Bound By Rules Essay, Research Paper
THE DEATH OF COMMON SENSE How Law Is Suffocating America. By Philip K. Howard
Have rules replaced Thinking? This is the question that corporate lawyer, Philip Howard, asks of American law throughout his work. He argues that rules are simply not enough and that they cannot supercede human judgment. He believes that the excess of government regulations does not only not protect Americans, but in fact can even immobilize them and their ability to take action. Howard’s book makes an undeniable point that common sense has been lost in American law and he pleads for a freedom from rules, yet he lacks in the way of solutions to the problem that he makes so clear.
Howard’s undeniable point, proving the weakness of big government, is reached by relating endless stories of illogical and inefficient governmental bureaucracy. First, the example of New York City laws forbidding Mother Theresa from opening two multi-storied homeless shelters unless she were to install elevators in the renovated buildings. Also, Howard questions the U.S department of Defense spending $2.2 billion dollars to process paperwork for $2 billion dollars worth of travel. Other examples of ludicrous government control include a 33-page manual describing the qualification and uses of a hammer, and contract bidding procedures that inadvertently but obviously encourage corruption. Howard clearly makes his point, that the abundance of rules interferes with common sense and this makes it difficult for citizens to retain any power to make their own decisions. But then again, who would seriously dispute that?
The second section of Howard’s book explains how the routine of the law has brought us to the point where people argue, not even about right and wrong, but about whether something was done the right way. He sees government playing a referee role more often then it finds itself being the decision maker. Howard again concludes with the same principle by emphasizing the dangerous side effects caused by using government to solve every problem and regulate every process.
In the final section of his book, Howard moves on to explore the “rights revolution”. This is a recent movement in which government has taken on the role of “your rich uncle under your personal control” and now everyone can be a part of a discriminated-against minority. “Rights” now exist for the handicapped, for the poor, the endangered species, and even the left handed. Howard believes that these “rights” weaken the understanding of authority and responsibility, and forces government to continue to help them. This does not result in bringing minority groups into society; in fact it has prevented citizens from working together and caused even more segregation and competition. Howard concludes this final section by encouraging the acceptance of responsibility and the value of compromising and maintaining a balance.
The main flaw in the book is not the recognition of the problem, which should be obvious to most people, but in the solution. So, sure Philip Howard presents a wonderful case that proves our legal system is too big; there are too many laws and “rights” that are infringing on our freedom and hampering our nations prosperity. But what does he offer for a clearly focused solution? A return to common sense is all that he offers. No list of ramifications that would result from loosening the hold of the government is included. Nor is there even a list of areas where government could loosen its hold. The main difficulty lies in the fact that there are no easy solutions to this problem. If you loosen regulation you allow bad judgment. If you tighten regulation you don’t allow good judgment. It seems like Mr. Howard doesn’t acknowledge the difficulty or near impossibility of solving this problem.
The beauty of Mr. Howard’s book is the great challenge that it presents to its reader to find a way, any way to bring this country out its stupidity and back to sanity. Emotions will stir at mention of the book even weeks after you finish it. Anger, frustration, and a desire for an answer will drive you nuts. Perhaps, this was Mr. Howard’s exact intention? Perhaps, he only wanted to share his thoughts that have plagued him with those same emotions; in hopes that maybe someone will find a solution to the problem with this current system of government?
Другие работы по теме:
Thoreau Essay Research Paper As I sit
Thoreau Essay, Research Paper As I sit in front of the computer typing this essay I can only think of how Thoreau s ideas seemed flawed. Word processing programs on the computer have greatly decreased the time needed to create a document. I can write faster and more legibly with a word processor than by hand. Not only that with a computer you have a clean sheet of paper instead of one ruined by mistakes that are bound to happen if written by hand.
Serfs Essay Research Paper They are the
Serfs Essay, Research Paper They are the ones who supply the lord with food. They are the ones who do the lords work. they are the ones bound to the land, never to leave it. They are the ones who do all these things without reward. They are the serfs. In return for all of their work the lord protects them. It was said by nobles and lords, that without protection they would surely be looted and killed.
Jewelry From Africa Essay Research Paper Most
Jewelry From Africa Essay, Research Paper Most jewelry of Africa comes from the kingdom of Benin, which is located in a tropical rain forest in southern Nigeria. In the kingdom of Benin, the Oba rules over the life and death of his subjects. In the Equatorial Rain Forest, ivory is plentiful and is valued for it?s rich patina and magical powers.
Cohesion With Contrast
– Gene Vs. Finny Essay, Research Paper Although a friendship often implies many similarities, Gene and Finny also appear very different in many aspects of life. Their friendship gives the impression that at some times it was unstable, but overall it was bound to be everlasting. This companionship is a primary example of any real-life friendship of the common person.
Baseball
’s New Rules Essay, Research Paper Baseball’s New Rules I started to watch baseball again since the World Series is starting but I have noticed that there are a couple of new rules in
State Of Nature Essay Research Paper If
State Of Nature Essay, Research Paper If human beings lived in a state of nature they would be free. Free from any form of government. Free from people telling them how to live and how to do their job. These people would have no boss or parents to deal with. Ideally this would be the kind of environment that people would like to live in.
Freedom Bound Essay Research Paper In his
Freedom Bound Essay, Research Paper In his book, Freedom Bound, Robert Weisbrot argues that the civil rights movement is interwoven with American political reform of the time, and furthermore, that “the black quest for justice and the national crusade for a ‘Great Society’ are best understood in relation to each other” (Weisbrot xiv).
Boxing Rules Essay Research Paper Marquis of
Boxing Rules Essay, Research Paper Marquis of Queensberry Rules Governing Contests for Endurance That s right, there s a new set of standard rules out for the fighters. They were created by, John Sholto Douglas and John Graham Chambers, two of the worlds best boxers ever seen to hit the ring.
Creative Poem Essay Research Paper Hope you
Creative Poem Essay, Research Paper Hope you are enjoying the Day! To have a friend, you must be a friend, Starting with yourself. The greatest hunger a person has is to be needed.
Jane Eyre Essay Research Paper Caretakers had
Jane Eyre Essay, Research Paper Caretakers had an important role in the renaissance and the Victorian period. Mainly women were accepted to be a caretaker while their class was usually a low one. Their duty changed from period to period, their class was not bound to be low, but still, it was lower than the person who hired them.
Crefew Essay Research Paper Graduation Night CurfewFive
Crefew Essay, Research Paper Graduation Night Curfew Five years ago I graduated from high school. I felt like I was finally free of the rules that parents enforced while I was in school. Example of my parents rules are no playing till after homework is done and curfew on school nights. After all, I just finished twelve years of school and deserved some reward.
Homeward Bound Essay Research Paper Homeward Bound
Homeward Bound Essay, Research Paper Homeward Bound Homeward Bound is a satiric play, which attacks the socially accepted standards of today s society. This play is known as a comedy of manners; defined as light social satire. Homeward Bound also consists of amusing characters that the audience can relate to.
Desert Island Essay Research Paper Giligan and
Desert Island Essay, Research Paper Giligan and the Professor when stranded on an isolated island in the Pacific did not get to chose the items that they would bring with them on there three hour cruise. Given the opportunity to choose what item that I could take when isolated on a deserted Island, provided that my basic needs where taken care of, I would take a bound notebook with a black pen.
Pele Essay Research Paper Little is known
Pele Essay, Research Paper Little is known about the origin of soccer. The modern game is very different from it’s accent origins this paper will explore those origins and show how modern day soccer evolved.
Group Work Outline Essay Research Paper Group
Group Work Outline Essay, Research Paper Group Conflict Resolution Annotated Outline I. Introduction In this section, we will state our topic, which is group conflict resolution. We will present the subtopics we will focus on in the paper. We will briefly tie the four subtopics into each other under the umbrella topic of group conflict resolution.
Teenage Curfews Essay Research Paper Should our
Teenage Curfews Essay, Research Paper Should our teens have a teen curfew implemented in our neighborhood? What is there to do so late at night? That?s what many parents ask their children. But
Kingdom Of God Essay Research Paper The
Kingdom Of God Essay, Research Paper The "Kingdom of God" is a commonly used phrase in the Christian community. It rolls off the tongue of believers worldwide, yet the meaning of
Poetics Essay Research Paper The subject of
Poetics Essay, Research Paper The subject of the Poetics is poetry, including epic poetry, tragedy and comedy. Unlike Plato, Aristotle regards poetry as a techne. The practice of poetry is governed by rules; these rules can be formulated and taught. Poetry is rationally comprehensible.
On Social Classes In Pride And Prejudice
By Jane Austen Essay, Research Paper In the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, life for the upper-middle class and the aristocracy was simple and comfortable, at least on the surface. Strict manners and morals, that often prevented them from asserting or protecting themselves, bound these two classes of people.
Anthem Essay Research Paper Anthem EssayPrometheus the
Anthem Essay, Research Paper Anthem Essay Prometheus, the hero in this novel, has struggled to free himself from the collectivist world that he lives in. His victory was possible by breaking a lot of the rules. He realized from the beginning that he wasn’t like all the other children at the home of the infants and at the home of the students.
Types Of Parents Essay Research Paper Protective
Types Of Parents Essay, Research Paper Protective parents are the easiest category of parents to spot. Most parents in this category illustrate an extreme sense of strictness through the use of several rules and harsh punishments. For instance, Mr. and Mrs. Gallop ground Jennifer from riding in a car because she was ten minutes late without notifying her parents first.
Buddhist Economics Essay Research Paper Buddhist EconomicsMost
Buddhist Economics Essay, Research Paper Buddhist Economics Most people think that religion and economics don?t mix. So you would think the same in the case with Buddhism and economics. But actually the there is a set of rules that go along with our modern day economics that have their own meanings. Buddhists believe that spiritual health and well being go hand in hand.
Our Friends Ourselves Essay Research Paper In
Our Friends, Ourselves Essay, Research Paper In the reading Our friends, ourselves by Steve Duck he tells us that there are four rules that characterize friend ship. The rules are to hold a conversation, not to disclose confidences to other people, what I think is important and to refrain from public criticism, and to repay debts and favors.
Animal Cell Essay Research Paper Animal CellThe
Animal Cell Essay, Research Paper Animal CellThe model cell that you are looking at is an animal cell. The model is labeled with all of the typical organelles within a cell membrane. The following words are parts of the cell structure and the different jobs each one performs:Cell Membrane- phospholipid-protein bilayer; separates cell content from the environment.
Article Essay Research Paper EN102018 January 2001The
Article Essay, Research Paper EN1020 18 January 2001 The Article ?British Airways sacks pilots seen drinking before flight?, talks about how pilots abuse the drinking rules set up by the airlines. One of the airlines, British Airways, announced that they had fired two of their pilots because they had been filmed while drinking and they were due to fly the very next day.
Starbucks Coffee Company Essay Research Paper CONCEPT
Starbucks Coffee Company Essay, Research Paper CONCEPT PAPER COMPANY: Starbucks Coffee Company The purpose of the video program is to orient and inform employees about the goals and objectives of the company. In addition to this, the rules and benefits of employees will be featured. The video will employ a factual style in conveying its purpose.
Gun Control Essay Research Paper Gun EssayShould
Gun Control Essay, Research Paper Gun Essay Should we really just keep adding gun control laws? Well, I don’t think so. I think that Senator Larry E. Craig said it best “the criminal that wasn’t stopped by 20,000 laws won’t stop at 20,001.“ My viewpoint is that we should have better law enforcemnt.