’s Existence Essay, Research Paper
The first argument introduced by Aquinas states that nothing could move, unless it is being moved by something else, suggesting that there is an original mover. Aquinas asserts that motion is nothing else than the reduction of something from potentiality to actuality, but nothing can be reduced from potentiality to actuality except by something in a state of actuality. Further, he concludes that since the relationship between motion and mover can’t go on to infinity, there must have been a first mover- God. However, the first argument ignites several questions. First, how do we know that all things are in motion? The idea of motion is based on sense perception, simply showing but not proving that all existing things are in motion. Then, which sense perception is the accurate one? Apparently, Aquinas does not present facts supporting his idea for the existence of God. He uses the notion of motion introduces earlier by Aristotle, but in opposition to him, St Thomas saw all motion as purposeful. A purpose denotes a plan and, if there’s a plan, there must be planner. Therefore, movement in the universe happening to the scale at which it does “proves” a grand planner indeed. Aristotle didn’t see movement as having an end, one designed by God. Motion to Aristotle, and to many atheists, can just be motion, with no particular plan behind it. Then, another question appears of what if the creation of the universe has happened by chance and not by design. Thus, there is no necessity for a first mover. Finally, it is also reasonable to imagine the universe to be infinite in space and time, with a never-ending series of causal movements. How can then Aquinas logically link something unknown in the world with something known in the world? At best, this teleological argument can only suggest the possibility of a grand architect but cannot provide evidence that God, the unmoved mover, has created the universe. The second proof for the existence of God, defined by Aquinas, is related to the first one and also rests on the Aristotelian philosophy. To Aquinas, since nothing can exist prior to and as cause of itself, there must be an order, chain of efficient causes in the world. Similarly to the idea in the previous argument, Aquinas states that there can’t be an infinite number of efficient causes, and thus he identifies the first efficient cause as God. Again several paradoxes are formed from the formulation of this argument. To begin with, the question appears of how St Thomas Aquinas decides that everyone calls this first cause “God.” Obviously, this proof relies heavily on acceptance of the first proof. Aquinas again assumes that motion has purpose, and that purpose denotes an intelligent planner. However, there is no evidence that simply because God is the first cause and pure actuality, God is the cause of His own being. Further by stating that the line of causes cannot go on to infinity, Thomas Aquinas establishes the endpoint of God. The problem I see is that this argument could always be tested to be false by asking the question, “What Caused God?” St. Thomas Aquinas would probably answer that God is the uncaused cause because God has always existed. To prove this argument, St. Thomas Aquinas must accompany it by another argument that proves God has existed forever. Then, God would not need to have been caused since He would have always been. This would lead to a paradox in that he could not prove God existed, until he proved God has existed forever, and he obviously cannot prove that God has existed forever until he proves that God exists at all. Cycling around those questions doesn’t prove the existence of God. In addition, Aquinas’ philosophy does not allow for simultaneous causation, which can be a reasonable explanation of the creation of the Universe. Moreover, Aquinas does not provide evidence that there is just one uncaused cause. Because of this, I do not believe God’s existence can be proved by means of St. Thomas Aquinas’ first and second arguments. The third proof for the existence of God is the one out of the ideas of contingency and necessity. Following the ideas of Avicenna, Aquinas considers God’s existence as inseparable from His essence. This leads to the notion that there is no possibility in the Aquinas’ philosophy for the existence of God as an independent one. God is existence himself and has the power to confer existence to other beings. Logically, if we ask the question, “Who made the universe?” then, it is also reasonable to ask the question, “Who made God?” Aquinas stated that God is the only one whose existence is out of necessity. However, if you can come to the conclusion that at least one being came into existence of its own necessity, why not two, three or more? The God of the Bible is a Trinity of Persons. Thus, who is to say there was only one original Prime Mover? Isn’t there a possibility that there were many Gods, working on the creation of the Universe together? Perhaps, our universe is a result of one of many attempts of creation. Further, the question appears of whether the Universe itself exists out of necessity. Then, does the Universe have teleology or a goal? If there are only contingent beings and this universe has existed through an infinite amount of time, then all possibilities of everything must have already occurred. And one of those possibilities is the simultaneous non-existence of all beings.
To Aquinas, the fourth proof of the existence of God rests on the observation of degrees of perfection or goodness in the word. This argument from gradation is drawn from the ideas of Augustine and Plato. Aquinas considers that there are degrees of perfections: good, better, perfect and so on. This implies the notion that there is Being that is the most perfect one. This highest “being,” according to Aquinas, is the cause for the relative perfection of other beings. In addition, Aquinas presumes God’s existence as equal and inseparable from his essence. However, the conclusion that Aquinas reaches is based on an observation of a different existence, existence that is not relevant to God and therefore can’t be compared with Him, as He is the only one who is essence and existence are the same time. The question is obvious as to how can someone know of the existence of God, when there is nothing else that one can compare that existence to. Human view is too limited to allow extrapolation from the physical world into the divine world. St Thomas has not yet demonstrated that God exists but he is “proving” God’s existence by describing God’s qualities. Also, when describing God as the only being that is both existence and essence Aquinas regards “being” as a characteristic related only to Him. Can “being” be a characteristic and if it is then it must be separable from essence? Thus, one can see the circular conflict that erupts from Aquinas’ ideas about the nature of God. Another problem recognized according to the premise of the fourth argument is the existence of evil and its place in Aquinas’ philosophy. Evil cannot belong to the created order, as God both conceives of the forms and creates the substance. Existence for the beings created by God is understood as good that tends toward its goal, or Him. Thus, Aquinas’ explanation is based on the notion that there is no “duality,” meaning evil does not exist separate. However, evil is the worst argument against the existence of God. How can a good God create beings and order that does not exclude evil in the framework? St. Thomas Aquinas’ fifth argument is based on the rules and laws that operate in the Universe, suggesting that there is an order in it. This is the teleological argument, which states that the order in the Universe presumes the existence of a Being that has established this order. Aquinas states the argument from design for the existence of God based on analogy. However, does an intelligent design means the existence of an intelligent designer? By looking at nature, it is evident that nature is a dynamic existence. Then, the question of what exactly is nature or the Universe spurs diverse descriptions of its essence. Sense perception reveals the complexity and dynamics of this living organism. However, the result or effect of something does not prove the cause of its existence. Again, Aquinas implies that by knowing the physical world we should know God. At the same time, human knowledge, which arises out of experience and perception in the physical world, has in lesser capacity than God himself but can be compared with him. By suggesting the above notion, Aquinas wants to proof his world-view, which assumes that God has not only created the divine order but also sustains this order. Then, logically we can ask, “How can such a divine and complex order be compared to the physical, perceptive world?” To Aquinas, God’s functions not only by overlooking the order that he has created, but he also sustains the universe. Thus, St. Thomas Aquinas attempts to describe qualities and functions of God, by means of which he wants to prove his existence. Therefore, this proof of the existence of God made by analogy of something so incomprehensible as the divine world cannot be strong evidence. There is no straight relationship between the result of creation and the creator. Thus, the order of the universe cannot prove the existence of an intelligent designer. In conclusion, Summa Theologica presents Aquinas’ attempt to integrate faith and reason. He endeavored to prove that the two truths could never be in conflict. Aquinas believed that the natural mind could find truths concerning the physical attributes of the universe, but without faith, reason couldn’t grasp spiritual truths such as God. However, it becomes obvious that there are many uncertainties and questions about the existence of God. This leads to the conclusion that it is impossible to integrate faith and reason, without presenting conflicting truths derived from the attempt to unite Aristotelian philosophy with Christian theology.
Другие работы по теме:
God Essay Research Paper Sharon ChongINTPHILDecember 10
God Essay, Research Paper Sharon Chong INTPHILDecember 10, 1999 DOES GOD EXIST? If you take a look up out in the sky on a seemingly clear night, try and ask yourself how the stars, the moon and everything else came to be. Again the question of existence takes over your mind the same way it did everyone else’s years ago.
Slagle Essay Research Paper 1 How does
Slagle Essay, Research Paper 1. How does direct reason differ from garden variety intuition? Well,garden-variety intuition is one species of direct reason, I suppose. Just as our deductions can be known with greater or lesser degrees ofprecision and certainty, so too can our direct reasonings be knownwith greater or lesser degrees of precision and certainty.
Terms And Conditions Essay Research Paper TERMS
Terms And Conditions Essay, Research Paper TERMS AND CONDITIONS The conditions for the design price quote are as follows: 1) This quote is for the above stated AppleWax Music, Inc. proposal only. Any changes will require a new proposal and price quote.
Archimedes Of Syracuse Essay Research Paper Archimedes
Archimedes Of Syracuse Essay, Research Paper Archimedes of Syracuse (ca. 287-ca. 212 BC) Greek mathematician who flourished in Sicily. He is generally considered to be the greatest mathematician of ancient times. Most of the facts about his life come from a biography about the Roman soldier Marcellus written by the Roman biographer Plutarch.
Euclid Essay Research Paper Euclid of Alexandria
Euclid Essay, Research Paper Euclid of Alexandria is thought to have lived from about 325 BC until 265 BC in Alexandria, Egypt. There is very little known about his life. It was thought he was born in Megara, which was proven to be incorrect. There is in fact a Euclid of Megara, but he was a philosopher who lived 100 years before Euclid of Alexandria.
Christianity Vs Evolution Essay Research Paper While
Christianity Vs. Evolution Essay, Research Paper While a good portion of the wold’s population has already made up their minds, evolutionists are still searching for new evidence proving evolution over the more common and realistic belief of the Christian God. All Christians admit that evolutionists have far more evidence and information, however each theory contradicts the others in some way.
Aquinas Essay Research Paper According to Aquinas
Aquinas Essay, Research Paper According to Aquinas everything is created was created by God. Aquinas made five proofs to proof the God exists and HE created everything. His five proofs are motion, efficient cause, possibility/necessity, gradation, and governance of the world.
Saint Thomas Aquinas Writings Essay Research Paper
In “Summa Contra Gentiles”, by Saint Thomas Aquinas, one of the major proofs of the existence of God is the second proof. The second proof is based on the “everything has a cause” theory. He states that there are ordered lines of efficient causes, and nothing can be it’s own cause. Yet it is impossible for the line of efficient causes to extend into infinity.
St Thomas Aquinas Essay Research Paper What
St. Thomas Aquinas Essay, Research Paper What is the Best Way to Prove God? A Comparison of St. Thomas Aquinas St. Thomas Aquinas is one of the greatest theologians that has ever been. He recognized that there
The Forms And Limits Of Adjudication Essay
, Research Paper Adjudication is the process of judgement within the government as well as within relations in common society. Any person who stands to judge an action of another person is participating in adjudication. Creating social order if the defining principles of adjudication, The The relation of men to regulate one another.
Spinoza Essay Research Paper This paper will
Spinoza Essay, Research Paper This paper will outline Spinoza s argument in Part 1 of his Ethics of substance. He argues that there is only one substance, which is the same as God, that includes everything in the universe. It will walk through each proposition and explain his proof of it, which relies of his stated definitions.
The Origin Of Ideas Essay Research Paper
The Origins of Ideas Webster’s dictionary defines the word idea as 1) something, such as a thought or conception, that potentially or actually exists in the mind as a product of mental activity, 2) an opinion, a conviction, or a principle, 3) a plan, scheme, or method 4) the gist of a specific situation, and 5) a notion.
Aliens Essay Research Paper Aliens Are They
Aliens Essay, Research Paper Aliens, Are They Really Out There Aliens, are they really out there? One may ask that question. There are no proofs of any interaction with aliens. So many people report being abducted by aliens is that true? So many questions and no little answers. Aliens can be fragments of our imagination, moreover human imagination is very wild.
The Art Of Euclid
’s Writing Essay, Research Paper In Elements book one, Euclid incorporates stylistic devices in the process of proving a series of mathematical theories. One stylistic aspect of Euclid?s writing is his use of common notions, such as the whole being greater than the part, and postulates, such as drawing a line from any point to any point.
Pythagoras Essay Research Paper In 580 BC
Pythagoras Essay, Research Paper In 580 B.C. there lived a man who is know for creating one the best known theorems ever. His name was Pythagoras and the theorem, the Pythagorean Theorem. This Theorem states that the sum of the squares of the two legs of a right triangle equals the hypotenuse squared. This theorem as you can see can be very useful for finding the lengths of a right triangle.
Atlantis A Lost Continent Essay Research Paper
Introduction. Atlantis was a continent of the Atlantic Ocean where, according to Plato, an advanced civilization developed some 11,600 years ago. Plato affirms that, as the result of a huge volcanic cataclysm of worldwide extent, this continent sunk away underseas, disappearing forever. Official Science – the one you learn at school – rejects the actual existence of Atlantis, as it has so far been unable to find any traces of its reality.
The Fundamental Theorem Of Algebra Essay Research
Paper The Fundamental Theorem of Algebra states that every polynomial equation of degree n with complex coefficients has n roots in the complex numbers. In fact, there are many equivalent formulations: for example that every real polynomial can be expressed as the product of real linear and real quadratic factors.
St Thomas AquinasProofs Of Gods Existance Essay
, Research Paper St. Thomas Aquinas: Proofs of God?s existence. Aquinas says that God?s essence (feeling) is his existence. That there is no Actual need for proof of his existence. Before he actually developed his
Stigmata And The Truth About God Essay
, Research Paper The film Stigmata is a graphic and frightening tale of spiritual awakening that provokes the viewer to question their own faith in religion. It is not merely a film about a young stigmatic woman. More importantly director Rupert Wainwright has produced a film portraying his view of the Catholic Church.
Mathemtical Logic Essay Research Paper Mathematical logic
Mathemtical Logic Essay, Research Paper Mathematical logic is something that has been around for a very long time. Centuries Ago Greek and other logicians tried to make sense out of mathematical proofs. As time went on other people tried to do the same thing but using only symbols and variables. But I will get into detail about that a little later.
If I Can
’t See God, How Do I Know God Exists Essay, Research Paper The mystery of God’s existence has been a crucial element of many religious studies and traditions. Who is God? What is God? Where is God? To effectively discuss the existence of God, it is necessary to illustrate the notion of faith. People of faith believe that God does exist, and that relationship with God gives meaning to their lives.
Jealousy In Othello Essay Research Paper What
Jealousy In Othello Essay, Research Paper What is the most disastrous human emotion? William Shakespeare s Othello makes it clear that the answer to this question is jealousy. After all, it is jealousy that drives Iago to concoct the plan, which ruins the lives of several innocent people including Othello, Desdemona, Emilia, and Roderigo.
Cosmological Argument Essay Research Paper How Well
Cosmological Argument Essay, Research Paper How Well Does the Cosmological Argument Hold Water? The Cosmological Argument is one of the most heavily disputed arguments for God’s existence of our time. The argument in its simplest form is: “Everything has to be caused by or created from something else . . . therefore there must be a first cause, namely God.” The very basis of the argument, everything is caused, is what makes it an argument.
Work Of Euclid For Geometry Essay Research
Paper The Work of Euclid for Geometry Euclid is one of the most influential and best read mathematicians of all time. His prize work, Elements, was the textbook of elementary geometry and logic up to the early twentieth century. For his work in the field, he is known as the father of geometry and is considered one of the great Greek mathematicians.
A Proof For The Existence Of God
Essay, Research Paper The quandary of the existence of God has troubled mankind for thousands of years. The existence of God was once never denied, as His presence, His existence was evident in miracles and the people s faith. But time and the advancement of modern science have called God and His very nature into question.
Ernest Hemingway- Allegorical Figures In THE
SUN ALSO RISES Essay, Research Paper Hemingway 1 Ernest Hemingway: Allegorical Figures in The Sun Also Rises Hemingway 2 Thesis: Hemingway deliberately shaped the protagonists in The Sun
Philosophy 2
Philosophy – God Question Essay, Research Paper Philosophy as defined by our required text is said to be “the love of wisdom. It is the search for the larger picture, the demand for knowledge.” There are many questions in philosophy, many involving the subject of religion. Does God exist? Should we believe in God? Is belief in God justified? These are just some of the questions attempted to be answered in philosophy.
Odysseus The Great Essay Research Paper Odysseus
Odysseus The Great Essay, Research Paper Odysseus the Great Of all the mythological heroes, Odysseus would have to be the greatest. His adventures strengthened him and made him wiser. Although his men assisted him in his warfare, Odysseus was always at the heart of the battle. Odysseus was a true epic hero.
Geometry Essay Research Paper Differences in Geometry
Geometry Essay, Research Paper Differences in Geometry… Geometry is the branch of mathematics that deals with the properties of space. Geometry is classified between two separate branches, Euclidean and Non-Euclidean Geometry. Being based off different postulates, theorems, and proofs, Euclidean Geometry deals mostly with two-dimensional figures, while Demonstrative, Analytic, Descriptive, Conic, Spherical, Hyperbolic, are Non-Euclidean, dealing with figures containing more than two-dimensions.
Daughter Of Fortune Essay Research Paper Daughter
Daughter Of Fortune Essay, Research Paper Daughter of Fortune In the book, Daughter of Fortune, by Isabel Allende, the characters are ever changing. You have Eliza, who through most of the novel dresses as a boy, Jacob Todd who transitions between a Bible salesman and a newspaper reporter, Joe Bonecrusher who transitions from a tough, emotionless woman to a very caring person, and Joaquin who transitions from an innocent, poor Chilean boy to a person who is hunted down and killed.