Allegory of the Cave
In Books II and III of The Republic, Socrates sets the stage for a
view of education for the warriors in the culture, asserting a need for the
study of different disciplines, including art and athletics. Though this
provides a sense of Plato’s perspective on education, his outlining of
educational premises in Book VII, including his view of rational though,
education, and the responsibilities of both the student and the teacher in
his “Allegory of the Cave” defines a call for a curriculum in education based
on the directives and significance of the student, and can be asserted as
the foundations of modern liberal arts educational philosophies.
In order to understand the different views on education provided by Plato,
it is first necessary to consider the messages provided in Book II, Book III
and Book VII. Plato initiates his discourse on education through the
dialogue of Glaucon, Adeimantus and Socrates and their perspective on
the appropriate education of the guardians of any polis. The warriors,
soldiers or guardians of a city are a separate class of people, and
distinguished by their knowledge and deduction to the central elements of
society. Because of their distinctions and their need to understand
wisdom and make appropriate and “educated” choices, the education of
the guardians is a necessary component in defining self-protection. It is
Socrates’ (and therefore Plato’s) assertion that there is a need to educate
the guardians in musical and physical areas, and to promote a correlation
between participation as a warrior and educational prowess. In other
words, it was Socrates’ contention that it was not enough to simply educate
a guardian in warfare, but instead, their role necessitates an understanding
of other premises, including history, song, art, philosophy and even
literature.
It is also Plato’s assertion in the last segment of Book II that one of
the failings of society is the fact that myths of valor and feats of strength
clearly impact the conduct of guardians, and that there is a need to
demonstrate that the warriors are not simply blood-thirsty war-mongers, but
instead have the capacity for rational thought and for the development of a
wide variety of personal characteristics. Book II of Plato’s Republic
begins with the assumption of the necessity for the education of the
guardians but takes this argument further by demonstrating the benefits of
physical and musical training. It is Plato’s assertion that these are
necessary in order to determine that the warriors, the guardians of
the city are actually true and virtuous. As a component of the arguments for
education in the guardian class, Plato also suggests that the man cannot
be assumed to be truly wise or to have the capacity for effective decision
making if he cannot comprehend basic aesthetic virtues like beauty as well
as more complex issues like morality. The guardians of any ideal city, then
would demonstrate their capacity for instilling virtue in others and directing
the course of their own actions to maintain this premise. In conjunction,
Plato asserts the need for a moral education of the guardians in order to
determine the capacity of guardians to instill morality in others.
In Book VI, Plato sets the premise for his argument for education in
his determinations regarding the soul, the search for truth and the pursuit of
intelligence.
The most substantive view of the correlation between Plato’s premises and
modern educational philosophies can be seen in Book VII, when Socrates
presents the “Allegory of the Cave”. This story, provides and outlines the
role of both the teacher and the student. Socrates’ message begins in the
idea that individuals can develop within surroundings that are so limited
that they have know way of experiencing truth outside of what they can
directly perceive, and this is the essential underpinning of ignorance. But if
an individual can learn to understand the possibilities outside of the
realm of singular understanding, and by exposure to different things,
determine new understanding, then Plato would assert that all men have
the potential to move from ignorance to knowledge.
The basis for the “Allegory of the Cave” is this: a prisoner is held in a cave
for his whole life (since birth), only able to see and experience that which is
placed before him. For example, the fire that is used to luminate the cave
becomes the center of the world much like our own sun is such a
compelling central component, and the prisoner experiences everything
that he sees and understands relative to the fire. In conjunction, the fire
become a means of visualizing other elements, including exposure to a
puppet and the shadows on the wall, and all of these factors make
up the specifics of what is known in the world of the prisoner. The divided
line is an imperative concept within the scope of this premise. In essence,
the teacher is the individual who directs the pursuit of knowledge past the
initial limitations that have been set. It is not the teachers responsibility to
simply say “here is the sun, here is the moon…now you know everything”
because the student would never understand the process necessary to
continue with the directive of self education. As a result, the process of
wisdom requires that individuals adapt and learn their own skills for
learning. Knowledge, then, is not simply sensory based (because the
prisoners in the cave, for example, believed they had the knowledge of the
fire, the shadows and the cave itself as if these were the only elements in
the world that needed to be known), but also extends past our senses into
the realm of logical reasoning, constructive reasoning, and a process
orientation to learning and developing wisdom. Rather than simply
producing information and addressing the learning process and the
students in order to bring them into complicity, it is Plato’s contention that
the learning process, the same process that occurs when the prisoner in
the cave is allowed to leave and experiences the sun, the moon, trees, and
all of life’s sciences and concepts, should be student directed. The teacher
is simply a means by which the student can come into connection with the
ways of attaining knowledge, but the process of learning itself must be
singular and directed by a personal learning focus. The teacher provides
the individual with the means to perceive themselves, to evaluate their
nature, and to consider the search for truth as a major aspect of the
educational process. It can be asserted that this kind of student focus
is the primary component of the modern liberal arts system, and
underscores the importance of the student in the learning process.
In addition, it is also Plato’s assertion in Book VII that the metaphor
of the cave, asserting man’s ignorance prior to learning, results in the need
for a teacher who can provide exposure to different subjects, different
perspectives and a range of educational subject areas. The Cave scenario
allows for the evaluation of the many different areas in which man should
pursue study, including the study of the actual, the factual, the scientific
and the conceptual. It is not enough to simply assert that by studying a
number of different subjects, the prisoner will gain enough knowledge to
determine their own route towards wisdom: there is greater support for the
view that the process orientation of learning, which includes the
assessment of the learning process and the determination of impacts for
wisdom underscores the benefits of this perspective in the development of
a modern curriculum.
Другие работы по теме:
The Allegory Of The Cave By Plato
Essay, Research Paper Plato was born 427 B.C. and died 347 B.C. He was a pupil under Socrates. During his studies, Plato wrote the Dialogues, which are a collection of Socrates’ teachings. One of the parables included in the Dialogues is “The Allegory of the Cave”. “The Allegory…” symbolizes man’s struggle to reach understanding and enlightenment.
The Clan Of The Cave Bear Essay
, Research Paper The Clan of the Cave Bear starts out with a naked girl named Ayla swimming in a river. After that an earthquake occurs and she is surprised because she had never experienced one before. The earthquake kept on going, and she became even more frightened. She cried for her mother, but she was alone.
The Cave Essay Research Paper Notes on
The Cave Essay, Research Paper Notes on ?The Cave? author- Jean McCord George- Bum who lived in a cave and made statues Charles- Main char. Charles was running when he saw a cave. He stopped and
Enlightenment Vs Unenlightenment Regarding Racism Essay Research
Paper There is no doubt that racism exists in the United States. Almost everyone can admit this. The interesting part is that some people will admit that they themselves are racist while others will claim that they are enlightened and that they are not racist or prejudiced. The truth is that the one who can admit he is racist is actually the enlightened one.
Cinematic Aspects Of Cave Art Essay Research
Paper Kristine McCarthy October 1, 2000 Cinematic Aspects of Cave Art by Edward Watchel I think Watchel formed a very good, accurate arguement in saying that cave paintings are cinematic.
Israel Essay Research Paper Teams of archaeologists
Israel Essay, Research Paper Teams of archaeologists were excavating in Israel when they came upon a cave. Written across the wall of the cave were the following symbols, in this order of appearance: A woman, a donkey, a shovel, a fish and a Star of David.
Cave Art Essay Research Paper At thefoot
Cave Art Essay, Research Paper At the foot of a cliff in the Ard?che Gorges, in south-eastern France, amateur speleologists discovered the world’s oldest painted prehistoric cave. Discovered
The Crystal Cave Essay Research Paper People
The Crystal Cave Essay, Research Paper People or events that appear very briefly in life may have dramatic effects on the lives of people they touch upon. Basketball coaches from the junior high school level often influence their athletes to take up playing basketball in their high school career. Dying friends often compel people to conduct research and dedicate their lives to the study of medicine.
Plato Essay Research Paper Plato
Plato Essay, Research Paper Plato’s theory of knowledge is found in the Republic, particularly in his discussion of the image about the myth of the cave. Plato distinguishes between two levels of awareness:
The Relationship Of Allegory Of The Cave
As Compared To Learning And Education Essay, Research Paper The relationship of “Allegory of the Cave” to learning and education. The “Allegory of the Cave” is Plato’s attempt to explain the relationship between knowledge and ignorance. Starting with the image of men in fetters that limit their movement and force them to look only ahead, this is the idea that all men and women are bound by the limits of their ignorance.
Plato And The Cave Essay Research Paper
Plato and the cave After reading Plato?s cave several times, I learned that every time I read it I gained a completely different interpretation. You can relate all of the different symbols to any aspect of life, and still have a clear understanding of what Plato is talking about. My first interpretation of the cave was, the world as the cave.
Huckleberry Finn Essay Research Paper Huck and
Huckleberry Finn Essay, Research Paper Huck and Jim both have seen money differently because Huck is white and has a chance in like and can make it. Jim was a slave and really couldn?t make money. Huck had a lot of money but didn?t spend it that easily ?Oher a hundred and fifty dollars. Quite a fortune for you?(p.12). huck and Tom were in a cave and found six thousand dollars that robbers left there.
Chinese Poetry Essay Research Paper Although the
Chinese Poetry Essay, Research Paper Although the Chinese poetry I encountered was relatively short, their significant was not at all compromised. It did not matter that these poems were written hundreds of years ago they felt relevant to me. They reminded me of what should be a priority of life, finding inner peace.
Allegory Of A Cave Essay Research Paper
Lisa Ann Haney Philosophy 101 Allegory of the Cave Paper #2 Is our perception of this world true or is it merely a reflection or shadow of the real world? Can knowledge be passed from teacher to student or must each student travel his own path to enlightenment? Are the enlightened responsible to the rest of society? Are they the only people qualified to run society as a whole? These are the questions that plagued Plato and resulted in his famous portion of The Republic entitled Allegory of the Cave.
Allegory Of The Cave Analysis Essay Research
Paper In Plato?s "The Allegory of the Cave," he suggests that there are two different forms of vision, a "mind?s eye" and a "bodily eye." The "bodily eye" is a metaphor for the senses. While inside the cave, the prisoners function only with this eye. The "mind?s eye" is a higher level of thinking, and is mobilized only when the prisoner is released into the outside world.
Caves Essay Research Paper Formations and Types
Caves Essay, Research Paper Formations and Types of caves A cave is a chamber beneath the surface of the earth or in the side of a hill, cliff, or mountain. Caves vary in size and shape, and many have large openings to the surface. There are many types of caves, such as: ice caves, solution, wind, gravity-slip-block caves, fissure or rift, talus, sea, and lava tube caves.
Canto Of Pope Essay Research Paper In
Canto Of Pope Essay, Research Paper In this Canto, Pope describes the satirical decent of Umbriel into “underworld” as the last literary convention of epic poetry that Pope uses.
Allegory In The Divine Comedy Essay Research
Paper Dante wrote The Divine Comedy between 1308 and 1321. The Divine Comedy was written as an allegory, Which is a narrative that takes place on both a literal and a figurative or symbolic level. Dante uses himself as the main character and uses allegory to describe himself in the epic.
The MATRIX Essay Research Paper The MatrixIn
The MATRIX Essay, Research Paper The Matrix In viewing the Matrix, a 1999 Warner Brothers/Village Roadshow Picture release, there are numerous references to philosophy portrayed in the movie. In analyzing the Matrix one will be able to see how Descartes? Meditations on Methodic doubt, his Evil Genius Hypothesis, and Plato?s allegory of the cave are portrayed in this film.
The Allegory Of The Cave Turn Around
Essay, Research Paper The Allegory of the Cave: Turn Around Putting the Allegory of the Cave into my own words seems comparable to the Christian idea of using the lord’s name in vain. First, I’d like to
Plato Allegory Of The Cave Essay Research
Paper The majority of people in school today, and they don?t want to be there. School is painful to them. They, the unenlightened, have not seen the light. In Plato?s Allegory of the Cave, the prisoners can resemble those who do not thirst for knowledge. They seem to be prisoners in their own world.
The Allegory Of The
Cave Essay, Research Paper The Allegory of the Cave Plato gives rise to an interesting thought in The Allegory of the Cave . He suggest that people are to trusting in an unreliable society. Though he wrote this many years ago, it still applies today. It is ironic that people are willing to believe what the are told to be true, rather than search for the actual truth.
Plato The Allegory Of The Cave Essay
, Research Paper Theory of Dimensions In Plato s The Allegory of the Cave, allows an individual to realize that which they already know. The situation in the cave seems dark and gloomy, like a place no one would ever want to go. However, the reality is that some people are at a point in their lives where that is where they are, in their own cave .
Plato The Allegory Of The Cave
Plato: Essay, Research Paper Plato: The Allegory of the Cave Within the Allegory of the Cave, Plato expresses his theory of humanity s unconscious resistance to change through a conversation Socrates may have had with a fellow philosopher. In the beginning of this allegory we see human beings in an underground den.
Modern Plato
’s Cave Essay, Research Paper In the Allegory of the Den written by Plato. In his writing he explains human beings live in an underground den, here they have been from their childhood, and have
Socrates The Cave Essay Research Paper The
Socrates` The Cave Essay, Research Paper The cave I think that the idea of the cave and one man breaking lose from the chains is a good representation of the select few in the world. It takes great courage to break away from the group and venture out on your own. Once you find what you are looking for do you have a choice of weather or not you should go back to the group? If you found the one thing that could explain all of life?s mysteries would you keep it all to you?re self or would you want to share it with the world? Personally I would have to share it with at least one person.
Reality Essay Research Paper Reality is
Reality Essay, Research Paper Reality is . . . something that is neither derivative nor dependent, but exists necessarily, as stated in Webster s Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary. What this means is that reality does not exist because of something; there is nothing existing because of it; yet, still it exists throughout everything.
Fahrenheit 451
– Symbolism Essay, Research Paper Symbolism in Fahrenheit 451 Light, especially fire, and darkness are significantly reoccurring themes in Fahrenheit 451. Guy Montag, the main character, is a fireman, but in this futuristic world the job description of a fireman is to start fires wherever books are found; instead of putting them out.
Life Is Like The Movies Essay Research
Paper Going to the movies is fun. You get your candy and your drink and are taken away into a fictional world for two or three hours, then leave the theater and get back to reality. But is what you’re going back to really reality? Plato said no. In the "Allegory of the Cave" (chapter XXV) in the The Republic he proposes that we all live like people in a movie theater, only he uses prisoners in a cave to illustrate the situation.
Curiosity Essay Research Paper More likely the
Curiosity Essay, Research Paper More likely the cat was just unlucky (l. 1-2). In this narrative poem Curiosity , by Alastair Reid, he gives a dissertation on cats and dogs. Cats are adventurous and dogs do not take chances. Reid uses symbols Have you ever heard the saying curiosity killed the cat (l. 1)? and allegory to disclose the theme that life can be more fulfilling if one opens the door to new and different prospects.
Theory Of Dimensions Essay Research Paper PhilosophyDavid
Theory Of Dimensions Essay, Research Paper Philosophy David Doriot December 8,2000 The theory of Dimensions In Plato?s? The Allegory of the Cave, allows a person to realize that which they already know. The situation in the cave is dark and gloomy, a place no one would ever want to go. However, the reality is that some people are at a point in their lives where that is where they are, in their own self-made ?cave?.
Oedipus The King And Allegory Of The
Cave – Comparative Analysis Essay Essay, Research Paper In Sophocles? play, Oedipus, the King, there are various instances where Oedipus tries to escape his destiny?enlightenment?only to discover the truth that he cannot. Similarly, in Plato?s ?Allegory of the Cave? the prisoner travails to understand and adjust to his newly visited environment.