Paper
Electoral College Vs. Popular Vote.
When given this assignment I had no clue what topic I might choose. I waited and waited until the recent elections blew up in my face. This past election was a learning experience for me because I just turned 18. This was the first year I could ever vote and a weird election like this occurred. I noticed how many people were actually very disturbed with how Gore won the popular vote but will most likely lose the election only because he couldn’t win enough electoral votes in one state.
The Electoral College was designed in 1787 at the Constitutional Convention. A variety of ideas were originally brought to attention. Two significant and highly regarded options were a) Congress selects the President and b) the popular vote. Both ideas were disregarded. Having Congress elect the President would give the legislature complete control over him (6: 159-162). The idea of the people and only the people voting for the President was eliminated because the founding fathers of the U.S. Government felt that normal people would not be able to vote for the best President in an intelligent manner. Despite the fact that many of the original convention members thought that the popular vote would be the best option, there were still too many that opposed the idea (Glennon 7). George Mason, a former political officer in the 1800’s, states that a it would be “as unnatural to refer the choice of a proper character for chief Magistrate to the people, as it would, to refer a trial of colours to a blind man” (qtd. In Glennon 7).
I became very interested about the whole system of the college and thought that I could present an argument about how it’s really outdated and could use a big change. And so the Electoral College is created. It is made up of electors from all of the states in the nation. The electors from each state are what we the people actually vote for in the November elections (“Electoral College”). Each state can have no less than 3 electors. This is because they get an elector for every chair they fill in both the Senate and the House of Representatives. Because all states have two Senate members and at least one House member, we see why. All together, including all of our nation’s states we have an Electoral College consisting of 538 members. In order for a candidate to actually become the President he must obtain at least 270 electoral votes, giving him the majority plus one (Glennon 19). Because we use the Electoral College, it has come to occur on numerous occasions that a candidate with a higher percentage of the popular vote is defeated by his political opponent by the electoral tally (Glennon 19), thus defeating the purpose of a Democracy. A Democracy exists if we the people have “the right to self- governance.” “American ‘democracy’ has existed for over 200 years, and citizens are ready, as they have been for decades, if not centuries, to finally control their own country” (“Electoral College Problems”). Therefore the use of the Electoral College is completely useless and should be abandoned to the idea of the popular vote. If not completely thrown out, then altered by an amendment.
Under the form of the present college, it is noticeable that almost all of the third party candidates are not even glanced at. Most people don’t even know their names or what party they come from. Many people still find no problem with the ways of the college. Enthusiasts of the College point out that it has no budget what so ever, and really has no way to “defend itself.” Many also argue that if the government were as efficient we would be much better off. If the Electoral College were not established, candidates these days would most likely skip over the states that don’t have a significant number of electoral votes. For example, the District of Columbia, which has the minimum of three votes. Andrew Spano, a Westchester County executive states that “The system forces you to campaign all over the U.S. as you try to accumulate electoral votes… It fits with the diversity of our country”(Yancey). The Federal System is supposed to have the power. The people are not the Federal system, the states are the Federal system.
Anti-electoral citizens believe that they should have control of who becomes the president. They point out that under the present Electoral College mindset, every person in the United States that votes, is basically wasting their time. In an article found on the World Wide Web, it states that, in the Presidential election, “individual votes are not even tallied” (“Electoral College Problems”). In respect to the “third” party candidates, the Electoral College gives them absolutely no chance of winning. This comes forth because even if a voter likes one of the “third” party candidates the best, he or she will not vote for them because they think it will be a wasted vote. This is quite true because if they do vote for the candidate he will more often than not even receive one electoral vote. For example, in 1992, Ross Perot, a member of the Reform Party received this very misfortune. Despite the fact that he won 12% of the popular vote, he failed to obtain a single electoral vote (“Electoral College Problems”). This demonstrates the very “stumbling block” that the Electoral College has become. It is best summed up with another quote found on the Citizens for True Democracy web site. “The Electoral College is not worth saving” (“Electoral College Problems”).
The disadvantages of the Electoral system are obvious. On top of the above listed problems found with the system there comes another. As stated before, many people won’t even vote for their favorite candidate sometimes if he/ she may be in a “third” party. Many times, these parties fail to materialize in states that, more often than not, are controlled by one specific party. Whether a state has three votes or thirty-three votes, its electoral voters are only supposed to vote for the candidate they have been pledged to (6: 159 -162). This means, in the 2000 election for example, that if an electoral voter from Florida wants Gore to win he has to vote for Bush anyway. He has made a promise that he will vote for Bush and only Bush. Despite this promise, many of the voters still may vote for the person they feel will fit the position best. It doesn’t happen too often (“Electoral College”). But if it does you cannot tell who has done it because votes are cast on unnamed ballots (Longely 103).
In many of our nations past elections, the Electoral College has demonstrated its capacity to give the win to the real loser. For example, in 1888 Grover Cleveland was the winner of the popular vote by just about 100,000 votes. His opponent Benjamin Harrison won the election because of his win in the electoral votes. This also happened in 1876 when Rutherford B. Hayes stole the election from Samuel J. Tilden (6: 159 -162).
These examples demonstrate why the Electoral College should be either eliminated or at least controlled. Because of these failures of the Electoral College, numerous options have been thought through to prevent further complications. Since the Electoral College is in the Constitution, it would take an amendment to create any change what so ever. If we could change to a direct popular vote, many third parties may emerge into the running (“Electoral College”). Ideas that have been introduced have been trying to work since when it was first created. If the Electoral College were to be completely demolished the concept of direct election would be the best way to go. Under this form, all citizens who are eligible would vote for the candidate they feel best fits the position. If we have sixty million people that can vote in the United States a candidate would need thirty million plus one to win (Glennon 19). Under this option, the candidate that the majority of the people want as president will actually become the President. The other will not somehow weasel his way out of it. In two states, the Electoral College has already had its total power limited. Maine and Nebraska have their own little plan. The idea of popular vote is used in these two states. In Maine there are four electoral votes. Three belong to the major statewide popular vote winner and the other goes to the candidate who wins the 2nd congressional district. In both areas, whoever wins the popular vote gets some of the electoral votes (Curry).
We have been speaking about changing it for years and finally it’s such a big issue. It was very interesting how this happened just as I was old enough to vote. I know that if I were still not old enough I wouldn’t care as much. I would be very caught up in the whole situation but would not mind. Now that I have voted I feel that I am still excluded along with everyone else in the nation that casts their vote. It reminds me of how insignificant I am in the process. Because of this I agree with those who want a change. In my opinion I feel that having the Electoral College is bad, but not what is holding us down the most. The winner-takes-all function is a major problem. If we can somehow get that to fall apart our elections will work much better. The “Electoral College” under its present form has got to go. If a candidate wins the popular vote he should ultimately be declared the people’s favorite and therefore should not have to deal with being voted out by a silly electoral vote. If we can somehow compromise the situation I think that our nation will benefit the greatest. Let’s say for example that if a candidate wins 65% of the votes in a given state, he will also receive 65% of the electoral votes. This way, having no winner-takes-all system, the candidate who wins the popular vote will win the electoral vote also. So we won’t have to deal with all of the past problems that we as a nation have had.
“Electoral College Problems.” Citizens for True Democracy 1998-2000
“Your Vote Does Not Count! You Can Thank the Electoral College.” Citizens for True
Democracy .1998-2000
Curry, Tom. “Making Sense of the Electoral College: How the indirect, intricate system works.”
MSNBC.
Enrich, David. “2000 Presidential Campaign Showcases Electoral College Problems.”
Citizens for True Democracy 23 October 2000
Glennon, Michael J. When No Majority Rules: The Electoral College Presidential
Succession. Washington, D.C.: Congressional Quarterly Inc., 1992.
Kesler, Charles R. The Federalist Papers. Ed. Clinton Rossiter. New York: Penguin Inc.,
1961.
Longely, Lawrence D., and Neal R. Peirce. The Electoral College Primer.
New Haven: Yale University, 1996.
MacBride, Roger L. The American Electoral College. Idaho: Caxton Printers, 1953.
Margasak, Larry. “Florida Voters take to Web.” Times Union 10 Nov. 2000: A16
“Electoral College.” Microsoft Encarta Online Encyclopedia. 2000. 10 Nov. 2000
Wechsler, Alan. “Election Drama a Great Lesson.” Times Union 10 Nov. 2000: A16
“Electoral College.” The World Book Encyclopedia. 1990 ed.
Yancey, Roy. “States’ Gore Electors Question Electoral College system.”
Times Union 10 Nov. 2000: A9
Другие работы по теме:
The Affects Of The Electoral College On
The Significance And Legitimacy Of American Voting Essay, Research Paper In the 1996 United States presidential election, only 49 percent of the voting age population cast a ballot (Federal Election Committee). Only 56 percent of whites voted, followed by 50 percent of African American, and only 27 percent of Hispanics (Federal Election Committee).
Time For Reform Considering The Failures Of
The Electoral College Essay, Research Paper Time For Reform? Considering The Failures of The Electoral College Description: This paper discusses the many shortcomings of the Electoral College,
The Electoral College And Proposed Reform Policies
Essay, Research Paper The Electoral College and Proposed Reform Policies Receiving 300,000 more votes than his best opponent, Candidate A was clearly the favorite among the eight million citizens who placed their vote. Much to his and the rest of the country s surprise, however, he was not elected due to a legal ramification that instead awarded the office to Candidate B.
Electoral College Must Stand Essay Research Paper
The Founding Fathers wrote the Electoral College into the United States Constitution as insurance against popular passion electing the chief executive into office. They believed there needed to be a buffer between the people and election of the president. Also a concern of the forefathers was they did not want the states with a larger population to completely overshadow the states with a smaller populace.
Electoral College Persuassive Essay Essay Research Paper
~Electoral College~ In the United States we are all guaranteed one vote per person. Everyone has an equal voice in electing the people that serve in the government. Every four years during the month of November citizens of America go to the polls to vote for a president and vice-president of the United States.
No Electoral College Essay Research Paper In
No Electoral College Essay, Research Paper In with the Popular Vote, out with the Electoral College The recent Presidential election between Al Gore and George W. Bush has sparked a controversial flame among American citizens. Should we keep the Electoral College, or is it time to get rid of it and go by the Nation s Popular Vote? The Electoral College worked when it was first created, but problems have been coming up and deciding the President would be more efficient, and less problem-laden if Americans awarded the Presidency to the winner of the popular vote.
Electoral Systems Essay Research Paper From my
Electoral Systems Essay, Research Paper From my limited studies of comparative government I have come to the conclusion that a plurality type of electoral process where winner takes all is a superior compared to proportional representation for several key reasons. Proportional representation is based on having an election based on census instead of consensus.
Electoral College Reform Essay Research Paper In
Electoral College Reform Essay, Research Paper In order to increase the ease of creating and establishing a federal government with a central figure of office, the framers of the Constitution created the Electoral College. The College was formed to ease the process of electing a president every four years.
The Electoral College And The Influence Of
California Essay, Research Paper Peter Robinson Examine the operation of the Electoral College in Presidential elections and consider the view that a candidate who cannot win California cannot win the Presidency. In what ways has the balance of power in the Electoral College shifted in recent years?
The Electoral College How Effective Is It
? Essay, Research Paper The Electoral College: How Effective Is It? Our founding fathers wanted to devise a plan to elect the executive branch of the government without it being affected by partisan politics. In the beginning, they instituted and stated in Article 2, Section 1, of the Constitution, the method of selecting electors is delegated to the separate state legislatures, and the voting procedure to be followed by the electors is carefully defined (Encarta, History).
Vote Essay Research Paper Why should Americans
Vote Essay, Research Paper Why should Americans exercise their right to vote? Why should we vote? Is it really worth our time? The answer is YES . People say that one vote won t change the outcome, but take a look at Florida! Right now, the election of our president is in the people of Florida s hands. [Your] one vote is very important.
Ellectoral College Essay Research Paper The Electoral
Ellectoral College Essay, Research Paper The Electoral College has been used to elect the President since the beginnings of the United States. In the two hundred some odd years of history, there have been instances when the college did not work. There have been many ideas that have floated around about fixing the problem with the electorate.
Electoral College 2 Essay Research Paper Electoral
Electoral College 2 Essay, Research Paper Electoral College: It s time for reform It s not fair. It s not fair to the candidates running for office, not fair to the campaign volunteers and especially not fair to the American people. Although the Electoral College System was originally considered to be a brilliant innovation that cleverly solved a cluster of 18th-century problems, as we approach the 21st century, we confront different problems and our constitutional system of presidential selection does not look so brilliant.
Us Democracy Essay Research Paper Ant V
Us Democracy Essay, Research Paper Ant? V. Williams Political Science 1101 February 1, 2001 It’s Not Right, Get Rid of It In theory, the United States became a democracy when we signed the Declaration of Independence in 1776. This theory is not true. The textbook defines a democracy as a system of government in which ultimate political authority is vested in the people, of course you know that this is just not so.
Electoral College Is Wrong Essay Research Paper
The Electoral College is the name given to a group of electors who are nominated by political activists and party members within the states. The electoral college really isn’t necessary and should be abolished. There are numerous reasons why this is so. With the Electoral College in affect third parties don’t have a chance to become the president, which isn’t fair.
Electoral College Is No Longer A Functional
System Essay, Research Paper The electoral college has been our method of electing presiden’s sinc eth constitution was formed. With increasing popoulations and the addition of third parties, it can be
Electoral College 2 Essay Research Paper The
Electoral College 2 Essay, Research Paper The Undisputable Necessity for the Electoral College Criticism as to the relevancy of the Electoral College system used in our presidential elections has been around since the implementation of the system into our constitution. This criticism, however, is without true reason and common sense added into these assumptions.
Electoral College System Essay Research Paper After
Electoral College System Essay, Research Paper After the last presidential election, which is still underway apparently, there is much controversy over what should happen to the Electoral College system. There are people who say that the Electoral College is good but should be modified to meet the needs of the modern world.
Electoral College Essay Research Paper Electoral CollegeThe
Electoral College Essay, Research Paper Electoral College The Electoral College, friend or foe? The answer behind this question is in the minds of those that understand it. Whether it be a “friend” or a “foe” there will always be opposing sides and a controversial verse. Since the political circumstance of today, the Electoral College seems to be the topic in every conversation and the thesis to every essay.
Electoral College Should Be Here To Stay
Essay, Research Paper Title: The Electoral College Should Be Here to Stay General Purpose: To persuade Specific Purpose: To persuade individuals that the Electoral College is not at fault for the
Electoral College Essay Research Paper ELECTORAL COLLEGEElectoral
Electoral College Essay, Research Paper ELECTORAL COLLEGE Electoral College, the constitutional system for the ELECTION of the PRESIDENT and VICE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES. It is the collective name for a group of electors, nominated by political parties within the states and popularly elected, who meet to vote for those two offices.
Us Electoral College Essay Research Paper ELECTORAL
Us Electoral College Essay, Research Paper ELECTORAL COLLEGE SYSTEM: Is it time for a change? The recent presidential election brought to the forefront of the American public s mind the question of whether the Electoral College remains an appropriate method of electing the nation s highest-ranking public official.
History Of Electoral College Essay Research Paper
HISTORY OF THE ELECTORAL COLLEGE The Electoral College is the name for the electors who nominally choose the president and vice president of the United States. Each of the states receives a certain number of electors, which is determined by the total number of senators and representatives it sends to the U.S.
Should The Electoral College Be Reformed Essay
, Research Paper The body that elects the presidents and vice-presidents of the United States is known as the electoral college. Article 2, Section I, of the Constitution provides that each state “shall appoint” as many presidential electors as the state has members of Congress. (Three is the smallest number of electors a state may have, since every state has two senators and at least one member of the House of Representatives.) The Constitution gives the legislature of each state the authority to decide how that state’s presidential electors are chosen, and every state has provided that the electors shall be directly elected by the voters.
The Electoral College Essay Research Paper When
The Electoral College Essay, Research Paper When the Constitutional Convention gathered in 1784 they had the difficult task of determining how our government should be assembled and what systems we should use to elect them. They quickly decided congress should have the powers to pass laws and the people should elect these people to ensure they are following the will of the people.
Paul Ryan Essay Research Paper Dear Paul
Paul Ryan Essay, Research Paper Dear Paul Ryan: Do we really need the Electoral College? I?m writing to you saying that we really don?t need it. I am looking forward in voting in my future years for further elections, but is the Electoral College really needed? I believe that the way that our country votes is wrong.
Us Election Essay Research Paper 1 How
Us Election Essay, Research Paper 1. How elect a US President? The rules of US Constitution specifies that a president must be elected every four years. Candidates must be at least 35 years old and a US citizen born in the USA.
Presidential Election Fact O Essay Research
Paper The Presidential Election of 2000: Fact or Farce When the subject of the Presidential Election is brought up, most people think of all the chaos that was caused between Florida and the rest of us. What I would like to state to you today is about how our electoral system is out of date and how it goes against everything that we should do to elect the proper president.
Democracy Or Repulic Essay Research Paper A
Democracy Or Repulic Essay, Research Paper A DEFINING ESSAY: DEMOCRACY OR REPUBLIC? Many Americans have grown accustomed to hearing that the United States is a democracy when in fact it s a republic. Often Americans today seem to be unable to define the important difference between these two meanings. By understanding the foundation and true nature of our republic system of government, ones appreciation for the freedom to vote can be greatly enhanced.
Not The Best But Better Than The
Rest Essay, Research Paper “Not the Best, but Better Than the Rest” “The method of choosing the president proved to be But one of many vexing problems for the fifty-five men who assembled in Philadelphia in May 1887” (Euchner, and Maltese 2). Our forefathers were faced with many hard decisions that would have repercussions for the next two centuries.
The US Presidential Election Essay Research Paper
The United States has recently elected a new president. The two frontrunners for the presidency were George Bush and Al Gore. It was a close race all way up to Election Day. There was some controversy over the ballads, which prolonged the election. In some states their had to be a recount to see who would win that states electoral votes.
Debat3 Essay Research Paper The 2000 Presidential
Debat3 Essay, Research Paper The 2000 Presidential election between Vice-President Al Gore and Texas Governor George W. Bush was and still is a close campaign. This race has still not ended due to the closeness in the state of Florida primarily and the state of Oregon. Florida which contains 25 electoral college votes was and still is to close to call, which means that the race is close as of last time that I had checked the race was only separated by about 1800 votes.