Sweetness and Power is a historical study of sugar and its affect on society and economy since it was first discovered. Sugar has had a large impact on society and the economy that is not noticeable unless thoroughly studied. The following is an analysis of the work done by Sidney W. Mintz in his attempt to enlighten the educated layperson .
Mintz uses a very basic system for organizing the tremendous amount of data found within in the book. The book is divided into 5 chapters: Food, Sociality, and Sugar , Production , Consumption , Power , and Eating and Being . Each of these chapters discusses different issues dealing with the main idea while moving in a more or less chronological order. For example, the chapter entitled Production begins by discussing the means by which sugar was produced in its earliest existence, and then ends by discussing more modern forms of production. Within the chapter, Mintz branches off and discusses various effects sugar has had on the economy and society. However, to fully understand the structure of the book, each chapter must be looked at individually to see how each is organized.
Chapter one begins by describing the connection between different groups of society and the food that each of them eats. Mintz argues that food is a factor in which one can identify and categorize a society and/or those who belong to that society, which is shown on page 3 with the line Food choices and eating habits reveal distinctions of age, sex, status, culture, and even occupation. Later in the book, Mintz will continue this contention by describing sugar as a symbol of power and nobility. Another important idea revealed to the reader in chapter one is the source of focus for the book, which is shown in this statement on page 5:
Specifically, I am concerned with a single substance called sucrose, a kind of sugar extracted primarily from the sugar can, and with what became of it. The story can be summed up in a few sentences. In 1000 A.D., few Europeans knew of the existence of sucrose, or can sugar. But soon afterward they learned about it; by 1650, in England the nobility and the wealthy had become inveterate sugar eaters, and sugar figured in their medicine, literary imagery, and displays of rank. By no later than 1800, sugar had become a necessity albeit a costly and rare one in the diet of every English person; by 1900, it was supplying nearly one-fifth of the calories in the English diet.
These few lines will be extensively discussed and analyzed in the remainder of the book as the topics for chapters two through five.
Another important idea proposed by Mintz is that sweetness is naturally desired by humans. He supports this by reporting on the work of researchers studying infants in the United States and how they are drawn to sweetness without having prior experience with it. He also states on page 15 that Alaskan Eskimos consume sucrose despite the discomforts associated with the offending items.
Chapter two, as the name implies, discusses the steps taken in the production of sugar, and how those steps evolved and spread throughout the world. Mintz begins on page 19 by giving the reader the basic definition of sucrose, an organic chemical of the carbohydrate family. He continues by describing the history of sugar cane and the history of production. He then goes on to describe the economics of sugar production and how it directly affected world economics. A very important fact discussed in this chapter relates sugar to the evolution of capitalism. Mintz contends that as sugar becomes less of a symbol of power and more of a common item for the common person, that mercantilism begins to die out. As this happens, capitalism begins to play more heavily on the economy. Mintz quotes Fernando Ortiz s phrase describing sugar as the favored child of capitalism, and furthermore arguing his point as shown in this statement found on page 46:
Mercantilism was finally dealt its quietus in the mid-nineteenth century, and the sugar market and its potential played a part. By then, sugar and consumer items like it had become too important to permit an archaic protectionism to jeopardize future metropolitan supplies. Sugar surrendered its place as luxury and rarity and became the first mass-produced exotic necessity of a proletarian working class.
Chapter three, the most lengthy chapter entitled Consumption , finishes the discussion, first introduced in chapter two, of how sugar became less of a symbol of power and more of a necessity for the common person. In chapter two, however, Mintz described this change by relating it to the economy. In the third chapter, Mintz describes the change in a manner relating it to societal values. Sugar s various purposes are described in great length, among which included preservation, decoration, medicinal use, as well as a spice. Sugar as a sweetener was given much of the credit for the shift of its use amongst various groups of people. Mintz writes on page 108:
Sugar as a sweetener came to the fore in connection with these other exotic imports tea, coffee, and chocolate of which one, tea, became and has since remained the most important nonalcoholic beverages in the United Kingdom.
Mintz contends that as sugar began to infiltrate the British diet, its popularity and demand began to increase. As the demand went up, so did the supply, causing the proletariat to be able to incorporate sugar into their everyday diet. As time went on, sugar became more and more integrated into the diet of the common person until about the mid-1800 s where, as Mintz puts it on page 143,
A century later, the place of tea and sugar in the working-class diet, together with treacle, tobacco, and many other imported foods, was completely secure. These were the new necessities. The figures for tea and sugar consumption after the 1850 s mount steadily in the case of sugar, to just below ninety pounds per person per year by the 1890 s.
With that, sugar had become part of the common person s diet, and was no longer a symbol of power and luxury, but as a prime source for calories for all people.
Chapter four consists mainly of a repetition and summary of that which has already been discussed. Mintz uses this chapter as an opportunity to explain the connection between ideas discussed in the previous two chapters and how one leads to the other. Sugar, having many uses, became very popular among the upper class. Mintz shows that inevitably, sugar would spread to the lower classes due to this popularity. The final paragraph in the chapter illustrates the purpose of the chapter by showing the connection between the uses of sugar and how it spread to the lower classes:
It served to make a busy life seem less so; in the pause that refreshes, it eases, or seemed to ease, the changes back and forth from work to rest; it provided swifter sensations of fullness of satisfaction than complex carbohydrates did; it combined easily with many other foods, in some of which it was also used (tea and biscuit, coffee and bun, chocolate and jam-smeared bread). And as we have seen, it was symbolically powerful, for its use could be endowed with many subsidiary meanings. No wonder the rich and powerful liked it so much, and no wonder the poor learned to love it.
This line illustrates to the reader how sugar became more and more desired by the rich and powerful due to it many uses, as well as how this increases in sugar popularity also lead to its spread to the lower classes, and finally, its common presence in the English diet.
In chapter five, entitled Eating and Being , Mintz draws the book to a conclusion. In this chapter, Mintz strays from the effects of sugar in the past and present, and ventures as far as to make some educated opinions about the future of sucrose. On page 206, Mintz makes the statement:
Yet in spite of these many virtues, the fate of sucrose is by no means entirely assured. In the last decade, et another sugar, high-fructose corn syrup, has been making inroads into the sugar market, particularly among prepared-food manufacturers. The most crushing blow came when Coca-Cola partly replaced sucrose with HFCS; it seems probable that other defeats will follow. At any rate, corn syrups are cutting into the consumption of other sugars and will probably do so more and more.
Mintz uses the data and makes an educated guess of what he believes lies in store for sucrose. Another important item contained within this chapter is Mintz s own acceptance of the decreasing quality of anthropology. He states on page 213 that anthropology is dangerously close to losing its sense of purpose , and that anthropologists are blinded by their own romanticism . With this acceptance, Mintz explains to the reader the purpose for writing the book. He points out two things. One, he illustrates the loss of quality in Anthropology, and most importantly, he asks the reader to fully understand and consider the effects that sugar has had on modern society and economics by arguing in the last paragraph of the book found on page 214:
We must struggle to understand fully the consequences of that and kindred events, for upon them we erected an entirely different conception of the relationship between producers and consumers, of the meaning of work, and the definition of self, of the nature of things. What commodities mean, would thereafter be forever different. And for that same reason, what persons are, and what being a person means, changed accordingly. In understanding the relationship between commodity and person, we unearth anew the history of ourselves.
With this, Sweetness and Power has effectively told the story of sugar, and its affect upon society and the economy in the modern world. For the most part, the book is a social history. Mintz is constantly describing the impact of sugar upon societal groups (i.e. upper class, middle class, etc.). However, chapter two strays from this and goes into some economic history by describing the growth and promotion of capitalism.
The book contains massive amounts of data, which leads to a very in depth and thought provoking book. As stated before, the book is directed towards an audience known as the educated layperson . That is, someone who is assumed to have some background with historical knowledge as well as a interest in the topic of sugar, in a historical sense.
Mintz uses many sources to back up the data and conclusions presented in the book. He does a good job of supporting all of his arguments with the proper source, however, he does not explain these sources to the fullest extent. The assumption is made that the reader clearly knows how the sources relates to the argument at hand, but sometimes the passages that Mintz cites are unclear. Also, Mintz understands that a field such as anthropology requires fieldwork to be strong. However, in that same line on page 213, Mintz states, Those strengths continue to lie in fieldwork (there is little in this book I confess). By this, Mintz himself has identified another one of the few flaws present in his book.
Sweetness and Power is a strong study relating the evolution of sugar to societal growth as well as to economic change. Despite the flaws contained within the structure of the book and the lack of fieldwork, the book is an excellent collection of data regarding sugar, a topic that most people do not think of as being a major factor in the lives they live today. Mintz forces the educated layperson to look around the world today, and really think about what it would be like without the luxury of sugar.
Другие работы по теме:
Power Essay Research Paper Power is as
Power Essay, Research Paper Power is, as anyone will tell you, a tantalizing addiction. The natural human craving for power derives from the simple ideals of a genuflecting mass of humanity; bowing, scraping, praising and carrying out one?s every whim. The sheer exhilaration of controlling, manipulating, and yes, even hurting someone is almost too much for out feeble minds to overcome.
Power In Macbeth Essay Research Paper There
Power In Macbeth Essay, Research Paper There are many different types of power which a person may have. Some of the time, however, the person in that power is not the best person to be in that power. This is especially true in William Shakespeare’s Macbeth. Throughout the course of the play, the Three Witches and Lady Macbeth are the people with the most power over Macbeth’s life.
Sweetness And Power Essay Research Paper Sweetness
Sweetness And Power Essay, Research Paper Sweetness and Power: The Place of Sugar in Modern History Some of the most brilliant minds have made many unorthodox suggestions. This is the case with Sidney Mintz’s thesis in Sweetness and Power: The Place of Modern History. Mintz’s suggestions that industrial capitalism originated in the Caribbean sugar plantations may seem to contradict the European version of world history fed to most of the Western world, but is nevertheless supported by substantial evidence.
Nuclear Power Plants Essay Research Paper Nuclear
Nuclear Power Plants Essay, Research Paper Nuclear Plants The question of whether the U.S. should have nuclear power plants is very controversial. There are two sides that one can take; however, both sides have their own share of problems. If you chose to not have nuclear plants, then eventually all natural resources will run out.
Power Essay Research Paper Hydro Power
Power Essay, Research Paper Hydro Power My alternative power source is Hydro power. It comes from water. The oldest and simplest form was the water wheel first used in ancient Greece for grinding grain. The water wheel design was changed by Jean Victor Poncelet in the 18th century. He made the blades curved which raised the efficiency by 70 percent.
Terrorism Essay Research Paper Terrorism is defined
Terrorism Essay, Research Paper Terrorism is defined as “the use of violent means against non-military targets”. Acts of terrorism are typically designed to destroy the authority and legitimacy of a country. While the US is a legitmate world power, we do not experience a substantial amount of terrorism.
Power In Negotiating Essay Research Paper What
Power In Negotiating Essay, Research Paper What is power in negotiating? Is it finesse? Is a real? Is it perceived? It could be all these things and more. Power in negotiating is defined by the book pass “the ability to bring about outcomes they desire” or “the ability to get things done the way one wants to be to to”.
Stealing Our Rights Essay Research Paper Stealing
Stealing Our Rights Essay, Research Paper Stealing Our Rights From the dawn of the first organized communities, to the powerful United States of America today, there have always been power hungry people who
Mercantilism Essay Research Paper Mercantilism as a
Mercantilism Essay, Research Paper Mercantilism as a global economic policy tends to subscribe to the following premises: wealth is an essential means to power, power is essential as a means to the acquisition of wealth, wealth and power are each proper ultimate ends of national policy, and there is a long run balance of trade between these ends.
Power Essay Research Paper Does the world
Power Essay, Research Paper Does the world belong to the strong? As they are used in this sentence, belong and strong are two multifaceted words. They can each indicate different definitions, changing the meaning of the question.
Legislation Essay Research Paper What then is
Legislation Essay, Research Paper What, then, is legislation? It is an assumption by one man, or body ofmen, of absolute, irresponsible dominion over all other men whom theycan subject to their power. It is an assumption by one man, or body ofmen, of a right to subject all other men to their will and theirservice.
The State Essay Research Paper The state
The State Essay, Research Paper The state is like God, some believe that it?s the all mighty powerful being that controls all and others just think it?s a big overblown idea. The idea of the state (and God) is fairly confusing but rarely ever challenged, except by those rare few who seem to form their own opinions.
Ceremonial Speech Walter Payton Essay Research Paper
Today I would like all of you to join me in a tribute to the greatest running back ever to play in the National Football League Walter Payton. His career with the Chicago Bears began in 1975 and Sweetness continued to run until 1987 his legacy continues much longer.
Power Of One Essay Research Paper Power
Power Of One Essay, Research Paper Power of One I did not enjoy this movie. I thought it was poorly done, the camera shots were very basic, it was extremely predictable and ?deja vu?. Since I am no
Jurassic Park Essay Research Paper The story
Jurassic Park Essay, Research Paper The story Jurassic Park, by Michael Crichton takes place on a small island near Costa Rica, it s about a park full of dinosaurs created by Dr. Hammond. The
Electrical Energy Essay Research Paper Electrical EnergyA
Electrical Energy Essay, Research Paper Electrical Energy A capacitor can store electrical energy. Connecting it across a resistor or other device discharges it. Across the resistor there is a potential difference that creates the electric current. When the charge in the capacitor decreases, at the same time the voltage decreases.
Plutonium Essay Research Paper Plutonium239 an isotope
Plutonium Essay, Research Paper Plutonium-239 (an isotope of plutonium) is used in making nuclear weapons. Plutonium- 238 is used to power equipment on the moon by means of the heat it emits. Plutonium is also used in radionuclide batteries for pacemakers.
Federalism Essay Research Paper Due to the
Federalism Essay, Research Paper Due to the immense power of our federal government, people often argue that it is too powerful and should be lessened. Since the 1990?s there has been an effort to shift power
The Godfather Essay Research Paper Violence and
The Godfather Essay, Research Paper Violence and The Godfather Throughout time there have always been people who held more power than others. There are many different methods used to both demonstrate and maintain the power which they possess. Often times violence is the method chosen to achieve these goals.
Dyslexia Essay Research Paper The hardest thing
Dyslexia Essay, Research Paper The hardest thing a child or an adult can ever experience, which happens to be a fact is to be labeled by society as an ? ILLITERATE?. This misconception comes about a pre-judged opinion by society, who think themselves capable of classifying people, by either their looks, their money, or their power.
The Importance Of Balance Of Power In
Europe Essay, Research Paper B.O.P. essay Without losers, there would be no winners. Moreover, if there were no evil in the world, then kindness would not exist. This is exactly the way the principle of balance of power in Europe operates. It prevented empires, and helped to aid lesser states in their times of need.
Police Essay Research Paper The PoliceWhy is
Police Essay, Research Paper The Police Why is it that so many minorities have a problem with the police? Are all minorities simply unruly, or is it that police officers with lower intelligence levels and a false sense of power abuse their ability to mistreat people they do not like? In my opinion, I believe that police officers should have to go through more of a rigorous training and have minority sensitivity training before they are given their badges.
Machiavelli Essay Research Paper Machiavelli
Machiavelli Essay, Research Paper Machiavelli Machiavelli’s views revolved around the ideas that one must do anything within his (Machiavelli did not refer to ?her’) power to keep the influence and
Divine Discontene Essay Research Paper Each and
Divine Discontene Essay, Research Paper Each and every human strives to be better.A desire, a subconscious power, known as divine discontent leads them to dedicate themselves twoard becoming better or achieving greater goals. Divine discontent leads some to happiness, and others who do not succeed to failure.
Windows 30 Essay Research Paper Windows 30
Windows 3.0 Essay, Research Paper Windows 3.0 With window’s 3.0, you can unleash the power of your 286 or 386 computer’s protected mode. Unlike earlier releases that made you purchase separate versions
Beauty Essay Research Paper Beauty Power or
Beauty Essay, Research Paper Beauty: Power or PassivityBeauty is most definitely a form of power. If a person is considered beautiful, or possesses the qualities that the public eye deems beautiful, they tend to have a certain degree of power. Beauty is most often used in the advertising business. On television, many commercials for products ranging from shampoo to cars depict women of beauty.
2 Stroke Engines Essay Research Paper Paul
2 Stroke Engines Essay, Research Paper Paul Wehunt 2- stroke engines! The power that’s needed in today’s high performance Motor sports. Let us take a closer and more through look into the workings of the 2-stroke engine of today.
Wisdom Essay Research Paper Wisdom in my
Wisdom Essay, Research Paper Wisdom, in my opinion is ?The knowing of many things?. Wisdom is what all people should strive for during their entire life. For being wise is having the power of knowing and judging what is right and good, you have the power to discern what you should and should not do. You can look at situations in life and have the wisdom to know what you should do.
Comparison Of Karl Marx And Matthew Arnold
Essay, Research Paper Comparison of Karl Marx and Matthew Arnold Through their writing, Karl Marx and Matthew Arnold show their opposing views on the importance of internal and external functions of culture. In the
Federal Government Essay Research Paper How does
Federal Government Essay, Research Paper How does the constitution divide power between the national government and the states? The constitution did not give the national government or the states total supremacy. Instead, power was distributed. The national government was given certain express powers, while some powers were reserved to the states.
Great Expectations Essay Research Paper Great Expectations
Great Expectations Essay, Research Paper Great Expectations involves many characters but Joe Gargery is one of the few that has the trait of humbleness he was always giving compliment but never taking them. Maybe his compliments were not noticed but they were given, in a way that only Joe could give them, quietly.
International Relations Realism Essay Research Paper In
International Relations: Realism Essay, Research Paper In the discipline of International Relations realism, which developed as a reaction to idealism during the Cold War, has become the dominant school of thought . Realism makes power the currency of international politics. Realist argue that by accumulating power states can ensure the security of the population within the state.
MS Power Point Essay Research Paper Reflection
MS Power Point Essay, Research Paper Reflection on MS Power Point The Microsoft Power Point presentation that we just completed was a fun project. I learned how to set up Power Point slides while infiltrating animation and sound.