’s Plans Essay, Research Paper
In the late 1780s, prominent political leaders in the United States came to realize
that the government created under the Articles of Confederation was ineffective and
impractical and could not serve a nation in managing relationships among states nor
handle foreign nations. The fear of creating a government that was too powerful was the
basis for foundation of the Articles of Confederation. It created a weak national
government that allowed for most of the power to be under the control of the state
legislatures. Under the Articles, Congress had no means to prevent war or security
against foreign invasion. The federal government could not check the quarrels between
states or regulate interstate trade, collect taxes, enforce laws. These weaknesses of the
confederation distressed political leaders; in response, they requested a assemblage in
order to revise the Articles and revive the ailing nation. In May of 1787, representatives
from each state gathered in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, to find the means of turning the
United States government into an efficient and powerful business that conducted affairs
in practical ways.
The delegates meeting at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia in 1787
were given expressed consent to alter and revise the Articles of Confederation. With the
exception of those from New Jersey and Virginia, the delegates intended to revise the
Articles. One of 55 delegates, William Paterson and his colleagues Roger Sherman,
Ellsworth, and Dickinson offered a list of suggestions for revising the Articles of
Confederation in his New Jersey Plan. Paterson was a delegate from New Jersey who
favored the weak national government that the Articles created. Patterson asserted the
rights of the small states against the large states and wished to expand upon the Articles
making a more practical and efficient government. The New Jersey Plan suggested the
Congress maintain its unicameral house system, with states equally represented. They
proposed that the Congress would have the power to regulate interstate trade and could
have closely limited power to tax. It also called for a ?federal Executive? with persons
appointed by Congress who could be removed on the request of a majority of the state
governors. The New Jersey plan also allowed for a ?federal Judiciary? with a single
?supreme tribunal? appointed by an executive. The New Jersey plan offered a series of
solutions to the growing concern that the government was too weak under the Articles.
Patterson?s proposals were supported by those who discouraged a strong national
government.
Just as Patterson created a plan, James Madison created a plan that offered
solutions to the flawed Articles of Confederation. Prior to their arrival at the Philadelphia
Convention, Madison and the other Virginian delegates formulated a revised document
that would eliminate the Articles of Confederation and create an entirely new document.
The Virginia Plan called for a stronger national government. The Plan would create a
federal system with the existence of two governments, national and state, each given a
certain amount of authority. Under the Virginia Plan, the national government would
have the power to collect its own taxes and make and enforce its own laws. The
government would consist of three separate branches, the legislative, the judicial and the
executive. The legislative branch, under the Virginia Plan, was bicameral, with the
number of representatives in each house based on proportional representation, or the
number of people in each state. The representatives of the lower house, or the House of
Representatives, would be popularly elected and the representatives of the upper house, or
Senate, would be chosen by the lower house. Congress would also have the power to
veto any state law in conflict with national law, and to accept new states to the Union. In
addition, an Executive branch would have the authority to execute national law and the
Judiciary branch would consist of one or more supreme tribunals and of inferior tribunals.
Both the Judiciary and the Executive branches would be able to override and veto acts of
Congress creating a system of checks and balances.
While both the New Jersey and the Virginia Plan offered solutions to the
problems governing the United States created by the Articles of Confederation, there
were major differences between the two plans. The major differences debated at the
Philadelphia Convention concerned the debate over what powers to give the new
government, the creation of subsequent branches, checks and balances, and the principles
of representation, singular of plural executive. After hours of delegations, it seemed as if
neither Plan could be accepted by small states who did not want proportional
representation and those who feared a tyrannical leader of there was a singular executive.
The delegates to the Constitutional Convention disputed over the two proposals. After
three days of deliberations, the New Jersey Plan was rejected due to the overwhelming
demand to create an effective national government. Despite the advantages of both plans,
neither posed a solution to the fears of all the delegates consequently the Virginia Plan
was also discarded. What they created instead was a bundle of compromises. The new
Delegates compromised to secure the integrity of the smaller states and relinquish the
fears of those who believed the central government was too powerful.
If I had been a delegate to the Philadelphia Convention, I would have opposed the
idea of a plural executive and favored that of a singular executive. I would support the to
have With an appropriate number of advisors, the American people could be assured that
an Executive leader could be relied on make quality decisions to ensure the success of the
nation. In addition, a single executive is more likely to be responsible for the decisions
made and in effect be more prudent in the process. It seems that an executive committee
would create chaos in the executive branch by the way of disagreement on how to handle
the affairs of the nation. That kind of uncertainty would not assure the people that
government was in good hands.
Alexander Hamilton asked, ?And what even is the Virginia Plan but democracy
checked by democracy…?? The parts of the VA plan that are ?democracy checked by
democracy? are the provisions that provide for three separate branches that can veto the
other and override decisions. This complicated system of checks and balances is the basis
of the government that the Constitution of the United States created.
368
Другие работы по теме:
Antonin Scalia Essay Research Paper Supreme Court
Antonin Scalia Essay, Research Paper Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia was born on March 11, 1936 in Trenton, New Jersey to a Sicilian immigrant father and an Italian-American mother and was raised in Queens. He attended Catholic schools in New York City as a child and teen. Scalia then attended Georgetown University, spending his junior year at the University of Fribourg in Switzerland, and graduated at the top of his class with an A.B. (Sorry, I don?t know what that means) in 1957.
The Great Compromise Essay Research Paper In
The Great Compromise Essay, Research Paper In May 1787, fifty-five delegates from eleven of the thirteen American states assembled in Philadelphia. Their goal was to revise the current government created by the Articles of Confederation, which had been in effect since 1781. The Articles had created a weak alliance among the states.
Federalists Vs Antifederalists Essay Research Paper Federalists
Federalists Vs. Antifederalists Essay, Research Paper Federalists vs. Antifederalists To amend the Articles of Confederation, unanimous approval by all thirteen colonies was a necessity. Instead of reforming the preexisting document, it was decided that once approved by nine states, a newly written document would become the supreme law of the land.
Espanol Essay Research Paper Yo naci en
Espanol Essay, Research Paper Yo naci en Nueve Jersey, pero vivi en Nueva York. Cuando tenia tres anos me mude a nuevo a Nueve Jersey. En el verano iba con mis padres a la India a visitabamos mis
Compromises Of Political Ideals In Favor Of
Political Expediency Essay, Research Paper Compromises of Political Ideals in Favor of Political Expediency The Constitution of the United States of America was a document that contained many compromises the balanced political idealism with political expediency. Political idealism is the set of beliefs that the Constitutionalists ultimately wanted to achieve in the new government.
Piedmont Essay Research Paper One of the
Piedmont Essay, Research Paper One of the physical regions in New Jersey is a piedmont. The Atlantic Coastal Plain Piedmont Ridge, and Valley region and high land have different land. They are also regions. Some of New Jersey s biggest cities are in Piedmonts. Some piedmont cities in New Jersey are Newark, Jersey City, Elizabeth, East Orange, Hoboken, Passaic, Clifton, Paterson, and Union City.
AntiFederalists Essay Research Paper AntiFederalists were people
Anti-Federalists Essay, Research Paper Anti-Federalists were people who opposed the ratification of the Constitution. They believed strongly that the Constitution would not be able toe maintain a system of republican government because the Federalists were proposing a government that was the opposite of what they believed in.
New Jersey Vs TLO Essay Research Paper
Christopher D. Monroe II New Jersey Vs. T.L.O. Facts of the Case On March 7, 1985 T.L.O. and another student were found smoking in the woman?s bathroom. They were then taken to see the Assistant Principal, Mr. Choplick, and were questioned about smoking
Constitution Essay Research Paper The Constitution of
Constitution Essay, Research Paper The Constitution of the United States of America We the people of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, ensure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
Framers Of The Constitution Essay Research Paper
Framers of the Constitution The constitution was never in any way a perfect document. Opponents of thisopinion say that the framers meant it to be that way, leaving much space for change,when the changes became necessary. The constitutionhas had to have many changes made,which makes it look as if the original writers of the constitution had no idea of whatwould come of this country in the future.
An Opinion On Age Requirements In The
US Essay, Research Paper Since the beginning of time people have had an idea of right and wrong. As civilization progressed, we adapted these ideas and made them into laws. Laws are in place so people have rules and boundaries. These things are necessary so people don?t just run amuck doing harm to others and instilling chaos.
The Formation Of The American Government Essay
, Research Paper The United Kingdom had been the dominating force of government in the colonies since the arrival of the first settlers. These colonists benefited significantly from British rule. They were provided with an ordered, limited, representative government ( A government which was later to be used as the model to form their own).
Constitution Essay Research Paper The United States
Constitution Essay, Research Paper The United States Constitution was discussed and established from the Constitutional Convention of 1787. The Convention was held in the Pennsylvania State House. It lasted from May 25, 1787 to September 17, 1787. The thirteen stated that existed at the time were invited to attend.
TLO Vs New Jersey Essay Research Paper
TLO vs. New Jersey: When Is The Constitution Invalid? In the case of New Jersey vs. TLO, I rule in favor of the petitioner, the state of New Jersey. In this case, I found no reason in the claims made by
Kentucky Virginia Resolution Essay Research Paper The
Kentucky Virginia Resolution Essay, Research Paper The Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions The Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions were authored in secret by Thomas Jefferson and James Madison in response to the repressive Alien and Sedition Acts passed in 1798. In the opinion of Jefferson and Madison, the Acts were unjust.
Our Founding Fathers Motives Essay Research Paper
Some people see the Founders of our constitution as capitalists, out only to benefit themselves and their bank accounts, and yet others see them as people who were only out to benefit the actual people of the United States. In my opinion, every man that was involved with writing the constitution was a little of both.
Virginia Woolf And Her Friendships With Women
Essay, Research Paper Virginia Woolf – Friendships With Women Virginia Woolf was sexually abused as a child. While the extent and duration of this abuse is difficult to establish, it is known that two of her older stepbrothers sexually harassed and abused her between the ages of twelve and twenty-one and perhaps as early as six.
Virginia Woolf Essay Research Paper My Thought
Virginia Woolf Essay, Research Paper My Thought on Virginia Woolf There are many authors who have the ability to be one of the greatest writers of all time, but to my knowledge of books I believe the majority I read are excellent. Virginia Woolf to many, is a prominent writer. I wish I could say the same as well.
John Marshall The Great Chief Justice Essay
, Research Paper John Marshall: The Great Chief Justice John Marshall was born in Fauquier County, Virginia on September 4, 1755. He was the first son of Thomas Marshall and Mary Randolph Keith. His role in American history is undoubtedly a very important one. As a boy, Marshall was educated by his father. He learned to read and write, along with some lessons in history and poetry.
John Marshall Essay Research Paper My name
John Marshall Essay, Research Paper My name is John Marshall. I am the son of Thomas and Mary Marshall. I was Born on the 24th of September, 1755. I was the oldest of fifteen children in my family. As a child I lived in the near frontier region of Virginia. I was mostly educated by my parents at home. I had more teaching at an academy in Westmore land County.
John Tyler Essay Research Paper Early CareerJohn
John Tyler Essay, Research Paper Early Career John Tyler was born in Charles City county, Va., on March 29, 1790. A member of the tobacco-planting aristocracy of Tidewater Virginia, he was the son of John Tyler, governor of Virginia from 1808 to 1811, and Mary Armistead. Bent on a political career, he attended the College of William and Mary, graduating in 1807.
Thomas Jefferson Essay Research Paper When i
Thomas Jefferson Essay, Research Paper When i say Thomas Jefferson, many people think of the Declaration of Independence and the Bill of Rights. Thomas Jefferson was born in 1743 and died in 1826. He was the third president of the United States. Jefferson’s fathers name was Peter Jefferson and he was a prosperous Virginia planter.
Patrick Henry A Brief Overview Essay Research
Paper Patrick Henry Patrick Henry was a great patriot. He never used his fists or guns to fight for his country, but he used a much more powerful weapon at which he held great skill: his words. Possibly the greatest orator of his time, his speeches such as “Give Me Liberty or Give Me Death” struck a cord in the American spirit of those who opposed oppression and tyranny.
Virginia Essay Research Paper In the world
Virginia Essay, Research Paper In the world today there are many things that are alike and that are different. These things have comparisons and contrasts. There are also comparisons and contrasts in old literature. There are many things alike and many things that are different about General History of Virginia and of Plymouth Plantation.
Constitution 3 Essay Research Paper The American
Constitution 3 Essay, Research Paper The American Constitution The basis of all law in the United States is the Constitution. This Constitution is a document written by “outcasts” of England. The Constitution of the United States sets forth the nation’s fundamental laws. It establishes the form of the national government and defines the rights and liberties of the American people.
The Bill Of Rights Essay Research Paper
The Bill of Rights Bill of Rights The first ten amendments to the US constitution are called the Bill of Rights because they provide basic legal protection for individual rights. The
Patrick Henry Essay Research Paper
“If this be treason make the worst of it!” These were the words I spoke in my speech against the Stamp Act of 1765. As explained to me by my father and mother, John and Sarah Winston, I, Patrick Henry was born May
Constitutional Convention Essay Research Paper The Constitutional
Constitutional Convention Essay, Research Paper The Constitutional Convention Our country was based upon the idea that every citizen has certain rights that can not be taken away from him/her; these inalienable rights form the backbone for our democracy. Our constitution, which secures our rights and how we are governed, was not an easy task to write.
Cohen Vs Virginia Essay Research Paper is
Cohen Vs Virginia Essay, Research Paper is Cohens vs. Virginia, in which the question arose as to the right of the Supreme Court to exercise its appellate jurisdiction over the judgment of a state court involving the validity of state legislation. The contention of the counsel for the state struck at the very root of the judicial system of the Union, with its authority to review state decisions which involved the binding effect of the Federal Constitution and laws: and so to the discussion of this fundamental question Marshall brought his heaviest artillery.
The Beginning Of The Constitution Essay Research
Paper The Beginning of the Constitution The constitution was made up of many impressive and historic documents, which when combined made one of the most historic documents in world history. The constitution takes many of the most historic facts from other resources. For example, the Magna Carta and the Leviathan.