In Retrospect Essay, Research Paper
Robert McNamara In Retrospect Random House New York, 1995
Vietnam had long since been a place of controversy, and where our government focused
it?s fear of communism for many years. Throughout the Kennedy and Johnson administrations
the government maintained that the war between the Communist north and the south can only be
won by the South Vietnamese, and that our military cannot win it for them. It stressed that the
fall of South Vietnam to communism would threaten the rest of the western world.
Robert McNamara, the Secretary of Defense during the Kennedy and Johnson
administrations, wrote In Retrospect because he wanted to ?Put Vietnam in context,?(xx).
McNamara wanted to explain why the mistakes of Vietnam were made, not to justify them, but
to help the American public understand them. He relies not only upon his memories, but upon
the record whenever possible.
People have often called Vietnam, McNamara?s war, because he made it his
responsibility. As he learned more and more about south Vietnam, he became well acquainted
with it?s leader Ngo Dinh Diem. Diem portrayed himself as a man who shared our western
values. Though as our government would soon realize he was not the man we had hoped for.
Diem needed to be removed from power, he was becoming more and more unpopular with his
people. The Kennedy Administration seemed split on how democratic Diem really was. His
conflicts between the Buddhists and Catholics were becoming more outrageous than ever. The
administration supported a general?s coup to get Diem out of power. Diem and his brother Nhu
were both assassinated during this coup.
On November 22, 1963, Kennedy, himself, was also assassinated on the streets of Dallas.
McNamara poses many questions as to whether the war would have continued on the same route
had Kennedy not been killed. McNamara feels that had Kennedy lived he would have pulled us
out of Vietnam. His reasoning was that Kennedy had told his cabinet ?We are not going to
bungle into war.? Kennedy was ready to start pulling our troops out because it was obvious that
the war was un winnable.
Lyndon B. Johnson now becomes president. Many debates are being held on what to do
in Vietnam. After Diem?s death, the Johnson Administration faced political problems in Saigon.
The demands for U.S. military actions were growing.
On August 2, 1964, North Vietnam launched an attack against an American ship in the
Gulf of Tonkin. A second attack was supposed to have taken place on August fourth, but
McNamara has now concluded that the second attack never happened. Using the Gulf of Tonkin
event to his advantage Johnson went to congress. The Gulf of Tonkin resolution gave the
president the broad war powers. Meanwhile this resolution had been based on an attack that
might well have never taken place. McNamara discusses whether the Gulf of Tonkin resolution
gave too much unlimited power to the president. He does not feel that the Congress understood
what was happening in Vietnam nor how the Johnson administration would respond to it.
Though he never answers his own question as to whether the administration was given too much
leniency when it came to its actions in Vietnam, it seems as if the Congress was misled on all
the facts pertaining to the Gulf of Tonkin.
After the Gulf of Tonkin U.S. military troops were increased in Vietnam from 23,000 to
175,000. McNamara in hindsight looks back and wonders, why? Why did they escalate and not
withdraw? South Vietnam seemed like a lost cause. Their leaders were fighting among
themselves and yet we continued to fight on their behalf. He believes that we could have
withdrawn without any negative affects on our country. Was there another way to stop these
injustices, McNamara feels that all other resources were not exhausted before we ventured into a
war that we had little hope of winning.
Our government overestimated the fall of South Vietnam, would it really have threatened
the rest of the western world, probably not. McNamara lists eleven reasons for the major causes
of Vietnam. They include that the U.S. embellished the danger it would cause us had we not
intervened, both the Kennedy and Johnson administrations lacked the knowledge of that specific
area, so there was no one to consult when major themes of this war needed to be debated. It
seems that whenever the Johnson Administration got the Tonkin Resolution passed they failed to
think of consequences before they reacted to a situation. McNamara is not only to blame for this
war many mistakes were made, including the entire administration, generals, and Vietnamese.
The disagreements within the state department were also a fundamental cause of this armed
conflict. McNamara makes it crystal-clear that many of the contentions were not fully
discussed.
The basic reasoning behind us being in Vietnam was to advise the South Vietnamese on
how to stop pressures from the north. McNamara reveals that failure to organize properly did in
fact cause many of the oversights made. There was no ?war cabinet? to focus on strictly on
Vietnam.
Our Government must learn through these mistakes. It is obvious the mistakes that the
state department made during these fateful years. It may have been avoided had it not been for a
series of unknown disasters, such as the assassination of Kennedy, the overthrow and
assassination of Diem, and the relatively unknown Gulf of Tonkin incidences.
When McNamara left the state department he had realized that the U.S. ?could not
achieve their objectives in Vietnam.? In the last few months of his term he came to the
conclusion that continuing on the present course would eventually prove fatal and cost many of
innocent lives. Johnson did not agree so he purposely left McNamara?s views out of discussions
regarding the next course of action. What they needed was a rapid end to this war, and he felt
that the bombing and the expansion of the ground war would not do the job. He proposed a list
of alternatives such as stopping the bombing of the north to bring about negotiations, transferring
the responsibility from our military to the South Vietnamese. Although he made his contentions
well-known to the president, the president was not ready to hear him. His last deed in regards to
Vietnam was to oppose General Westmoreland?s petition for 200,000 supplementary troops.
McNamara?s reasoning behind this book was to tell the American people what went on
behind the scenes during the Vietnam war. Many critics of the Vietnam war feel that it was the
inexperience of the state department, though they were extremely intelligent, they were not
trained in the finer workings of the military which caused the escalation. Their were many times
when we could have pulled out of Vietnam, but they thought that it would cause the United
States to lose rank with the rest of the world. Both Administrations, I feel overstated the threat
that if South Vietnam fell to communism than the rest of the east would fall like a line of
dominoes. McNamara summed up alot of misconceptions of what really happened, he doesn?t
try and sugar coat he comes right out and says ?We were wrong, terribly wrong.? The book
makes a lot of valid points though it is hard to follow at times. In Retrospect has allowed me to
become painfully aware of a war that I knew relatively little about. This book shows reasons as
to why, right or wrong, we intervened in Vietnam, and why we should have withdrawn sooner
than we did.
Другие работы по теме:
Home Burial Essay Research Paper In the
Home Burial Essay, Research Paper In the poem “Home Burial” by Robert Frost, it is easy to see both positive and negative aspects of both characters. I feel that Frost favors the man. Although he talks about how the man seems to not have feelings, the man actually does. The man feels sad for his dead child. He just goes about showing it in a different way.
On The Bench Essay Research Paper In
?On The Bench? Essay, Research Paper In his essay, ?On The Bench?, Robert Parker shows the trials and tribulations of trying to be both mentally and physically strong. He writes about how horrible it is being thin and weak, and having to hold on to his wife?s arm when it is windy out. I hope that this essay was intended to be humorous, because it did in fact make me laugh.
Robert Frost
’s “The Road Not Taken” Essay, Research Paper ?Robert Frost was one of the United States’ best-loved poets. Frost was greatly influenced by his move from San Francisco to New England at
Freshman Yearimbas Essay Research Paper I remember
Freshman Yearimbas Essay, Research Paper I remember walking into South Brunswick High School on the first official day of high school freshman year. It was like nothing out of the ordinary. I had already been in the school all summer. I was there every day for summer football practice with coaches: Homman, Simmons, and Harding.
Awakening Essay Research Paper When Edna swam
Awakening Essay, Research Paper When Edna swam out into the ocean at the end of The Awakening, I think it was because she realized her situation. She was madly in love with Robert and she was married. Her husband, Leonce, was much too proper and business-like to please her childish spirit. However, in the end, she understood she could not be with Robert.
The Awakening Essay Research Paper This novel
The Awakening Essay, Research Paper This novel takes place in the early 1920’s on the Grand Isles of Louisiana. Grande Isle was a resort for wealthy people, to get away from the city. The remainder of the novel takes place in New Orleans. The theme of this book is about women and her “awakening”, a sort of liberation.
Robert Herrick Essay Research Paper Robert Herrick
Robert Herrick Essay, Research Paper Robert Herrick and Andrew Marvell are both well know seventeenth century poets. Herrick’ s “to the Virgins to Make Much of Time” and Marvell’ s “To his Coy Mistress” have basically the same themes which are that one should not waste time, one should not be coy, and one should not yearn for a different age.
Robert E Lee Essay Research Paper A
Robert E. Lee Essay, Research Paper A Southern Hero It all started on January 19, 1807. A little baby boy was born, not yeet know to be a hero. Young Robert admired two wonderful soldiers, George Washington and his very own father, Henry Lee. Robert was born on January 19th to Henry and Anne Carter Lee, in Westmoreland County, Virginia.
Robert Francis Waxwings Essay Research Paper Waxwings
Robert Francis- Waxwings Essay, Research Paper Waxwings: Robert Francis The overall theme of Robert Francis Waxwings is the belief of Taoism. This idea obviously is stated in the first line of the first stanza and then subtly throughout the rest of the poem. The title of the poem can also present a hint of Taoism.
The Outsiders Essay Research Paper A Day
The Outsiders Essay, Research Paper A Day No Pigs Would Die Robert Newton Peck The book took place in rural Vermont with a young Shaker boy named Rob Peck. The novel was basically about this boy going through joyful and trying times in his youth, and his friendship with his pet pig named Pinky. Robert Peck was the main character, he was loving towards Pinky and he was obedient,( he knew if he wasn?t, he?d be in big trouble.)
Treasure Isand Essay Research Paper Robert Louis
Treasure Isand Essay, Research Paper Robert Louis StevensonA thriller… Treasure Island is guaranteed to keep you on the edge of yourseat. When I read it I sat down and read it for hours. I could barley put itdown. All 296 pages are filled with suspense, action, and power. The authormakes you feel like your right there on Treasure Island with Jim Hawkins,Mr.
BlindFaith Essay Research Paper Blind FaithIn the
BlindFaith Essay, Research Paper Blind Faith In the story “Cathedral” by Raymond Carver, the main character, goes through a major personal transformation. At the beginning of the story, his opinions of others are filled with stereotypes, discrimination and prejudice. Through interaction with his wife’s blind friend Robert, his attitude and outlook on life changes.
Vietnam Essay Research Paper The United States
Vietnam Essay, Research Paper The United States of America prides itself as the self proclaimed leader of the free world. Since the end of World War II the United States has chosen to use force in order to insure this so called "freedom" of other less fortunate nations who do not have the ability to defend themselves.
The Wars Essay Research Paper The Wars
The Wars Essay, Research Paper The Wars “A picture is worth a thousand words,” we say. From the eyes and mind of the archivist studying the pictures of Robert Ross’ experience with war, they are worth a lot more. The photographs in the epilogue of Timothy Findley’s “The Wars” play an important role in Findley establishing both a trust with the reader, and a sense of realism to his war story.
Critical Lens Essay Research Paper In life
Critical Lens Essay, Research Paper In life we come to many conflicts. Some are easy some are hard. The quote, “The harder the conflict, the more glorious the triumph” by
Robert Cormier Essay Research Paper Robert CormierRobert
Robert Cormier Essay, Research Paper Robert Cormier Robert Cormier was born on January 17, 1925, in Leominster, Massachusetts and has lived there for most of his life. He is the second of eight children in his family. When he was in elementary school his seventh-grade teacher read one of his poems and told him that it was very good and he could be a writer.
Kate Essay Research Paper 2 Trace Edna
Kate Essay, Research Paper 2. Trace Edna Pontellier’s awakening. Edna awakening comes very soon in the story, because first of all Edna never feels connect to the wealthy Creoles of New Orleans. The whole life style of the Creoles just never fits to her and the type of person she is. Then on vacation, Edna starts to fall for a man named, Robert Lebrun.
Cathedral 2 Essay Research Paper Cathedral The
Cathedral 2 Essay, Research Paper Cathedral The story is about a blind man who visits a married couple. He is an old friend of the wife, but the husband does not look forward to see the blind man (called Robert) because he does not know what to expect. He has never known any blind persons and his picture of these is based on a very little foundation.
The Wars Robert
’s Struggle Essay, Research Paper In the book The Wars, by Timothy Findley, asserting maleness is a big deal. Men aren’t supposed to do what is feminine. Through the many incidents in the novel, maleness is most emphasized on, reason being of the war in the novel, all these men have to act like “tough guys” because their sensitivity will be discriminated.
Child Development Essay Research Paper In a
Child Development Essay, Research Paper In a typical four year old child, many social developments can be viewed. Four year old children are more independent of adults, but yet they seem to want attention from them, as well as peers. They begin to ask permission and they find that the like to have an adult nearby.
Book Report On Novel
“Uh-Oh” By Robert Fulghum Essay, Research Paper Uh-Oh SOME OBSERVATIONS FROM BOTH SIDES OF THE REFRIGERATOR DOOR Book By Robert Fulghum Report by (Your Name Here)
Darwin Research Essay Research Paper Darwin was
Darwin Research Essay, Research Paper Darwin was born in Shrewsbury, Shropshire. He was the son of Robert Waring Darwin and his wife Susannah; and the grandson of the scientist Erasmus Darwin, and
FireandIce Essay Research Paper Fire and Ice
Fire_and_Ice Essay, Research Paper ?Fire and Ice? by Robert Frost is an epigram which presents the poet?s dislike of hatred, indifference, and desire that human beings display towards one another. Compressing these feelings into an epigram tends to make his message quite clear and brief. Thus, Frost?s tone in ?Fire and Ice? is somewhat glib and straight to the point?perhaps even slightly stoic.
Early American Lit Essay Research Paper American
Early American Lit Essay, Research Paper American Literature consisted of many well known writers. These writers wrote excellent pieces of literature which are widely read today. These writers wrote about some aspect of American life, and they depicted America very well. Some of these writers are Stephen Crane and Robert E.
Robert Capa Essay Research Paper Robert Capa
Robert Capa Essay, Research Paper Robert Capa Robert Capa was born in Budapest, hungary in 1913. Robert Capa is most known for his photographs in war. Known for obtaining photos taken during a war that shows what it is like to be in a war. Showing things like the hardships that soldiers have to endure and the suffering of people whose homes and cities were destroyed as a result of war.
Mythic Heros Essay Research Paper When I
Mythic Heros Essay, Research Paper When I think about mythic heroes, for many years the first name that came to mind was Sinbad: Sinbad the sailor. In his days as an adventurer, he went on seven fantastic voyages which earned him fame for the rest of his life. Yet, now in retrospect, I no longer consider him to be the great adventurer that I saw him as in my childhood.
Robert Frost Essay Research Paper In Robert
Robert Frost Essay, Research Paper In Robert Frosts’ poem “The Road Not Taken,” Frost talks of choosing between two roads to travel. Frost has come to a split in the road and has to choose which road to pick. In Randy Travis’ song “I Told You So,” a man learns that his girlfriend is choosing between himself and another man.
Cell Nulceus Essay Research Paper The Discovery
Cell Nulceus Essay, Research Paper The Discovery of the Cell Nucleus The cell nucleus was discovered in 1828. At this time no one really understood what it did but eventually it was found to be the control center for the cell and it organelles. The cell was discovered by a Robert Brown, a botanist. Robert Brown invented his own microscope with a crude system of lenses.
Robert Bunsen Essay Research Paper Robert Wilhelm
Robert Bunsen Essay, Research Paper Robert Wilhelm Bunsen s name was famous for a a few discoveries in the field of chemistry. For example you might recognize Bunsen from the lab device, the Bunsen Burner . He also helped invent the spectroscope and discovered spectrum analysis. And at the beginning of his career, he discovered that iron oxide is an antidote for arsenic.
Road Not Taken Essay Research Paper Robert
Road Not Taken Essay, Research Paper Robert Frost The Road Not Taken The poem “The Road Not Taken” by Robert Frost is about the choices that one makes in life. It tells about a man who comes to a fork in the road he traveling upon, he feel
Robert Frost Critique Essay Research Paper Choices
Robert Frost Critique Essay, Research Paper Choices are never easy- men face multitudes of them in their lifetime. Some decisions to these choices are clear while others are sometimes more difficult to effectuate. The poem “The Road Not Taken” by Robert Frost is a first person narrative tale of a monumental moment in the speaker s life- Frost can be considered the speaker.
Why Philosophy Essay Research Paper Why PhilosophyAaron
Why Philosophy? Essay, Research Paper Why Philosophy? Aaron R. Nino Religion “Philosophy is simply his effort to avoid doing this in the dark,” says Robert Johann. He is referring to using his freedom to take his personal stand on everything and be responsible for the stand he takes. So what then is Philosophy? Is it to throw some light on the meaning of life as a whole, to give man some idea of what he is about.
Inherit The Wind Essay Research Paper In
Inherit The Wind Essay, Research Paper In our Consititution, citizens have many righhts, but do we have the right to think? In the play Inherit the Wind by Jerome Lawrence adn Robert Lee, a man is on trial for teaching his students about the theory of evolution. Drummond, the lawyer for this man, said “With all respect to the bench, I hold that the right to think is very much on trial.”