Paper
Vita Activa, Action and Arendt
What follows is the basic structure of Hannah Arendt’s account of vita activa, as I understand it. Arendt classifies the modes of human activities as “action”, “work”, “labor”, and additionally “speech” which is to be accompanied by action. Each corresponds to the human conditions of “natality,” “worldliness,” “life itself” and “plurality” respectively. In addition are the “faculties” of freedom, self-disclosure of identity of the actor, fabrication and (re)production. Arendt’s method is designed to calibrate the transformation of “constellation” referencing the ancient constellation, an archetype Arendt reconstructs from ‘fragments’ of human possibilities found in the political life of the ancient Greek polis. In the constellation, freedom belongs to action, self-disclosure of identity of the actor to the coupling of action and speech, fabrication to work, and (re)production to labor. It is also important to note here that, for Arendt, human beings are simultaneously natural (like other creatures) and unnatural. Her categories of human activities directly correspond to this order. Labor serves to the natural, or biological, “necessity” on the one hand. Work, action and speech to unnatural requirements, especially “freedom” on the other hand. Arendt’s concept of “worldliness” as a property of the “human world” is one of the human conditions for unnatural dimension, as well as for plurality and natality. It is a defensive boundary between nature and human world whose basic properties are “artificiality” and “stability,” relative to permanence and durability. In addition, Arendt provides two properties, that of publicity, and in-betweeness. Publicity means that the existence of the human world as such is common to all people, whereas in-betweeness means that, nevertheless the perspectives of each person in the world are irreducibly different. For Arendt, “action” is a simultaneously blessed and troublesome mode of activity. “Blessed” because, as mentioned above, it is a faculty of freedom to begin a new process and to bring about something unexpected against all odds. In the ancient context, by virtue of this faculty accompanied by speech, and grounded within the condition of natality and plurality, actors could disclose irreplaceable identities. Thus weaving their unique lives on the one hand, while establishing new communal relationships among actors grounded by plurality on the other. In this sense, action is essentially political. The first aspect of the function of the faculty of freedom described here seems rather apolitical, but in the phase of “establishing new power relations and community,” it becomes quite crucial.
The troublesome aspect lies in for example fundamental uncertainty. The unpredictability and unboundedness of the range of consequences of an action, the sheer happenstance or arbitrariness of an action and the irreversibility of the initiated process are all sufferings that are inevitably associated with the fact that we are free beings. Thus Arendt mentions “the actor…is never merely a ‘doer’ but always and at the same time a sufferer” (p.190). Furthermore, these sufferings originate in a condition of plurality based upon which the blessing capacity of action is enjoyed. Namely, every action is always interference into the preexisting “web of human relationships,” the essential elements of which are the deeds and words of plural actors (p.183), and its resultant chains of action-reaction spread over the web, altering the state of affairs. In the case of the vita activa, for Arendt, the “redemption” for the troubles of action comes from the same origin. In other words, action itself is a source of redemption, and its necessary condition is again plurality. Therefore, we may call these abilities “auto-redemptive abilities” to cope with uncertainty. Concretely, the example of those abilities Arendt suggested are “promising” and “forgiving” (pp.236-47). The former is a faculty to cope with unpredictability of the consequences of action, whereas the latter to the irreversibility of what has happened, with the help of other faculties of virtue i.e. trusting, responsibility, generosity and so forth. For Arendt, these faculties are essentially political abilities, namely abilities to “live together” without any coercion, and based on plurality. Promising, for example, is “the only alternative to a mastery which relies on domination of one’s self and rule over others” and “corresponds exactly to the existence of a freedom which was given under the condition of non-sovereignty” (p.244). In addition, plurality is the condition for the possibility of the auto-redemptive abilities precisely because one can never, and should not pretend to, promise and forgive by oneself, without self-deception. So, the continuing to remain within the web of human relationships and being embedded in the condition of plurality is simultaneously and ironically the source of both inability and redemption. The disintegration of the boundary between humans and nature, caused and amplified by the increasing capacity of man’s acting into nature is characteristic of the contemporary condition for making the auto-redemptive abilities unattainable. Arendt states that, acting into nature is dangerous because plurality as a source of redemption is simply absent from the relationship between human and natural things (p.238); meaning all the moral concepts of the break down between humans and nature. Non-human material consequences of our action into nature cannot be “promised” and “forgiven” among men and natural entities. To conclude, the boundary between human and nature, the defensive boundary of human world, is a defense for the possibility for the auto-redemptive abilities to cope with uncertainty. Auto-redemption is possible only when we limit our exercise of power to act inside the human world. Likewise, the ability to intervene into nature should be conducted in a mode of work, i.e. it must be exercised for the sake of building up and stabilizing the human world. The collapse of this order of activities and the human/nature boundary is the loss of the conditions for auto-redemption. This collapse is what Arendt later calls the “worldlessness” of the modern world.
Другие работы по теме:
Arendt And Freedman Political Freedom Essay Research
Paper Political freedom is an ideal for both Arendt and Friedman. As political theorists they offer not only definitions to understand what political freedom is for them, but what necessary preconditions must exist in order for their ideal to be vitalized. Arendt explains political freedom as the right to be a participator in government.
Untitled Essay Research Paper I messed up
Untitled Essay, Research Paper I messed up; I made a mistake, But please, haste do not take. I love you more than any action or words could ever express, Still I find my heart drowning in loneliness.
La Vita E Bella Essay Research Paper
La Vita E Bella La storia si svolege nel 1938, anno in cui Guido Orefici (Roberto Benigni) arriva in una citt toscana con l’intento di aprire una libreria. Intanto lavora come cameriere presso il Grand Hotel dove conosce Dora (Nicoletta Braschi), una ragazza appartenente ad una buona famiglia, gi promessa in sposa ad un funzionario comunale non molto sveglio e fascista.
BDSM Essay Research Paper BDSMBDSM stands for
BDSM Essay, Research Paper BDSM BDSM stands for Bondage Discipline Sadism and Masochism. Most regard this as a perverted form of sexuality limited only to gays who they also regard
Afermative Action Essay Research Paper In times
Afermative Action Essay, Research Paper In times of today most topics of conversation generally have something to do with politics and hot political issues. Everything from abortion to gun control to affirmative action and that?s exactly what I am going to talk about, affirmative action. What exactly is affirmative action? According to Dr.
Affirmative Action Essay Research Paper When it
Affirmative Action Essay, Research Paper When it comes to affirmative action I have mixed emotions and opinions. Although I hate what affirmative action does and what it represents I strongly support its continuance.
Global Warming Essay Research Paper Ocean SolutionsSolutions
Global Warming Essay, Research Paper Ocean Solutions Solutions to Save the Ocean Many years ago nobody would have thoought that the ocean would ever need saving. The covers over 90% of the earth’s surface. People would wonder how something so collosal ever be effected by their actions. Unfortunately, the oceans do suffer from mankind’s carelss, selfish acts.
GUIA DE EXAMEN PARCIAL DE EXCEL 97
Essay, Research Paper 1. Que es una hoja de calculo?Es una ayuda para el ser humano para poder hacer c?lculos diversos eintroducir formulas. 2. Que nombre recibe el cursor de una hoja de calculo?Celda activa.
Affirmative Action 13 Essay Research Paper Affirmative
Affirmative Action 13 Essay, Research Paper Affirmative action, what’s that mean to you? There are many misconceptions about this act; for example, many opposing sides of this will argue that affirmative action will cause employers to turn down a qualified white man for a job, and higher a unqualified minority, or woman instead.
Descartes Philosophy Procedural
– Hannah Arendt Essay, Research Paper Procedural – Hannah Arendt Sections 7 and 8 On Appearance In section 7 of the chapter on appearance in her book The Life of the Mind, Arendt is for the most part critiquing Descartes’ “suspicion of man’s cognitive and sensory apparatus”. Descartes was trying to find the thinking ego or the soul whose reality and existence was beyond the “illusions of sense perception”.
Affirmative Action Essay Research Paper Effects of
Affirmative Action Essay, Research Paper Effects of Affirmative Action on Society and the Quality of Life of the People Now that we have been given a brief overview of the history of affirmative action, I will discuss the positive and negative aspects of the policy, which effect society and the quality of life of the people.
Definition Of Drama Essay Research Paper 1
Definition Of Drama Essay, Research Paper 1. Write a brief history of drama from its beginnings to the twentieth century. Drama is defined by Aristotle as “a criticism of life, on a stage, with action, characters and dialogue.” The Greek word for “deed” or “action” is dram. In traditional Greek drama, the chorus is also considered as a character in the development of the plot.
Arendt Paper Essay Research Paper Arendt s
Arendt Paper Essay, Research Paper Arendt s Understanding of Public Spaces This critical essay is about Arendt s understanding of public spaces. In this essay I will show how she understands the distinction between action, labor, and work and the relation between freedom, power and action. In the conclusion of this essay, I will show that the city of Chicago in both its architecture and its public spaces does not exhibit Arendt s notion of the public.
Machiavelli Vs Arendt Essay Research Paper Tales
Machiavelli Vs. Arendt Essay, Research Paper Tales There are some similarities between Machiavelli’s, “Qualities of the Prince,” and Arendt’s, “Ideology and Terror.” Hannah Arendt’s piece deals with governmental leadership using totalitarianism as its backbone. Machiavelli’s piece deals with how a prince should properly keep his power over the country in which he rules.
Arendt
’s Eichmann In Jerusalem Essay, Research Paper Arendt’s Eichmann in JerusalemThe enthusiastic efforts of all those that have spent their time in the pursuit of former Nazis that successfully evaded capture by the authorities that tried their compatriots at Nuremberg state their reasons generally to be a pursuit of justice.
Kant Essay Research Paper KANTKant begins to
Kant Essay, Research Paper KANT Kant begins to claim that there is nothing in the world that can be regarded as good without qualification except good will. He says that qualities of temperment such as
Bc Speech Assignment Essay Research Paper Research
Bc Speech Assignment Essay, Research Paper Research Assignment #4 Your fourth speech is a research-based persuasive speech. Since your primary goal will be to convince your audience to take a specific action your research burden is higher. Your research is due via email on the date listed on your course schedule.
Affirmative Action Essay Research Paper In years
Affirmative Action Essay, Research Paper In years past, Americas of every race, color, and nationality have been pushing for equal rights and equal representation in everything from politics, to professional sports coaches, to jobs, and colleges. In American colleges there is a little thing called affirmative action.
Virginia Woolf And Her Friendships With Women
Essay, Research Paper Virginia Woolf – Friendships With Women Virginia Woolf was sexually abused as a child. While the extent and duration of this abuse is difficult to establish, it is known that two of her older stepbrothers sexually harassed and abused her between the ages of twelve and twenty-one and perhaps as early as six.
Aquinas
’ First Proof Of The Existence Of God Essay, Research Paper I have chosen to write St. Thomas Aquinas proof citing motion as proof of the existence of God. Although I must admit to being a little confused the wording, I see it as being in terms of ability too, act of, and the first to act.
Political Freedom Arendt And De Tocqueville
Essay, Research Paper Political Freedom: Arendt and de Tocqueville Freedom in America emanates from the state of political freedom held by the citizens. Both Hannah Arendt and Alexis de Tocqueville provide criticism of the apparent shape freedom maintains in America as well as insight regarding how they perceive true political freedom.
Essay On Profanity Essay Research Paper ProfanityBy
Essay On Profanity Essay, Research Paper Profanity By ***** **** My essay is on Profanity in our school. I am against disciplinary action towards profanity for several reasons. I?m writing this essay because I use profanity all the time and I know other people do also, even the teachers. So my argument is going to clearly state if you do it we can do it too.
Hamlet Essay Research Paper HamletIn the play
Hamlet Essay, Research Paper Hamlet In the play Hamlet, William Shakespeare proposed two kinds of men. Horatio is the character who represents a man of thought. The other kind of man is represented by
Modern Vs Premodern Essay Research Paper Modern
Modern Vs. Premodern Essay, Research Paper Modern vs. Pre-modern There is one simple way to classify the difference between the modern and the pre-modern, and that would be to separate them by years. Unfortunately this would not be cut and dried; it would be a rough estimate because no one really knows when the change took place, or if there even was a change.
Ery Essay Research Paper Affirmative action works
Ery Essay, Research Paper Affirmative action works. There are thousands of examples of situations where people of color, white women, and working class women and men of all races who were previously excluded from jobs or educational opportunities, or were denied opportunities once admitted, have gained access through affirmative action.
Study On Judges Essay Research Paper Study
Study On Judges Essay, Research Paper Study on Judges: 1. What are the major findings with regards to the impact of race in each area of study? Finding on this studies have been a major impact on Judges due to minority judges have been well looked at through the eyes of the world. Progress has been made in appointing minorities to the federal bench and nearly three out of four minorities are confirmed.