, Research Paper
One of the most interesting topics discussed by early philosophers is mortality and what happens to the human soul after death. Of the pre-Socratic philosophers, Pythagoras and Heraclitus are the two noteworthy philosophic thinkers on this subject. This paper will discuss the views of both Pythagoras and Heraclitus in regards to death and the soul and how their thoughts are similar and differ. For instance, I will explain how each would respond to the following questions. What happens to the human soul after death of the body? Is the soul reincarnated into other bodies, and if so what kind of bodies? Does this process of reincarnation ever cease, and if so, how does man interrupt it? These are some of the fundamental questions that both philosophers answer in their philosophy and it is the job of this paper to illustrate their main points. This is our next order of business. So then, what becomes of us at death? We begin with Pythagoras.
Known for his religious ideas, Pythagoras was fascinated with the human soul and questioned what happened to it when man died. He believed that after death the soul would be incarnated into another body. He did not think the human soul was limited to incarnating itself into another human body. Instead, he held that a person?s soul could ?transmigrate? into animal bodies showing a belief that humans and animals share a close relationship. Pythagoras furthered this thought by forbidding the eating of animal flesh. But he not only believed in the transmigration of the soul, he also thought that the soul was immortal. This is very significant because it makes his idea of soul much more important in relation to the body, which until Pythagoras, the soul was not looked at as being as important. So for Pythagoras, when death came, the soul lived on and would incarnate another body not necessarily limited to humans. This is more or less the base of Pythagoras? thought about death and the soul. Before I explain more of his philosophy, I will set forth Heraclitus? ideas concerning death and the soul.
Heraclitus was a free thinker but his writings and ideas are sometimes hard to interpret. Because of the nature of Heraclitus? writing style (mainly because he wrote in aphorisms, which are often times ambiguous and confusing), the true meaning of his philosophy is open to interpretation. The view herein is intended to be a fair representation of his true meaning, but one must realize that it is not the only way of interpreting his philosophy. In response to what happens to the soul upon death, Heraclitus thinks the soul does undergo a material transformation. But this transformation does not entail transmigration of the soul into another body as Pythagoras thought. Instead, it is more like the soul being recycled into different ?stuff? or entities. For Heraclitus, death is just another phase in the cycle, and what makes up our soul is the same stuff that previously made up other stuff. Unlike Pythagoras, he does not think the human soul incarnates into other bodies. Although the soul is recycled into other stuff, it still does exist, albeit as a different entity. But even if it does constantly get recycled, the personal identity of the soul is undoubtedly lost. Hence, it would be misleading to say that Heraclitus thought the soul was immortal as Pythagoras did.
Now that we understand the core ideas of both philosophers? in regards to what happens to the soul after death, it is time to further the discussion. Pythagoras? idea that the soul is immortal suggests reincarnations were to go on forever. But he also believed there was a way of breaking this cycle of reincarnations. In order to understand how this is done, you must be aware that Pythagoras saw continuing incarnations as a form of punishment for doing wrong. To stop the cycle of continued reincarnation, man must clear himself of wrong doing through purification. But how is this done? Pythagoras believed this is accomplished through intellectual activity and the study of mathematics. The role of intellectual activity in achieving purity is important because in doing this we discover the order in things which helps to produce a kind of order in our soul. Through intellectual activity we can eventually copy the order of the world into our psyches, making us godlike. This assimilation of human to god is important because it puts us at one with the world and breaks free the cycle of incarnations. The end of the otherwise endless cycle of soul transformation from body to body signifies purity, and an end to the punishment.
Heraclitus holds a far different view in terms of what ultimately happens to the soul after death. His ideas take into consideration how the soul?s life was lived. For example, ?Heraclitus held that the souls of those people who live excellently will not suffer death by becoming moist but will continue to exist as psyche-stuff.? (Ring, p79) The souls of those people who do not ?live excellently? will be part of the system of recycling or material transformation. Here we see an important point. What man does while living does have some impact on what ultimately happens to the soul. That we as humans have some control over what happens to our soul. This view is similar to many modern day religious ideas such as the Christianity, who believe in receiving a spot in heaven based upon how your life is lived on earth. In a way, it is also similar to Pythagoras? view of purification. They have in common a kind of reward for living life a certain way. But, if what we do in life plays on what happens to our soul, this could suggest a sort of personal identity moving on with the soul after death. However, it is unlikely that Heraclitus thought personal identity of the soul survived death and the material transformation.
Heraclitus goes on to expand the possible outcomes of living excellently and the impact this has on the soul. As mentioned earlier, those living well will continue to exist as ?psyche-stuff.? He classifies this in two different ways. An ?uncorrupted psyche? would either ?rise to become part of the fiery upper air; overseeing the processes of transformation occurring below. They rise and become the watchful guardians of life and death? (Heraclitus, Fragment 63). Or, those psyches that lived well would remain ?psyche-stuff.? Acting as the rationality in everything. Not exactly the same idea as Pythagoras? purity by means of intellectual activity and the assimilation to being godlike. However, both do have some views in common as I will now show you.
Heraclitus and Pythagoras philosophy of death and soul may not be in pure harmony with one another, but not agreeing doesn?t necessarily mean they disagree. Heraclitus may not think that the soul is immortal, or that it transmigrates from body to body as a sort of punishment. But he does think the existence of the soul extends beyond the life of the body. Pythagoras certainly would not agree the soul could become part of the fiery upper air looking down on further transformations, but he does believe in the possibility of breaking out of the recurring cycle of reincarnation. So, in so much as they disagree, they agree. The details of their philosophy may be different, but the overwhelming idea that something does indeed happen to the soul upon death is held by both. In a time where mythology and mysticism was prevalent, Pythagoras and Heraclitus ventured out of the norm and discovered ideas for themselves. Their ideas may differ, but the fact that both did this at a time when no one else had gives them something in common. As a result, both are known for their groundbreaking and unique thought including but not limited to death and the soul.
Works Cited
Ring, Merrill. Beginning With The Pre-Socratics, Mayfield Publishing, 1987.
Heraclitus, Writings, Title Unknown by Myself, Approximately 540-480 BCE.
35d
Другие работы по теме:
Sonnet About Death Essay Research Paper Death
Sonnet About Death Essay, Research Paper Death is full of sorrow and surprise Sooner or later it comes at anytime. Even though I do not remember my demise In my hearts I still remember my greatest crime.
Fear And Religion In Lucretius Essay Research
Paper Religion is one of Lucretius favorite topics to argue against in his poem On the Nature of Things. What religion does to man and the fear of the life after death that is instilled on the living is unjust per Lucretius. For while the nature of the gods must necessarily of itself enjoy immortality, the life of men lay foully groveling, crushed beneath the wait of a Religion.
Comparative Essay On Deat Essay Research Paper
Death is an aspect of life that everyone becomes acquainted with sooner or later. From my own experiences I am more familiar with death than I could ever want to be. Poetry is something that is very difficult for
Capital Punishment Essay Research Paper I am
Capital Punishment Essay, Research Paper I am all for Capital Punishment. I think that if you kill someone you should be given the death penalty. I think that the death of the killer would give family and friends a bit of ease
The Moral Of Everyman Essay Research Paper
The Moral of Everyman Everyman, an English morality play, is an allegory of death and the fate of the soul. Summoned by Death, Everyman calls on Fellowship, Goods and Strength for help, but they desert him. Only Good Deeds and Knowledge remain faithful and lead him toward salvation.
Two Ideas Essay Research Paper Two Poems
Two Ideas Essay, Research Paper Two Poems. Two Ideas. One Author Two of Emily Dickinson’s poems, “Because I Could Not Stop For Death” and “I Heard A Fly Buzz-When I Died,” are both about one of life’s few
Death Essay Research Paper Why must there
Death Essay, Research Paper Why must there be death? Death is sad. So why must we bare sadness? Because nobody can stop death. Why do people die? Why must our loved ones die?
A Woeful Trap
…Act 1 In Hamlet Essay, Research Paper A Woeful Trap Is he mad or sane? Or just mad in craft, yet punished with sore distractions. Perhaps Hamlet is the victim–as we all at some time feel to be–of the world’s sane view of insane perplexities. He is the man at war within himself; a traveler with a passport into strange, twilight regions of the soul.
Peace Essay Research Paper The poem
Peace Essay, Research Paper The poem, Thanatopsis, written by William Cullen Bryant, is a wonderful literary work which explores the often controversial questions of death. Within his well written lines Bryant attempts to show the relationship between death s eternal questions and the ongoing cycle of nature and life.
Socrates Vs Gilgamesh Essay Research Paper Sarah
Socrates Vs. Gilgamesh Essay, Research Paper Sarah Raske October 11, 2000 Socrates Vs. Gilgamesh Socrates? view of death in the Phaedo, Crito, and Apology is complex. His argument tries to prove that philosophers, of all people, are in the best state to die or will be in the best state after life because of the life they lead.
Phaedo Essay Research Paper The first item
Phaedo Essay, Research Paper The first item of discussion in Socrates’ argument is the separation of the body and the soul. Socrates gains full agreement from Simmias and Cebes when he says that death is simply a separation of the body and the soul. He then makes the argument that this parting is what the philosopher should look forward to and work for.
Four Arguments For The Immortality Of The
Human Soul Presented By Plato In The Phaedo. Essay, Research Paper In Plato s Phaedo, he argues that the soul will continue to exist, and that it will go on to a better place. The argument begins on the day of his execution with the question of whether it is good or bad to die. In other words, he is arguing that the soul is immortal and indestructible.
Transmigration Of The Soul Plato
’s Theory Of Human Knowledge Essay, Research Paper Plato contended that all true knowledge is recollection. He stated that we all have innate knowledge that tells us about the things we experience in our world. This knowledge, Plato believed, was gained when the soul resided in the invisible realm, the realm of The Forms and The Good.
Style Analysis Of Holy Sonnet 10 Essay
, Research Paper John Donne?s diction, detail, point of view, metaphysical format, and tone used in ?Holy Sonnet 10? convey both a feeling of cynical and domination, and also a sense of mockery of death. The effects on the reader include assurance and confidence in facing death.
Personhood Essay Research Paper What is a
Personhood Essay, Research Paper What is a person? That sounds like a harmless question, but the answer can get very complicated. Is a person just a lump of skin, muscles, bones, and other materials? Is a person something immaterial like a mind or a soul? Or is a person a combination of these two things? Really there is no right answer, and it all depends on the point of view that you hold.
ItS Never Too Late Essay Research Paper
Could Faustus have saved his soul had he repented to God before facing his impending damnation? Coming from a Christian upraising and parochial schooling, I would have to think that Faustus could have saved himself. I was always under the assumption that sincere repentance could be given at any time in one s life for salvation.
Why Us Essay Research Paper gjh but
Why Us Essay, Research Paper gjh but when he came we ask again why us and well always ask again why us byut ANGEL N SOUL Darkness beside the color redness the sun was going down? it was December the 12th. That day people always said is the day were lovers meet and make love on the beach. It was kind of windy and that was the kind of weathers angels’ love.
John Proctor Faced WIth Death Essay Research
Paper Being faces with a decision like death why would one decide to be put to death. At the same time while death stare one in the face a man must look deep into his soul to come up with the answer that would satisfy his soul. Knowing that there is a final judgment after man Proctor decided to let his final judgment become by God.
The Sin Of Avarice Essay Research Paper
In life everyone is searching for something or someone. Sometimes we just do not realize we have found it until it is too late. What we find may not always be what we are looking for. This is what happens in the Pardoner s Tale by Geoffry Chaucer, the three rioters are searching for death in the physical form. They do find death or rather it finds them in the very end of the story.
Life Vs Death Essay Research Paper Life
Life Vs Death Essay, Research Paper Life verses Death You listen to the speeches, they draw up the ballot, and you vote. Simple you say? I hope you don t. The matter always depends on what is on that ballot. What if the ballot read: Should the Death Penalty be used to dispose of harmful criminals? Having a hard time on which box to check? Have you ever realized the irony involved when a convicted criminal is put to death? Most of the supports see this, and delight in the “eye for an eye” mentality.
Socrates Essay Research Paper Philosophy is a
Socrates Essay, Research Paper Philosophy is a vast field. It examines and probes many different fields. Virtue, morality, immortality, death, and the difference between the psyche (soul) and the soma (body) are just a few of the
PhilosophySoul Is Immortal Essay Research Paper The
Philosophy:Soul Is Immortal Essay, Research Paper The Soul Is Immortal The task of this paper is to explain how the soul is immortal and lives on through people’s impressions. There is something inside of all human beings that lives on forever. Even when death is upon us, the soul of a person never dies. Thus, we arrive at the statement the soul is immortal.
The Phaedo Essay Research Paper Philosophy 106Steve
The Phaedo Essay, Research Paper Philosophy 106 Steve Anthony In “The Phaedo,” Plato explains his theory of forms and ideas concerning the mortality of the soul. We find that the soul and body are separate and that the soul lives after death and had lived before. This leads us to the idea of forms and how we acquire the knowledge of these before birth.
Plato The Soul And The Theory Of
Forms Essay, Research Paper The Relationship Between Plato?s Theory of Forms and the Immortality of the Soul Preface In the Phaedo, Plato set out to show many things, including that the Soul is Immortal. Through the aid of the Theory of Forms Plato proved that the soul is immortal.
Socrates And Descartes On Dualism Essay Research
Paper Socrates and Descartes on Dualism Dualism means the complete separation of the mental world and the physical world. In philosophy, it is the theory that the universe is explicable only as a whole composed of two distinct and mutually exclusive factors: the mind and the body. Socrates and Plato are called dualists because they think that mind and body are separate and distinct substances.
Evangaline Essay Research Paper Pain and LoveIn
Evangaline Essay, Research Paper Pain and Love In life love and pain are always connected. This is also true in Evangeline. Many things can cause love and pain. Separation and death are the main and obvious things that have love and pain. Devotion to one person can also cause love and pain in your heart and in the relationship.
The Dead 2 Essay Research Paper Life
The Dead 2 Essay, Research Paper Life After Death James Joyce states it best saying, Better pass boldly into that world, in the full glory of some passion, than fade and wither dismally with age (p.143). Not only is he talking primarily about the death of relationships, but also that of literal death and other mortalities and the way they take shape.
After Apple Picking Essay Research Paper The
After Apple Picking Essay, Research Paper The speaker uses the word “sleep” six times in the poem. This repetition, along with additional words that connote sleeping or resting, comes to suggest the presence of death. The speaker has endured a long hard life, and his routine activity, no matter how fulfilling it must have been at first and throughout, has agonized him and brought exhaustion to his soul.
Nietzche Vs Socrates And Plato Essay Research
Paper Nietzsche s thoughts on finite differed dramatically from Socrates and Plato. Nietzsche believes that everyone should embrace the finite because you will enhance this life and make it more beautiful. He rejects the theory that eternity is of more importance than the present life. To Nietzsche, pursuing what you love to do is the only way to excellence.
The Soul Essay Research Paper Out of
The Soul Essay, Research Paper Out of all the philosophers we have examined in this unit, Ren? Descartes (On Thinking and the Soul) presents the best argument about what a soul and body are. In contrast, I believe that Locke?s interpretation of the body, mind, soul and self was my least favorite interpretation.