, Research Paper
In his book The Future of An Illusion, Freud (1928) struggled to create a theory that
would distinguish morality from religion so that people would still be able to know right
from wrong even if they did not believe in a God. According to Freud, humans belonged
to civilization to control nature and to regulate human relations. However, Freud claimed
that humans have often paid a great price for civilization; this price, he believed, was
neurosis. Consequently, humans began to look for some kind of compensation to confront
the neurosis. Freud’s theory maintained that religion often evolved as this compensation.
Freud suggested that religion and ethics, to this point, have acted to maintain civilization.
However, Freud also proposed that humans were helpless before the forces of nature and
thus “needed” something to protect them. Thus, he concluded that religion has sprung out
of helplessness and therefore was unhealthy to the individual. Based on this theory of
religion, Freud proposed the need to consider a way to sustain morality apart from
religion.
As is generally known, the central Freudian criticism of belief in God is that such a belief is
untrustworthy because of its psychological origin. That is, God is a projection of our own
intense, unconscious desires; He is a wish fulfillment derived from childish needs for
protection and security. Since these wishes are largely unconscious, any denial of such an
interpretation is to be given little credence. It should be noted that in developing this kind
of critique, Freud has raised the ad hominem argument to one of wide influence. It is in
The Future of an Illusion (1927, 1961) that Freud makes his position clearest:
Religious ideas have arisen from the same needs as have all the other achievements of
civilization: from the necessity of defending oneself against the crushing superior force of
nature. (p. 21)
Therefore, religious beliefs are:
…illusions, fulfillments of the oldest, strongest and most urgent wishes of mankind . . . As
we already know, the terrifying impression of helplessness in childhood aroused the need
forprotection-for protection through love-which was provided by the father . . . Thus the
benevolent rule of a divine Providence allays our fear of the danger of life. (p. 30)
Although such historical speculations fail to impress most people, Freud’s psychological
theories, appearing mostly in The Future of an Illusion, are a bit more credible. He made a
deliberate point of refusing to grant religion any sort of privileged status among human
endeavors. He put religion squarely in the middle of the larger context of human culture
and thus made it as accessible to scientific investigation as any other human conduct.
There were to be no sacred cows, no exemption from detailed analysis.
A number of different psychological motives underlying religious impulses are discussed
throughout the book and briefly in other works. A principle component for Freud was the
feeling of helplessness, occurring in a number of different areas, namely external dangers,
internal impulses, death, and society. As wish-fulfilling illusions, religious faith and gods
had specific tasks:
They must exorcize the terrors of nature, they must reconcile men to the cruelty of Fate,
particularly as it is shown in death, and they must compensate them for the sufferings
which a civilized life in common has imposed on them.
The first, of course, would be the feeling of helplessness before the awesome and
unpredictable powers of nature – mortal dangers from the external world. We are
confronted in life by many uncontrollable dangers, from hurricanes to disease – a condition
which Feud likened to the situation children find themselves in. Children, however, look to
their parents to protect them from danger. Adults thus create gods for themselves
precisely because they had similar “gods” in their homes as they grew up. Freud regarded
the link between the two to as “incontrovertible.”
However, it should be recognized that this link served Freud, since the inclusion of
childhood moved the issue to the home turf of Freud’s psychoanalysis which focused
strongly on childhood traumas to explain adult neuroses.
Perhaps the greatest danger facing a person is their own eventual demise. Religion,
however, typically promises the existence of an afterlife and hence that there is no genuine
death. Not only is death not genuine, but the “true believer” can look forward to
wonderful rewards for their allegiance to the “true faith” as compensation for whatever
tribulations they endured on earth. This was an important theme for Freud, as he
considered civilization to be oppressive on human nature, engendering many forms of
neurosis. Although he considered it necessary for survival, it was at best a something to
endure and not appreciate.
Psychological Analysis: Obsessions
A final form of helplessness against which religion acts is, according to Freud, our
helplessness before our own internal and uncontrollable desires. Freud made much of the
similarities between religious rituals and obsessional rituals (for example, the compulsive
need to wash your hands in a specific pattern every time), the latter of which functioned to
protect the ego from the emergence of fantasies, desires, and especially sexual impulses
which were normally repressed. In the ritual, however, they gain some partial expression
and release.
Freud saw “neurosis as an individual religion, religion as a universal obsessional neurosis.”
Drawing this parallel between the two, Freud called religion:
…the suppression, the renunciation, of certain instinctual impulses. These impulses,
however, are not, as in the neuroses, exclusively components of the sexual instinct; they
are self-seeking, socially harmful instincts, though, even so, they are usually not without a
sexual component.
Anyone who has noticed the Christian obsession with all matters sexual, and particularly
with the constant efforts to repress and deny most forms of sexual expression, will find
that even if Freud is not entirely correct, he has certainly hit upon something important.
Illusions and Delusions
The issue of “illusion” is another very important part of Freud’s critique of religion. At all
times we must keep in mind that he drew a sharp distinction between “illusion” and
“delusion,” using only the former to describe religious beliefs. Illusions, including those of
religion, are such not because of their content but by their sources. Calling religious beliefs
illusions does not automatically deny them any sort of validity – they may, after all, even
come true. Their problem lies in their source: undisciplined and uncritical human wishes.
It should be pointed out of course, that in Freud’s theories just about all thinking, including
scientific thinking, can have nonrational sources and be indicative of wishful thinking.
With both religion and science, it is not that the source determines the value of an idea – a
great idea can have a nonrational source, and a poor idea can have a rational source. What
is key is just how much influence that source continues to hold over the idea in question.
Scientists can and do come across revolutionary ideas intuitively, but their intuition and
wishful thinking are supposed to remain disciplined. Ideas are supposed to be open to
rational critique, demonstration and verification. Convictions, no matter how strong, must
be capable of being refined, modified and even abandoned if necessary. Scientific thinking
can thus be differentiated from religious thinking, since religion rarely if ever allows for
such an atmosphere to hold sway.
Freud, S. (1927/1961). The future of an illusion. New York: Norton.
A Probe of Sigmund Freud’s View of Religion
April Quetschke
July 22, 1999
Philosophy 101
Другие работы по теме:
Alfred Adler A Humanist And A Psychodynamic
Theorist Essay, Research Paper Alfred Adler: A Humanist and a Psychodynamic Theorist The antecedent influences for Adler’s theory, as with much of modern day psychology, can be found with Freud. Whether it is in direct opposition or in agreement there can be no question of Freud’s influence on Adlers individual psychological theory.
The Failings Of Future Of An Illusion
Essay, Research Paper In Sigmund Freud?s The Future of an Illusion, Freud suggests that humanity is driven by instinctual wishes that they suppress, such as incest, cannibalism, and a lust for killing. What keeps humanity from acting upon these wishes, and resulting in the break down of civilization, are the moral laws of that civilization.
Personality Essay Research Paper Freud Piaget Erikson
Personality Essay, Research Paper Freud, Piaget, Erikson, and Maslow are the last name of prominent psychologists. They have all gone to great lengths to develop their own unique theories. The theories that they have created, pertaining to personality, happen to be the four best-known theories of personality growth.
ShakespeareS Macbeth Essay Research Paper Illusion versus
Shakespeare?S ?Macbeth? Essay, Research Paper Illusion versus Reality in Shakespeare’s “Macbeth” Throughout the entire text of William Shakespeare’s play, “Macbeth”, there is an evident struggle between reality and illusion. In the very first scene of the play, the Weird Sisters prophesize a future that Macbeth is assured will come true.
Illusions In The Great Gatsby Essay Research
Paper Illusions in the Great Gatsby Fitzgerald implicates the idea of ignorance is bliss. He helps to show this idea by quoting in the preface, ??the loss of those illusions that give such color to the world so that you don?t care weather things are true or false?? Gatsby has an ever-lasting love for Daisy. While Gatsby is having this obsession over Daisy, he is content with his life until he losses the illusion that he can have her.
A Discussin On Libertarian Philosophy Essay Research
Paper Assignment: Comment on the Following Statements 1) Out of the people edited in Abel or discussed by Palmer, the following are hard determinists Well, Palmer only discusses two hard determinists: B.F. Skinner, and Sigmund Freud. Out of the texts read in Abel, Abel discusses Skinner and D Holbach as hard determinists.
Thesis Is There A God Or Is
He(?) An Illusion? Essay, Research Paper Thesis: Is There a God or is He(?) an Illusion? An illusion is one’s own interpretation and perception of someone or something.
The Communist Manifesto And Karl Marx And
Frederick Engels Essay, Research Paper The Communist Manifesto and Karl Marx and Frederick Engels In The Communist Manifesto, Karl Marx and Frederick Engels present their
Locke And Freud Essay Research Paper Many
Locke And Freud Essay, Research Paper Many different people have their own beliefs of the understanding of human nature. After reading Dr. Sigmund Freud’s letter to Professor Einstein, Why War?, the
B.F Skinner
’s Waldo Two: Positive Change In World Through Manipulation Of Behavior Essay, Research Paper B.F Skinner’s Waldo Two: Positive Change In World Through Manipulation of
Freud Dream Theory Essay Research Paper Freud
Freud Dream Theory Essay, Research Paper Freud has many theories in to the incite of the human unconscious. One of these theories is the dream theory. Many annalist think that dreams are the connection to our in most secrets and desires. Freud is among these people in thinking that dreams are the center of our repressed desires.
Sigmund Freud Essay Research Paper Theories of
Sigmund Freud Essay, Research Paper Theories of a Mad Man Sigmund Freud rocked the world of psychology with his new and unorthodox theories. He went against the establishment teaching what he considered to be the ?great truth? or the way he thought the mind actually behaved. Freud opposed the traditional and early trends of the twentieth century, this was a time when society placed importance on morality, loyalty, intellect, and emphasized the importance of family.
Comparing Nietzsche And Freud Essay Research Paper
Nietzsche and Freud both had the same idea that society was a major factor effecting ones behavior. However they differed in their perception of the innate qualities of humans and how human progress is best achieved. It will be shown in this paper how Nietzsche and Freud differ in their perception of the innate qualities of humans.
Freud Essay Research Paper Sigmund Freud physiologist
Freud Essay, Research Paper Sigmund Freud, physiologist, medical doctor, psychologist and father of psychoanalysis, is generally recognized as one of the most influential and authoritative thinkers of the twentieth century. He elaborated the theory that the mind is a complex energy-system, the structural investigation of which is proper province of psychology.
The Life Of Sigmund Freud Essay Research
Paper Sigmund Freud s revolutionary ideas, have set the standard for modern psychoanalysis. Students of psychology can learn from his ideas which spand from the field of medicine to our daily living. His studies in areas such as unconsciousness, dreams, sexuality, the Oedipus complex, and sexual maladjustment s laid the foundation for future studies and a better understanding of the small things which shapes our lives.
Sigmund Freud Essay Research Paper SIGMUND FREUDImagine
Sigmund Freud Essay, Research Paper SIGMUND FREUD Imagine this: a man who can know the brain and understand the conflict that is occurring when we encounter anxiety and unhappiness. Mr. Sigmund Freud had this ability. He knew the human brain all too well. Before entering the University of Vienna in 1873, the youthful Sigmund Freud had signs of brilliance and intelligence.
The Freud Museum Essay Research Paper The
The Freud Museum Essay, Research Paper The Freud museum is a small ?house museum? which was formerly the home of Sigmund Freud and his family when they escaped the Nazi annexation of Austria. Thus Nazi persecution of Freud led to the extraordinary environment in which he had developed his epoch-making theories being transported, in its entirety, from Vienna to London.
Psychoanalysis Essay Research Paper PsychoanalysisSigmund Freud was
Psychoanalysis Essay, Research Paper Psychoanalysis Sigmund Freud was the first to talk about psychoanalysis, a technique that allows an individual to recount dreams but what psychologists call free association. Free association is the individual saying whatever comes to mind when something is said.
The Sexual Enlightenment Of Children
” Essay, Research Paper Jeffrey Miller Intro to Psychology Due: 4-17-98 A review of “The Sexual Enlightenment of Children” by Sigmud Freud “The Sexual Enlightenment of Children” is an open
Oedipus Complex Essay Research Paper One of
Oedipus Complex Essay, Research Paper One of the cornerstones of psychoanalysis is the Oedipus Complex. According to the generally accepted version during a session of self-analysis, Freud unearthed a childhood memory of being sexually aroused by seeing his mother naked.
Misanthrope Essay Research Paper The tension of
Misanthrope Essay, Research Paper The tension of illusion and reality present a tremendous problem for the characters in Moliere?s Misanthrope. Another tension, to a lesser extent, is that of love and principle. Throughout the play the characters are saying or thinking one thing, but saying or doing the complete opposite.
Human Nature Is Inherently Bad Essay Research
Paper Human Nature Is Inherently Bad There are many theories as to Human nature. One of which exists, under the thoughts of a prominent philosopher, and founder of Psychoanalysis Sigmund
Freud Essay Research Paper Freud is uninformed
Freud Essay, Research Paper Freud is uninformed as to the coming events of the twentieth century, especially the Second World War and the Holocaust. This work was published in 1930. In 1931 when they published a second edition, Freud added a final sentence speculating whether Eros or Death would come out as stronger in the coming years.
Freud Essay Research Paper Freud
Freud Essay, Research Paper Freud’s Personality Theory The development of gender roles in deifferent forms of feminsm gives us a revealing overview of Freud’s personality theory. It is relatively
Illusion Of The American Dream Essay Research
Paper The Illusion of the American Dream The American Dream is what all Americans strive to achieve. It is the illusion of prosperity and happiness. The American Dream consists of three different elements, money, sex, and power. The plays “Death of a Salesman” and “The Glass Menagerie” are about families who strive to achieve the American Dream.
Freud And Jung
’s Differences And Similarities Essay, Research Paper Freud and Jung Both Sigmund Freud and Carl Jung are famous psychoanalysists with unique approaches to personality. At one point they shared many of the same theories and had a deep friendship. In fact, Jung was to be heir to Freud’s position as president of the International Psychoanalytic Association.
Test Anxiety Essay Research Paper Test AnxietySome
Test Anxiety Essay, Research Paper Test AnxietySome students forget all that they have learned when they walk into a testing situation. We call this “test anxiety.” Psychologists explain “test anxiety” in several different ways, depending on the philosophy of the psychologist who addresses the problem.
Freudian Theory Essay Research Paper Freudian TheorySigmund
Freudian Theory Essay, Research Paper Freudian Theory Sigmund Freud was a Viennese physician, whose psychoanalytic theory is the best-known psychodynamic approach today. He believed that behavior revealed unconscious internal forces. His work shows there are probably three parts that make up individual personality.