When President Bill Clinton reluctantly signed the Personal Responsibility and
Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996, he had an idea of what the
critical responses would be. The hope was to induce a program that would
bring significant benefits to the needy and hungery people of our country.
However, the response and criticisms are equivalent to what our president
expected, very negative.
Mary Jo Bane believes the new welfare law poses serious dangers to poor
children and families. As assistant secretary for children and families in
the Department of Health and Human services, she supported the
administration’s efforts to refocus the welfare system on work and to increase
state flexibility through the waiver process. But in the course of reviewing
state welfare reform proposals, she became concerned that politics and
financial pressures were pushing states into a “race to the bottom”(Bane). As
long as the old law was in place the federal government could insist on
guaranteed assistance and protections for recipients. Her fears about what
would happen to poor children when states were no longer required to provide
the modest assurances and protections we insisted on in waiver demonstrations
led her to resign after President Clinton signed the welfare bill (Bane).
The reform takes away national level responsibilities and puts the money and
responsibility into the individual states. A good amount of flexibility is
provided, which may or may not result in a positive manner. For instance,
they money could be used on the work reform and job preparation, while others
could find loopholes in the laws, and while their purposes may not be
malicious, the money would not truly be carrying out the role intended.
“No longer will cash assistance to dependent children be guaranteed by the
federal government. Instead it will be provided, or not, by states using
block grants.” (Bane) This is the basic premise of the new bill.
Specifically, there are nine titles addressing separate issues involved. The
bulk of the 54 billion dollar savings appears in Numbers XV and XIII. They
offer the most serious impact, according to Mrs. Smith and they were also
considered the most flawed by President Clinton. Title IV bans most legal
immigrants from receiving most federal benefits. Title XIII cuts food stamp
benefits across the board and restricts food stamp benefits to unemployed
adults without disabilities or dependents to 3 months out of 36 (Bane). Most
of the 54 billion in savings come from these two titles alone. Mary Jo feels
the greatest weakness of the reform is the lack of response to the children,
who are in turn, not supported anymore after the parent has failed to win a
job and has used up their five year limit on assistance. What would happen to
them we ask? There is no data to tell us.
Another reporter is more concerned with the unrealistic ideals of the job
program. Although in some states it has in fact benefited them, it could
ultimately spell disaster. The preparation program has little to no focus on
post secondary education, which is really what leads into most of the
worthwhile jobs (The Issues, Welfare Reform p.2-3). Without even a high
school diploma, the majority of the jobs taken are merely in the fast food
industry, making 5-6 dollars an hour with no benefits (Heaven knows what would
happen if there was an accident.) These type jobs also inculde a highly
unpredictable work schedule. The individual would never have a reliable
income. Even more distressing is that in the estimated required wage for a
single mother to earn in order to feed, house, and transport is around 8-9
dollars an hour, a considerable amount less than the average.
Another problem with the work-based part of the program, is that there may be
no jobs left over to be acquired. There are certainly not enough well-paying
programs to go around. It is quite possible that without the creation and
implementation of a public-sector employment agency, there may never be enough
jobs. Can we deny people assistance because there are simply no jobs
leftover? (The Issues, Welfare Reform p. 5)
Another agrues that it is not truly welfare refrom. It does not promote work
effectively, and it will hurt millions of poor children when it fully
implemented. He is also deeply concerned with the fact that it bars hundreds
of thousands of legal immigrants — including many who have worked in the
United States for decades and paid a considerable amount in Social Security
and income taxes — from receiving disability and old-age assistance and food
stamps, and reduces food-stamp assistance for millions of children in working
families. If the said parent fails to find a job or exceed their five year
total, what would happen to the children? The answer, disturbingly, is
nothing. During a floor debate, Senator Edward Kennedy described this as
“legislative child abuse”. (Edelman)
While the authors are agreed that this is ,overall, a bad idea, they also each
can’t help but praise a few pieces of the legislation, such as the child care
and self-improvement initiative. They express how the program set forth in a
well intended manner, in the hopes of correcting one of our nations greatest
problems, can turn into many new problems. The hardest part lies in the fact
that there is no universal answer to an issue as large, widespread, and
diverse as the welfare program. We have learned that there is much work to be
done and many changes to be made before we will ever have a “win-win”
situation.
Bane, Mary Jo. “Welfare as We Might Know It”. Copyright 1997.
Political Science Quarterly. 40 par. 11 June, 1999
.
“The Issues, Welfare Reform”
CQ Researcher, December 6, 1996
Edelman, Peter. “The Worst Thing Bill Clinton Has Done” March 1997
The Atlantic Montly. 109 par. June 13, 1999
theatlantic/issues/97mar/edelman/edelman.htm
Другие работы по теме:
Welfare Reform Essay Research Paper One hotly
Welfare Reform Essay, Research Paper One hotly contested aspect of the recent welfare debate is the unsubstantiated characterization of welfare recipients as having alcohol and drug problems, according to authors of a study published in the American Journal of Public Health. In their study, the authors present the most recent national estimates of alcohol and drug use, abuse and dependence among recipients in five social service programs.
Pros Of Welfare Reform Essay Research Paper
Pros of Welfare Reform In the summer of 1996, Congress finally passed and the President signed the “Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996″, transforming the nation’s welfare system. The passage of the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act sets the stage for ongoing reconstruction of welfare systems on a state-by-state basis.
Begging Essay Research Paper By the middle
Begging Essay, Research Paper By the middle of the fourteenth century, begging was becoming a social problem. During periods of economic dislocation, the unemployed began to roam the countryside and migrated to the towns looking for work. Capitalism, wage labor, and poverty continued to grow. The American welfare state is dated from the Social Security Act of 1935.the act continued and hardened the categorical programs that had been enacted by the states between 1910 and the 1920s.
Black History Final Essay Research Paper March
Black History Final Essay, Research Paper March 17, 1998Black Studies 137E Final1. b) According to Wilson, there is a positive relationship between structuralopportunities and culture. ” ‘Culture’ may be defined as the sharing of modes of behaviorand outlook within a community…To act according to one’s culture…is to follow one’sinclinations as they have been developed by influence or learning from other members ofthe community that one belongs to or identifies with” (Wilson, p. 66).
Politics Essay Research Paper Frank Sinatra once
Politics Essay, Research Paper Frank Sinatra once said, “You’re riding high in April, shot down in May. But I know I’m gonna change that tune, when I’m back on top, back on top in June.” Does the epitome of individualism lie in the lyrics of a
Poverty In America Essay Research Paper Brandon
Poverty In America Essay, Research Paper Brandon Cristobal Mr.Orozco 9/25/00 Phil 103 ? Poverty, all day, everyday? Coming home everyday to nothing to eat is the scenario for the young children whose parents are on welfare. Those parents are stuck on welfare and can?t give there children anything they want, they take the money the state gives them just to get by, maybe not even able to get the biological needs to survive.
Ruling Ideologies Essay Research Paper Core Studies
Ruling Ideologies Essay, Research Paper Core Studies 3 Casilda Adames Take-Home Exam November 16, 1999 The ruling ideology dealing with welfare is a negative view among the majority of Americans. It states that welfare recipients are lazy people who have lots of children and collect checks for a long period of time.
Welfare Programs Essay Research Paper Government
Welfare Programs Essay, Research Paper Government’s Welfare Programs For a long time now, since the accomplished formation of a stable government, the U.S government has had programs and passed laws that either
Fitting The Poor Into The Econ Essay
, Research Paper In the article “Fitting the Poor into the Economy” Herbert Gans provides a number of antidotes to poverty which i fell will help sturgling familys and
Corporate Welfare Essay Research Paper Welfare is
Corporate Welfare Essay, Research Paper Welfare is a big part of tadays society and economy. The question of whether there is too much welfare or whether there is too little. For example President Clinton had pledged to end welfare as we know it while otehrs say society should only reform welfare. Welfare should be reformed greatly especially in the areas of corporate welfare, Medicaid, Food Stamps, and other funded areas which are wasting money.
The Klan Essay Research Paper The
The Klan Essay, Research Paper * The Klan name and symbol break through the paper curtain of the anti-White media and brings us to the attention of those who want to
Constitution Essay Research Paper The Constitution of
Constitution Essay, Research Paper The Constitution of the United States of America We the people of the United States, in order to form a more perfect union, establish justice, ensure domestic tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general welfare, and secure the blessings of liberty to ourselves and our posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
Violent Kid Profile Essay Research Paper THE
Violent Kid Profile Essay, Research Paper ?THE VIOLENT-KID PROFILE? Are students being judged by the way they act, by what they say, or even by the way they dress? Sadly, the answer is yes. Not by their peers, but
A Need For Welfare Essay Research Paper
A Need for Welfare There?s an old joke that asked,? Where do you find a welfare recipients check?? Under his work boots of course (Armitage 45). For a long time now, since the accomplished formation of a stable government, the U.S government has had the programs and passed laws that either dealt with issues of or influenced family.
Welfare Where Is It Going Essay Research
Paper Welfare: Where is it going? Millions of Americans today are signed up for a program called Welfare. Welfare is a program designed to aid poor and needy families. Every human being has essential needs that cannot always be met due to difficult or demanding situations. In most cases, these situations are long term and almost seem impossible to get out of.
Immigrants Essay Research Paper Are Immigrants A
Immigrants Essay, Research Paper Are Immigrants A To the U.S? Immigrants are not a burden to the U.S. Therefore, we shouldn’t stop all immigration . Immigrants are hard workers and are not causing unemployment for
An Essay On Poverty And Welfare Essay
, Research Paper Essay on Poverty and Welfare Today it seems as if everyone has a theory about fighting poverty, now it is not necessary to be moving in the theoretical plane. Our country has had successful anti-poverty
Is Welfare In Keeping With The Norms
Of Social Justice? Essay, Research Paper Is Welfare in Keeping with the Norms of Social Justice? In order to answer this question we must first begin with the starting point of all Catholic Social Teaching; the dignity of the human person. All social action, and activities, between individuals, lesser organizations, and the governing body must seek the common good of all society and of the individual person.
Welfare Essay Research Paper In brief first
Welfare Essay, Research Paper In brief, first, the global economy has brought with it high rates of unemployment and economic inactivity in much of Europe. It has also generated strong pressures to de-regulate and create flexible labour markets with sharp rises in wage dispersion, part-time, temporary and casual employment particularly in the UK and USA.
Scrooge Essay Research Paper Ignorance
Scrooge Essay, Research Paper Ignorance & Want In the famous story A Christmas Carol, the Ghost said to Scrooge “”These are your children Ignorance and Want.” as he opened his robe to reveal two small unfortunate poverty stricken children. By this, the ghost meant that because of the cruelty of the world and irresponsibility, these innocent children must suffer.
Welfare Essay Research Paper Purpose The purpose
Welfare Essay, Research Paper Purpose The purpose of this discussion is to compare and contrast the values and assumptions of both Charles Murray and Lawrence Mead vis-a-vis Michael Harrington and William J. Wilson, specifically addressing poverty programs and the reasons for their failure during the 1960’s and 1970’s.
Child Poverty Essay Research Paper CHILDREN AND
Child Poverty Essay, Research Paper CHILDREN AND POVERTY IN CANADA The purpose of this project is to discuss child poverty and child welfare practice. There is a need to critically examine the issue and situate the causes of
The Shrinking Welfare State Essay Research Paper
Welfare has been the topic of much controversy over the past few years. The welfare program has been important for many people. The purpose of welfare is to assist people who are jobless or can t make ends meet financially. One of the stated purposes of the Personal Responsibility Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996, popularly known as welfare reform was to end the dependence of needy parents on government benefits by promoting job preparedness, work, and marriage.
Immigration 3 Essay Research Paper Analysis of
Immigration 3 Essay, Research Paper Analysis of a Disagreement over Immigration The authors of the 3 articles on immigration reform all seem to agree that the 1990 immigration law is inadequate, but they agree on little else. They find different impacts on the workforce, positive and negative. And they differ sharply over whether recent levels of immigration help or hurt the economy: one writer suggesting higher levels of immigrants and the other two suggesting a reduced level.
UK Welfare State Essay Research Paper Good
UK Welfare State Essay, Research Paper Good health is an important factor to an individual?s welfare. It is an essential prerequisite for the enjoyment of life. For this reason the importance
Welfare Reform Essay Research Paper Title Welfare
Welfare Reform Essay, Research Paper Title: Welfare ReformCategory: otherDescription:Body of paper: Welfare is a subject that many people can not agree on. It is one of the most debated topics in almost every political campaign because of it s great importance to the American public. Bill Clinton offered his view on the subject in his 1992 speech “Ending Welfare as We Know It”.
Welfare Reform Essay Research Paper Econ 251Welfare
Welfare Reform Essay, Research Paper Econ 251 Welfare Reform will hit economy hard A new law is going to be implemented in the near future, which requires welfare recipients to work increasing amount of time for their benefits, and places a five year limit on aid! This new policy is thought to make some people and some of their problems go away…but people don s just go away.
Mythology And Policy Essay Research Paper Mythology
Mythology And Policy Essay, Research Paper Mythology and policy has been a part of human culture for as long as there has been civilization . Day provides us with a history of the beginnings of social welfare. She speaks how social policy as well as social welfare has effected individuals, families, and the larger society of today.
Capture The Satellite Essay Research Paper It
Capture The Satellite Essay, Research Paper It was late in the evening when two astronauts approached the spinning 3,000 pound satellite. They reached out to grab the lost satellite and bring it safely back to the U.S. space shuttle. This may sound like a clip out of a recent science fiction movie, but this is the story of the lost SPARTAN satellite.The SPARTAN satellite was sent up in the U.S. space shuttle.
Should Social Policy Be Concerned With Creating
Equality Essay, Research Paper Social policy covers a social wide range of social welfare provisions,? that the vast majority of society are able use.? As Mishra notes ?social policy? social arrangements,
Big Daddy Essay Research Paper Big KidOne
Big Daddy Essay, Research Paper Big Kid One of the most recent movies that i have seen is Big Daddy. When this movie came out in theaters I knew that it was going to be a hit because the main character (Adam Sandler)
Aids In Africa Essay Research Paper Dear
Aids In Africa Essay, Research Paper Dear, Dr. Feedlebom of ?Conspiracies and Cover ups? magazine. I would like to share with you some information concerning the Aids epidemic in Africa. HIV, which causes