At the heart of our being human lies the existence of language. And at the heart of language is the existence of ideas. In fact, language is commonly viewed by communication scholars such as Professor Lankershim as shaping our very ability to think (Lecture, 1999). Inherent to language is also the ability to share ideas share thoughts that were arguably formed through language. Needless to say, there is some catch 22 at play here. Ancient philosophers spent a great deal of effort meditating on language and thought. After all, they were thinkers by trade. And in their thinking they saw the need for being able to effectively persuade others to accept their thoughts. Enter a term known as rhetoric. Rhetoric, in ancient Greek times a methodology for speech making and persuasion, is now adapted to refer to the symbols used to communicate (Lecture, 1999). Let us span two vastly separated periods of time, thus being the brink of the 21st century and ancient Greece, to examine how rhetorical philosophers Plato and Aristotle would evaluate a modern editorial column by Robert Scheer. Plato contends that rhetoric is only valuable if it involves knowledge of some class of objects (Harrick, 55). He provides an analogy to clarify: true rhetoric is like athletic activity in that it builds upon and restores the health of the body. In other words, effective rhetoric is founded in truth, and cannot manipulate the audience. Rhetoric, to Plato, is the tool by which speakers can inform and impart knowledge. In the LA Times article entitled Now That End Is Near, GOP Can t Let Go, columnist Robert Scheer focuses on right wing politics from a leftist stance. Scheer argues that the Republican party is self destructing, and that its leaders are to blame. While I tend to agree, I do not feel as if Plato would accept the argument. The very basis of politics is the existence of more than one party insisting that they are the holders of absolute truth. I am right, you are wrong and are bad for the health of the country. This battle for power and policy lends itself quite easily to manipulation, and it is the manipulation present in Scheer s article that Plato would find erroneous. For example, Scheer uses loaded terms to describe the leaders of the GOP. Of course the infamous Kenneth Starr is present and accounted for: Kenneth Starr [is] a sinisterly prudish inquisitor employing the power of the state to intrude on the most private of moments (Scheer, 1999). Sinister. That is definitely a nametag that prompts a negative image of the man through word choice alone, don t you think? Also, Scheer s choice to phrase oral sex with an intern as the most private of moments avoids the absolute truth and instead triggers sympathy in the reader. After all, would you like your private moments intruded upon? No? Well then, you must agree that Starr is a scumbag. This is manipulation, and it surfaces more than once in Scheer s column, again with the accusation GOP leaders are angry scolds, guilting us at every divisive turn (Scheer, 1999). Scheer then continues to make the brutal assumption that Senator Trent Lott and Representative Bob Barr are racist because they appeared at ease when addressing an avowedly racist group in the deep South. This not a conclusion, this is an assumption. However, to a liberal audience looking for any support material in favor of Republicans being anti-gay racists, it will be taken as truth and Plato would find anything manipulative taken as truth to be in violation of his rhetorical theory. In the dialogue Phaedrus, Plato argues that true rhetoric betters the individual and society. Through Socrates, Plato establishes rhetoric to be the influencing of the soul through words in addition to a knowledge of truth (Harrick, 66). This combination leads to the good ordering of our lives, which is called virtue (Harrick, 67). Essentially, the rhetor has the responsibility of leading his audience on a moral and soul improving road. To Plato, rhetoric is persuasive if this goal is always in the mind of the speaker.
This leads me right into a conflict. Because the dialogue of Scheer s argument contains manipulative phrases, I feel as if Plato would scold the author. But I also feel as if Robert Scheer has the best interest of the nation in mind. His message is that the GOP is falling apart, and that to follow the republican path is to follow in the footsteps of the immoral and unethical. Scheer intends to better the lives of his audience, and to further support the opinions that he truly feels are moral and uplifting. But then again, Plato insists that it is a combination of true knowledge and virtuous intentions that comprise true rhetoric. Aristotle, another Greek philosopher with his own views of rhetorical theory, believed that dialectic is a requisite for an effective persuasion. Dialectic is a term referring to the give and take of arguments when considering an issue. To Aristotle, it is necessary to consider both sides of an issue and answer potential questions from your opposition. Robert Scheer would have done a somewhat commendable job according to Aristotelian rhetoric. Albeit, political opinion usually leaves very little room for the fair representation of the other party. But nevertheless, when addressing the monster tendencies of some GOP officials, Scheer does pay tribute to the obvious Republican rebuttal well, what about George W. Bush?!? Scheer does a nice job of quieting this opposition by pointing out that there are compassionate conservatives out there, but they are denounced by the more powerful GOP leaders. This is in direct support of Scheer s thesis in that the GOP is destroying all attempts at making themselves appeal across party lines. Aristotle also believed that a key to rhetoric lies in finding the available means of persuasion (Harrick, 78). This means that the speaker, or in this case the author, must find the most appropriate way of communicating to his audience. Scheer succeeds in doing this. He understands that he is writing a column for a liberal audience that is likely to be sensitive to the role of the republican party in the Clinton scandal, and that the liberal reader is likely to be easily charged by anti-right-wing sentiments. Thus Scheer s attack: GOP leaders have become angry scolds, guilting us at every divisive turn while shunning all who are less pure in their devotion to the Christian right . So while Plato would view Scheer s argument as manipulative and not founded in a truth that could be considered absolute, Aristotle would support the column and review it as a good example of his rhetorical theory. As far as I am concerned? I favor Aristotle s stance. When I read Platonic philosophy in general, I feel as if he views himself as the all knowing source of truth. Yet truth is far from absolute. I found the article entertaining, informative, and an example of a well-formulated argument wherein the opposition, while quite brutally attacked, was well represented.
Harrick, James. (1998). The History and Theory of Rhetoric Needham Heights, MA: Allyn and Bacon. Scheer, Robert. Now That End Is Near, GOP Can t Let Go. The Los Angelels Times 10 Feb. 1999, Metro.
Другие работы по теме:
Political Analysis Essay Research Paper A famous
Political Analysis Essay, Research Paper A famous politician by the name of Bush once said “The American dream is so vivid- but too many feel: the dream is not meant for me.” Even though the dream is for everyone. The way he uses rhetoric in his speeches help to persuade the audience to follow his cause. He uses very vivid words, which give his speeches life.
Cleon As A Leader Essay Research Paper
Cleon as a leader: Cleon was not a real leader but rather a ?false leader?. His leadership skills were the best for any citizen because he was said to be one of the most persuasive, hot tempered and trusted citizens of the time. Cleon was also thought to have mastered rhetoric speaking and to be a professed ?protector? of the common people.
Quotes Essay Research Paper Love like you
Quotes Essay, Research Paper Love like you’ve never been hurt, and dance like no ones watching The ultimate measure of a man is not where he stands in moments of comfort and convenience, but where he stands at times of challenge and controversy.
Obsessive Compulsive Disorder Essay Research Paper If
Obsessive Compulsive Disorder Essay, Research Paper If you take a close look at your own behavior you will probably come to the conclusion that some of the things you tend to do are a bit obsessive. We may check several times throughout the night to make sure a door is locked, or we may avoid stepping on cracks in the sidewalk.
Ritalin Essay Research Paper Ritalin is a
Ritalin Essay, Research Paper Ritalin is a drug used to quell HYPERCATIVE children and perk up the inattentive. Six times as much ritalin was used in 1995 than in 1990
Change Essay Research Paper Change as changing
Change Essay, Research Paper Change as changing times and techology…………….. People often use these terms without realizing that word CHANGE has neither a denotation nor a connotation of advancement,improvement or progress; a change can take place at any direction: forward, backward, up and downward!
Shane Essay Research Paper Sometimes I need
Shane Essay, Research Paper Sometimes, I need you more than I need air And sometimes I miss you more than I will forever, never forget the times that we have shaared. The are priceless
Tragic Hero Essay Research Paper While Aristotle
Tragic Hero Essay, Research Paper While Aristotle’s analysis of tragedy may not be directly related to his philosophy of rhetoric, no study of Aristotle would by complete without a short introduction.
Descartes Essay Research Paper Questions I
Descartes Essay, Research Paper Questions I & III It seems evident that due to it’s limited access via social castes as well as it’s provincial ideology once attained, education before the 1800’s played a limited role in the history of Education. From the rhetoric-based Greek age of Plato and Aristotle to colonial America, education was mostly an elitist institution that was inaccessible to most and, if one was so privileged as to attain it, full of hackneyed, non-progressive ritual; thus making its’ impact evident mostly in history textbooks.
Rhetoric Essay Research Paper Rhetoric as a
Rhetoric Essay, Research Paper Rhetoric as a communal making of meaning versus a platform for demonstrating intellectual prowess of an individual through victory over an opponent, or even as a means to put an existing point across seems to be at least one theme in these articles. For us, as educators, this seems a distinction to be reckoned with.
The Difference Between Post Modern Age And
Medieval Age Essay, Research Paper I feel that medieval times and today?s times differ extremely. Many people seem to think that it is much better in today?s times, but in some ways I feel differently.
The Logic Behind The Assertion Essay Research
Paper The Logic Behind the Assertion In Martin Luther King Jr.?s ?Letter from Birmingham City Jail,? he argues the commonly believed assumption that activating our rights as human beings precipitates violence. Even though these actions may be nonviolent, those individuals who have tried to bring about the truth have been condemned because their quests were believed to be a disturbance among society.
A Civil Action Essay Research Paper In
A Civil Action Essay, Research Paper In a trial, rhetoric is an important part in the success or failure of a case. This is a double-edged sword; it can play out either good or bad. Rhetoric can be used to stress an important detail or idea, but it can also to derail the other side s case, or, just take them out mentally.
Julius Caesar Essay Research Paper Born in
Julius Caesar Essay, Research Paper Born in Rome on July 12 or 13, 100 BC, Caesar belonged to the prestigious Julian clan; yet from early childhood he knew controversy. His uncle by marriage was
The Godfather Essay Research Paper Violence and
The Godfather Essay, Research Paper Violence and The Godfather Throughout time there have always been people who held more power than others. There are many different methods used to both demonstrate and maintain the power which they possess. Often times violence is the method chosen to achieve these goals.
To Tell Or To Lie Essay Research
Paper To Tell or to Lie Maral Frendjian For modern students, a training in rhetoric such as that offered by Gorgias is more preferable, rather than learning how to distinguish truth from
Faked Smile Essay Research Paper I sat
Faked Smile Essay, Research Paper I sat on the cliff facing the sea, Mixed emotions accompanied me, Did I say or do anything wrong, That broke the bond that could have last long.
Global Crisis Essay Research Paper In times
Global Crisis Essay, Research Paper In times of global crisis, is it reasonable to expect that nation-states will put aside rivalries and join together to deal with the crisis?
The Road Essay Research Paper Oh how
The Road Essay, Research Paper Oh how many times i have driven this road with butterflies in my stomach, a gleam in my eye. Just knowing i was going to see you.
High Protein Essay Research Paper A high
High Protein Essay, Research Paper A high protein diet is essentially that, a diet that is high in protein. However… The diet is not only high in protein, but it is low in other nutrients
Classical Rhetoric And Its Influence Essay Research
Paper Classical Rhetoric and its Influence The influence that classical rhetoric has had on very famous modern-day speeches can be accredited to Cicero, the greatest Roman orator of all time. The same rhetorical devices and the elements of style that Cicero incorporated in his compelling oration against Catiline are still utilized today.
The Directand Indirectimpact Of Rhetoric On The
Color Purple) Essay, Research Paper Emory Lott 12/05/96 English 1001 page 1 The Direct and Indirect Impact of Rhetoric In the world that we live in, rhetoric always affects and is a part of everything that happens. Rhetoric, in its broadest sense, is communication, and how people relate to each other. The movie The Color Purple is about relationships.
Rhetoric 2 Essay Research Paper Rhetoric and
Rhetoric 2 Essay, Research Paper Rhetoric and Rhetorical Schemes The definition of rhetoric is as simple as the art of persuasion, but what makes rhetoric effective is the way it is applied. In order to use rhetoric in writing and in speech, the meaning of rhetoric and its purpose must be clearly understood.
Personality Essay Research Paper PersonalityWhat is personality
Personality Essay, Research Paper Personality What is personality? Personality is defined as a ingrained and relatively enduring patterns of thoughts, feeling and behavior. How can anybody be certain how his or her personality is going to turn out. I think people go through many different types an stages of personality throughout life.
The Earth Essay Research Paper THE EARTH
The Earth Essay, Research Paper THE EARTH The Earth’s Place In Space: Despite its own special conditions,the Earth is in some ways similar to the other inner planets the group of planets
Andromeda Strain Essay Research Paper Michael Crichton
Andromeda Strain Essay, Research Paper Michael Crichton uses three common devices with ease in his novel, Sphere. The devices being: rhetoric, semantics, and style. Crichton uses these devices to incorporate a sense of unity in the writing. It is not difficult to incorporate this unity into a novel when the devices are properly used.
Hope Essay Research Paper Hope What do
Hope Essay, Research Paper Hope: What do you guys hope for? I hope that the Dodgers win. I hope I do okay on the finals. I hope the teacher doesn^?t catch me. You
Best Friends Essay Research Paper BEST FRIENDSIn
Best Friends Essay, Research Paper BEST FRIENDS In New York times are always rough for teenagers growing up. Teens must deal with things like school, violence, drugs, and parents. But when you have good
The Playground Essay Research Paper I have
The Playground Essay, Research Paper I have a friend I used to know who had a playground where we would go The times we had are fresh in my mind but they are from another time