the lower class peasants did not possess. In result the lack of efficient farmers lead to the lack of grain, and finally a devastating famine broke out among the collective farms which in no way helped the agricultural dilemma but rather deepened the predicament (Lewis 65).
There was total chaos among the peasants. Many people died every day.
A schoolgirl stated “In 1933 it really was frightening. Every day somebody did not show up for school. The children were very scared and all swollen up. I’ll never forget this. There were a lot of them who died in our class (Lewis 66).”
Around the mid-1930’s peasants started to realize that all of their hard work did not pay off because all of their produce was taken by the government and in reaction they ceased in the amount of effort they put into the collective farming (De Jong 236).
The government did not care about the people during the famine. A lot of the grain that they had, they exported, and all the leftovers were left in granaries to spoil or given to feed city workers. They made it illegal to eat any crops in the field and if one happened to violate this law they would be deported to a prison camp in Siberia. The people consumed anything that seemed edible that they could possibly get their feeble hands upon. One man even resorted to killing his own child for it’s meat (Lewis 66).
How did Stalin feel about all of this confusion? Truthfully, he really did not care. Stalin felt that it was the people’s faults because of their inexperience of knowing how to run the fields; he wanted them to realize that it was also the Kulaks fault for resisting the plans of collectivization, resulting in not being able to help the peasants make the fields more productive (Lewis 68).
Collectivization as a whole was not a success in improving Russia’s agricultural difficulties at the time, nor did it help the country to become a more powerful nation. The only thing collectivization proved was that Stalin had a massive amount of power in the way he ran the country. Stalin cared little about anyone other than himself after the death of his first wife. He said “This creature softened my heart of stone. She died and with her died my last warm feeling for people (Lewis 21).” Obviously all Stalin cared about was to improve the problems in the country even if it meant the death of many people because in 1932-33 about seven million people died in the treacherous famine, and a total of at least seventeen million died from 1929-1940 (Lewis 109). “A single death is a tragedy, a million deaths is a statistic (”Stalin” Com. Soft.).”
Considering all of the extreme downfalls collectivization caused upon Russia why would Stalin have ever thought of doing it in the first place? and why would he deport the most ablest farm workers? It is said that Stalin felt that the lower and middle-class peasants would be capable of handling the idea of collectivism and also Stalin might not have been thinking only about collectivism. Stalin was also worrying about a possible future uprising by the peasants, so by running collectivism he would have an absolute power over those people (De Jonge 236-237).
For several years Stalin’s collectivization plan ran the country’s agriculture to a massive low. It in no way helped the post revolutionary agricultural problems because when Stalin finally got his way in 1938 and ninety percent of all peasants lived on collective farms the production increased to the way it was before the plans of collectivization even started in 1928. The early years of collectivization caused an enormous amount of death in the Russian peasant population and did not accomplish Stalin’s goals of better production (Tucker 347).
Stalin’s ideas were looked at as a good way to make Russia’s agriculture more productive but actually it really started a civil war between peasants and the government.
The disposing of unwilling people turned out to be a bloody massacre not a productive plan (Deutscher 324).
Collectivism as a whole from 1928 to 1938 was a complete failure in increasing the productivity of agriculture in Russia and making it an affluent nation. A huge famine broke out, many people perished, a small war began, and agricultural production dropped. Stalin wasted ten years of precious time to run the country’s agriculture into the ground and later bring it back up to the level it was at before. Would one call that an accomplishment? Would one think it helped Russia in any way? Would one say that what Stalin had done was irrational and immoral? and finally Was Stalin’s collectivization plans really about helping the agricultural problems? Or not.
Conquest, Robert. Stalin: Breaker of Nations. New York: Penguin Group,
1991.
De Jonge, Alex. Stalin and the Shaping of the Soviet Union. New York:
William Morrow and Company Incorporated, 1986.
Deutscher, Isaac. Stalin. New York, Oxford University Press, 1967.
Lewis, Jonathan and Phillip Whitehead. Stalin: A Time for Judgement. New
York: Random House, 1990.
McNeil, Robert H. Stalin Man and Ruler. New York: New York University
Press, 1988.
Radzinsky, Edvard. Stalin. New York: Doubleday, 1996.
“Stalin, Josef.” Microsoft Bookshelf’s Bartlett’s Familiar Quotations. Computer software. . Power CD, ‘93 ed. IBM, PC Windows 3.1, CD-ROM.
Tucker, Robert. Stalin as Revolutionary. New York: W.W. Norton and
Company, 1973.
Works Cited
Conquest, Robert. Stalin: Breaker of Nations. New York: Penguin Group,
1991.
De Jonge, Alex. Stalin and the Shaping of the Soviet Union. New York:
William Morrow and Company Incorporated, 1986.
Deutscher, Isaac. Stalin. New York, Oxford University Press, 1967.
Lewis, Jonathan and Phillip Whitehead. Stalin: A Time for Judgement. New
York: Random House, 1990.
McNeil, Robert H. Stalin Man and Ruler. New York: New York University
Press, 1988.
Radzinsky, Edvard. Stalin. New York: Doubleday, 1996.
“Stalin, Josef.” Microsoft Bookshelf’s Bartlett’s Familiar Quotations. Computer software. . Power CD, ‘93 ed. IBM, PC Windows 3.1, CD-ROM.
Tucker, Robert. Stalin as Revolutionary. New York: W.W. Norton and
Company, 1973.
Другие работы по теме:
Napoleon And Stalin Essay Research Paper Napoleon
Napoleon And Stalin Essay, Research Paper Napoleon and Stalin: In his Communist Manifesto, Karl Marx described his vision of the future, where the proletariat, or working class, rises up to topple the bourgeoisie and create a society without social classes. The Russian revolution of 1917, led by Vladimir Lenin, attempted to do just that.
The Big Three Essay Research Paper the
The Big Three Essay, Research Paper the big three leaders of world war 2 are stalin, roosevelt, and churchill. They allied together to dfeat hitler. Stalin lead the russians.
Joseph Stalin And Adolph Hitler Essay Research
Paper 3-2-98 Joseph Stalin and Adolph Hitler Once lived the two most horrible people on earth. Both of those people were leaders of a country and both of them killed millions and millions of people just to rise to power. Their names are Adolph Hitler and Joseph Stalin.
STALIN TAKES OVER RUSSIANS Essay Research Paper
There are many people in Russia who don?t agree with Stalin or any of his policies. This upset the leader and he wanted to crush this opposition the only way he knew how– terror. The program of terror he began was called ?The Great Purge?. He even formed a secret police.
Soviet Leaders Essay Research Paper When you
Soviet Leaders Essay, Research Paper When you are talking about the Soviet people and say that they are non-political people who don’t believe in ideology you need to examine it more. From the time the Soviet Society evolved into the communist society that they were until they lost the stigma of being a communist society these statements were by and large true.
Animal Farm Stalin And Napoleon Essay Research
Paper The novel Animal Farm, by George Orwell, was an allegory about the Russian Revolution in which the author used a farm and it?s members to symbolize major characters and their actions. In this composition, I will reveal to you many of Joseph Stalin? s important contributions and how they relate to the actions of Napoleon from Animal Farm.
Stalin Essay Research Paper Joseph Stalin an
Stalin Essay, Research Paper Joseph Stalin, an official of the Communist party, was the successor of Lenin after his death. His goal was to continue what Lenin had left behind ? that is to build a classless society in which the means of production were in the hands of the people.
Stalin As A Continuation Of Lenin Essay
, Research Paper Stalin as a continuation of Lenin Communism is like a mining town. The government owns the people. They are forced to buy government food, work for the government, and follow what the government says, or else. No one can escape because their pachecks come from the same people they pay, causing them to did themselves deeper and deeper into debt.
Stalin His Life Essay Research Paper No
Stalin His Life Essay, Research Paper No man more fully epitomized this era than Joseph Stalin did. As political, economic, and social leader, Joseph Stalin has emotionally, physically, psychologically, politically, economically, and socially affected Russia even to this day.
Stalinism 2 Essay Research Paper Stalinism To
Stalinism 2 Essay, Research Paper Stalinism. To mention this term, this policy, is to evoke panic and fright in almost all Russians. Stalin rose to become the dictator of Russia in 1929, and remained in that position until 1953. He morphed the Soviet Union from what was once one of the world’s most underdeveloped countries to one of the greatest in industrialization. “Socialism in one country” was his policy, and it quickly became a ubiquitous law.
Stalin And Trotsky Vs Piggy And Jack
Essay, Research Paper Lord Of The Flies vs. U.S.S.R leaders The events in Lord of the Flies seem to model what happened in the struggle for power in the U.S.S.R. in the mid-1920’s. Both show what happens when dissension grows and people get desperate. There is an obvious battle between good and evil. In the beginning of the novel, there is one group, where all the boys essentially work together, and there is order and peace.
Stalin Essay Research Paper Rule Under StalinIn
Stalin Essay, Research Paper Rule Under Stalin In one point in Russia a man with the name John Stalin ruled. He was supposed to be a great ruler. He had many ideas for the country, which before his rule was run in the worst of ways.
Stalin And The Ussr Essay Research Paper
Stalin, Joseph Vissarionovich 1879-1953, Russian revolutionary, head of the USSR (1924-53). A Georgian cobbler’s son named Dzhugashvili, he joined the Social-Democratic party
Essay Writing Essay Research Paper email 7cdgqlinkqueensucaEssay
Essay Writing Essay, Research Paper email: 7cdg@qlink.queensu.caEssay Writing An essay is a literary composition. The purpose of a good formal essay is to try out an idea, thesis, or opinion, within the confines of a proper literary composition. To do this successfully one must know their topic, formulate a thesis, and finally write the essay.
During The Time Leading Up To World
War Ii Essay, Research Paper During the time leading up to World War II, there were two leaders who were on rival sides, the men were Adolph Hitler and Joseph Stalin. These men were each dominate in their rise to power. These two leaders were similar in the ways that they achieved their objectives. Their success was mostly identified by their new ideas and strong political stances.
The Impact That Stalin Had On Russia
And The Russian People Essay, Research Paper Stalin ruled Russia from 1928 to 1953. He had some short-term impact on Russia but he was single-minded and not pragmatic- unlike Lenin-
A Comparison Of Animal Farm And The
Russian Revolution Essay, Research Paper George Orwell?s controversial novel ?Animal Farm? has often been thought of as Orwell?s opinions, or interpretations of historical events that happened around the time it was written. The historical event that it is most often compared to is the Russian Revolution. ?Animal Farm? and the Russian Revolution have many similarities and ideas.
Joseph Stalin The Most Infamous Leader Essay
, Research Paper In 1879 on Dec 21 Joseph Stalin was born he ended up dying in 1953 on March 5th. That was only the begging. He grew up and had become one of the undisputed leaders of the USSR from 1929 till his death.
Life Of Joseph Stalin Essay Research Paper
The Life Of Joseph Stalin The “Man of Steel,” or Stalin, was born in Georgia, was educated at the Tiflis Theological Seminary from which he was expelled for “propagating Marxism.” He joined the Bolshevik underground and was arrested and transported to Siberia. He escaped in 1904. The ensuing years witnessed his closer identification with revolutionary Marxism, his many escapes from captivity, his growing intimacy with Lenin and Bukharin, his early disparagement of Leon Trotsky, and his co-option, in 1912, to the illicit Bolshevik Central Committee.
Joseph Stalin Essay Research Paper Joseph StalinJoseph
Joseph Stalin Essay, Research Paper Joseph Stalin Joseph Stalin is credited as being one of the most powerful leaders of all time. He helped his country, the Soviet Union, become a dominating world power. Born on December 21, 1879 under his original name Iosif Vissarionovich Dzhugashvili, he renamed himself Stalin meaning “man of steel.” Stalin was the unchallenged leader of the USSR from 1929 until his death in 1953.
The Man Of Steel Essay Research Paper
I am a person who believes that all people should be treated fairly. I believe in the freedom of thought, the freedom of religion, the freedom of speech, but most of all the freedom to control ones own destiny. During his dictatorship Joseph Stalin stripped his people not only of freedom of thought, religion and speech, but of many other rights as well.
Animal Farm And The Russian Revolution Essay
, Research Paper Animal Farm and the Russian Revolution have many similarities and ideas. The characters, settings, and the plots are the same. In addition Animal Farm is a satire and allegory of the Russian
Animal Farm Essay Research Paper Although George
Animal Farm Essay, Research Paper Although George Orwell was a Socialist, he was critical of Communism. He hated totalitarianism, and it has been said that his “Animal Farm” was written as a biting satire of the 1917 Russian Revolution. In fact, many of the characters in “Animal Farm” are thought to be caricatures of the main figures of the Russian Revolution.
Stalins Purge The Greater Holocaust Essay Research
Paper Joseph Stalin was ruler of the Soviet Union from 1929-1953. While he was in power the Great Depression devastated the world economy, the Nazis invaded the U.S.S.R., Berlin was cut off from the rest
Joseph Stalin Essay Research Paper Joseph StalinStalin
Joseph Stalin Essay, Research Paper Joseph Stalin Stalin was a dictator of the U.S.S.R from 1929 until 1953. He rose from bitter poverty to become ruler of the country that covered one sixth of all the land area in the
Joseph Stalin 2 Essay Research Paper JOSEPH
Joseph Stalin 2 Essay, Research Paper JOSEPH STALIN: TYRANT OF STEEL Iosef Vissarionovich Dzhugashvili (a.k.a. Joseph Stalin), was the undisputed leader of the Soviet Union from 1929 to 1953. Although Stalin s reign in power did not begin immediately his contribution to government began in 1912, and from then on he slowly rose to the high chain of command.
Stalin Essay Research Paper Joseph Stalin lived
Stalin Essay, Research Paper Joseph Stalin lived from 1879 till 1953. Stalin was one of the most ruthless communist dictators of all time. After Lenin?s death, Stalin pushed his way to the top and was set out to make the Soviet Union into an industrial power.
Stalin 2 Essay Research Paper Stalin In
Stalin 2 Essay, Research Paper Stalin In History Of the many noted dictators in history, Stalin will go down as one of the most, if not the most formidable. He personally had
Catherine II And Stalin Essay Research Paper
Catherine II (the Great) and Joseph Stalin were both leaders of Russia that demonstrated an awareness of the West. They tried to emulate some of the elements of the West while purposely neglecting others. For
Operation Barbarossa Essay Research Paper Operation BarbarossaOn
Operation Barbarossa Essay, Research Paper ?Operation Barbarossa? On June 22, 1941 Operation Barbarossa took the Soviets by surprise. By blitzkrieg tactics, the three million Germans strong force struck deep into Russia, capturing whole Russian armies. Though expecting the raid, Russian president, Josef Stalin, was forced to sacrifice huge numbers of troops to stop the Germans’ approach.
Untitled Essay Research Paper Stalin Essay
Untitled Essay, Research Paper Stalin Essay Much like Adolf Hitler, Joseph Stalin was one of the most ruthless and diabolical people in the history of the world. Hitler once said of Stalin, ” He is a beast, but he’s a beast on a grand scale who must command our unconditional respect. In his own way, he is a hell of a fellow!” (Stalin Breaker of Nations, p.xvi) What Hitler said of Stalin is only his opinion, and it is not a valid one at that.
Stalins Rise To Power Essay Research Paper
Rise to Power Stalin first became interested in politics when as a theology student; he began reading illegal the works of political philosopher Karl Marx. He eventually gave up his religious education to devote his time to the revolutionary movement against the Russian monarchy. After becoming involved in the movement, Stalin joined the Russian Social Democratic Labor Party.