Surrogate Motherhood Essay, Research Paper
Surrogate Motherhood: Good or Bad?
There are many controversies surrounding the idea of
surrogate motherhood, by its definition, it is a course of
action that goes outside natural reproduction. Although
surrogacy was first brought up in the bible it is only until
recently that it has actually become an issue for criticism
and debate. Factors such as the growth of infertility in
modern society, coupled with the declining number of
children available for adoption, and the development of
surrogacy contract and commercial surrogacy agencies in
1976, have resulted in increasing publicity and public
interest in the formation of agreements between infertile
couples and surrogate mothers (Stuhmcke, 3). Surrogate
motherhood can be approached in more than one way, and some
surrogacy procedures receive more condemnation than others.
One type of surrogacy is when an egg is extracted from
the infertile female and placed in a petri dish and is then
fertilized by the fertile male?s sperm, the fertilized egg
is then placed into the fertile female?s uterus so she can
give birth to the child. This procedure is done when the
uterus of a female is in some way defective, but her eggs
are in fine condition, this is called invitro fertilization
surrogacy or IVF surrogacy (Hanafin, 3). IVF surrogacy, or
total surrogacy is the procedure that receives the least
criticism because the baby is in no way related to its
carrier. The more common type of surrogacy is through
artificial insemination or AI. This is when the couple
wishing to have a child are unable because of the female?s
eggs, the male then uses his sperm to impregnate a fertile
woman. In this case the child would not be related to the
legal mother in any way, and would have the genes of the
surrogate mother, this is also known as partial surrogacy
(kizuna.cwru.edu/rlgn120/projects/feminism/opinions.
html).
Laws about surrogacy vary from state to state. However,
only a few states have actually passed laws concerning the
matter, the others have simply dodged the issue. Partial
surrogacy in comparison to total surrogacy is much more
difficult to work out legally. There are the issues of
half-siblings, the biological mother?s role in the child?s
life, whether or not the woman raising the child will be
able to handle such issues, and what the child will be told
when he/she gets older. For such reasons, surrogate
motherhood has been avoided by lawmakers in most states
(phoenix/~townhall/surrogat/surlaws.html).
The initial demand for surrogacy is likely to come from
women, or the partners of women incapable of pregnancy, and
there are many ways a couple can go about finding a
surrogate mother. There are agencies in states that have
legalized surrogacy, and there are also online databases,
such as wwwrrogacy, which display message boards of
people looking to be surrogate mothers or couples looking to
use a surrogate. Before an arrangement is made there are
many issues to discuss and precautions to be taken.
The first issue would be whether or not the surrogate
mother will be paid for her troubles, in almost all cases
she is given some sort of fee, and in nearly every case her
medical bills and living expenses are taken care of by the
parents that will be raising the child. When a surrogacy
arrangement is done for money it is called a commercial
surrogacy. Commercial surrogacy is looked at by some as a
form of prostitution because the woman is being paid for use
of her body. However, it is difficult to find a surrogate
mother that would carry a child simply out of love or
sympathy. Nonetheless, when an arrangement is made without
compensation for the surrogate mother it is called
altruistic surrogacy (Stuhmcke, 2).
Other debates include moral and ethical questions. Does
surrogacy go against natural selection, and is the burden it
will cause to the children, the parents, and the surrogate
mother, worth it? Some people believe that if an individual
does not have the ability of reproduction, it should be
selected, and technology should not be used to alter God?s
plan. Another reason people think it is a risky matter is
because of the effect it could have on the child. Some
believe a normal parent-child relationship could not be
formed, and it could leave the child feeling confused and
alone. I, however, look at surrogacy as having the same
effect on a child as adoption. While there may be confusion,
there will not be a lack of love for the child because
he/she was not conceived or carried by the legal parents.
I am all for surrogate motherhood. I believe the
advantages far outweigh the disadvantages. Surrogacy
provides some couples with their only hope of raising a
child genetically related to at least one of them. I believe
that everyone should be given the chance to have a family,
and if the surrogate mothers are willing to do it, I do not
see a problem with it.
Bibliography
Hanafin, Hillary. ?An Overview of the Psychological
Evaluation and Counseling in Surrogacy Parenting.?
1996. The American Surrogacy Center, Inc. <
wwwrrogacy/psychres/article/eval.html>.
Stuhmcke, Anita. ?For Love or Money: the Legal Regulation
of Surrogate Motherhood.? May, 1996. <
murdoch.edu.au/elaw/issues/v3n1/stuhmck1.txt>.
No Author listed. <kizuna.cwru.edu/rlgn120/projects/
feminism/opinions.html>.
Другие работы по теме:
Beginnings Of Christianity Essay Research Paper By
Beginnings Of Christianity Essay, Research Paper By the time Constantine declared himself a Christian in 313 CE, almost half of the Roman population had abandoned the traditional Roman gods for Christianity (Galloway 4). The reason for the spread of this particular religion was because the ideas behind it were simple and easy for the people of the Roman world to embrace.
Cloning Essay Research Paper Cloning became to
Cloning Essay, Research Paper Cloning became to be, as a Finn Dorset ewe would provide the mammary cell for the cloning process. Secondly the mammary cell containing all copies of every gene that is needed to make the sheep. Although the only genes for proteins that are required by mammary cells are active.
Medical Maryjane Essay Research Paper The thesis
Medical Maryjane Essay, Research Paper The thesis of this 10 page paper is that there is a medical necessity for the legal use of marijuana. There is significant evidence that supports the benefits of THC,
Geneology Essay Research Paper Genetic Engineering
Geneology Essay, Research Paper Genetic Engineering Two years ago Scottish scientists announced that they had successfully cloned a sheep. They named it dolly and it was an exact copy of the original sheep. Is cloning morally right? Is it ethical? Some people think that it is wrong and that it shouldn?t be practiced on any animal.
Women Of Today Essay Research Paper Throughout
Women Of Today Essay, Research Paper Throughout most of history women generally have had fewer legal rights and career opportunities than man. Wife hood and motherhood were regarded as women’s most significant professions. In the 20th century, however, women in most nations have gained the right to vote and have increased their educational job opportunities ( WIC, 1).
Gather Togeher In Maya
’s Name Essay, Research Paper “A baby’s love for his mother is probably the sweetest emotion we can savor.” (Angelou) By consistently weaving the theme of motherhood into her literature, Maya
Surrogate Mothering Essay Research Paper Motherhood
Surrogate Mothering Essay, Research Paper Motherhood – Nine Months vs. A Lifetime “You’re about ten meters dilated?it’s time to push!” You grab hold onto your husband’s hand a little tighter. Take a deep breath?and the labor process begins. This is a common everyday scenario that happens thousands of times a day in hospitals all over the world.
Marks Essay Research Paper MARKS My husband
Marks Essay, Research Paper MARKS My husband gives me an ?A? for last nights supper, an incomplete for my ironing, a B plus in bed. My son says I am average, an average mother, but if
Art History Essay Research Paper Gallery Writeup1
Art History Essay, Research Paper Gallery Write-up1. There are a number of references to motherhood in Katrin Wiese s work. Although I never felt as though she was shunning motherhood, I do believe she is expressing how the task of being a mother completely engulfs a person. However this is but issue I found in her work that is relates to our class so far.
Surrogate Motherhood Essay Research Paper Approximately 10
Surrogate Motherhood Essay, Research Paper Approximately 10 to 15 percent of married couples in the United States who want to have children find that they are not able to bear children due to infertility problems attributable to one couple member or both. The American Fertility Society estimates that as many as 50 000 couples each year need the help of a third person- either a surrogate mother or a donor of sperm or egg- to have a child.
Me Essay Research Paper From unwed motherhood
Me Essay, Research Paper From unwed motherhood to sex and adultery, many of the moral issues and stigmas of Puritan society are still being dealt with today. In The Scarlet Letter, Hester Prynne is forced to wear a large, red “A” on her chest when she is found guilty of adultery and refuses to name the father of her illegitimate child.
Critical Essay On
“Making Single Motherhood N Essay, Research Paper Mike Taylor Ms. Kugel 12-02-98 In the essay “Making Single Motherhood Normal”, the writer Iris Marion Young uses many strategies to make her piece rhetorically effective. When writing the piece, Young considers many factors such as her audience, the style in which she writes it, the content of her message, and the credibility she wants to display about herself.
ROLE OF KAT ALL QUIET ON THE
WESTERN FRONT Essay, Research Paper World War I was one of the greatest military conflicts of all time. During this time of great death and destruction men came together and formed support groups. In Paul?s group as in most groups there emerges a single leader, someone who can guide and protect its members.
Jet Li Essay Research Paper Jet LiRain
Jet Li Essay, Research Paper Jet Li Rain Noe from AsianAvenue writes, When he speaks, he co-articulates with frenetic gestures as if explaining something to a deaf person with ADD Though not a
Motherhood Essay Research Paper In today s
Motherhood Essay, Research Paper In today s age the rate of single motherhood is growing rapidly. The job of being a single mother is not only difficult but exhausting. Single mothers have to work extra hard to make money to pay the bills, while trying to care for there children, and also fitting time in for themselves.
In Vitro Fertilization Essay Research Paper Vincent
In Vitro Fertilization Essay, Research Paper Vincent Santoro February 25, 2001 Biology Honors Position Paper With the new technology in our present day culture, In Vitro Fertilization is a practice that I believe should not be done by any person by all means. IVF conflicts with the process of nature by bringing the sperm and egg together in an un-natural way, in a glass.
Symbolism The Chrysanthemums Essay Research Paper Symbolism
Symbolism- The Chrysanthemums Essay, Research Paper Symbolism- “The Chrysanthemums John Steinbecks’ “The Chrysanthemums” is a story that utilizes symbolism on many levels. Most of all, I believe in the character of Elisa Adams. Elisa and her garden seem to be considered one. Because of all of her hard labor and love the Chrysanthemums flourish.
Reproductive Technology Essay Research Paper The natural
Reproductive Technology Essay, Research Paper The natural method of reproduction has become only one of many new techniques used today. There are millions of couples that do not have the ability to reproduce on their own because of infertility and therefore, must resort to these new techniques. The main causes of infertility are that of hormonal malfunctions and anatomical abnormalities.
The Differences Between The Two Novels Women
Of Brewster’s Place By Gloria Naylor And As I Lay Dying By William Faulkner Essay, Research Paper The differences between the two novels Women of Brewster’s place by Gloria Naylor and As I lay dying by William Faulkner are many and varied. They differ in their tone, style, handling of characters and overall continuity.
The Motherhood Essay Research Paper THE MOTHERHOODI
The Motherhood Essay, Research Paper THE MOTHERHOOD I have read the two plays, “The Glass Manegerie” by Tennessee Williams and “A Raisin in the Sun” by Lorraine Hansberry, both of have a big impact on me. The two plays circle around the family values that convey the character of motherhood where mothers have to have a responsibility to raise, to provide their best and to sacrifice for their children.
The Joys Of Motherhood Or Not
…) Essay, Research Paper The Joys of Motherhood… (…Or Not) Buchi Emecheta?s choice of title for her book The Joys of Motherhood is very ironic. I believe she chose this title in order to make the reader reflect
Harwood Poetry Essay Research Paper Poems although
Harwood, Poetry Essay, Research Paper Poems, although they can be appreciated individually, are better understood if the reader sees them in the context of the poet s other works. One such poem that benefits from being approached in this way is Mother Who Gave Me Life . Mother is one of several poems Harwood wrote about motherhood and the role of women in society.
The Godfather Essay Research Paper A wedding
The Godfather Essay, Research Paper A wedding is a great vehicle to motivate a plot in both literature and life. In Mario Puzo’s The Godfather, Michael Corleone’s wedding is one of the most influential scenes of the entire book. This wedding carries this influence because of three things, first, the reader meets Michael Corleone for the first time, second, the reader experiences a dramatic Italian Mafia wedding in all its prestige and tradition, and lastly, the reader becomes aware of just how respected the head of a Mafia family can become.
Prevelant Issues In Surrogate Parenting Essay Research
Paper The Prevalent Issues of Surrogate Parenting Surrogate parenting refers to an arrangement between a married couple who is unable to have a child because of the wife s infertility and a fertile woman who agrees to conceive the husband s child through artificial insemination, carry it to term, then surrender all parental rights in the child.
The Bean Trees Essay Research Paper he
The Bean Trees Essay, Research Paper he Bean Trees Differences in Characters In “The Bean Trees,” by Barbara Kingsolver, readers are given the chance to see how two characters that have completely
Artificial Insemination Essay Research Paper Artificial insemination
Artificial Insemination Essay, Research Paper Artificial insemination is the injection of SEMEN into the vagina by instrumental means. The first artificial inseminations of viviparous (live-bearing) animals were performed by the 18th-century Italian physiologist Lazzaro Spallanzani, who proved that the male contribution to reproduction resided in the semen, although he did not recognize spermatozoa as the fertilizing agents.
Values For Me Values For You Essay
, Research Paper Values for Me, Values for You Values are everywhere. For the most part, however, values are part of society and are what defines people?s reputation. Indeed this is true in Charles Dickens?, A Tale of Two Cities, where the values of Lucie Manette, Sydney Carton, and Madame Defarge define who they are.
Responsible Teens Essay Research Paper Responsible TeensTodays
Responsible Teens? Essay, Research Paper Responsible Teens? Today?s teenagers’ actions speak for them. Abuse of controlled substances, auto accidents, and teen violence are all on the rise. Teenagers today, as a whole, are definitely irresponsible.
Feminism In Medea Essay Research Paper Feminism
Feminism In Medea Essay, Research Paper Feminism in Medea The play Medea by Euripides challenges the dominant views of femininity in the patriarchal society of the Greeks. While pursuing her ambition Medea disregards many of the feminine stereotypes/ characteristics of the patriarchal Greek society.
Cloning Essay Research Paper In 1938 a
Cloning Essay, Research Paper In 1938, a German scientist, Hans Spemann theorized that organisms could be reproduced. His belief was that by transplanting the central element of one animal’s cell into the egg of another animal, the animal supplying the cell could be reproduced or “cloned.” Dr. Spemann believed that the central element or “nucleus” of a cell contained the genetic blueprint for the structure of an organism.
Cloning 4 Essay Research Paper CloningAttempts to
Cloning 4 Essay, Research Paper Cloning Attempts to create a human being by cloning should be banned for several reasons. Although cloning has some benefits, attempts to clone a human will bring up many moral and ethical issues. Seppa (1997) reports that the National Bioethics Advisory Commission (NABC) concludes that it would be morally unacceptable for anyone in the public or private sector… to attempt to create a child by implanting cloned embryos in a woman.
Personal Growth Experience Essay Research Paper Personal
Personal Growth Experience Essay, Research Paper Personal Growth Experience As a mother I have cared and tried to push my son s education so that he can succeed in his life. I came from a large family in Brazil. I wasn t the only child; I learned to share, how provide for myself, and for my 3 sisters, and 3 brothers.
The Moral Legal And Economic Impediments Of
Surr Essay, Research Paper “Blimey!” I exclaim. “Sounds like a plant!” “It was,” she replies without the slightest irony. (Handel 3) In this country, the last trait in a mother that needs to be supported stands as the attribute of being able to let a baby out of her hand at the drop of ten grand. The fact that surrogate motherhood demands a mom give up her infant at any point remains immoral.