Essay, Research Paper
In Sigmund Freud?s The Future of an Illusion, Freud suggests that humanity is driven by instinctual wishes that they suppress, such as incest, cannibalism, and a lust for killing. What keeps humanity from acting upon these wishes, and resulting in the break down of civilization, are the moral laws of that civilization. In European/Western civilization these moral laws are based on religion, specifically Christianity and Judaism. Religion creates a moral system by which those that do evil are eternally punished, and those that do good, rewarded, thus keeping society in line. In addition to preventing humankind from acting on its instinctual wishes, Freud states that religion also helps humanity ?exorcize the terrors of nature? and ?reconcile men to the cruelty of fate? (Freud 22). Freud argues that since humanity sought to have these three wants, (need for the control of society, protection from nature, and compensation for suffering) satisfied, it created God and religion. Because of this fact, Freud says that religion is an illusion; a fulfillment of our oldest, strongest, and most urgent desires (Freud 39). Although Freud recognizes that European/Western civilization rests on religion, he argues that humankind would be much better off if it were to give up religion. He says that religion represses the ignorant masses and prevents truly free scientific thinking. Freud argues that society should cast religion aside and replace with an ideology value system based on knowledge science, and reason. At this point, however, Freud?s argument falls apart. Religion plays a highly valuable role in our society and it is impossible to replace or remove it.
Freud?s reason for believing that religion should be cast away rests in psychoanalytic thought. He argues that religion is a universal neurosis, arising out of the Oedipus complex of childhood. Freud believes that humanity created God in the image of its own father. He comes to this conclusion by looking at the many aspects of our relationship with God. In Christianity and Judaism, we are God?s ?children?, God is our ?protector? and our ?provider?, and God tells us what is good and bad and rewards/punishes us for obeying/not obeying his word. Freud says that these are all things that are attributed our father, and in our neurosis, have manifested themselves into characteristics of God. Freud believes that the need for religion is simply a stage in humankind?s growth, just as the Oedipus Complex is a stage in the growth of a child. He believes that the next step, the step that will allow humankind to reach its true potential, is when we cast religion away and replace it with a society where science, knowledge, and reason reign supreme
While one can see the logic in this way of thinking, it is hard to believe that a society such as this will be capable of providing all of humanity?s needs. Knowledge and science may flow more freely in such a society, but they alone will never be able to eradicate all human suffering, and without religion, where will the humanity go for solace? Just as Freud says, religion provides people with an explanation of fate, and if humanity looses this explanation, they loose something that fulfils one of its key needs. Without religion, humanity will be left to cope with the harsh realities of the world by itself, and no matter how advanced science and knowledge become, they will never be able to console a human the way that a close relationship with God is able to.
Religion also provides a moral code that humanity is obligated to follow. This divine code, which is the basis of European/Western law, is unquestionable because it has come from God. However, if you remove this base, as Freud suggests, the strength of the law is weakened. Freud argues that society will follow this new code simply for the good of humanity (Freud 52), but this is not so. Humanity is flawed. It cannot be trusted to rule itself justly and impartially. It needs to be compelled to do good by something greater than imperfect human law. It needs divine religious law, simply because it is unquestionable. Religion ensures that all will eventually be punished for their failures to obey, if not in life, then in death. This is something that any ideology or value system, besides a religious one, cannot guarantee.
A good example of how chaotic and lawless a system can become when you attempt to remove religion from society is that of the French Revolution. During the French Revolution, specifically the ?Reign of Terror?, a government that was ruthless and void of morals controlled French society. A ?Committee of Public Safety? of 12 men, dominated by extremist Maximilien Robespierre, was established. This committee, in order to rule, ?exercised virtual dictatorial control over French government? (Britannica ?Terror, Reign of?). The new government was run upon a philosophy of reason, and many of its members supported the ?anti-Christian campaign of autumn of 1793, which sought to destroy Roman Catholic institutions in France? (Britannica ?H?bert, Jacques-Ren?). The government attempted to establish a rule of law that was based not on religion, but reason instead. This culminated in the passing of ?the Law of 22 Prairial, year II (June 10, 1794), which suspended a suspect’s right to public trial and to legal assistance and left the jury only a choice between acquittal and death? (Britannica ?Terror, Reign of?). This law resulted in the arrest of nearly 300,000 and the execution of around 17,000 French citizens (Britannica ?Terror, Reign of?). Obviously, this experiment in rule by reason was disastrous. It shows that man in incapable of ruling himself, and that God is a necessary part of justice in our civilization.
Often, when society has attempted to cast away religion it has simply developed another ideology that is just as oppressive. One of religion?s main purposes, as previously stated, is to help control society. It does this by installing a value system that is backed by a divine being. If you attempt to take away this backing, you leave a void in humanity?s basic needs. That is why societies that are based on non-religious ideologies often fail. Their ideologies, no matter how hard they are indoctrinated into their people, never have the same strength as religious one?s do. They are established by man, and therefore susceptible to flaw, whereas religion and its laws are established by God and are fundamentally divine and perfect.
This point can best be illustrated by the example of the failure of the society that existed in the Soviet Union. This society attempted to replace religion with an ideology based on Marxism-Leninism. Many have called Marxism-Leninism a quasi-religion. This can be seen in two aspects of its ideology. First, ?Marxism-Leninism has connections with the metaphysics of G.W.F. Hegel, an 18th-19th-century philosopher who interpreted reality in terms of a spiritual absolute? (Britannica ?Religion, Philosophy of?). Second, it requires of its followers a dedication and devotion that mirrors that of traditional religion. ?Furthermore, like a religion, it has provided themes of fulfillment and hope–a revolution interpreted as the initiation of a Communist world society that would be a final consummation? (Britannica ?Religion, Philosophy of?). With religion banned by the government, the people of the Soviet Union were left without a true faith. Marxism-Leninism, no matter how hard it was indoctrinated into society, never was able to fulfill the needs of humanity as well as traditional religion was. This resulted in great civil unrest. After over half a century without religion, the people of the Soviet Union demanded reform, resulting in the perestroika (reforming) and glasnost (openness) movements by the Soviet Government (Britannica ?Soviet Union?). These movements, however, were not enough, and they ultimately failed. This proves that society does indeed need religion. Ideologies developed by man are incapable of successfully fulfilling the needs that religion does.
Many of the points that Freud makes in The Future of an Illusion are very insightful. It is quite possible that humanity created God and that religion is indeed both an illusion and a universal neurosis. Religion may also to some extent harm society. For example, religious fundamentalism often hinders free thought and the questioning of the status quo. Despite these facts, however, religion has many indispensable functions in Western/European society and around the world. Religion gives people a sense of purpose in their lives. It consoles them when they meet hardships in their life and, it keeps civilization under control by the laws and morals that it lays down. These functions are irreplaceable. If they were cast aside, society would be hard pressed to find a value system or ideology that could do as good a job. I would be so inclined as to say that society could find no such system capable of fulfilling basic human need as well as religion does. True, it is possible that religion may be based on an illusion that humans made up out of want, but religion is perhaps the lynchpin of society and if one were to pull it, it is conceivable that society as a whole could collapse.
Другие работы по теме:
Authority Struggle In Tempest Essay Research Paper
The Tempest: Is It Series of Treacheries and Rebellions? Yes the play consists of ?a series of rebellion, treacheries, mutinies and conspiracies against authority? but the overall view of the dramatic action is much more complex. Many other aspects and themes such as illusion and the supernatural (magic) also play a very important part in shaping the plot.
Bouwsma
’s “Descartes’ Evil Genius” Essay, Research Paper Dylan Ragan Oct. 28, 1999 PHIL 1000H/Woller The Intent of Bouwsma’s “Descartes’ Evil Genius” Bouwsma’s essay critiques Descartes’ use of the evil demon in his Meditations on First Philosophy through the creation of two situations in which the “evil genius” attempts to use his powers for their express purpose, that of deception.
Gr8 Expec Essay Research Paper There are
Gr8 Expec Essay, Research Paper There are many common, familiar clich?s about illusion versus truth. “All that glitters is not gold” and “Things are seldom what they seem” are the most universal hackneyed phrases, but they do not cover entirely every aspect of appearance versus reality. In Charles Dickens’ novel, Great Expectations, there are several differences between the illusion and the truth.
Ethan Frome Essay Essay Research Paper Ethan
Ethan Frome Essay Essay, Research Paper Ethan Frome Essay Could you ever imagine living your entire life in the same town and if you try to leave something will keep bringing you back. In the novel, Ethan Frome, the main character Ethan Frome lives his life in this way. Through his silence, isolation, and illusions he causes himself to be trapped in Starkfield.
ShakespeareS Macbeth Essay Research Paper Illusion versus
Shakespeare?S ?Macbeth? Essay, Research Paper Illusion versus Reality in Shakespeare’s “Macbeth” Throughout the entire text of William Shakespeare’s play, “Macbeth”, there is an evident struggle between reality and illusion. In the very first scene of the play, the Weird Sisters prophesize a future that Macbeth is assured will come true.
Willy Is A Child Essay Research Paper
Willy s life in Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman can be summed up by Charley s one line, “When the hell are you going to grow up?” (97) Willy’s spends his entire life in an illusion of a great man with both popularity and successful. Meanwhile, Willy displays many childlike qualities. Many of these qualities have an impact on Willy’s family.
Glass Menagerie World Of Illusions Essay Research
Paper A World of Illusion Every character, including Jim uses illusions of the past to escape the reality in which they live in, and non can live in the outside world, the present. They are so dependent on their fantasy worlds that they cannot function properly in their own lives. The characters in Tennessee William s The Glass Menagerie constantly live in a world of fantasies rather than living in the present reality.
Illusions In The Great Gatsby Essay Research
Paper Illusions in the Great Gatsby Fitzgerald implicates the idea of ignorance is bliss. He helps to show this idea by quoting in the preface, ??the loss of those illusions that give such color to the world so that you don?t care weather things are true or false?? Gatsby has an ever-lasting love for Daisy. While Gatsby is having this obsession over Daisy, he is content with his life until he losses the illusion that he can have her.
Discovering The Future Essay Research Paper Discovering
Discovering The Future Essay, Research Paper Discovering the Future “Values are the way you measure the rightness of your vision” Before I saw the video, I told myself “oh no this one of those boring videos again that makes you fall to sleep” but I was wrong. I found the video “discovering the future” quite interesting.
The Births Of Kings Essay Research Paper
The Birth of Kings Two plays, “Hamlet”, written by William Shakespeare and “Oedipus Rex”, written by Sophocles share a common bond of illusion and innocence. The protagonists in both plays appear at the beginning only to have changed so that reality has broken through the illusion with less than desirable results for either.
Thesis Is There A God Or Is
He(?) An Illusion? Essay, Research Paper Thesis: Is There a God or is He(?) an Illusion? An illusion is one’s own interpretation and perception of someone or something.
Future Of An Illusion By Freud Essay
, Research Paper In his book The Future of An Illusion, Freud (1928) struggled to create a theory that would distinguish morality from religion so that people would still be able to know right
A Dead End Dream Death Of A
Salesman Essay, Research Paper Death of A Salesman,” by Arthur Miller, is a play that tells the story of a traveling salesman, Willy Loman, who encounters frustration and failure as he reflects on and experiences his own life. Willy s quest for the American Dream leads to his failure because throughout his life, he pursues the illusion of the American Dream and not the reality of it.
Illusions In The Glass Menagerie Essay Research
Paper We all have illusions. We can hardly live without them. Most of the time they are harmless thoughts about things that are usually unattainable. An example would be when a person sees something that they want and then dreams of having it. Whenever someone holds an opinion based on what they think is true, or in some cases what should be true, rather than what actually is true, then that is an illusion.
Caught With Rye Essay Research Paper Caught
Caught With Rye Essay, Research Paper Caught With Rye An optical illusion is something that appears to be one thing, but in reality is something different. Holden Caulfield is like an optical illusion; he appears to be one way but is nothing like what he appears to be. The reason for the false appearance that Holden portrays is that society has branded him with this image.
The Effect Of Realism On Leo Tolstoy
Shown In The Death Of Iv Essay, Research Paper The Influence of Realism in Tolstoy?s The Death of Ivan Ilyich The novella, The Death of Ivan Ilyich, shows the influence of Realism on its author. Leo Tolstoy. The illusion of reality, the main theme of the novella, is an aspect of Realism that Tolstoy effectively used in this novella.
An Anthology Of Short Stories By Jorge
Borges Essay, Research Paper An Anthology of short stories by Jorge BorgesIn the following three short stories by Jorge Luis Borges, we see how the idea of real the and illusion influence one another as described by the author and in his work. In the first short story, Everything and Nothing, Borges explains how people hide behind the illusion of being an actor in order to be some one other than themselves.
Comparison Of Paul
’s Case, The Rocling Horse Winner And The Secret Life Of Walter Mitty Essay, Research Paper In the short stories, “Paul’s Case,” “The Rocking-Horse Winner,” “The Secret Life of Walter Mitty,” and “Mr. Reginald Peacocks Day,” the main character has their own form of illusion. These characters try to escape from everyday reality by living in their own fantasy.
The Great GatsbyTrue Love Or Just An
Illusion) Essay, Research Paper In F. Scott Fitzgerald s The Great Gatsby, many people of the high social status such as Tom, Myrtle, and Nick wonder if Gatsby is truly in love with Daisy, or if he is in
Death Of A Salesman Theme Essay Essay
, Research Paper Throughout Death of a Salesman the males of the Loman family cannot distinguish between the reality of the American Dream and the illusion of it. Willy cannot see who Happy and Biff actually are as individuals or himself for that matter. Therefore, Willy and his sons believe that they all know and have what it takes to be a success in life and in business.
Misanthrope Essay Research Paper The tension of
Misanthrope Essay, Research Paper The tension of illusion and reality present a tremendous problem for the characters in Moliere?s Misanthrope. Another tension, to a lesser extent, is that of love and principle. Throughout the play the characters are saying or thinking one thing, but saying or doing the complete opposite.
A Dream Of An Angel Essay Research
Paper Heaven’s light shines in the sky Crystal tears fall from my eyes. An illusion of an angel is infront of me His angelic features in my memory. Skin so soft I would love to touch
Reality Illusion And Foolish Pride Essay Research 2
Reality Illusion And Foolish Pride Essay, Research Paper Giraud 1 Reality, Illusion and Foolish Pride In the play “The Cherry Orchard” by Anton Chekhov set in Mrs. Ranevsky’s estate and ” A Doll’s House” by Henrik Ibsen set in Helmers’ flat the protagonists shape the story. In both plays the protagonists’ mental beliefs combine reality and illusions that shape the plot of each respective story.
Illusion And Reality In A Streetcar Named
Desire Essay, Research Paper #6 – Illusion and Reality Is illusion necessary to life? Discuss the role of illusion in the play. I believe that illusion is not necessary to everyone?s life but rather it helps them to avoid the harsh realities that they may have to deal with in their lives. I also believe that a major theme of this play was how our lives can often experience a fierce battle between these illusions.
Illusion Of The American Dream Essay Research
Paper The Illusion of the American Dream The American Dream is what all Americans strive to achieve. It is the illusion of prosperity and happiness. The American Dream consists of three different elements, money, sex, and power. The plays “Death of a Salesman” and “The Glass Menagerie” are about families who strive to achieve the American Dream.
Morgana Essay Research Paper Morgana fe lay
Morgana Essay, Research Paper Morgana fe lay ( From the Arthurian cycle )My brother, king Arthur is nothing but a na ve idealist. His dream, or should I say fantasy of Camelot is nothing but an illusion. All dreams must end when one awakens. When Arthur dies and is replaced our son Mordred, the people will awaken from this dream created by him and by his charisma and the magic of Merlin.
Illusion And Reality In Gatsby Essay Research
Paper In The Great Gatsby, the confusion between reality and illusion is prominent within the key characters; Fitzgerald portrays this confusion though Gatsby’s obsession with Daisy, Nick’s idealism, and Myrtle’s dreams of success. Each of these characters possesses a flaw that causes their disillusion and their inevitable downfall.
Illusion In M Butterfly Essay Research Paper
Illusion in M. Butterfly In David Henry Hwang’s play M. Butterfly we are introduced to Rene Gallimard who has unknowingly been sexually involved with another man for twenty years. The idea of mistaken gender within the play causes the reader to question how could one mistake his/her lover’s gender for so long? In Rene Gallimard’s search for self-identity he ignorantly chooses illusion over reality.
The Great Gatsby Gatsby
’s Illusion Of Himself Essay, Research Paper The Great Gatsby: Gatsby’s Illusion of Himself F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby is considered a novel that