Comparison Between Marie Colvin and
Primo Levi s Journalistic Works
In this essay I will compare the ways in which two journalists have managed to give reportage of an event. The first reportage is by Marie Colvin and the text is known as Baghdad under fire . The second is by Primo Levi and the text is known as On The Bottom . These two pieces are quite different in their actual subject matters and also in the way that they are expressed. Colvin s intentions were, by writing this piece to expose some of the realities of the Allied (mainly American) bombing campaign. The facts were very often silenced and or blurred in order to keep the general public supporting the war effort. The realities were that many innocent civilians were also being killed or having their livelihoods ruined. Colvin wanted to allow the general public to be able to see through the propaganda circulating at the time. Levi has written On the Bottom in an attempt to expose the truths about what happened to Jews in concentration camps. He also wants to tell other people how he is feeling, as he is clearly disturbed by what he has been through. Perhaps he believed that by expressing himself in this way he might rid himself of an emotional burden.
During the course of reading the two reports the biggest thing to strike me was the very clear difference in the way in which the author involved him/herself with the presentation of the fact. Levi makes no secret of his emotional feelings, especially here:
We Italians had decided to meet every Sunday evening in a corner of the Lager, but we stopped it at once, because it was too sad to count our numbers and find fewer each time
To me this shows that Levi is showing direct emotional involvement. This is not necessarily a good thing as it may well have clouded his judgement and made the entire piece useless if trying to use it to show a true representation of the Holocaust, for the piece may well be biased. While Colvin s Baghdad under fire may well be biased, the way in which the piece is expressed could not be any more different to that of Primo Levi. Colvin decided to adopt a completely deadpan style of reporting, with no direct emotional involvement. This is shown very clearly here:
Hussein agonised. Baghdad was home; perhaps thieves would come to the empty souk and steal his carpets; but there was no business anyway because everybody was hoarding their money.
She has however chosen the people whom she interviews whom she feels will best express her own views. This means that Colvin does not appear to for or against either the allies or Saddam. I do feel though that Colvin indirectly expresses her emotions, again, by interviewing those who will show this, for example:
My taxi driver . said he was not at the front because he had a piece of shrapnel in his head.
Because Colvin is reporting about destroyed civilian homes, dead civilians, civilians having to leave Baghdad, civilians being forced into bankruptcy and the like it seems to shows that she accepts these things as facts which people outside of Iraq needed informing of, i.e. they did not know; maybe she herself didn t know of these facts before she arrived. When she describes the damage caused by missiles and bombs she really is showing her private view, which is not shared by the general public. The general public were fed with strings of lies, especially about the accuracy of cruise missiles. Levi does not seem show any surprises he may have had during his stay in Auschwitz. I think that this is because nobody tried to keep the nazi s activities secret from the Jews.
Clearly they will kill us, whoever thinks they will not is mad, it means he has swallowed the bait, but I have not;
Levi uses other characters in his report to mirror his own thoughts. For example:
There is nowhere to look in a mirror, but our appearance stands in front of us, reflected in a hundred livid faces, in a hundred sordid puppets.
Here Levi has said this because he is trying to show that they have been stripped of all, even their own individuality. In Baghdad under fire , Colvin again uses characters she meets to show her own opinions, as said previously. Surprisingly, Levi does not mention any characters from public life, other than the SS in the camp, whereas Colvin constantly refers to prominent figures. I think that this is because Levi wants to show the camp worker s lack of any connections to the outside world; they had no knowledge of any activities going on outside of the camp. Colvin mentions prominent public figures as many people from allied countries were very interested as to why a dictator such as Saddam Hussein had so much public support.
I think that Colvin was very concerned that the public view was inconsistence with what was actually happening. The same applies to Levi, whom I think wanted to make sure that nobody was under any sort of delusion of the goings on in work camps in that area, at that time. Colvin s point of view can be seen when she goes into great detail of the effect of the allied bombing campaign. Levi uses this statement which I thought made it very clear what his point of view of the camp was:
this is not a sanatorium, the only exit is by way of the Chimney.
Levi was indeed concerned that public get to know what happened in the work camps, as I believe he thought it would allow for a more peaceful world.
The language that Levi uses in his reportage makes everything somehow seem as though the events he describes are nothing out of the ordinary. He tends to avoid showing his own emotion, which leads to a seemingly emotionless piece; of course Levi is very much emotionally affected. Perhaps Levi is trying to make sure that the reader makes up his own mind. This is of course a basic rule of good journalism. Colvin does the same thing, except for she seems even more deed pan because the material she has produced is very controversial, yet she sees no need to back this up with her own emotions, simply what she says she sees.
To conclude, both writers have produced excellent accounts of several very different experiences and events yet have both used some of the same basic methods of expressing themselves, despite Levi giving a subjective account while Colvin gave an very objective account.
Другие работы по теме:
Comparison Contrast Essay Research Paper When one
Comparison Contrast Essay, Research Paper When one is deciding to purchase new furniture there are many options that one can take. One can buy furniture unassembled and assemble it themselves, or you can buy it pre-assembled. But which way is the most efficient way? I feel that buying pre-assembled furniture is a much more efficient method.
The Stranger 2 Essay Research Paper Albert
The Stranger 2 Essay, Research Paper Albert Camus novel, The Stranger, examines what happens to a passive man when mixed in a murder. During the trial of the main character, Meursault, the prosecutor examines Meursault s normal behavior as callous and cold. In order for the prosecutor to have a case in the reader s mind, Camus must create the past that the trial calls for.
Women And Shopping Essay Research Paper What
Women And Shopping Essay, Research Paper What motivates women to shop? I attempted to answer the age old question by surveying five ladies who are self-proclaimed experts at the “art” of shopping. These five ladies, Joanne, Kim, Marie, Shirley, and Kimmie sat down with me individually and this is what I basically gathered from the discussion sessions.
Condorcet Essay Research Paper Marie Jean Antoine
Condorcet Essay, Research Paper Marie Jean Antoine Nicolas de Caritat, better known as Marquis de Condorcet, was born in Ribemont, Paris. He studied at Jesuit schools and the college de Navarre and
Le Rossignol Essay Research Paper Le Rossignol
Le Rossignol Essay, Research Paper Le Rossignol est un lai de Marie de France qui s?etait traduire en vers romans de huit syllables entre les annee 1160 et 1180. Dans Le Rossignol, Marie de France examine l?amour courtois et l?amour de la court qui observe des regles. Un exemple de ses regles s?appele **Traite de l?amour ?courtois?** de Andre Le Chapelain qui nous avons deja lu en classe.
Pierre Curie Essay Research Paper Born in
Pierre Curie Essay, Research Paper Born in 1859 in Paris, Pierre Curie was a French physicist who spent a great deal of his life dealing in the fields of chemistry and physics. During his lifetime, he was known for his work in radioactivity, magnetism, piezoelectric effect, and his work and studies with his wife Marie Curie in discovering new elements on the periodic table.
Marie Curie Essay Research Paper Why was
Marie Curie Essay, Research Paper Why was Marie Curie a significant woman in European Science? Marie Curie was the most successful scientist to come out of Poland. She saw science as a beauty that she wanted to withhold.# Science to her was an unknown fairy tale phenomena that she was determined to discover.
Marie Curie Essay Research Paper Marie CurieMarie
Marie Curie Essay, Research Paper Marie Curie Marie Curie was born in Warsaw on November 7, 1867. She was actually born to the name Marja Sklodowska. When she was 24, she went to Paris where she changed her name to Marie and started school in Sorbonne. In 1893, she received her degree in physics. When she needed a lab to experiment in, a Professor Kovalski said that there might be space in the School of Physics and Chemistry.
Marie Curie Essay Research Paper MARIE CURIELIFE
Marie Curie Essay, Research Paper MARIE CURIE LIFE OF MARIE CURIE Marie Curie(1867-1934) was a French physicist with many accomplishments in both physics and chemistry. Marie and her husband Pierre, who was also a French physicist, are both famous for their work in radioactivity.
Marie Curie Essay Research Paper Marie Curie
Marie Curie Essay, Research Paper Marie Curie is the most famous woman of physics. She has been recognized for her work with Nobel Prize awards in both physics (1903) and chemistry (1911). She got a late start with her education obtaining her license in physics in 1893 and the corresponding degree in mathematics in 1894.
Marie Curie Essay Research Paper The ashes
Marie Curie Essay, Research Paper The ashes of Marie Curie and her husband Pierre have now been laid to rest under the famous dome of the Panth?on. Through her discovery of radium, Marie Curie paved the way for nuclear physics and cancer therapy. Born of Polish parents, she was a woman of science and courage, compassionate yet stubbornly determined.
Marie Curie Essay Research Paper Curie Mariephysicist
Marie Curie Essay, Research Paper Curie, Marie physicist and twice Nobel laureate, best known for her Curie, Marie, nйe Maria Sklodowska (1867-1934), French work on radioactivity, with her husband Pierre. Maria Sklodowska was born in Warsaw, Poland, which was then part of the Russian Empire. Her father, an ardent Polish nationalist, taught mathematics and physics at a secondary school, but was denied promotion because of his political views, which he passed on to his daughter.
Comparison Essay Essay Research Paper Comparison EssayThere
Comparison Essay Essay, Research Paper Comparison Essay There are many different ways to explain the beginning and creation. Genesis and Edith Hamilton?s ?Mythology,? are two of many literary works you can find. Both show how characters were created and formed. They give detailed understanding and examples of creation.
Othello And King Lear A Comparison Essay
, Research Paper Othello and King Lear: A comparison If Shakespeare was alive today it is certain that there would be a lot written about him. We would read reviews of his new plays in newspapers,
William Blake Essay Research Paper This week
William Blake Essay, Research Paper This week I was scheduled to work with Irene Balli. She is one of dining services main managers. She mostly oversees all of the banquets that go on here at Marywood. On the 16th of April was the Cor Marie, which is a very large banquet that consists of all major heads of all departments at Marywood.
Mad Shadows Essay Research Paper Mad Shadows
Mad Shadows Essay, Research Paper Mad Shadows is a book about obsession and delusion. It’s characters exhibit fixations on beauty, wealth and revenge. This coincides with the fact that all the main characters are defected
The Stranger Essay Research Paper Camus entitled
The Stranger Essay, Research Paper Camus entitled his novel The Stranger because his protagonist actually was a stranger to both his associates and his surroundings. Monsieur Meursault was never really known by
The Voltaire Essay Research Paper Voltaire Francois
The Voltaire Essay, Research Paper Voltaire Francois Marie Arouet (pen name Voltaire) was born on November 21, 1694 in Paris. Voltaire’s style, wit, intelligence and keen sense of justice made him one of France’s greatest writers and philosophers. Young Francois Marie received an excellent education at a Jesuit school.
Get In Essay Research Paper Click Here
Get In Essay, Research Paper Click Here If YOU Have Friends! Can’t find the paper you need? Try Collegiate Care Comparing Casablanca to 1984 Charlie Parker at Storyville
Comparison Essay Essay Research Paper Comparison EssayTwo
Comparison Essay Essay, Research Paper Comparison Essay Two individuals dominate the late night airwaves, Jay Leno and David Letterman. Leno uses a conservative humor and Letterman’s humor is progressive. While the two shows claim to be different, they both follow the same format. Both shows include a ten-minute stand up routine, strange co-hosts and interviews with celebrity guests.
BookMovie Comparison Hamlet Essay Research Paper Usually
Book-Movie Comparison Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Usually, when a movie is made about a story in a book or a play, the two stories are not exactly the same. The movie tends to add small details or leave some out in order to meet time limits and to make the story what they think will be more interesting. Such is the case with Shakespeare s Hamlet.
Compare And Contrast Essay Research Paper 100200English
Compare And Contrast Essay, Research Paper 10/02/00 English 119 Assignment # 2 Comparison and Contrast I have never really thought about my experiences with the birth in a comparison before. I have shared or swapped stories with other mom’s picking out our likenesses. So taking on this assignment has made me see the differences that have occurred between the births of my children.
Fiddler On The Roof In Comparison To
Elizabeth Rex Essay, Research Paper Elizabeth Rex in comparison to Fiddler On The Roof By Magill Foote More specifically, the comparison to be made is between both of Brent Carver’s performances in the aforementioned plays.
Hamlet Video Comparison Essay Research Paper Hamlet
Hamlet: Video Comparison Essay, Research Paper Hamlet: Video Comparison Hamlet is one of the best known pieces of literature around the world, and has fascinated many people from all walks of life, from critics to
The Train Essay Research Paper The Train
The Train Essay, Research Paper The Train, by Diane Hoh, is a thrilling book. It has five main characters; Hanna Deaton, Jean Marie Westlake, Lewis Joseph Reed, Kerry Oliver, and Mack Mc. Comber, who all went to Parker High School. Hanna is a not so bright girl with naturally wavy chocolate covered hair and claustrophobic.
So This Was Adolescence By Annie Dillard
: Author Writing Style Essay, Research Paper So This Was Adolescence, by Annie Dillard: Author Writing Style Different authors use different styles of writing to express the ideas.
The Blue Hotel Essay Research Paper Leah
The Blue Hotel Essay, Research Paper Leah Miller Comparison Essay English J In the Blue Hotel, by Stephen Crane, four characters play four games of High Five. The game is played with partners. There are both similarities and differences in the