Paper
Going to the movies is fun. You get your candy and your drink and are taken away into a fictional world for two or three hours, then leave the theater and get back to reality. But is what you’re going back to really reality? Plato said no. In the "Allegory of the Cave" (chapter XXV) in the The Republic he proposes that we all live like people in a movie theater, only he uses prisoners in a cave to illustrate the situation. He creates an image of prisoners, chained down in a cave, so all they could see was shadows created by puppets in front of a fire on the cave wall. Their reality was merely the shadows and it is the same for us (as the common man.) According to Plato, our reality is nothing more than figurative "shadows."
Everything in the cave can be attributed to a part of society. The fire can be equivocated to "unwisdom" (229) or even evil, and in society is created by the greed that some have for power over others. It is the driving force behind the entire scheme to misrepresent reality. By controlling what people believe is reality, they in turn gain control of the people by telling them what is true and what should be valued, which gives them the power they crave. The fire (greed) is necessary for the shadows to be cast, without it nothing at all could be seen. Without the fire, the puppeteers would have no purpose, no reason to hold the objects up at all. Without the greed for control, society’s "puppeteers" would not have any desire to misrepresent reality.
The puppeteers are the manipulators in society (the greedy people). People in a variety of different positions act as the puppeteers. Anyone who tries to skew reality for his or her own personal gain is a manipulator. Religious and business leaders, as well as politicians are all likely candidates for the role of the "puppeteers" because they often control people’s realities. Religious leaders convince massive amounts of people that their ideas and their religion is reality. Business leaders use advertising campaigns to persuade people into believing their products are the best and will change their lives. Politicians often manipulate issues to make people see them their way. In conjunction with each other, all of these manipulative forces basically dictate society’s values.
These "puppeteers" take the objects and let their own greed (fire) distort them, so only a small portion of what is "real" is revealed (in the form of a "shadow"). The objects are equivalent to the sermons, the add campaigns and the political agendas of world leaders. Because they have nothing else to look at, the prisoners (society as a whole) believes these shadows of reality to be true, because the manipulators have not given them any other options.
When the relationship between the "puppeteers" and the "prisoners" is examined more closely, the question of whether or not the manipulators actually know what reality is must be addressed. The answer is that they don’t. They still only see what is inside the cave, and the enlightened world exists solely outside of it. Most of them actually believe in what they are promoting, which are essentially just "artificial objects" (228). Plato’s Theory of Forms explains that one can only have beliefs and opinions about material thing, and the only thing that one can know is science (and universals.) Because these
objects can’t be known, they can’t be a part of the universal reality that exists "outside of the cave" or as in society beyond the boundaries of the material, manmade world. In the "Allegory" as in life, the only people that are "enlightened" (who know the true, universal reality) are those who leave the cave somehow, or those who see beyond our material world.
The prisoner who is set free and ascends into the light experiences a great deal of pain, "Suppose one of them set free and forced suddenly to stand up.and walk with eyes lifted to the light, all these movements would be painful." (229) Imagine the shock that
would come from realizing that the whole world as one knew it for their entire life was only actually a "meaningless illusion" (229.) It would be extremely painful, not just because of the physical affects of bright light on eyes that have never experienced it, but also the emotional struggle one would have to go through to accept a completely new reality. For some amount of time, they would have to be more alone than they ever had before, because they wouldn’t even have a reality. In that time of rejection of the first "reality" and acceptance of the new "reality", they would have complete nothingness. It would be much easier for them to forget what they saw and go back to the comfort of believing in what they had their entire lives, rather than try to figure out and then accept a new "reality." But this separation from their former reality is the necessary first "step" in the enlightenment process. Plato shows that one must leave what they know as real and step into nothingness before being able to grasp the new "enlightened" reality (which is the second "step" in the process he illustrates.)
If someone did go through this process and didn’t go mad after such alienation, why would they ever want to return from the "sunlight" to the "cave?" The only reason that they would have to leave the glory of "enlightenment" to return to society would be to help other people achieve the understanding that they had. But throughout history, people who have become "enlightened" and "come back" to teach what they have learned (in some people’s eyes, this could include Jesus, Ghandi and/or Socrates) have been tormented by the people. It would take an incredibly strong person with unbelievable moral character to actually complete the third "step" in this process, because people don’t want to listen to them. Rather than listen to what these "enlightened" people have to teach them, they shun them from society because they are scared, "If they could lay hands on the man who was trying to set them free and lead them up, they would kill him." (231) If they chose to accept the teachings, they too would be forced to go through the terrifying realization that everything they thought they knew was a lie. Plato is clearly stating that the masses are not strong enough to go through this process, ".they would laugh at him." (231) instead of trying to understand the "enlightened" person, they would rather just believe what they have been taught.
Can an "enlightened" person really teach what they have learned? Just as the prisoners still in the cave could not really understand what the "escapee" from the cave would try and tell them, what the "enlightened" person has learned can not be completely communicated. How could the sun be described to someone who had never even seen direct light? It is a big, bright ball in the sky, but what is the sky? It’s the blue area above the earth? Obviously, this process would go on forever, since the people in the cave would never have seen anything more than shadows and had no concept of the sun, the earth and the sky. The objects can be described, but the cave prisoners would not really understand until they actually experienced "enlightenment", or until they saw the objects for themselves. Until a person actually goes through at least the first two "steps" (separation and "enlightenment") and finds the "reality" themselves, they cannot truly understand, therefor the "enlightened" cannot truly communicate their wisdom in it’s totality.
Plato’s "Allegory of the Cave" is clearly more than just an illustration of the way society works. He explains people’s resistance to change or to move out of the "comfort zone" of their realities to explore new ideas. Because of this fear and resistance to change, most people never even make it to the first "step" in the enlightenment process, which is leaving everything they believe in search of something better, or in this case more "real." If they actually get past this and become enlightened, completing the third "step" of returning to try and communicate their experience and understanding, they are met with unbelievable opposition and rejection. What they now know cannot actually be communicated to those who haven’t experienced it, so these efforts must be fruitless. The only thing that these "enlightened" people can do is to convince people that there is more out there, and push them to find it for themselves, which is what we all must do.
Другие работы по теме:
Holocaust Unit Summary Essay Research Paper Holocaust
Holocaust Unit Summary Essay, Research Paper Holocaust Unit SummaryI was mostly affected by this unit because it showed me that in the midst of allthe unkindness of the Nazi party, that there were still some people left who were kindenough to put their own lives on the line to save someone else’s. I didn’t understand,until the stories and the movies cleared it up, how the people could not figure out thatthere was something wrong when they were being pushed around by the Nazi soldiers.
River Phoenix
– My Favorite Famous Person Essay, Research Paper Do you like to see the movies? Do you know the most handsome boy in Hollywood? Though the handsome boy that everyone thinks can be different , I think that River Phoenix is the movie star who is just the right man who sparkled in Hollywood even if he doesn?t exist in this world and there are a large number of actors and they appear in the future.
Beowolf Essay Research Paper 5 Paragraph EssayBeowulf
Beowolf Essay, Research Paper 5 Paragraph Essay Beowulf, the first piece of Angelo Saxon literature, truly a masterpiece in itself. Beowulf unfortunately has no author, but was translated and re-written by Vinerable Bede. Beowulf was a hero much like the hero’s we have here today. Grendel on the other hand was an evil villain, like the ones in the movies.
Holocaust Unit Summary Essay Research Paper I
Holocaust Unit Summary Essay, Research Paper I was mostly affected by this unit because it showed me that in the midst of all the unkindness of the Nazi party, that there were still some people left who were kind
ROTC Entrence Essay Essay Research Paper entrance
ROTC Entrence Essay Essay, Research Paper entrance essay For almost as long as I cn remember, I have been interested in th military. Influenced by such movies as “Patton”, and by my dad’s interest in military history, my
Jane Eyre Essay Research Paper Jane EyreJane
Jane Eyre Essay, Research Paper Jane Eyre Jane Eyre was originally a book, by Charlotte Bronte. It has now been made into a movie. There are two versions of the movie the BPC version, which is the British version and the American version. Both movies are very good and tell the story different. The British version is more like the book.
Vertigo Essay Research Paper Vertigo is probably
Vertigo Essay, Research Paper Vertigo is probably one of the more intriguing movies that I ve seen in a while, and almost as thought provoking as what team will win the NCAA tourney. In my opinion, it is truly a tragedy just because of the number of people that perished due to falling from a high place. The main protagonist, Scottie who was the cause of all of these deaths goes through the most trauma in the movie.
Television Harmful Essay Research Paper Is television
Television Harmful Essay, Research Paper Is television harmful to children? I think television is harmful to children, but I mostly think that it isn’t. There are many shows and movies on television that are harmful to children, but there are also many television shows and movies that are not. The biggest influence that television has on children is the violence.
Untitled Essay Research Paper In both the
Untitled Essay, Research Paper In both the traditional and not so traditional tales of ?Snow White? and ?Snow White Tale of Terror?despite there many differences, the plots are both based on jealousy. As viewers watch the movies they are dazzled by the mysterious mirror, entranced by the different takes of the story line, and know that there will be a happy ending.
Stereotypes Through The Pree Essay Research Paper
In Dorothy Nelkin?s article ?The Mystique of Science in the Press? she only touches the image of scientist?s in the newspaper. Nelkin explains that scientists are described as a combination of wonder-worker and nerd. Today scientists are portrayed through newspapers, movies, television, and books. They are stereotyped by having glasses, being nerdy, geeky, boring, disconnected from life, and super intelligent.
Hamlet Essay Research Paper Hamlet 2000 CritiqueWhen
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper ?Hamlet? (2000) Critique When we watch movies, we look for entertainment. That is the only reason why theatrical movies are created. Movies create entertainment which creates money.
Censorship Essay Research Paper CensorshipSince the beginning
Censorship Essay, Research Paper Censorship Since the beginning of art and entertainment society has tried to censor the public from the so called ?influences? of art, television, movies, and music. Censorship is suppose to protect the children from seeing form of sex, violence, profanity and drugs. If its suppose to protect the children from seeing these thing why do I see so many children doing those things.
The Glass Managerie Essay Research Paper Tennessee
The Glass Managerie Essay, Research Paper Tennessee Williams is well known for the use of symbols in her plays. Symbol or symbolism is when an object, a thing, a person, an animal or anything tangible represents an abstract idea. In the play The Glass Managerie, Tennessee successfully uses a variety
Blade Runner Essay Research Paper Blade RunnerThis
Blade Runner Essay, Research Paper Blade Runner This movie was very similar to the many other shall we say ?alien? movies out there. This movie may have been more correct with what may happen in the future. There wasn?t any explosions or planets blowing up, or anything as drastic as that. It was a more subtle thought of what happens if aliens really do take over.
The Movies Essay Research Paper The speaker
The Movies Essay, Research Paper The speaker in the movie viewed in class on February 5, 2001 gave a very good presentation on the procedures performed during C.P.R. and the benefits of knowing this life saving procedure. Although the speech was audience capturing, there were a few improvements that would have helped improve her presentation.
ALIENS Essay Research Paper No I do
ALIENS Essay, Research Paper No I do not believe in aliens. I will tell you why I do not believe in aliens. I don?t believe in aliens because I believe nothing that is not a fact, or some thing that
Who I Am Essay Research Paper Hi
Who I Am Essay, Research Paper Hi there. What?s going on? To answer a few of your questions, I live in Valley Stream in Nassau County. I will travel anywhere to be with the one I love. I am a very sensitive and caring guy. I love to go to the movies, I love to dance and no I do not smoke. Lol. I have perfect teeth and I want to keep it that way.
Genres Of Movies Essay Research Paper Tim
Genres Of Movies Essay, Research Paper Tim Robison English 1101.03 Myers March 30, 1999 Outline Topic: What types of movies do you prefer? Discuss these categories and explain your preferences.
Comparison Of Mary Shelly
’s Frankenstein To Movies And TV Show’s Frankenstein Essay, Research Paper Comparison Of Mary Shelly’s Frankenstein to Movies and TV Show’s Frankenstein
2Pac Shakur Essay Research Paper 2Pac Shakur
2Pac Shakur Essay, Research Paper 2Pac Shakur Tupac (Two-pahk) Amur Shakur, commonly known as 2pac, led a violent life. He died on September 13, 1996. He was a gangsta rapper/Aspiring actor. Tupac was
Stephen KingS Why We Crave Horror Movies
? Essay, Research Paper A Critique of Stephen King?s ?Why We Crave Horror Movies? Elliot Potter In Stephen King?s essay ?Why We Crave Horror Movies? he suggested that
Pirates And The Movies Essay Research Paper
Pirates and The Movies There are many things that effect people during the course of their lives. I myself don?t have anything that really affects me. Since I am a student I try to keep away from many issues that plague our society today, so it was quite hard to find two issues that I find special to me. The issues I found are on how movies can influence society bad and piracy over the internet.
Television Vs Movies Essay Research Paper Before
Television Vs Movies Essay, Research Paper Before there was television and motion pictures (movies), people used to spend their leisure time listening to the radio. They were offered little variety and often routinely listened to the same things. In the late 1800?s and early 1900?s, motion pictures and television were invented, respectively.
Why Do People Like Scarry Movies Essay
, Research Paper For years people have been scared by horror movies and they continue going back. Alfred Hitchcock once said, “drama is life with the dull bits left out.” Why do people like to watch other people get hurt and die while being scared enough to make them jerk in their seat? Movie goers like horror movies because people in general have dull lives.
Violence In Films Essay Research Paper What
Violence In Films Essay, Research Paper What place does violence have in the movies? Well, I believe that violence has a place in movies depending on the particular film and what the director of the film is trying to portray. If the director uses violence in his/her film and there isn’t any reason behind it, then I would disagree and say that violence shouldn’t be in THAT particular film.
Of Mice And Men A Comparison Of
The 2 Movies And The Book Essay, Research Paper In Class we watched two movies based on a book we read called Of Mice and Men. Both of the movies were very similar to the book. In I was able to hear exact lines from the book in the two movies.
Antigone Essay Research Paper In our society
Antigone Essay, Research Paper In our society today, movies and television shows are being broadcast all over the world to many genders, races, and ages. Some of these shows involve many violent topics and situations. For example, the news qualifies as a violent shows because three fourths of every broadcast involves a violent situation.
Perception Of Others Essay Research Paper Perception
Perception Of Others Essay, Research Paper Perception of others and myself has played a big role in my life. It has changed the way society thinks. It has us thinking twice about someone or something, before we can make an assumption. Without perception everyone would probably be boring. It was my first day at Walter J.high school.
Music 2
Music & Movies Essay, Research Paper Music & Movies This paper is based on what I know about music. Music is a way of life, and life would be a mistake without music. Music can encourage ones emotions, thoughts, and feelings.
People With Disabilities Essay Research Paper My
People With Disabilities Essay, Research Paper My Left Foot, The Elephant Man, and Mask are all movies about people with disabilities. These three movies depict the lives of three men and the way
Movies Essay Research Paper Many people go
Movies Essay, Research Paper Many people go to the movies. The movies are an escape into a fantasy world. Everyone has a different preference on what kind of movie is the best. Romance, horror, action, and comedy are different types of movies. The kind of movie someone goes to see can give clues to what kind of person they are.
Life Is Like Essay Research Paper Life
Life Is Like Essay, Research Paper Life is like a car. When it?s new, it usually works all right. As time drives by, it breaks down and needs repairs. Life is like a leaf. In its youth, it
Violence Essay Research Paper Violence Violence is
Violence Essay, Research Paper Violence Violence is the biggest problem kids, teenagers, and adults have in our society today. Everyday there is usually a headline story or article about a shooting, or killing.
Big Daddy Essay Research Paper Big KidOne
Big Daddy Essay, Research Paper Big Kid One of the most recent movies that i have seen is Big Daddy. When this movie came out in theaters I knew that it was going to be a hit because the main character (Adam Sandler)