Paper
Juliana Gomez-Frausto
Comm132
October 20, 2000
Group Climate and Achieving Goals
The climate in a group is very important. It greatly influences the outcome of the situation and
the outcome of the problem. The amount of support, the type of messages, and the degree of
cohesiveness are the defining factors which determine the climate of the group. The film ?Waking Ned
Devine? shows all these factors throughout the movie, especially in the church scene.
A defensive climate evolves when a member of the group focuses more on his own needs rather
than on those of the group. This person is primarily concerned with his own benefit, even at the his
group?s cost (Cartwright & Zander, 1960). This type of climate appears when the person attacks
another person instead of the issue, tries to manipulate the situation, has a hidden agenda, has no
interest, feels superior, and leaves no room for error (Beebe & Masterson, 2000). In the movie, the
?witch? Lizzie Queen tries to manipulate the situation to gain the most. Her secret agenda is to keep
most of the lottery money, and this brings on a defensive climate. She almost prevents the town of
Tulley More from achieving its goal; she brought the group climate down.
A supportive climate does the exact opposite. In this climate, members of the group truly care
for the group and goal, have no hidden agendas, and can admit when they are wrong (Cartwright &
Zander, 1960). There is also a sense of equality and trust in this climate (Beebe & Masterson, 2000).
There are several examples of supportive climates throughout the movie, including the scene in which
Jackie lets the town know of his plans and wishes of attaining the winnings. The town accepts the offer,
and the people begin working towards this goal with a sense of equality since the money will be spent
in 52 equal shares.
The climate of the group is greatly affected by the type of responses and messages the members
send to each other. The group is bound to have a defensive climate if members use disconfirming
responses, those that lower the people?s self-esteem (Cartwright & Zander, 1960). Ignoring,
interrupting, changing the direction of the conversation, rambling, or dominating the conversation are
all examples of disconfirming climates. Verbally saying something and having your body language say
another is also a disconfirming response (Beebe & Masterson, 2000). If a member receives this type of
response, he will not feel a real and essential part of the group and will therefore lose interest in the
group and its goal (Cartwright & Zander). Towards the first part of the movie, it seemed that Jackie
was sending disconfirming responses; he wouldn?t heed to Annie?s warnings and precautions. He
seemed to be ignoring her and completely undermining her. He put his agenda before that of his
marriage.
That changed, however, as the sum of the lottery increased and Jackie decided to bring in the
entire town. The responses changed between the original three from disconfirming to confirming. Annie
began reassuring her husband and offering him support. Confirming responses bring a feeling of
security into the group. They do so by the description of good feelings, reassurance, agreement,
acknowledgment, and clarification (Beebe & Masterson, 2000). When these responses are received,
they strengthen the commitment and members of the group work harder to achieve the goal
(Cartwright & Zander, 1960).
All this also plays a role in group cohesiveness, the attraction that exists between the members
of the group. This is not a physical attraction, rather, it is a sense of belonging, trust and commitment
that is achieved when the group goal becomes the individual?s goal (Beebe & Masterson, 2000).
Mutuality of concern is also a key part of cohesiveness, if members don?t feel the same level of
commitment, the group will suffer because this will lead to dissatisfaction and it will make the climate
defensive. On the other hand, if all members have the same level of commitment, they will increase their
communication and feel more attracted to each other. They will make and maintain a bond that will
improve the climate of the group(Cartwright & Zander, 1960). By working together to get the lottery
money, the people of Tulley More achieved cohesiveness. People who had never really associated
much were brought together and remained attractive to each other. The scheme brought the people
together, the group goal became each individual?s goal as each person planned what to do with his
share of the money. The members had a sense of belonging, and they liked it. Towards the end of the
movie, the attraction was established and demonstrated by the celebration in the pub.
The best scene in the movie, by far, is the church scene, when they are celebrating Ned?s
funeral mass. Jim Kelly shows up precisely when Jackie begins talking about Ned. Thanks to Jim?s
distinctive mark, his sneeze, the town people were able to recognize that he was the lottery man. Jackie
decides to change from Ned?s name to Michael, and he gives a wonderful speech. All the people in the
church pick up on this and ?go with the flow.? Nobody denies him or turns him in. This is the scene
where the deepest loyalty and commitment is present, therefore making it cohesive. Every single person
in that church shared the same level of commitment, and they all trusted and respected one another.
Their confirming response was to smile and nod at Jackie, reassuring him that he had their support. He
felt they were behind him all the way, and this created a supporting climate in which they all felt equal.
Everyone that was present maintained the same deep sense of loyalty they felt towards the goal and the
group.
The supportive climate, confirming response, and cohesiveness helped them make decisions and
solve their problems. Jim?s arrival was not expected yet, but since the group was already deeply
committed, all the members were able to make their decisions on the spot and they chose to encourage
and support Jackie at that critical moment. They were able to solve this problem of an ?almost-tragedy?
by sticking together and making good on their promises and remaining loyal to the group. Jim Kelly
asked all that were present if they could do him the favor of pointing out Ned Devine, and they pointed
over to Michael O? Sullivan, just like they had committed to do.
The group?s climate had a positive influence on the outcome of the situation. Through all the
support and commitment, the people were able to convince Jim that Michael was Ned Devine, which is
exactly what the goal was. They got the check and were finally going to get the share they wanted so
badly. They achieved the goal, completed the task, finished the job.
The outcome was a direct result of the group climate. If there had been no cohesiveness, if
there would have been more Lizzies, if no one would have been supportive, they would not have gotten
the money. he level of mutual respect and loyalty, the support, and the shared vision were necessary to
reach the goal. In order to achieve a goal, a group needs to build and maintain a good group climate.
Support, confirming responses, and cohesiveness are the deciding factors in climate.
Bibliography
References
Beebe, S. A., Masterson, J. T., (2000). Communicating in small groups: Principles and
practices New York: Longman.
Cartwright, D., Zander, A., (1960). Group dynamics: Resarch and theory New York: Harper & Row.
Другие работы по теме:
Goals Essay Research Paper A goal is
Goals Essay, Research Paper A goal is an achievement you want to accomplish. Many people have goals for certain reasons. There are many different kinds of goals such as short-term and long-term. Having goals are very important to some people because it gives them a sense of self-confidence.
Apa Crit Essay Research Paper APA Critical
Apa Crit Essay, Research Paper APA Critical Analysis: Teaching Students How to Learn Vol. 31, No. 6, June 2000 In ?Teaching Students How to Learn? it showed the correlation between high-achieving students and their self monitoring in classes. The article goes on to say that unlike high school, college students do not have the regulation in their classes.
Life Is Essay Research Paper There are
Life Is Essay, Research Paper There are only three basic types of people. There are those people who do not know what they want out of life and are doomed to make do with whatever life doles out to them. Then there are those people who know what they want out of life but are unwilling to take the necessary steps to achieve their goals.
Communication Climate Essay Research Paper I have
Communication Climate Essay, Research Paper I have found that the communication climate at the company I have worked for the last seven years is a combination of bureaucratic, human and system theories.
Sample Union White Paper Essay Research Paper
II. Negotiating Philosophy The union is looking to maintain all gains made in the last bargaining session. All areas identified as primary objectives will be improved upon. In addition, we are also seeking to improve our condition on many secondary issues.
Goals Essay Essay Research Paper My life
Goals Essay Essay, Research Paper My life will be the challenge of attaining three goals to their fullest degree: to learn, to love and to live. Oh! To learn- I will make my mind a sponge, soaking up every fact it encounters. In school and out of school, my ears, eyes and heart will be open to learn new things, and gather new facts.
Pursuing Your Dreams Essay Research Paper I
Pursuing Your Dreams Essay, Research Paper I have a dream. That quote by Martin Luther King, Jr. rings throughout our lives almost on a daily basis. We all have dreams and many of them become actual goals in our lives. Yet, what do we, as individuals, have to do in order to accomplish these goals? For me, to reach my goal of obtaining my Doctorate degree, I will have to have dedication, perseverance, and patience.
Norms Essay Research Paper NORMSNorms have a
Norms Essay, Research Paper NORMS Norms have a large impact on what makes a quality group. Without them, the group would basically go to pieces. When a group gets together for the first time there really aren?t any norms relevant. After one or two group meetings norms will start to come up, whether they be explicit or implicit.
Structure Of Hagia Sophia Essay Research Paper
Constantinople is a triangular peninsula surrounded by water except on the west and has a mildly temperate climate (Kostof, 265). No sources indicate that Anthemius and Isidore considered the climate or land conditions as considerations in design, but Hagia Sophia s base is longer on the north and south base and shorter on the east and west base as in many buildings that consider the path of the sun in design, indicating that some climate considerations were taken into account.
Ragged Dick Essay Research Paper Ragged DickRagged
Ragged Dick Essay, Research Paper Ragged Dick Ragged Dick is a novel written in the 1800 s by Horatio Alger. It is a story about a young boy named Richard Hunter, also known as Ragged Dick, as he progresses though his childhood. Ragged Dick is a typical Rags to Riches story where Dick struggles through the hardships of city life, trying to achieve the American Dream .
Goals Essay Research Paper Jonathan drlasEssay 4This
Goals Essay, Research Paper Jonathan drlas Essay 4 This is my first work on this paper. My goal that I?am going to incorporate in my paper is a money goal. I want to save up 3,000 dollars before I leave for school. I leave on the 15 of august so there is a little over two months that I have to achieve this goal.
Public Speaking Essay Research Paper Public SpeakingIn
Public Speaking Essay, Research Paper Public Speaking In the past, I have participated in a lot of classes and training dealing with many different topics, but unfortunately, public speaking and/ or communications was not one of them. In fact, the last class that I took even relatively close to this one was in junior high school.
Global Warming Effects Essay Research Paper How
Global Warming Effects Essay, Research Paper How the World is changing due to the effects caused by Global Warming The reason for this topic is our increasingly changing climate. Every year our climate
Why Are So Many Cultures Similar Yet
Different? Essay, Research Paper Why are so many cultures similar, yet different? Culture is the beliefs, behavior, language, and entire way of life of a particular time or group of people. Culture includes customs, ceremonies, works of art, inventions, technology, and traditions. The term also may have a more specific definition and can describe the intellectual and artistic achievements of a society.
Goals Essay Essay Research Paper In the
Goals Essay Essay, Research Paper In the following paragraphs I will be discussing my career goals and the steps I have taken to ensure my success in the future. I also will do a character profile of myself, which will include physical, emotional, and spiritual descriptions.
Macbeth Characters Essay Research Paper In the
Macbeth Characters Essay, Research Paper In the play Macbeth the characters are using certain prophesies to try and help themselves in gaining confidence and self-assurance in achieving their ultimate
Civil Diobedience Essay Research Paper While studying
Civil Diobedience Essay, Research Paper While studying Thoreau’s “Civil Disobedience” in my group, I learned that patience is necessary when working with people. Although when I came to this conclusion I was not aware of the comforts and advantages of working in a group. Some people like working in groups, then there are the independent type, these people enjoy working on their own.
Divine Discontene Essay Research Paper Each and
Divine Discontene Essay, Research Paper Each and every human strives to be better.A desire, a subconscious power, known as divine discontent leads them to dedicate themselves twoard becoming better or achieving greater goals. Divine discontent leads some to happiness, and others who do not succeed to failure.
Goal Setting Essay Research Paper Psychological
Goal Setting Essay, Research Paper Psychological training is an important aspect of any training program in sports. Goal setting is one particular aspect of a psychological skills training program. Often people brush this aside and do not pay the attention to it that is necessary. The first step in goal setting is to set short term goals that gradually build on each other.
Success Essay Research Paper SuccessOne has achieved
Success Essay, Research Paper Success One has achieved success who has lived well and laughed often. This quote seems to sum up what is meant by success. If you are able to laugh often and much then you have definitely achieved happiness. The idea of living well, though, is a very broad statement. In order, then, to define success in relation to this statement, we must first define what it means to live well.
Personal Goals Essay Research Paper Personal GoalsThis
Personal Goals Essay, Research Paper Personal Goals This is an essay about my personal goals that I have set for myself. I have set many different goals in my life. Some goals are more important than others, but all
Colonies And Their Goals Essay Research Paper
Achieving the Model Society (Colonies and their Goals) Many historical cultures are remembered for the successful way of life they achieved over time. Many of them achieved their success by creating goals and a vision and eventually fulfilling them. In America in the seventeenth century, the Northern and Southern Colonies were successful because of the goals that they set out to achieve.
Goals Essay Research Paper GOALS IN LIFEHigh
Goals Essay, Research Paper GOALS IN LIFE High school is a very important time in a persons life. This is the time to set goals. We not only set goals, but set out to find solutions. My first goal in no particular order is to become a good athlete. My next goal is to be a good student and graduate high school, with a 3.0 GPA.
Snowboarding And Safety Essay Research Paper RIDING
Snowboarding And Safety Essay, Research Paper RIDING SMART – ADVICE FOR SAFE SNOWBOARDING Preventing injuries will allow us to focus on fun, teamwork, and achieving individual goals. The most common injuries in snowboarding are to the wrist, shoulder, and head. Here are a few simple tips that I follow to reduce my risk of injury.
What Success Means To Me Essay Research
Paper What Success Means To Me Being successful can be looked upon in many different ways, such as being rich, having nice car, good job, or anything to make someone else jealous of what you have. Being successful to me means you accomplished what your goal or goals were.
About Me Essay Research Paper My culture
About Me Essay, Research Paper My culture, Hinduism, and race, Indian, have been the most influential characteristics in my life. These two characteristics combined also influence my other characteristics such as my age and sex. In America, my age restricts me from doing many things; but coming from a Hindu background brings me many more responsibilities along with my age.
Goals And Objectives Essay Research Paper Goals
Goals And Objectives Essay, Research Paper Goals and Objectives The number one goal of Hotshots is to provide a safe and enjoyable means of organized paintball, while incorporating a satisfying atmosphere for all of our customers. We will strive to create a fresh innovative environment to establish a new experience for every paintball fan.
Participation Essay Research Paper Chapter 9 Effective
Participation Essay, Research Paper Chapter 9- Effective Participation (Wilson 253-255) What: I will go through each of the five categories under effective participation and tell what I observed on our group for each one.
Dreams Essay Research Paper Without dreams our
Dreams Essay, Research Paper Without dreams our lives would be empty. There is no person alive that isn t filled with dreams, goals and ideals. These things are a part of life and human nature. We all have the inbred desire for a good life. Dreams are vital to the life of every person. Without dreams, there is nothing to plan or look forward to; therefore, no reason to live.
Principles Of Management Essay Research Paper Management
Principles Of Management Essay, Research Paper Management is a set of activities directed at an organization’s resources with the aim of achieving organizational goals in an efficient and effective manner. The first function of management is planning and decision making. Planning is setting and organization’s goals and deciding how best to achieve them.
Group Perception Essay Research Paper I personally
Group Perception Essay, Research Paper I personally think that working in a group can be an enjoyable experience if everyone in the group feels comfortable with each other making the communication sparkle. Unlike what most students in Sorenson s research expressed about their views of group work, the term grouphate to describe how loathsome the group experience is , I find group work a big key to success for everyone in the group if the group members understand how to communicate competently, which means that we have to know how to apply those four elements of communication competence (knowledge, skills, sensitivity and commitment) in our group activities.
The Workforce Essay Research Paper Hiring new
The Workforce Essay, Research Paper Hiring new employees is a difficult job for most employers to do. When a person is hired most jobs only know a little about their new employee’s personality. They only know what